New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

Posts

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#51

Re: inevitably..

jack curtis

Their shops are hydraulic and pneumatic run off of a diesel motor...

This shows a flagrant disregard for air quality, and to what point. See, you don't need spurious analogies using guns and diesel motors to discuss Richard's response, which was precisely to the point of this thread, however misbegotten.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#52

Re: inevitably..

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

"This shows a flagrant disregard for air quality"

So you're saying that it's better to use electricity outright instead of diesel, even if said electricity comes from coal power plants (I don't know if that's the case here)?

Just curious...

DC

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#53

Re: inevitably..

David Weaver

I would venture to guess that their overall environmental footprint is quite a bit smaller than ours. Even if it's straight up even in the shop, it is almost non-existent otherwise.

When hydraulics are in use, the diesel motor is on. When the air tank (which is usually a huge converted propane tank) needs air, then the diesel motor is on.

Otherwise, everything is off and they don't waste HUGE amounts of energy trying to extract the air from their work space 30 times an hour all day.

The point back to sharpening, though, is that they don't even enter this discussion because they're not using hand tools. And unlike a lot of us, who bloviate about what grade furniture must be, they are making furniture, trim and cabinets that the everyman can afford. No nose in the air moaning and groaning about ikea and chest pounding about how inferior everything else is. They just go about their business making furniture out of wood and ply and selling it to people, totally without any of the attempt at heaving a guilt trip on the buying public decrying a fantasy lifestyle that never did exist for a working furnituremaker in the past.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#54

Re: Good reality check!

Sgian Dubh

Wiley, I didn't link to that hoary old chestnut of a story because it's been seen so bloody often, and I didn't think it was really relevant, although I suppose it's true that I'm a minimalist when it comes to sharpening tools ... basically I'm a 'sharp'n'go' type. Never been much interested in jigs, tool steel, and all that stuff. If it ain't cutting, do something about it is my motto. Slainte.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#55

Re: Good reality check!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Richard,

Sorry, I should have left things the way you intended. As it happened, I may have stirred things up, which I didn't mean to do.

Apologies,

Wiley

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#56

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening? #56

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Has anyone ever done a study on the number of posts in a thread on a ww forum vs the topic?

Or is it just assumed that once it goes over 20 or 30 that the topic is sharpening?

I enjoy these threads immensely and thanks to all who contribute!

Seriously there's good information, entertainment, and practically free!

Bob in NJ (I make this #56)

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#57

Re: Oh no, we've got lots of them that go past 30.

david weaver

* Double iron vs. single iron

* comparison of steel types

* flattening panels with hand tools

* bevel down vs. bevel up

* japanese chisels vs. western chisels

But sharpening does usually bring the most, I guess.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#58

Re: inevitably..

jack curtis

Certainly in the shop; but I'm not fond of burning coal, either. Was it necessary that I cover the gamit?

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#59

I think it was

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

If you criticize a source of energy, you have to compare it to alternatives, otherwise your intervention is pretty much meaningless.

In the same line of thought, buying a Chevy Volt (or any other hybrid car) does not necessarily help the environment. In some states (Kentucky is one, I think), it is better to use regular gas instead of plugging a hybrid, cheaper and more economical, because of the energy source (coal).

DC

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#60

Re: inevitably..

Sgian Dubh

David, I have to admit the diversion into firearms lost me a bit, and I like to think I'm not big on producing run-of-the-mill cabinetry or kitchens either that might be described as "bland and commodity-type stuff", and I don’t believe I ” sand everything [to] make the surface dull and uniform.” I like to think that what I do produce has a certain amount of individuality or distinctiveness, and final sanding takes place to create a surface suitable for polish as quickly and efficiently as possible. To be honest I find the vast majority of furniture business, large or small, and with very few exceptions, all undertake final polish preparation that includes at least some sanding. The exceptions I mentioned are limited primarily to producers of rustic furniture where some tooling marks are considered part of the look, eg, scallops in table tops from the adze, panels scalloped with spokeshaves set up with heavily arced blades, and the like.

The discussion may, from your perspective, centre around there being a benefit to honing planes and chisels to a very fine edge in isolation from the, if you like, economic conditions in which all woodworkers work. To me that doesn’t seem to hold water because I can’t ignore the economic imperative to produce work efficiently. Some woodworkers may have a great fascination with the process of achieving a good or very good cutting edge. Some of those woodworkers may be excellent craftspeople, some may be professional, and some may be amateurs, and some may even be shockingly bad woodworkers ... but their tool’s edges are immaculately sharp.

