New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Diamond sharpening - questions

Posts

Diamond sharpening - questions

#1

Diamond sharpening - questions

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Hello all,

I finally got myself a cast iron plate. I plan on using it for final honing only. Tools to be used on the plate will have a slight hollow grind (setup not completed yet for that).

Now I can get water-based or oil-based diamond paste, some in monocrystalline or polycrystalline form (although one often can't find through the product description). Is water-based paste bound to rust the CI surface, or is it not an issue?

I guess I have two other questions. First, I've seen listed paste down to 0.1 micron; I'd like to get as fine as possible even if it means more honing strokes, I want the best edge possible. Will this work with a standard Blanchard ground plate? Where's the best place to get the paste?

Second, in a recent thread, Wiley scared me off trying diamond on Japanese tools... I wouldn't use coarse on these tools, but would sub-micron diamonds damage the steel? I would think not, but I wouldn't mind some reassurance before I try my Imai sword steel chisels on such a setup...

TIA,

DC

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#2

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

TomD

I bought all three grits that LV is selling. But so far I have only used the 1 micron, with complete satisfaction. I use mostly Japanese tools, and I haven't had any problems, in fact I sharpen all kinds of stuff, sewing machine needles to Japanese woodworking tools. It is certainly an easy material to use.

Even the small LV tube lasts years, so it is not a problem cost wise, at least not as an entry point. I like the oil based. I learned here it is an olive oil paste, which means I can use it on metal, and on leather.

I decided to up my supply by buying some 14000 off Lopacki.com/ But they did not seem to have an ebay simple ordering system. I order a lot of stuff from people I don't know, and I like just using the paypal system, and not having to go through some account set up. So I got my 14000 off ebay, but as a result I have no idea whether it is up to the same quality. It was a lot more economical than the LV, but I still have about 80% of the first tube to go.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#3

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#4

my experience confirms all of this post

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Hollow grind- fine EZlap- 1 micron This has been my sharpening procedure for many years now. Skew the blade a bit and pull toward you and you will find the bevel sucks right down on the plate providing secure registration for free-hand sharpening.

Now I can get water-based or oil-based diamond paste........ I use oil based for all the reasons given. We have found that WD 40 is exceptional for lubrication. Use enough of it to float the grunge off the plate as you sharpen. I put the plate on some of that expanded foam shelf liner to keep it from skidding about.

You will only need a "worm" of paste a few mm long to charge a plate. Spread the paste around with finger covered by a strip of grocery bag plastic.

I want the best edge possible. 1 micron is all one practically needs, if that. Will this work with a standard Blanchard ground plate? This is what we use. There will be a breaking in period.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#5

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

Lars Parrington

i've been using the water based diamond paste (norton, from tfww) on homemade mild steel laps. i haven't seen even a trace of rust so far. i don't clean the paste off the laps when i'm done.

i've only been using diamond paste for a month, so maybe rust problems will show up in the summer, when my shop is a bit more humid. i suspect the water-based aspect makes it easier to clean the black grit off my fingers when i'm done.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#6

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#7

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

david weaver

If you use it regularly, the simple lapping of the back of an iron is going to remove rust from the surface of any plates. Rust or oxidation or whatever. Far and away the best way to take light rust off of thing is fine abrasives and stones.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#8

the Japanese connection

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Denis and all,

Denis, in the last thread, Steve Elliott came in to say, when sharpening Japanese iron, that he had had chipping on a medium grit fixed diamond plate, but no problems with sub micron diamond paste on cast iron.

I just went out and touched up a Michio Tasai spokeshave iron on 1/4-micron diamond paste. I tested the result by how well the iron slid into the edge of the morning paper. The 1/4micron diamond worked OK. My finest edge came from 0.3micron Lee Valley green paper, followed by plain horsebutt strop.* Which is what usually happens. I see now, that the offering is 0.5micron:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=33004&cat=1,43072

This is anecdotal, of course, and proves nothing, but is consistent with Steve Elliott's experience. And Thom's.

If the first rule is 'do no harm', I don't think you'll do harm with submicron diamond.

