New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Diamond sharpening - questions

Posts

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#26

Specific reply

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you are worrying about Crisco becoming rancid (it won't because it has been hydrogenated), VOC's from grease (there aren't any) or grinding on the plate with silicon carbide (which will contaminate it) may I suggest postponing these concerns and investigations until you get some base line of experience using what has been shown to be of practical utility. Refinements can then be compared against this base line of experience and judged better or worse.

The practical goal for diamond sharpening is to make it as cheap, simple and quick as possible. Any refinements that claim "better" must be judged against whether they have affected cheap, quick and simple.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#27

good point

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'll consider it along with any other improvement that someone demonstrates offers a significant improvement in cost, speed or simplicity. I don't mean to be a smart ass here, but we must no loose sight of practical, nor the likelihood that this simple procedure is about as optimized as it needs to be. There is no end to the variables that could be diddled with. The risk is that a discussion of the possibilities runs the risk of confusing, or discouraging, the undecided and/or untried that aren't already using diamond on cast iron. Make it sound complicated and/or not optimized and it will be an excuse by many to not implement it.

The discussion has given Dennis several things to become distracted by. If we had just said "do this" he would be successfully sharpening by now instead of worrying whether Crisco will stink up his diamond plate. For someone that wants to do sharpening research the distractions are great. They aren't for someone needing to make a drawer.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#28

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#29

Re: On getting started with diamonds, summary

Patrick Gibbons

Years ago I bought a close out of a sharpening system that included plates with machining for the swarf and diamond of various grits. I believe the diamond is powder and the instructions said to apply the diamond and it would embed itself. An oil was provided to move the swarf. It works. I don't know why a grease is even necessary.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#30

OT can gray iron be welded successfully?

Patrick Gibbons

The gray iron plates available that David referenced could be used for making tools. I was thinking about a Preston-style router.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#31

Re: broken handplane sole = iron lap

Lars Parrington

in case there are any would-be diamond sharpeners out there hesitiating over the difficulty or expense of finding an iron lap. derek cohen has an article about this on somewhere on his website: inthewoodshop.com (note, the site seems to be down right now)

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#32

Re: Thank you all very much! Follow-up questions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Denis,

No problem about putting me on the hot seat re Japanese steel vs. diamond. At the submicron level, you won't be doing any harm. There remains the question of what sequence will give you the finest edge, which I think is your objective. This question will be answered by your own testing. I'll be interested in what you find out--I believe those Imai sword steel edges are high RC, and so my guess is that your best edge will come from a very fine water/ceramic stone, such as a Shapton 15K. It occurs to me that you might try some of that diamond powder on a hard strop like sugar maple (they got that in Canada, right? :b ), as a final step. My finest edge on the same steel comes from my best natural water stone (I don't own a 15K), followed by 1/2micron LV paper. I once checked this under 500X magnification, and it checked out there too. But I will be very interested in what you come up with, and am not at all resistant to trying something different.

Of course, none of this is important in getting a good working edge. It's just that the Japanese steel sometimes gets a person doing crazy stuff to see how fine it will get. Scott Nehring's test for plane blades, just after his normal working sharpening, was taking a hair 1/4 above the skin surface--but then you get into exactly what kinda hair you got, etc etc. blah blah yadda yadda.

Looking back, I agree with David about speeding up the plate break-in. You can check the flatness, and at the same time take the sharpness out of the Blanchard-grind swirls, by working the plate on abrasive paper on a granite plate. Suggestion: if you don't have a granite plate, get one, some of the best money I ever spent is on granite plates. Zillion uses. Anyway, use the paper ya got before buying anything else. I think 600g SiC is probably the final thing to use, though, not the first. It's already very fine for the task, and breaks down immediately to something finer yet. Suggestion: Start with 220g AlOx on granite, and go from there. You'll get an immediate check on flatness, plus softening.