Maybe I’m just different, but achieving sharpness in plane irons and chisels isn’t something I think about much. It’s a common but essential and, I think, should be a quickly achieved routine maintenance operation. There are very few occasions where “ultimate” sharpness in an iron or blade offers a significant benefit in my experience. I’m thinking of situations where some solid show wood is particularly interlocked, gnarly, twisted, etc, and needs some careful handling. So that’s when I’ll move beyond the routine of sharpening with an 800 grit stone to the medium Spyderco stone for a finer edge. The end result is an edge that cuts better of course, but it will only cut satisfactorily for a given period. After that it needs sharpening again to continue handling that tricky wood. It’s the case that the now somewhat dulled blade will plane less critical wooden surfaces for some time longer.

I find for most general purpose planing that sharpening with an 800 grit stone and getting back to work is more than adequate, and it doesn’t seem to me in those situations that the time invested in going up the grits every time to achieve the ultimate edge offers any advantage in the overall time it takes to make a piece of furniture.

Some people claim to routinely polish their furniture straight off the plane with little or no sanding between planing and polishing. I tried that once as an exercise about three decades ago, and whilst I was able to achieve it on a smallish coffee table or something similar, the time it took to get a really good surface lacking any real evidence of scalloping and other tool marks just didn’t make economic sense. If I remember it correctly it took me something like a whole day to get a polish ready surface that way, whereas if I’d used my normal method of planing, scraping and sanding I’d have got to the same stage in about a quarter of the time. Slainte.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#61

Re: Good reality check!

Sgian Dubh

Wiley, it's not a problem. And there's no harm if a few people are diverted to that old tale. Most people get a bit of a chuckle from it, and if that's the case, humour is no bad thing. Slainte.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#62

Re: inevitably..

david weaver

Well, I guess there are two things going on here, and first is the assumption that is exactly what I was talking about:

* the pressure to produce thing efficiently * (paraphrased from what you've said). it doesn't really exist in the way you're implying for most hobby woodworkers. Sure, there's always the urge to keep things moving and get as much as possible done, but it doesn't seem to keep people from wanting to have very sharp chisel and smoothing planes. I don't know what most people do for jack planes, I'd guess that they probably set them aside and use their planer.

* there is a false notion that we are working through some pattern of grits that takes a long time. I guess the only person I've seen doing that is paul sellers. He's tied to softer tools so he can get on with his method and avoid a grinder. Good for him. For the rest of us, getting a fine edge when you want one (a step short of the 0.25 micron talk) is two stones and takes the same amount of time as one medium stone and a strop. Maybe 30 seconds with a chisel?

There is the assumption built in there that someone asking a question has the skill to execute that. It hardly seems as unreasonable to me as it's made out to be, and doesn't involve some several minute exercise of running through grits and polishing extensive areas that will never contact wood.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#63

Re: I think it was

jack curtis

I disagree. It would have been disingenuous of me to have criticized a political argument about gun control only to have entered my own of energy. I don't think this is the place for either, nor could the topic be fully addressed in a message thread.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#64

Reality check

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Richard, it certainly sounds as if you have next to no experience using a smoothing plane. As David suggested, it takes little time to refine an edge once it is sharpened on a coarse stone. For me it takes about 2 minutes to take out a plane iron, sharpen it and have it adjusted again for a fine shaving. Maybe if I were satisfied with a crummy edge I could save 30 seconds, but I think the extra time is repaid in performance.

You once tried smoothing 30 years ago, and it took a whole day for a small table top? I cannot imagine what in the world were you doing all that time.

This morning I timed myself smoothing a frame and panel door. Two stiles, two rails, and a 14 X 26 panel: 2 minutes and 45 seconds.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#65

Re: Reality check

CStanford

Well, I think the point is the length of time it takes (for it does) to plane until there is no real evidence of their use. Tool marks are not always appropriate. Anybody who hasn't started to lay down shellac to have a clear, but unwanted, reminder of their use is either being untruthful, forgetful, or hasn't done enough woodworking to really opine on the matter, or at least not enough woodworking against the clock, or perhaps not enough woodworking on large, broad surfaces. Obviously, it's easy to plane a little board narrower than a plane iron is wide and have it look perfect. Next up the easy scale from that, would be stiles and rails only a little wider than an iron is wide. Can I get an amen on a reproduction Duncan Phyfe dining table top? Huh, maybe not so quick? I've been close to a real one. Not a tool mark to be seen on the broad surfaces. Only tool marks or evidence of hand work were found on the carved parts. They must have planed and scraped that rascal for, well, a little longer than a few minutes.

Woodworkers have been using abrasives for millenia and scouring surfaces post-planing in an attempt to obliterate tool marks and homogenize a surface for the finish for just as long.

