Re: I didn't ask any of these questions
wilbur
Hi Bill,
To answer your questions in reverse order:
How quick does the ultimate part of the ultimate edge dull and does it dull different from one less refined?
I would say Steve's data says yes. The graph that I made shows that the edge degrades in a more or less linear fashion, even below that 100 LF data point.
Or to word it yet another way, I take two identical planes and refined one edge to 1/4 micron and the other to something bigger - 1 or 3 - (or pick what ever abrasive format you wish, stones 3M film etc) and then planed 50 feet of lumber . Then I handed you each plane and you planed with each until you thought it was in need of touching up. Would you detect a significant difference between the two planes' edge life?
Personal experience says yes as well. I see increased edge life with planing if I go to my last sharpening step. If I give you two of my planes, one sharpened to my 5000 grit waterstone, and one sharpened to my 8000 grit waterstone, and you plane with them, and give them back, the 8000 grit plane blade will last longer than the 5000 grit one.
Another example: this isn't hand planes, but when I do turning, I use a Tormek, and I strop my turning tools on the leather wheel. I see an increase in edge life, even (or maybe especially) with roughing operations like taking a blank to the rough shape of the bowl that I want to make. This is probably much more of a test of edge retention since if I have an 8" bowl blank spinning at 1200 RPM, I'll go through over 2000 linear feet of wood in one minute of turning. Just so you know you're not alone, turners also argue as to whether there's much benefit of refining the edge of a gouge beyond what you get from a grinder.)
whether you will get significantly more edge life from an edge sharpened to the limit of what is available in a particular abrasive format
I would say yes, because the amount of extra planing time I get is more than the additional 30 seconds or so it took me to get to that ultimate edge. Of course, if you plane like a speed demon, that advantage may not be as great. 
So let me flip the question around. What are the disadvantages to going to the ultimate step in sharpening (12000+ grit waterstone, sub micron diamonds, stropping)? It's certainly not the additional time spent. The only thing I can think of might be cost in the case of waterstones, but that doesn't hold for diamonds or stropping. And cost really isn't an issue for me because I'm not insisting that everyone use waterstones, even though that's what I like to use myself. So what is it?