New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

Posts

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#26

Re: effect of initial sharpness on edge retention *LINK*

Lars Parrington

kees, are you specifically looking for a waterstone?

if not, diamond paste will get you to that level of sharpness for less $$. there was a relevant post here just a few days ago. intro to diamond sharpening:


http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/page/1/md/read/id/464180/sbj/on-getting-started-with-diamonds-summary/

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#27

Re: I didn't ask any of these questions

wilbur

Hi Bill,

To answer your questions in reverse order:

How quick does the ultimate part of the ultimate edge dull and does it dull different from one less refined?


I would say Steve's data says yes. The graph that I made shows that the edge degrades in a more or less linear fashion, even below that 100 LF data point.

Or to word it yet another way, I take two identical planes and refined one edge to 1/4 micron and the other to something bigger - 1 or 3 - (or pick what ever abrasive format you wish, stones 3M film etc) and then planed 50 feet of lumber . Then I handed you each plane and you planed with each until you thought it was in need of touching up. Would you detect a significant difference between the two planes' edge life?

Personal experience says yes as well. I see increased edge life with planing if I go to my last sharpening step. If I give you two of my planes, one sharpened to my 5000 grit waterstone, and one sharpened to my 8000 grit waterstone, and you plane with them, and give them back, the 8000 grit plane blade will last longer than the 5000 grit one.

Another example: this isn't hand planes, but when I do turning, I use a Tormek, and I strop my turning tools on the leather wheel. I see an increase in edge life, even (or maybe especially) with roughing operations like taking a blank to the rough shape of the bowl that I want to make. This is probably much more of a test of edge retention since if I have an 8" bowl blank spinning at 1200 RPM, I'll go through over 2000 linear feet of wood in one minute of turning. Just so you know you're not alone, turners also argue as to whether there's much benefit of refining the edge of a gouge beyond what you get from a grinder.)

whether you will get significantly more edge life from an edge sharpened to the limit of what is available in a particular abrasive format


I would say yes, because the amount of extra planing time I get is more than the additional 30 seconds or so it took me to get to that ultimate edge. Of course, if you plane like a speed demon, that advantage may not be as great. :D

So let me flip the question around. What are the disadvantages to going to the ultimate step in sharpening (12000+ grit waterstone, sub micron diamonds, stropping)? It's certainly not the additional time spent. The only thing I can think of might be cost in the case of waterstones, but that doesn't hold for diamonds or stropping. And cost really isn't an issue for me because I'm not insisting that everyone use waterstones, even though that's what I like to use myself. So what is it?

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#28

You're overstating your case....

CStanford

Really Tom? You noticed?

Lots of truth in there anyway Old Boy......

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#29

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

CStanford

Everything in the first two paragraphs is the God's Honest Truth and if I ever look at a damned woodshaving with any sort of magnification I hope somebody brains me with a transfer shovel.

Puhh, Freaking, leeez.

Dude, Dude... come on.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#30

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

CStanford

Tom, when I need to take a fine shaving I take a fine shaving. I don't need to write a Pulitzer Prize winning Haiku before I run a fine shaving or two.

You guys: MAKE. THIS. $HIT. WAY. TOO. HARD.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#31

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

TomD

Not to worry, I hadn't imagined poetry was in your gift.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#32

Interpreting that graph

Steve Elliott

The only blade that the Norton 8000 grit stone wouldn't sharpen properly was the Holtey S53 alloy blade which must have all kinds of carbide particles in it. (Holtey doesn't say exactly what the composition is.)

Most of the blades I've honed on the Norton 8000 have attained a nice sharp edge, plenty good enough to make the stone a good final one for most kinds of work. Maybe for all kinds unless you're an edge-chaser.

My guess about the poor performance of the Norton on the S53 blade is that the abrasive wouldn't cut the carbide particles, instead just wearing away at the surrounding matrix until the particles fell out. I remember making very little progress at removing steel as I honed until a slurry started to develop, after which the honing speeded up a lot. I think the particles of carbide that had been loosened became the effective cutting medium and their size must have been a lot larger than the size of the grit in the stone.