Plane, scrape, and sand standard trade practice can hardly be called a cop-out or even suggested as so. I think Richard knows his way around a smoothing plane and certainly knows his way around productive shops working for-hire and for-profit for a paying, discerning clientele. If the person writing the check isn't a fan of the subtle plane scallop we all think is so cute that's all that matters.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#66

Re: Reality check

Sgian Dubh

Warren, perhaps I should have put the table top or panel I described into some sort of context. It wasn't something like an accommodatingly even and mild grained hardwood, but a cantankerously hard and highly figured panel made of English oak with much rippling, knots, grain swirls and reversals. Laid flat it covered a decent part of the bench top, and it was perhaps 40" or 45" long by about 24" or 28" wide-- I don't remember the exact dimensions, but I do remember it was obviously going to be quite challenging to get a polish ready surface straight off the planes.

That was what I set out to achieve, for no good reason other than I felt like doing so to see how long it might take. Polish ready meant no evidence of such things as tear-out, scalloping left behind by the plane irons, etc. I did manage it through careful use of smoothing planes and a block plane, plenty of sharpening, lots of very short strokes from different directions, particularly as I got closer to the final stages, with ever finer setting of the blade in the plane, etc, all without recourse to a scraper and abrasive papers. I have to admit that in the end I had to do a bit of sanding, but that really was just some light hand sanding with something like 240 grit paper to remove the black staining you inevitably see when iron and some sweat come into contact with oak.

You might be right to say "it certainly sounds as if (I) have next to no experience using a smoothing plane". Apart from that one exercise about thirty years ago, which you might speculate discouraged and traumatised me intensely, and you also might have concluded that because of that I've perhaps ever since been avoiding the use of any sort plane or other steel based wood cutting tool, ha, ha.

PS. There is also the possibility that the edges I create on plane and chisel irons (that I perhaps have very little experience of using remember) are better than I realise, even though I rarely go beyond 800 grit to sharpen them. The backs are reasonably flat, although I know they're seldom perfect, and I hone the bevel of course, and I do a bit of stropping on the palm of my hand. I've never considered this level of sharpening to be especially pernickety, perfect, or "ultimate" in any way; but maybe these edges, average as I consider them to be, are better than the edges many people create and try to work with, often not particularly well too. Certainly, when I look at the edges that, for example, my students and others I've demonstrated sharpening to, theirs are often quite ropey looking with various nicks and odd looking back bevels, and I'm usually able to demonstrate how to achieve something a little better. Slainte.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#67

Re: inevitably..

Sgian Dubh

David, perhaps, as I said to Warren in a PS to a message in reply to one of his posts, I don't understand what constitutes a good or "ultimate" edge in the minds of some people. It may be the case, as I said in that message, that I do create what many would descibe as a good edge, although perhaps not "ultimate", on my plane irons and chisels. In my mind the edges I create are average or at least adequate for the job. Sharpening a plane iron or chisel doesn't generally seem to be a very difficult or challenging task whenever I tackle it. Perhaps I was just lucky and was shown how to do the job pretty well quite some time ago, and practice since has made it easier.

I do think some people struggle a bit in trying to get a good edge. Over the years I've shown quite a few how to sharpen their tools. Some seem to get it quite quickly, and some don't. I've even seen people using a chisel I describe as being just about good enough to dig the garden with after I've shown them several times how to sharpen. I suspect that in some cases, the last time the tool was sharpened was when I demonstrated the task on the self same tool... perhaps six months earlier, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#68

Re: Reality check

david weaver

I can't imagine the need to leave tooling marks in the surface of anything. If you dimension wood and smooth it, there will be no tooling marks unless you haven't set up a smooth plane correctly.

It takes no longer to smooth than it does to scrape or do anything else, unless you let your show surface become cupped. It's a simple matter of tool setup.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#69

Re: Reality check

TomD

"PS. There is also the possibility that the edges I create on plane and chisel irons (that I perhaps have very little experience of using remember) are better than I realise, even though I rarely go beyond 800 grit to sharpen them. The backs are reasonably flat, although I know they're seldom perfect, and I hone the bevel of course, and I do a bit of stropping on the palm of my hand. I've never considered this level of sharpening to be especially pernickety, perfect, or "ultimate" in any way; but maybe these edges, average as I consider them to be, are better than the edges many people create and try to work with, often not particularly well too. Certainly, when I look at the edges that, for example, my students and others I've demonstrated sharpening to, theirs are often quite ropey looking with various nicks and odd looking back bevels, and I'm usually able to demonstrate how to achieve something a little better. Slainte."

If we are talking 800 grit water stones, that is pretty bad, and I doubt it is better than the edges most people are getting other than the drastically under-performing. 800 grit sandpaper can actually be pretty sharp, depending on the usual things. A person who actually has a nicely constructed 800 grit water stone edge in their hand is 80% or better towards a scary sharp edge, so I see little reason to hold back at that point. That would be like having a pieced built and finished minus the coat of spray lacquer, or something.

