New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

Posts

Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#1

Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Let us consider two cases of practical planing and ask the question of whether there is practical benefit of "ultimate sharpening".

Case 1. Material removal- In this case the plane is being used to remove material. The surface will be further refined so surface finish is immaterial. Just to illustrate with some numbers, how many linear feet of lumber can the user plane with a blade sharpened to 1/4 micron vs 3 micron? The answer of whether 1/4 micron sharpening is of practical benefit depends on the "dulling curve", a plot of dulling vs feet planed. What is its shape- linear, bend up, bend down. Or to word another way, how many feet of lumber must be planed for a 1/4 micron blade to reach the dullness of a fresh 3 micron blade and will the dulling curves track past this point?

From a practical point of view I know of no other question of greater importance to get answered because I suspect the answer will reveal that we are over sharpening. But I don't know how to do the test.

Case 2 planing for finish- This case may be easier to test by an unbiased tester. Here the question would be how many feet planed before the finish appearance suffered. My gut feeling is that a higher refinement of sharpening has a greater chance of being beneficial in this case.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#2

Keeps us off the street corners   

John in NM

Other than that, I'm dubious that there is much point to sharpening beyond "enough"

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#3

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I use the same sharpening regimen for the jack plane that is used for rough stock removal as I use for the smoothing plane which prepares the wood for a fine finish. Around 1979 I experimented with omitting various steps in sharpening for the jack plane and found noticeable difference in both ease of planing and edge longevity. I concluded that the trivial amount of time to take a rough sharp edge to a refined edge was easily worthwhile.

As to whether additional steps are worthwhile, I think a craftsman's discernment comes into play. Sharpening is a lot more complicated than looking at a grit size. And a lot more is involved than trying out some test for sharpness. What is important is the tool's performance over the entire sharpening cycle and the worker's ability to gauge that performance. A guy can sharpen a fifty thousand plane irons, but if he is not at the same time getting feedback from use, noticing subtle differences, it is not that helpful.

There was a reference below to the "best edge possible". One can sharpen an edge with XX000 grit and have it pass all kinds of tests, but if it chips, bend, or crumbles when used to chop dovetails or mortises, something is very wrong.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#4

How dead do you want the fly

Ron Harper

You can kill a fly with a fly swatter or a ten pound sledge hammer. How dead do you want the fly?

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#5

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

jack curtis

Geesh, is there no end to this simple issue: You sharpen until the edge makes you happy to work, and you do this repetitively. If you find you are generally unhappy applying edge to wood, you figure out how to sharpen better and/or buy better edges. End of story.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#6

Easier to maintain an edge than recreate it

wilbur

Hi Bill,

I seem to recall previous conversations about this, and my reply may seem to be a bit of a rerun.

In any case, I think the wrong metric is being used in Case 1. You are proposing that the method of work should be to sharpen the plane to the degree that you want, then plane wood until the edge is dull to the point of not working well, then resharpen to the degree that you started at.

There's another way to go about using a hand plane. That's to stop planing and hone at a rate that's more frequent than the method of work described above. I would propose that in some cases, this is more efficient than the "plane until the edge gives up" method. Granted, you are stopping more frequently to hone the blade. But the total amount of time spent rehoning your blade could very well be less than stopping when the blade isn't working well at all and going through your whole sharpening routine.

Here's the illustration from Steve Elliot's website that I think best illustrates what I am talking about:


Suppose you are planing a panel and you stop after 100 linear feet. It's going to be trivial to use your finest sharpening grit (1 micron diamond, your favorite :D , 8000+ grit waterstone, strop with green compound) to get the blade back to its original profile. If you wait until the blade won't work well anymore, it will probably look like the profiles at 500 linear feet or worse. It's going to take more work to get the blade back to its original sharpness. And although I can't quantify it, in my hands the amount of work to stop and hone a blade 5 times is trivial compared to getting a blade back to sharpness when it's dull.

So the other question is whether 100-200 linear feet of planing is a reasonable life expectancy out of a plane blade. Maybe, maybe not. If you were planing a 2' x 2' panel for the side of a low cabinet with a smoothing plane that has a 2" wide blade, that's 4-8 passes over the entire surface with the plane before rehoning. From my experience, I'm going beyond that when planing a panel, but probably not by much. But the point still stands that refreshing the edge of the blade before it gets completely dull is probably easier than waiting until it gets very dull.

And for smaller parts, I think you could easily get reasonable performance out of a plane blade to get a clean surface. The desk that I am sitting at has 14" x 6" drawer fronts. That's 3.5 linear feet of planing to cover the surface once with a smoothing plane with a 2" wide blade. That's 28 drawer fronts before you get to 100 linear feet. My desk has six drawers. That's more than four passes over every drawer front before resharpening your blade.

