This much I know
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Bill,
"Real green or not, is there any benefit?"
______
It depends on one's point of view, whether chromium green (real stuff) at 1/2 micron mesh will improve a fine diamond edge. David Weaver testifies just above that his face can tell the difference when the razor is right off the diamond or ultrafine stone, or whether it's been stropped with chromium green on balsa. He has said the green refines the edge.
My test is not shininess--I doubt anyone does that. I have a simple test, which is to see how smoothly the edge slides into one page of the morning paper, the warp and the woof because they're a little different
. Takes about 5 seconds to do it.
Here is a small anecdote. This morning I prepared a second iron plate, this one with 1 micron diamond (rated 0 to 2 micron range by Sun Diamond). The other is 1/4 micron also from Sun Diamond and rated 0-1/2micron range). And my worn horsebutt strop from Joel with still a little green on it. I sharpened a Hock iron for an ECE smoother (it's either O1 or A2, not sure which). The used blade wouldn't slide into the paper, though the edge felt not too bad. The 1 micron blade slid in OK from the side, but not the top. The stropped 1 micron blade slide in from both directions, and more smoothly. Then I went to the 1/4 micron plate--off that plate the edge went into the paper edge about the same as 1 micron + green. Then I stropped the 1/4 micron edge on green, and it jumped into the paper like it didn't even see it.
What does any of this have to do with how many feet that blade will plane while still pulling itself into the wood? I don't know; it doesn't prove anything; just an anecdote. But then, I don't need to know the answer about planing. I just want it to be real sharp when I'm done sharpening.
That 1 micron blade, unstrapped, was plenty good. Stropped, I think it would pass most peoples' test for sharp. The 1/4 micron stropped blade sliced the morning paper slightly more smoothly--that's all I know for sure. Steve Elliott found that 1/4 micron cut thread with slightly less effort than 1/2 micron, but he didn't strop either of those edges--they're tested right off the diamond.
Practical difference in any of this, as it applies to planing wood? I doubt it. But if there is any benefit in sharper, I want it.
Wiley