Re: inevitably..
Sgian Dubh
David, I have to admit the diversion into firearms lost me a bit, and I like to think I'm not big on producing run-of-the-mill cabinetry or kitchens either that might be described as "bland and commodity-type stuff", and I don’t believe I ” sand everything [to] make the surface dull and uniform.” I like to think that what I do produce has a certain amount of individuality or distinctiveness, and final sanding takes place to create a surface suitable for polish as quickly and efficiently as possible. To be honest I find the vast majority of furniture business, large or small, and with very few exceptions, all undertake final polish preparation that includes at least some sanding. The exceptions I mentioned are limited primarily to producers of rustic furniture where some tooling marks are considered part of the look, eg, scallops in table tops from the adze, panels scalloped with spokeshaves set up with heavily arced blades, and the like.
The discussion may, from your perspective, centre around there being a benefit to honing planes and chisels to a very fine edge in isolation from the, if you like, economic conditions in which all woodworkers work. To me that doesn’t seem to hold water because I can’t ignore the economic imperative to produce work efficiently. Some woodworkers may have a great fascination with the process of achieving a good or very good cutting edge. Some of those woodworkers may be excellent craftspeople, some may be professional, and some may be amateurs, and some may even be shockingly bad woodworkers ... but their tool’s edges are immaculately sharp.
Maybe I’m just different, but achieving sharpness in plane irons and chisels isn’t something I think about much. It’s a common but essential and, I think, should be a quickly achieved routine maintenance operation. There are very few occasions where “ultimate” sharpness in an iron or blade offers a significant benefit in my experience. I’m thinking of situations where some solid show wood is particularly interlocked, gnarly, twisted, etc, and needs some careful handling. So that’s when I’ll move beyond the routine of sharpening with an 800 grit stone to the medium Spyderco stone for a finer edge. The end result is an edge that cuts better of course, but it will only cut satisfactorily for a given period. After that it needs sharpening again to continue handling that tricky wood. It’s the case that the now somewhat dulled blade will plane less critical wooden surfaces for some time longer.
I find for most general purpose planing that sharpening with an 800 grit stone and getting back to work is more than adequate, and it doesn’t seem to me in those situations that the time invested in going up the grits every time to achieve the ultimate edge offers any advantage in the overall time it takes to make a piece of furniture.
Some people claim to routinely polish their furniture straight off the plane with little or no sanding between planing and polishing. I tried that once as an exercise about three decades ago, and whilst I was able to achieve it on a smallish coffee table or something similar, the time it took to get a really good surface lacking any real evidence of scalloping and other tool marks just didn’t make economic sense. If I remember it correctly it took me something like a whole day to get a polish ready surface that way, whereas if I’d used my normal method of planing, scraping and sanding I’d have got to the same stage in about a quarter of the time. Slainte.