Wiley.....running on, sorry

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#33

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#34

Yes, but you need to find a really good welder

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Welding cast iron requires getting the iron fairly hot overall, doing the welding, then preventing warping as it cools, or, more often, machining it. Probably not a cheap project, unless you're a good welder.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#35

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#36

@?&(&%$##@@@#$@!!!

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I was nearly done writing a long response, when I "touched something" on the computer and lost my text (or the laptop did it by itself, not sure). Same result: GRRRRRRR... Gotta start again >(

DC

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#37

McMaster Carr for plates

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David,

Good lead on McMaster Carr. I think we did the LV steel plate thing before--I just wondered what the data is.

There's no big thought process behind the 1/4micron diamond--you and Bill have this thought through better than I have. I just like to have that one go-to finish plate that will cut anything. Then I go to 1/2 micron chromium--either the LV paper or the green powder on strop (mine is an old stash from Hand American)--and it will refine the "1/4 micron" diamond edge.

I treat the diamond grit ratings as nominal, since the rating is an average or median at best. The diamond source--Sun Diamond in the Bay Area--puts the range on the 1/4 micron from 0 to 1/2micron. To me, that translates as 1/2 micron. The diamond punches above its weight anyway, so I like to refine the edge left by the diamond, just as you do, with the chromium green.

To reset the primary bevel, if Shapton 1500 won't do, I go back to Tormek and grind a new edge, then the diamond plate, then green. For Japanese blades...well, it depends which one. But mostly I prefer water stones, then green.

Thanks for the help!

Wiley

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#38

try to find it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Happens to me frequently when I am fumble fingering a long WC post. . I think it is some key near "L" plus maybe shift. I would love to be able to disable it.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#39

Back at it... You guys must think I'm crazy...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

And you would be mostly right :D

Bill is right about over-complicating what is supposed to be a simple, very effective, sure-fire method to get a very sharp edge with the minimum fuss.

So, for those wishing to try sharpening with diamonds, disregard my "Tim Taylor" search for the limit of sharpness, which is probably 1. overkill and 2. inefficient. Follow Bill's recipe: take a CI surface, spread a little bit of 1 micron diamond paste, and hone away.

I just have the itch to see how far I can go. I fully realize that I walk into the realm of diminishing returns... At worst I will have lost a bit of time and money...

I purchased two different grits because the finest one came only in powder form, just in case I failed in making a paste that works (or the grit is just too fine) I have a backup with the paste.

Now I have the impression that I need to polish my plate because the grit is too fine and will hide in the valleys of the Blanchard grind. If I recall correctly Bill mentioned that I would contaminate the plate if I tried to polish it with silicon carbide paper (my idea was that, since SiC breaks down in use I would be safe), this is something I would really want to avoid... What should I use to polish the plate?

Back later, kids want to eat ;)

DC

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#40

Re: try to find it

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

I don't know what happened, it's like a couple windows opened up that show HTML code for what, editing? Should've taken a screen shot...

DC

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#41

Re: Cecil Pierce used plane soles back in 1992...

TomD

"The woodworking community owes much to Pierce for bringing final honing with diamond paste to the forefront."

He didn't I don't think very many took any notice, and I am perplexed at his mention of knifemakers. In any case the honour is apparently lost further back than that.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#42

Re: China clay — links repaired

TomD

I think it would be a great service to mankind if the essential and wonderfu info in there could be distilled, made into a recipe and planted in the articles section. There is a lot of toing and froing in the advice. We need to know:

- What grit

- What brand of commonly available Vaseline

- What proportions, to make the stuff we want as opposed to the instructions given which are for the stuff we don't want.

- If clay is wanted, is it the same as Kaolin, and are the ebay sources any good.

- If clay is not wanted, then forget about it.

- Etc...

I know when the time comes to actually do it, in a few years time something as valuable as that, that you have at your fingertips, would be very useful in the articles.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#43

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#44

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#45

plate refinement

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't subscribe to the notion that the Blanchard ground plate needs any further refinement. You have an opportunity to test if you first try it as received. If it won't grind then either it is too rough of 1/4 micron is too small to be useful.

