New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Diamond sharpening - questions

Posts

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#51

Re: Real or not is there any benefit

david weaver

For woodworking, I'd say there's no practical difference...pretty definitively I'd say that. For shaving, there's a fair difference between the two, but both can give a comfortable shave.

The powder on balsa is just about magic with razors - just about. It is just above the weeper limit, but still comfortable. Below the weeper limit is where any small bump on your face doesn't get cut off by the razor. Two things seem to me to be able to cause weepers. first is an edge that is not refined properly (these weepers will come with razor burn) and second is weepers that leave no razorburn, a smooth edge that is extremely sharp. The second isn't undesirable, you can avoid the weepers with technique.

I would imagine tools would beat up a balsa strop. I wouldn't dream of touching my razor strop with a tool - if it left a piece of wire edge in the strop, it would ding up the edge of a razor, the bevel on razors is too thin to tolerate any mickey mousing around.

(none of these are things I generally do ever with woodworking tools. Once in a while, If I dump chisels, especially parers, I'll do the edge and finish it with green chromium oxide powder just to get a rise out of the buyer).

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#52

Re: Sources for Chromium Oxide

david weaver

i would buy the cheaper stuff, too. It'll be 20 years before I get through my 3 or four ounces of powder, though.

Someone using it on more than razors would go through it faster than I do.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#53

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#54

Well, that GREEN's better be good!

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Just cost me $33 (Canadian dollar is almost exactly at par) at Woodcraft... Just felt like I've been had... $23 for shipping? Man...

DC

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#55

Re: There's green and then there's GREEN

TomD

One can dye wax, I would want something more positive than that to base it on.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#56

Re: Well, that GREEN's better be good!

TomD

I haven't gone to woodcraft for about 10 years. I buy stuff off ebay when they offer shipping, some places have free shipping. I am particularly lucky to have an internet friend who consolidates stuff and sends it up to me in boxes. No reason why he would do this. We met once, and he did not seem impressed, which was a bit of a surprise I have to say. But he has stuck with me none the less. He has acted as a patron to a few well known woodworkers, which does not apply to me, but I guess he just likes to help woodworkers. So if you can find someone like that...

So based on David's recommendation here, I will probably order a stick of that stuff delivered to NY for about 23 bucks, and at the margin the shipping and tax will be free.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#57

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#58

Hey, don't worry about it!

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I'd rather get the info, I decided to buy, not your fault!

Keep the good info flowing!

DC

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#59

good data...I like good data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I see the same thing on my skinning knife. Here "ultrasharp" does have a meaningful and lasting benefit for effortless hide removal. When I strop my CPM 3V blade on chrome it cuts with less effort. Skin connective tissue does not dull it quickly so the benefit lasts for several animals unless I start cutting against bone. A carbon steel knife edge (Ruana) lasts several animals less.

So, I am not denying a detectable effect of "ultrasharpening" What I am wondering about is how long the benefit lasts on wood. It would seem that it does not take much wear for 1/4 micron to get to 1 micron equivalent.

You seem to have a good semiquantitative test. Prepare an ultimate edge. Plane 10' and compare to 1 micron.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#60

BTW...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Also got the 0.3 powder from Amazon (better deal on shipping too) :D

No sweat, it's not like I won't be able to eat tomorrow (actually I could use skipping food for a few days) :)

Your help is truly appreciated!

DC

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#61

Re: good data...I like good data

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Bill and all,

"You seem to have a good semiquantitative test. Prepare an ultimate edge. Plane 10' and compare to 1 micron."

You're being very kind to my extremely unscientific effort. Here's where we need to have a discussion: Using Steve Elliott's method, one could start with a 1/4u blade, say, and a 1u blade, each with an initial sharpness reading at point zero. Then you could in principle find how many feet the 1/4u blade would plane before its thread-cutting effort (in grams) came to equal the initial sharpness of the 1 micron blade. And then conclude something like "well, the 1/4u blade is 20 feet better than the 1 micron blade" (making some assumptions here for the sake of clarity).

But I don't think that test answers the question of the relative durability of the two blades. Because there is an assumption buried in there, that the 1u blade is just like a 1/4u blade after a little planing. And therefore they would both follow the same dulling curve after the 1/4u blade dulled down to the initial sharpness of the still-unused 1u blade.