And at some point, I'm going to want to take a break from all that planing. :D

The best piece of advice I've ever heard about when to sharpen was this: "Sharpen before you think you need to sharpen."

Another piece of advice that really is saying the same thing is "The more you sharpen, the less you sharpen."

I am most likely going to be giving a sharpening demo at the Woodworking Show when it comes to New Jersey next month. Although I am going to take a beat up chisel and sharpen it, one of the points that I want to make is that this is a procedure that is ideally done once, and that once your tool is sharp, it's far easier to keep it sharp than it is to wait to it gets dull and go through the whole routine again.

So to answer your original question, "Is there any benefit to ultimate sharpening?" My answer is that the cost of maintaining the ultimate edge is really low, and the benefit of having a perpetually sharp edge is so good, that the cost/benefit analysis will be in favor of maintaining the edge.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#7

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

david weaver

There's no difference with where I end with sharpening, just differences in how I get there.

For smoother irons and chisels, some hard stone. For stuff that's very rounded, a trizact belt on a belt grinder to generate a fresh edge and then chase everything at the end with one of the same very fine stones that's used for everything else.

The fine stone is usually a shapton 15k.

I lap the face of everything on the shapton, too, including the jack plane irons. It hardly takes extra time.

I don't know what diamond equivalent a shapton 15k is, probably half micron.

If the edge is honed well, I usually stop and sharpen a smoother when its not comfortably cutting (as in I need to apply a lot of downpressure or some other such thing).

I stop with a jack when it's no longer comfortably cutting, too, which when you look at the edge ends up being a whole lot longer wear bevel.

I like warren's description. Several times, I've foregone the routine that I like to use, just experimenting with what other people say, but I don't like the feel of a semi-dull jack plane right off the stones and the same goes with chisels - heavy work or not, I have zero interest in working through half laps with a chisel that is duller (washita and bare leather strop) than the same time I'd spend on two shapton stones. So everything gets the same stopping point.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#8

Re: Easier to maintain an edge than recreate it

jack curtis

Thanks to you and Steve and the color red, I think I finally truly understand clearance. How about "once the clearance is too low, you can't keep the edge on the wood, the bulge pushes the edge off the wood?"

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#9

rephrase the question...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Your points are all valid and I don't question any of them. For the rest, I appreciate that someone that planes regularly and a lot and who also finds sharpening a distraction or needs to make a living at planing will have arrived at an optimum degree of edge refinement for the abrasive materials they prefer.

The question lies in the first two of Steve's pictures if this illustration will make things clearer. Will the details of the edge in Picture 1 have a significant effect on what the edge looks like (performs) in Picture 2?

Or pick any other two points on the beginning of the wear profile, or any other measure of wear. To phrase yet another way, is there a point of final edge refinement using available abrasive formats where there is a diminishing return?

Or another way, would anyone know after planing half way to where one normally sharpens whether the blade started out at 1/4 micron or 1 micron diamond ( or some analogous "ultimate" grit pair for some other abrasive series?)

Or, is the finest of many(most?) abrasive formats available ( 3M paper, diamond powder, ARK stones, water stones of this or that composition, etc) finer than there is any practical need to employ( say in the panel planing you illustrated)?

Or, are there materials or procedures available to woodworkers that enable sharpening to a higher degree than makes practical sense for planing wood. If so, where is the break?

Or, for those that like graphs, starting with the sharpest edge attainable, what does the wear curve look like in the first say 100' of planing? Do ultimate edges quickly dull and then settle in to a more or less linear wear rate for a while? Or does an ultimate edge delay the onset of a more or less linear wear rate? or some other?

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#10

Re: rephrase the question... *GRAPH*

wilbur

I could be wrong, but it sounds like that underlying your questions is the assumption that it's a lot of trouble to go through additional steps of sharpening to get to that ultra-refined edge. My experience is that it's not. Let's take a basic sharpening setup: you put your plane blade in a jig, and you have 1000, 5000, and 8000 grit waterstones. If I was to set about sharpening the plane blade, I would spend the most amount of time on the 1000 grit waterstone, and relatively little time on the next two steps. In terms of percentages, I haven't timed it, but it's probably on the order of 80%/10%/10%. In terms of absolute time, once I have the edge done on my first step, it's maybe 30 seconds or so on the next two.

If I was touching up a blade with my finest grit waterstone, it's also about 30 seconds or so of honing.