I don't like the S53 blade because it's so hard to grind and to hone. I do like the Norton 8000 stone. It's pretty soft but does a good job on carbon steel.

Kees, if you like the edges you get from whatever stone you are using there's no need to buy new sharpening gear. Since I did my experiments there's a whole new generation of premium stones that I've never seen in person let alone used. I'm not buying any because I'm happy with what I'm using now.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#33

thanks for the clarification!


Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#34

Re: Interpreting that graph

Kees

Aha, I'm glad to hear that. Well, my finishing stone is getting pretty thin allready. I will just use it up and keep in mind that a finer stone might have some advantage.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#35

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#36

Re: But you really could, you know.

CStanford

Perfect and would be perfect printed on the thinnest paper capable of being printed upon!

Wow, bunch 'o alliteration in there.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#37

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#39

Re: Would that be...

CStanford

Oh my Gosh. Just when I think you can't, you do. One-upped yourself.

Go, David, and one-up yourself.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#40

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

eliot feldman

What is the material difference between O1 and A2 steel?

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#41

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

david weaver

Alloying elements that make for wear resistance. Good for planes, pointless (or detrimental) for chisels at any angle where you'd actually want to use them, with the possible exception of mortise chisels - A2 makes nice mortise chisels.

O1 for chisels, whatever you want for plane blades. A2 does wear longer than O1 by a fair margin and much longer than old water hardening steel that has almost no additional wear resistance.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#42

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

eliot feldman

So is it A2 hat has more alloying elements in it? This one retains an edge better, is that right?

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#43

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

david weaver

If you give it what it needs, which is a final bevel angle slightly over 30, it holds its edge better in wood. A noticeable amount. It's more wear resistant.

If you give it 25 degrees, it probably won't.

If a2 is 1 1/2 times as long lasting as good O1 of similar hardness, high speed steel is probably double again A2 in "regular wood" and many mulitples better than both in tropicals that are really abrasive.

Cocobolo that his little glinting pieces of silica in it would be an example.

I think that the chance you run across that stuff much using hand tools, unless you're dimensioning a block for an infill plane (which is what I have used it for a couple of times), you're unlikely to see the benefit of high speed steel, though, especially on a smooth plane.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#44

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

eliot feldman

So what's PMV-11?

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#45

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

david weaver

your guess is as good as mine, they don't tell us what's in it.

They say that it holds up well at shallow angles, though, so it should be more wear resistant than A2 plus allow you to have more clearance.

I haven't used it in a bench plane, though, so I don't know for sure if that's true. I have one of the irons for the LA jack plane, but I rarely use that plane, so I don't know how it's comparable on long grain where you do most of your planing.

Or in chisels, the V11 chisels are above my pay grade.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#46

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

Sgian Dubh

"... ask the question of whether there is practical benefit of "ultimate sharpening"".

In my opinion, the answer is No. I mostly watch these threads that seem inevitably to lead to the to-ing and fro-ing in nitpicking detail about steel types, sharpening, and how close to set the cap iron to the cutting edge with a sort of fascinated horror. It's akin, in myself, to the ghoulish rubberneckers that slow down to check out the multi vehicle pile up on the motorway with the attendant ambulances and police cars and their flashing blue lights.

There always seems to be so much to say about all these subjects, but I can't think I've ever been able to apply any of it in a practical time saving way as a furniture maker aiming to get stuff out of the door to a customer. I guess ninety five per cent (or perhaps more) of my plane and chisel sharpening is achieved freehand on my trusty 800 grit ceramic stone, and back to work. The other five per cent of my sharpening of either planes or chisels involves jumping from the 800 grit stone to my 'medium' Spyderco ceramic stone, whatever grit that may be. What isn't taken care of by those two simple sharpening routines is dealt with by scrapers, and abrasive paper held in the hand for odd shapes, on a sanding block for flat stuff, stuck to a random orbital sander, or on some sort of sanding machine. Slainte.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#48

Re: inevitably..

david weaver

...these discussions always devolve into "it's not fast enough for me with a paying client tied to the situation". This is one of Charles' favorite things to say, too, despite the fact that he seems to have no time to do anything in the shop, he's got time to talk about sharpening with folks who aren't paying him anything.