But that is assuming what we're trying to prove. We need to know how quickly the two blades approach the point where we resharpen. If you make a horserace, the 1u blade will dull faster or slower or at the same rate as the 1/4u blade. We need the horserace. The test that is necessary, using Steve's approach, is to pick an endpoint. In Steve's terms, see here,

http://bladetest.infillplane.com/html/testing_sharpness.html

we might find that the 1/4u and 1u blades have initial sharpnesses of 60gm and 66gm, respectively, and the endpoint where we would resharpen is 110 gm. If the two dulling curves converge before 110gm, we would say the initial sharpness difference mattered not. And if the two blades got to 110gm after different feet planed, then we have a data point given that steel, that included angle, that attack angle, that wood. The 1/4u blade either lasted X feet longer. Or perhaps for some reason it broke down Y feet sooner than the 1u blade, and actually lost ground. Can't know without doing the work.

Maybe Steve has such data. The key point though is that the 1u blade cannot be assumed beforehand to be a slightly duller 1/4u blade. This depends upon the mechanism for blade dulling, which we don't know; it's been argued here a few times. What we want to know is which blade, the 1/4u or the 1u, will plane the most feet on the way to the resharpening value we pick (110gm in the above example). Both blades have to be tested to the endpoint. In my opinion, of course. Wonder if Steve has figures on this....

Wiley

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#62

Re: good data...I like good data

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been pestering Steve to get these data for 5 or more years. I don't think he has enough faith in his string test to do the work and not enough resolution with the microscope to detect the differences. Your quick and dirty would shed some light. Hell, if the effect is not obvious it would not be significant. You can readily tell if the 1/4 edge has rapidly dulled. However, you will be measuring a different sharpness than what we believe to be important in planing.

Given what we now believe is the significant dulling mechanism, namely wear off the bottom of the blade resulting in loss of clearance, it seems certain that a 1/4 micron blade (to pick any starting point) wears the same as a 1 micron. The only question is how quick the 1/4 micron gets to the same place as the 1 micron. Less than 10' is my bet which is why you don't see professional shops obsessing about sharpening.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#63

Re: Well, that GREEN's better be good!

david weaver

Just get the powder instead and mix it with mineral oil and put it in a bottle. Make it as pasty as you can and use it sparingly.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#64

Re: BTW...

david weaver

hah...I see you already took care of it. :b

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#65

Re: good data...I like good data

david weaver

Bill, you hit the nail on the head. I can only offer anecdotal evidence for planing, BUT, I have a deep pocketed friend who bought the 30k shapton stone.

We noticed no difference in surface finish on planed pieces and no difference in durability (in 0.5 micron vs. 1 micron stones), but there was a difference in surface quality between the 1 micron stones and the 3, one that you could see in terms of brightness.

I would bet that at the rate wood wears an iron, there are not many feet of planing to be had with a 30k stone until the edge is completely blasted away past where a good 1 micron stone edge is.

The virtue now is that if you're working a microbevel or a small area, the 1 micron stones are almost as fast as the older stones we used that were 3 microns, they're about the same price and there is no wire edge to deal with on anything but M2+ type stuff. And even then, you can ignore it.

I have PILES of stones, and I try to convince myself that there is no advantage to using a shapton pro 1k and 15k instead of a soft or hard arkansas followed by a translucent, but in practice there is really no doubt that it's faster to sharpen with the shapton pair and the edge is finer, even on carbon steel. To add insult, I got my shaptons cheaply, and they cost less than my good quality oilstones. With very few exceptions, the oilstones that are newer aren't even worthy of mention in the contest, especially at the same price.

There is a draw to the oilstones, the fact that they're natural and their performance depends more on skill, but functionally they're beaten by the latest round of stones, especially the harder ones.

That's my anecdotal conclusion, one medium stone and one 1 micron stone, both on the harder side so that everything can be sharpened on them.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#66

Question...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Hi David,

I seem to recall that you mentioned using the powder on balsa for putting the final touch on straight razors. What's the reason for the balsa?

If finishing a plane blade or chisel, what would you suggest for a substrate?