Here's another example. When I turn a bowl on a lathe, after I'm done with the gouges, I'll sand out tearout with a series of grits of sandpaper, starting at 80, then 100, 120, 150, 180, 220, 320, and 400. The vast majority of the time is spent with the 80 grit sandpaper. Once I have an even surface, it's trivial to go through the rest of the grits.

So if you want to look at the cost/benefit of going to higher grits, I would say that the cost of doing so is low enough that any amount of benefit is worthwhile. And even if you go "too far", what does that really cost you? It's only the initial process of achieving that edge, assuming that you are going to maintain the edge once you get there. So that's maybe a minute of sharpening time wasted. That's not much when you think about the total time spend making, say, a chest of drawers.

In terms of your question about the wear curve, I did a quick and dirty analysis. I printed out Steve's diagram above at a reasonably large size, and measured the length of the wear bevel in mm, and plotted it against linear feet of planing. Here's the graph:


That looks like a pretty linear response, which falls in line with my thought that getting to an ultra-sharp edge doesn't carry any added cost.

Probably a better analysis would be to integrate the area marked by the red, which I wasn't able to easily do, but eyeballing the growth of the red area, I would guess that that would make the top end of the curve look worse, in that the relative amount of red added from 0 to 200 would be less than the amount of red added from 600-800. Which again supports the idea that maintaining an edge is easier than resharpening once your edge gets dull.

You mention someone who planes regularly and a lot and who also finds sharpening a distraction. I would say that anyone who is going to use hand planes needs to accept that sharpening comes with the territory. It would be like wanting to use Waterlox Original except that you can't stand the smell. If you are going to use Waterlox, the smell comes with it. I would suggest that if someone really doesn't like sharpening, they would be better off using a random orbit sander. And I bet they would spend most of the time sanding at lower grits and zipping through the higher ones, which shows that you just can't get away from this idea. :D

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#11

Re: rephrase the question...

david weaver

My sense, bill, is that around the true 1 micron level, there's nothing more to gain in longevity, especially planing. I don't know if diamonds can be said to be there, though - I'm talking about stones that are graded very uniformly.

A nod to warren, proper use of the double iron has allowed me to plane with a smoother and still get a very nice uniform surface even as the plane dulls. I can plane really until it's not comfortable at all, and spend zero time worrying about anything.

I notice a difference in longevity between a 1 micron edge and something like a stropped 4 micron edge, both in the pleasure of using the tool to begin with and how long I can work.

I don't notice a difference below that mark. I suspect the edge is uniform enough that it is going to fail by wear somewhere around that mark.

I don't work through grits. Either microbevel in an eclipse honing guide (only for the finest of smoother edges where I want to have complete control of the camber) or do effectively the same thing by hand (much more often).

Similarly, in something like half laps, with a plain stanley chisel, I get better longevity and more pleasure in use if I lift the handle of a chisel and work it for 10 seconds on that fine stone (the shapton 15k), but do not get any additional excitement by going further (there is a STARK difference with a razor between shapton and green chromium on a softer surface, but no such noticeable difference with tools).

The 1 micron level to me is significant because there is no noticed wire edge with reasonable pressure. Essentially, it takes me about as long to strop, plus minimal time working the back of a chisel.

I would imagine the process on a chisel takes a little over 30 seconds between two stones. I've played with the oilstones and a strop before (Which is effectively an edge not quite as fine) and in reality, the edge isn't as good as quick as with the shaptons. I'd like to believe that it is, but it just isn't.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#12

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and All,

With questionnaires the answer you get depends on a lot on how you ask the question. If we ask, 'how sharp is sharp enough?', the answer for most will be, 'as sharp as I usually get them.' And if you ask 'Do you think using an abrasive down to 1/4micron is too much?' the answer will depend on whether the respondent does that or not. And if you ask, 'How much dull are you willing to put up with, in order to keep from using one more stone, or strop?' there won't be any answer, because the question will be considered rude or impertinent :) .

'Ultimate sharp' is undefined, isn't it? It's like the number Pi--no one can say exactly the value of Pi because like all irrational numbers it is endless. A mathematician would say it's bounded but unlimited. Sharp is too. There is a theoretical bound, but no practical limit that can be demonstrated. As one of the Headley's said somewhere, 'If anything can be sharpened, it can be made sharper.' He was talking about sharpening fret saw or scroll saw blades, I believe.

If you ask me, 'how sharp is too sharp?', I think it all depends. I don't think a paring chisel can be too sharp, or a carving tool either. But then once you develop a procedure for the most demanding tool, then why not apply the lessons to other blades? Learning is endless.