Wiley

*Finest edge short of the metallurgical technique suggested to me of diamond paste on paper--that is the finest edge I have ever gotten, but is in the parlor trick category.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#9

P. S.-- Blanchard ground plate

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Denis,

A small heads up....As you get down into the fine grits, and the edge is becoming very fine, I suggest a light hand, lubricant, and moving the blade either in circles or sideways. At least until the plate gets well broken in. It's pretty easy to catch the edge on a 'swirl' when using long straight strokes, at least in the early going. As the swirls start getting worn down, this is less of a problem. Just my experience, YMMV.

Wiley

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#10

Re:Blanchard ground plate

Bob Hackett

One thing that hasn`tbeen mentioned about blanchard ground plates is when using sub-micron diamonds you are wasting more far diamond by way of filling the grinding scratches as you charge/recharge the plate than you will with a smooth plate.

Seems like a common sense but I felt it needed to be said out loud.

Think about the function of all those blanchard grinding scratches, they are actually channels that are meant to collect/ divert the swarf created once the imbedded diamonds grind the metal away. When charging/recharging the plate the channels that aid you in the more coarse mesh diamond may actually work against you in the finer mesh as they become a place for your diamond to hide as it avoids being imbedded in the plate.

I just use more liquid to flush the swarf off my smooth iron laps imbedded with fine mesh diamond ( 1 or.5 micron). I `ve been using pieces cut from the CI tables of worn out WWing machinery such as jointers, band saws and tablesaws. I used to cut the tables up using a diamond blade in an old worm drive skillsaw. Now I have refurbished a diamond bladed brick/tile saw (dump find) and use that instead.

Diamond been berry,berry good to me. :D

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#11

Re:Blanchard ground plate

TomD

I had been wondering about Blanchard. It is a coarse surface. The piece of old iron I am using is very polished and I figure that gives me a lot more diamond standing up and cutting, and is a better performing surface.

I also have been having great results with my top grain leather strop. It is an old one I made decades ago, but never really used because the compounds of the day were not that great. But it sharpens the heck out of concave stuff. Actually, since it is dead easy to make one of these, I should probably make another one up, and use some of the coarse diamonds and see how that goes.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#12

Re: An update of sorts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I thought that Crisco would be about the right consistency for making home made diamond paste but how would one disperse the diamonds in it?

I have 25 carets of powder that I found to be inconvenient. I prefer the syringes or paste.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#13

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#14

Re: Rolling your own grease 'n' grit

TomD

Have you tried microballoons? Those are used in epoxies and make up, post it notes, etc... Easy to find. Thinking of a substitute for clay.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#15

thanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think I will mix on the iron plate...no waste that way.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#16

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#17

Re: Good instincts! Funny you should think of that

TomD

The WEST balloons are great, but I sometimes need finer, or cheaper stuff. I use q-cells. My favourite use comes from mining, is moderation of explosives. I guess when they are doing shots and pack their own explosives, by mixing in q-cells they can control the characteristics of the shot. Cool stuff.

Will be interesting to hear what your expert says on mixing paste.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#18

A discussion of how much "oil" to use

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Buried among this discussion are some comments on the amount of oil to use with oil based paste. I have arrived a the following....

One of the nicest things about tools on cast iron is how smoothly they glide across the surface and how well a concave bevel sucks into registration. These nice features depend on using enough oil and the right kind of oil.

We have found nothing better than WD40. Additionally, enough of it needs to be employed so that the plate does not become sticky. In my hands this means WD40 and black grunge floating over the edges of the plate when sharpening something large like a plane blade.


I put the plate on shelf liner to keep it from skidding and that on newspaper to absorb the grunge and oil. When done I wipe the plate and tool with a paper towel shred.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#19

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

note that this is a Blanchard ground plate. All I can say is that it works and it is not worth the price to me to have it ground smoother.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#20

You could always hand scrape it. :^)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#21

Blanchard Grind & Smoothness

Steve Elliott

Cast iron plates do wear a little as they are used and the surface of a Blanchard ground plate gets smoother. The picture below shows an unused surface on the left, a half-broken-in surface in the middle, and a surface I've used for years on the right.