Thnx

DC

In the middle of a gout attack

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#67

Re: Question...

david weaver

Balsa is just the right hardness so that the edge doesn't get rounded over (like it does with soft leather), but it presents the powder in a way that it still gets good contact with the entire edge of a razor.

The give in the wood lets the powder work a little finer than something like horse butt leather (which is pretty hard when it's glued down to a flat backing piece of wood).

I like horse butt glued down in a press (with hide glue or whatever) on wood for tools. I buy the butt strips of the 8/9 ounce weight on ebay, they're about $25 for the entire strip, which is probably enough to make 6 or 7 flat strops.

Balsa would probably work well for tools, though, too, I just don't allow my tools on the balsa strop because it's the only one I have. If a heavy hand is needed with a loaded strop, then the edge wasn't ready to get there, anyway.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#68

As a reference point

Bob Hackett

One of the things I found most enjoyable about Cecil was his ability to throw the box in the corner rather than just think outside of it. He was very big on using whatever you had surrounding you to proof an idea and then once that idea had proven itself to refine it not by referencing what others who had gone before you had done but by keeping the goal and final results firmly in sight.

Cecil`s shop was a collection used or cheap imported tools that he bought with the idea in mind that they were just a starting point and would hve to be modified (sometimes extensively) to do what he wanted them to do. When he passed he was working on a book describing his techniques to chase the refined edge using diamond. Last my son and I saw him he was using an adjustable jig made from a roller drawer slide bolted to a piece of plywood which held a cheap Enco belt/disc sander. The belts he charged with the diamond paste were home made using leather belts which came from the thrift shops around the area. The plane irons he was working on at that time were worn out Stanley plane irons with sections of HSS planer blades he salvged from local sharpening and boatbuilding shops. He cut the HSS to size with a cut off wheel attached to the disc area of the Enco sander and then brazed the section on to what was left of the Stanley iron usually cut off below the slot.

For his handmade (and much sought after) wood planes made from a single piece of wood (tote included) he favored old laminated irons and I was lucky enough to be given a box of them from his collection.

One of the most refreshing things about Cecil was that after 90+ years of making his way in the world as an accomplished woodworker, machinist, fly rod maker, boatbuilder and toolmaker he never felt he had all the answers. He expected to learn just as much from the person he was sharing his extensive knowledge with as they learned from him. Life was a two way street for Cecil. I very much enjoyed our time together and his lessons not only on WWing and machining but also how to connect with other people and communicate on a level which was appropriately adjusted to meet the time, place and person.

My youngest son really misses him. Through Cecil, Joe learned that the only limits are the ones you place on your time and yourself. He also taught Joe the most important tools in any shop are imagination and motivation. It was pure magic watch them work together in Cecil`s shop.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#69

Work it

Bob Hackett

I frequent a blacksmithing forum and at least once a month someone asks how best to polish the face of their anvil. The standard answer= "The absolute best way to polish the face of any anvil is to lay glowing hot iron on it and then repeatedly beat the heck out of that iron" :)

I would recommend that you use the plate you have now in exactly the form that it is in. Use it as intended and both you and the plate will refine yourselves until you both become exactly what you need.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#71

What a gift to your son

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

What a gift to your son that you introduced him to someone like that!

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#72

A gift to all involved

Bob Hackett

Such experiences become the heart of stories that, when told, influence lives well beyond the passing of kind and sharing people like Cecil. Joe uses the same,thoughtful, low key, carefully worded approach to explain how he does his work that Cecil used when walking Joe through a particular technique or process. The things I learned while watching how effective those exchanges of information were also incorporated into how I instructed others in both my military and civilian endeavors.

We lived a couple of miles from each other and I used to pick Cecil up to drive to meetings of the local WWing club as his sight at that time wasn`t reliable enough to be driving after dark. The first time I brought my son Joe to his shop I spent an entire afternoon watching the two of them work. Joe would pick one of the hand tools from the wall then Cecil would tell Joe the story and history behind that particular tool and then demonstrate it`s use. He`d then place the tool in Joe`s hands and guide him in it`s operation. At the end of the day he gave me his customary send off of "Come back any time, you know you`re always welcome". To this he added; "Be sure you bring Joe with you when you do though. I don`t want to have to go through all this twice".