How many different Bach recordings are enough? For me, it's one more than what I already have, and I'm always on the lookout for that one.

Wiley

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#13

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

TomD

1) I am not sure you have adequately defined what is ultimate. For me, ultimate sharpening is the point where the sharpening routine starts to break down and requires some of the following: a) power; b) a very long time to buff out all underlying scratches to move to the next grit, or get full benefit from the final grit; c) magnification and a d) jig to have any hope of reaching the goal.

2) I do think you have a point as to whether there is some breakdown between planing styles. I don't know anyone who takes a moulding plane to 20000 grit, and yet it is a final finish pass, and could conceivably benefit. There comes a point of diminishing returns that is based not on the work, but on the difficulty of sharpening certain profiles. In your roughing example, I would probably have a problem getting the roughing blade ultimately sharp as it would probably be a curved blade.

A professional example to satisfy you would be Toshio Odate. He had an actual apprenticeship, in a craft where the final finish is hand planed. A while back, he tried to deal with the profile and ultimate sharpness issue by developing special cambered diamond stones. They were too expensive for me to care, but it seems to make the point on edge geometry and ultimate sharpening possibility, and one might also say, on the need for all that.

3) I think species of wood is major in this analysis. For some uses, like rough planing pine the blades last and last. But on Maple they would not last well at all, and end grain maple worse still. There are many more challenging woods.

As an example of how the orthodoxy can be necessary, I once made some plane blades in the winter. I heat treated them out of doors, and got some random results. It's funny that a 50 degree difference in ambient temperature can so mess things up, I knew what to watch for. Some of you may remember I bought a Rockwell testing machine at one point, so I do try to keep to tolerances. Anyway, one of these blades saw a lot of use and eventually I ran into a heavy knot with it, and it felt like hitting a nail, when I looked at the blade, the rounded end had bent, indicating it was never properly hardened. Oops. I still use that plane, and it does not really create unusual problems. So sharpening and hardness, hard to know at times.

4) With planes, picking up on what W. was saying, how fast a plane cycles can be a major factor on how it can be sharpened, and whether it can be honed, or needs to be sharpened from scratch each time.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#14

Re: rephrase the question...

TomD

"Or, for those that like graphs, starting with the sharpest edge attainable, what does the wear curve look like in the first say 100' of planing? Do ultimate edges quickly dull and then settle in to a more or less linear wear rate for a while? Or does an ultimate edge delay the onset of a more or less linear wear rate? or some other? "

I don't know the answer to that, but I have been party to the thought, and the discussion, where people say that ultimate sharpening significantly extended edge wear, and I have certainly seen cases where it did not seem to help much. In my mind, without a lot of evidence, the degree to which the cut was a scrape vs, a cut has some bearing on this. I think there are a ton of factors, so I do not even know how a test could be designed. In some limited scenario like improving the performance of a razor, maybe.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#15

Re: effect of initial sharpness on edge retention *LINK*

Lars Parrington

"Or to word another way, how many feet of lumber must be planed for a 1/4 micron blade to reach the dullness of a fresh 3 micron blade and will the dulling curves track past this point?"

check out this chart of steve elliot's. to me it suggests that an initially sharper blade can retain it's edge better that an intially not-as-sharp blade. the initially sharper blade keeps performing better even after it has been dulled to the same level as the not-as-sharp blade.


img

http://www.bladetest.infillplane.com/html/initial_sharpness.html

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#16

Re: effect of initial sharpness on edge retention

Kees

Well, that Cherry chart is going to cost me dearly. It looks like my 8000 stone isn't "cutting" it anymore. It's a Naniwa superstone and I was always pretty pleased with it. But in the name of research it'll have to go :(

What 1 micron waterstone would be a good buy? Not too expensive hopefully?

And do you go straight from the 1000 stone to the 1 micron stuff, like I do mostly with my Naniwa?

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#17

Something comletely different: stropping.

Kees

That chart from Steve always makes me wonder why people like a strop so much. What does a strop do to the bevel, round it over a bit like the wear patterns in this graph? Won't you loose clearance when using a strop?


img

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#18

Re: effect of initial sharpness on edge retention

david weaver

I do, as long as the 1 micron stone is a strong one, no problem, just lift the handle or the bevel a little bit on the final few strokes if you feel it takes too long.

Shapton pro (not glass!!) cream / 15k or sigma power 13k (without base, or with if you don't mind a few extra bucks). The former is faster (1.2 micron), the latter is finer (0.73 micron). The former is harder, the latter is more forgiving.

Given the recent intentional weakness in the yen, I'd say stu tierney (toolsfromjapan.com) is your guy.