The plate in the center is 1/4" narrower than the well-used plate. I want to see if a plate about the same width as my plane blades will get a more uniform wear pattern, a small point when the wear is so minimal anyway.

In use the shiny surface does have a smoother feel. When I started using the narrower plate the 1 micron diamond had a grittier feel than I was used to, not that it was cutting better just a harsher feel. Although diamond on cast iron doesn't ever get to the sort of smooth feeling of honing on a soft waterstone, it does get smoother as the plate gets broken in.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#22

Re: Blanchard Grind & Smoothness

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Excellent post by Steve! Steve was kind enough to send me a cast iron plate like the one in the photo a couple years ago. I use it with 1/4micron paste. My plate did develop a softer feel through use, as well as by working it over on 15 micron and 9 micron PSA paper on granite. Mine looks to be somewhere between his second and third examples--you can only see the swirls now in a raking light.

These iron plates last forever, and get better and better with age and use!

Does anyone sell iron plates yet? What is the experience with LV's mild steel plates?

Wiley

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#23

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#24

Thank you all very much! Follow-up questions

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Man, you guys are good! I've been reading the responses as they appeared, and as new items/issues/concerns appeared, I thought I'd let things go for a couple days before barging in and disrupting a great thread :-)

I want to apologize to Wiley for putting him on the hot seat re: Japanese steel. It was not my intent, I had heard in the past about avoiding diamonds when honing Japanese steel, his passing mention brought back those memories. Sorry 'bout that...

I ordered Lapidary Pro powder and compound in the finest grades they carry. It is more expensive, but the price difference compared to other sources, when spread over a few years make that point moot, I think...

The powder is twice as fine as the compound, I figure I'll try the powder first, but since the diamonds are friable the 100,000 grit will soon crush down to the 200,000 level of the powder after some use, am I right? I know that I'm working on a diminishing returns plan sharp-wise, I guess I'm try to see how far I can push this thing...

Speaking of powder, there was mention of Crisco or Vaseline with Chinese clay as options for a mixing medium. Since Crisco is vegetable-based (I think), won't it get rancid over time? Vaseline seems to be too thick for the task (I have no idea where to find Chinese clay, don't even know what it is), I guess I could heat it up in a double boiler then mix the diamonds in... comments? When I read that part of the thread, lithium- or other medium- grease came to mind, any reasons (other than smell or VOC content) for not trying them?

There were a number of comments about breaking-in the plate before it works optimally. Can this breaking-in process be accelerated? Like, sanding the plate down to 600+ grit SiC paper? If that's not possible (or desirable), then are there other options? As it stands, my plate looks more like the middle one in Steve's picture.

Thanks again to all, the advice is much appreciated!

DC

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#25

On getting started with diamonds, summary

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This reply is more directed to those on the side lines that may be considering using diamond on cast iron. There is no end to what could be tried, explored, refined etc. But if the goal is to get something sharp enough to use in a practical situation diamonds on a cast iron plate don't need to be complicated.

Buy a 5 mL syringe of anybody's "oil" based 1 micron paste. A typical Blanchard ground plate works fine (I don't know if all Blanchard grinding is equal). Put a 1/2 centimeter "worm" of paste on the plate, smear it around with a finger covered with a "condom" of plastic grocery bag. Add a few drops of WD 40 and have at it. This minimum approach will get you back to woodworking with the least fuss.

Over time the plate may become 5% better. It might get 10% better after some further refinement of finish. It could be possible that there will be a fleeting benefit from sharpening to a higher refinement than 1 micron. Or, it might be found that 3 micron is quicker and shows no practical difference. If by mistake one bought powder instead of paste turning the powder into paste could be investigated. The possibilities for investigating grease are endless. But I have not got around to it yet (I just bought some replacement paste ). The point is that all these variables can be explored, and maybe refined, but don't need to be to gain immediate practical benefit from diamond on cast iron sharpening.