It's sort of like the argument that certain firearms aren't protected by the second amendment because they have no hunting purpose. You know what I mean by that?

What I mean by that is there's a false condition put in that doesn't exist for most of us. Just like there's no second amendment condition that states RTKB exists for hunting, for the vast majority of us there's no paying customer condition. Surely we'd be more concerned about time if we were making stuff for paying clients. I'd certainly have more power tools, I'd probably sand everything because it would make the surface dull and uniform and a lot of people probably like that. I wouldn't *think* of sanding something that was for me. Not unless it was something bland and commodity-type stuff like kitchen cabinets.

The discussion isn't about whether there is benefit to sharpening to a fine edge *if you're doing work for paying clients*, it's whether or not there's benefit to sharpening to a fine edge...without any such conditions.

Now, if you have time to run a chisel on an 800 stone and a medium spyderco, you are doing something that takes the same amount of time as a medium stone and a 1 micron resin based ceramic abrasive stone. IF you were finishing a surface with a plane, there would be great value in that vs. a medium spyderco. If you're not, then there probably isn't.

The finest craftsman I know, (and finest by leaps and bounds, not just a little bit) had the same fascination with keeping his tools sharp and went so far as going through various stones and razor hones until he settled on a medium and UF spyderco followed by a loaded strop as a general regimen.

I have seen warren (who also works for paying customers), describing significant effort in keeping tools sharp.

The whole "real craftsmen don't use tools that are that sharp" isn't as universal as some catchy online "grampy says" stories would have us believe.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#49

Re: inevitably..

TomD

Yeah, the subject is pretty modest, it is asked from the perspective of doubt that there might be any benefit whatever. To which the suggestion that there could be a benefit, is hardly a takeover of the other 99.9999% of woodworking.

And, I have been hired to school pro woodworkers, have worked in their shops, and socialized with some. The vast majority are crap. If they had the skill, were working in the right tradition, and had the right clients, the answer would not be in doubt. You make money around here by charging the largest amount of money for the most minor gig, that you can repeat ad nauseum. Hand planes are not even in the shops.

Can we get back to talking about ARs? Of course they are used for hunting; of course they are used for target shooting; of course they are the weapon that has the largest base of shooters trained in safe use, admin, and shooting by pros like the military; of course they are devastating weapons that could be replaced in a Newtown scenario by many weapons from the Civil War onward; of course they depend on civilians for their perfection in doctrine and in form, and as a result are the people's gun. The military was happy to leave them as underpowered guns with a poor record for reliability. As great an endorsement as that is, and to swing back to wood, I remain a longbow man.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#50

Re: inevitably..

david weaver

Yew are one of those longbow shooters!!

(who could resist a monday quality pun on a friday?)

I know two amish cabinetmakers, neither of them use hand tools, though they do have them. They just don't use them. Their shops are hydraulic and pneumatic run off of a diesel motor, and when they do site work, they have a full complement of electric power tools - they're allowed to use them as long as they're on the jobsite (and not in their own shops) and someone else is supplying the electricity).

I don't doubt that most of the folks who are making money using hand tools some have their minds filled with a lot of other stuff that has nothing to do with sharpening, but it's annoying when a question can't get answered objectively.

Sgian doesn't troll, so it's not that I expect he was harrassing people asking questions, just a matter of convenience since his post brought up the line of thought this time.

If we all took the shop argment to the limit (the one about being money driven, vs. most of us working as hobbyists), we'd have no business building anything in the first place. It certainly isn't a money savings, because there's no need for any of us to have the furniture we make instead of used furniture we could pick up at flea markets or RTA furniture and cabinets that are cheap (albeit offensive, we only really think they are because we're woodworkers - nobody else cares).