I'm glad to see a chart like that, I'm not imagining it when I see a 3 or 4 micron stone edge last less long on a smoother.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#19

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

CStanford

I have a Marples razee Jack (Marples & Sons Hibernia Works iron) that only sees medium and fine synthetic oilstones and am absolutely convinced that going to a finer stone (a hard black Ark for me) does not really do that much in terms of extending time between honings. These two stones sit out in the fresh air on a board. I easily raise a distinct, scratchy burr in about four strokes on the medium stone, take six or eight more on the fine, rub the back ONCE on the fine stone, and back in the plane. That's it. I'm a big believer in removing bluntness and moving on. Burr raised=bluntness gone. I'd expect to get twenty to thirty minutes of continuous, hard planing (rapid stock removal) on red oak, white oak, ash with the iron so treated.

I couldn't possible tell you how long the iron in my smoother lasts. I rarely take more than two or three passes all the way across a workpiece before I call it done. Anything I notice after that sees a scraper. Can't plane forever unless you like a lot of out of dimension workpieces or you start with 5/4 rough stock to produce 3/4 finished, blasphemy that I bet happens more than I'd like to think it does. I never have a board on the bench that is not being planed to a finish line unless I'm just squaring up something to turn between centers and sometimes even then I am.

At the end of a the day, I'll be damned if I'm going to remove an eight of an inch of stock a thousandth at a pass just to convince myself I know how to tune a plane and sharpen a cutter. I'd rather gouge my freaking eyeballs out than dance around ankle deep in shavings a half a thousandth of an inch thick or whatever the bloody standard is supposed to be now. Fluffy shavings my foot. If 75% of what I put on the floor isn't thick enough to stub a toe on I'm just doing some candy-a$$ed imitation of hand tool woodworking.

Cheery-O!

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#20

Re: Something comletely different: stropping.

david weaver

If it's hard like on MDF, you can use it like a stone. IF it's bare and soft, it does a nice job of ripping off stuff that shouldn't be on the edge.

Other than that, I agree. A fine stone is a one-time expense and affords a lot more control.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#21

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

TomD

You are overstating your case. I am all for planes that take a heavy shaving, and still see them as an under-served segment. But that said, there is plenty of serious work that involves fine shavings, and where your gonzo approach is not going to get it done.

Moving along, one of the problems with the resharpen paradigm is that few people are actually ultimate sharpening for crude work. Normally they ultimate sharpen, to some degree, for fine work, and with fine work, you can't extend the edge, it is going to need refreshing as often as a coarser cutting plane does. If you are trying to get 4/10000 shavings, you are going to have to resharpen before it drops down two grits.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#22

I didn't ask any of these questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What I asked, to word it yet again, is whether you will get significantly more edge life from an edge sharpened to the limit of what is available in a particular abrasive format, or whether the feet of lumber planed (to pick some metric) will be about the same because that ultimate edge dulls to the next best increment after 3 feet (to pick some number).

Or to word it yet another way, I take two identical planes and refined one edge to 1/4 micron and the other to something bigger - 1 or 3 - (or pick what ever abrasive format you wish, stones 3M film etc) and then planed 50 feet of lumber . Then I handed you each plane and you planed with each until you thought it was in need of touching up. Would you detect a significant difference between the two planes' edge life?

Or, yet again....How quick does the ultimate part of the ultimate edge dull and does it dull different from one less refined.

Elliot's work shows that dulling is loss of metal that results in loss of clearance. We re-sharpen when we feel the unacceptable effects of this loss of clearance. I don't see the benefit of ultimate edginess for this model of dulling.

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#24

Re: I didn't ask any of these questions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

Your question interests me in an academic way. Although controlling the variables would be difficult though, especially 'what wood', 'what included angle', what 'effective planing angle', and so on.

But what's it all about? Wilbur prefaced his remarks above to say that the OP question presumes there is some significant barrier to getting sharper. He then by example explains that the final degrees of sharpness are costing 10 seconds of time on the stone or strop. What is the virtue in avoiding that 10 seconds?

I tried to construct a couple of metaphors to suggest that when doors are open to us, why not walk through them?

Wiley

Re: Is there benefit in "ultimate" sharpening?

#25

Re: I didn't ask any of these questions

Lars Parrington

i think bill is asking whether there is a benefit to sharpening beyond what we would normally consider fine (i.e. 8000 grit or 1 micron).

this is a different question then whether one should stop at 1000 grit; the question which some of you seem to be answering.

while it may be trivial to go from 1000 to 8000, there is a point at which it becomes non-trivial to go finer.