To me, neither of these edges are ultimate edges, except in the sense that for some people, well most in the case of a scary sharp edge, they represent the last step taken. An ultimate edge to me is the best tool, sharpened, to a hair popping degree, through some existing series of refinements, that few people generally avail themselves of. I want my edges to be scary, but since the final surface is likely to be sanded if only to provide a uniform knock back, I am not in need of an ultimate edge for most things. I do think there are things that benefit from it though.

An example from another field is sanding on turnings. Tunings can come straight from the tool, or they can be sanded to some degree of refinement that would be recognizable to most woodworkers, and finished conventionally. But some materials allow polishing with very fine papers, that will bring up a shine that does not require finish. This is practical because turning allows the use of small pieces of special material that most of us can't afford or get for larger projects. Turning also allows one to wet sand, and to power sand with great efficiency rarely available in other fields. So how do you feel about ultimate sanding? I rarely take it beyond 400 grit, but on turnings one can go many steps beyond that, and it is perfectly practical to do so, at some scale.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#70

Re: Reality check

Sgian Dubh

"If we are talking 800 grit water stones, that is pretty bad..." an 800 grit ceramic stone in the workshop is the normal stone, but the 'rough' site tools are sharpened with the 'fine' side of a combination oilstone, although in desperate moments when the oilstone has been left out of the on-site tool kit for some daft reason I've used a bit of handy sandpaper, anything from 80 grit to probably about 240 grit, and even the smoothish top face of a concrete step has got me out of a hole from time to time.

An ultimate edge to me is the best tool, sharpened, to a hair popping degree... It's easy to 'pop' a few hairs off the back of the hand or off the forearm after sharpening with either of the stones described above-- it's not so easy to demonstrate after touching up an edge on a concrete step or a bit of 80 grit abrasive paper I'll admit. Slainte.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#71

Re: Reality check

Sgian Dubh

"Turning also allows one to wet sand, and to power sand with great efficiency rarely available in other fields. So how do you feel about ultimate sanding? I rarely take it beyond 400 grit, but on turnings one can go many steps beyond that, and it is perfectly practical to do so, at some scale."

Sorry Tom, I forgot to respond to this bit of your post. I've chucked stuff on a lathe and turned a bit, but it's not really a field of woodworking that gets my juices flowing. If there's ever been a significant element of turning in any of the work I've been involved in, it was either done by the guy that did turning in the wood machine shop or, in my own designs, it's subbed out to someone that charges whatever they charge for it, which I pass on to the client with a mark-up for profit.

As for sanding of cabinetry, chairwork, and other general furniture items, I seldom go finer than 240 grit, and that's reserved for close grained woods like beech, sycamore, maple and cherry. Coarse stuff, like ash, oak and elm aren't worth sanding beyond 180 grit (although sometimes I'll go as far as 220 grit if I'm using power sanding techniques) because the texture of the wood is coarser than the abrasive grit size. By the time you get a film forming polish over the sanded surface you can't see the sanding striations, so why waste time sanding beyond a point that the human eye can see once the polish is applied? If you want to hide a diamond, throw it into a glass of water, and the same sort of thing applies to sanded wood under polish. Slainte.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#72

Re: I think it was

David Weaver

To express either conclusion from any argument as fact would be self-indulgence, anyway.

It was just an example at the top of my head where a false condition is created. 2nd amendment doesn't mention hunting and the fact that an amateur might want to know if there's benefit to a certain degree of sharpening has does not require the highest pay per hour of work.

The argument about moral or ethical dilemmas of either, as well as energy, is for another place.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#73

Re: inevitably..

CStanford

Oy vey, what the hell is a "1 micron resin based ceramic abrasive stone?" I'm sure I should know.

Didn't I read a post recently on a forum, might have been this one, where you stated you hated making furniture? You seem to know a lot about how furnituremakers ought to run and equip their operations and maintain their tools for somebody who hates to build furniture even as an amateur. What's up with that, bro?

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#74

Re: Reality check

TomD

Don't get me wrong I am not criticizing your procedure, I have a couple of chisels I file sharpen for my framing belt.

Hair popping could be one of the more subjective test. But I do have a condition at the upper end where the hair just explodes off my arm. It doesn't happen for me when I have even a very sharp edge.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#75

Re: Reality check

TomD

I would agree with that, and the 240 comment. The purpose of ultimate planing and ultimate sanding can be to sidestep finishing at all. Some materials can be "polished". And they need a really fine abrasive to get the shine up. But they are plastic enough materials in the kind of finish they can hold that they do not require any finish.