Re: good data...I like good data
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hello Bill and all,
"You seem to have a good semiquantitative test. Prepare an ultimate edge. Plane 10' and compare to 1 micron."
You're being very kind to my extremely unscientific effort. Here's where we need to have a discussion: Using Steve Elliott's method, one could start with a 1/4u blade, say, and a 1u blade, each with an initial sharpness reading at point zero. Then you could in principle find how many feet the 1/4u blade would plane before its thread-cutting effort (in grams) came to equal the initial sharpness of the 1 micron blade. And then conclude something like "well, the 1/4u blade is 20 feet better than the 1 micron blade" (making some assumptions here for the sake of clarity).
But I don't think that test answers the question of the relative durability of the two blades. Because there is an assumption buried in there, that the 1u blade is just like a 1/4u blade after a little planing. And therefore they would both follow the same dulling curve after the 1/4u blade dulled down to the initial sharpness of the still-unused 1u blade.
But that is assuming what we're trying to prove. We need to know how quickly the two blades approach the point where we resharpen. If you make a horserace, the 1u blade will dull faster or slower or at the same rate as the 1/4u blade. We need the horserace. The test that is necessary, using Steve's approach, is to pick an endpoint. In Steve's terms, see here,
http://bladetest.infillplane.com/html/testing_sharpness.html
we might find that the 1/4u and 1u blades have initial sharpnesses of 60gm and 66gm, respectively, and the endpoint where we would resharpen is 110 gm. If the two dulling curves converge before 110gm, we would say the initial sharpness difference mattered not. And if the two blades got to 110gm after different feet planed, then we have a data point given that steel, that included angle, that attack angle, that wood. The 1/4u blade either lasted X feet longer. Or perhaps for some reason it broke down Y feet sooner than the 1u blade, and actually lost ground. Can't know without doing the work.
Maybe Steve has such data. The key point though is that the 1u blade cannot be assumed beforehand to be a slightly duller 1/4u blade. This depends upon the mechanism for blade dulling, which we don't know; it's been argued here a few times. What we want to know is which blade, the 1/4u or the 1u, will plane the most feet on the way to the resharpening value we pick (110gm in the above example). Both blades have to be tested to the endpoint. In my opinion, of course. Wonder if Steve has figures on this....
Wiley