But, if you wish to explore the benefits of further polishing then do it with an abrasive that is fixed to some substrate or sintered such that this abrasive stays put and doesn't transfer to the plate where it can embed just like the diamond. The 3M films come to mind. But I'll bet that it is easy to wind up with a plate that is less flat.

Silicon carbide is readily crushed which is why it is a poor abrasive for hard tool steels. But, how much rubbing will it take to crush what ever is left stuck in the cast iron to less than 1 micron and how will you know when you get there? The problem with the crushing presumption is that the difficulty of crushing gets greater as the particle size gets smaller. This fact is why very fine silicon carbide is effective for polishing hard steel, where as larger grits suffer short life (and sea sand stays about the same size).

The bottom line is that if the diamond was 15 micron I have no doubt any silicon carbide would be crushed past this size. But for 1/4 micron, who knows and how could you tell if the resulting plate was charged with 1/4 micron diamond or some mix of diamond and silicon carbide.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#46

Real or not is there any benefit

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Not using this stuff I can only presume that the chisel bevel looks more shiny after using the chrome than is the case with 1/4 micron diamond ( or what ever the diamond equivalent). In the case of sharp, looks are deceiving. I suspect that reflection of light off the surface has little to do with sharpness. Given that even the best of this stuff is rich in aluminum oxide, as far as removing material goes why not just stop at diamond?

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#47

Re: Hand American

david weaver

Hand american still sells the real green stuff, and it's cheap! Well, now they don't sell it directly, but star shaving sells it.

The company who makes those sticks that LV, rockler, woodcraft, TFWW use...they do make green sticks that are primarily chromium oxide.

At the same time, I believe that theirs issard also promotes some sticks that a few razor makers use. I'd rather just have the powder, but woe be to the person who would ever accidentally drop an open bag.

At any rate, the edge it makes on a razor makes me dislike diamonds. Despite all of the legendary talk of different natural finish stones, I still haven't found one that can't be improved by quite a bit using green chromium powder on balsa. Clean strops are absolutely essential with a razor, though. What is an annoyance on a chisel can be absolute disaster on a razor.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#48

Re: Hand American

Patrick Gibbons

David, I have Hand American's corian base with their leather on top that I put the green goop on. The other day I looked at their site and see they don't sell direct anymore. It doesn't appear they have these two items anymore. Too bad, they're really useful.

Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#49

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Diamond sharpening - questions

#50

This much I know

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

"Real green or not, is there any benefit?"

______

It depends on one's point of view, whether chromium green (real stuff) at 1/2 micron mesh will improve a fine diamond edge. David Weaver testifies just above that his face can tell the difference when the razor is right off the diamond or ultrafine stone, or whether it's been stropped with chromium green on balsa. He has said the green refines the edge.

My test is not shininess--I doubt anyone does that. I have a simple test, which is to see how smoothly the edge slides into one page of the morning paper, the warp and the woof because they're a little different :) . Takes about 5 seconds to do it.

Here is a small anecdote. This morning I prepared a second iron plate, this one with 1 micron diamond (rated 0 to 2 micron range by Sun Diamond). The other is 1/4 micron also from Sun Diamond and rated 0-1/2micron range). And my worn horsebutt strop from Joel with still a little green on it. I sharpened a Hock iron for an ECE smoother (it's either O1 or A2, not sure which). The used blade wouldn't slide into the paper, though the edge felt not too bad. The 1 micron blade slid in OK from the side, but not the top. The stropped 1 micron blade slide in from both directions, and more smoothly. Then I went to the 1/4 micron plate--off that plate the edge went into the paper edge about the same as 1 micron + green. Then I stropped the 1/4 micron edge on green, and it jumped into the paper like it didn't even see it.

What does any of this have to do with how many feet that blade will plane while still pulling itself into the wood? I don't know; it doesn't prove anything; just an anecdote. But then, I don't need to know the answer about planing. I just want it to be real sharp when I'm done sharpening.

That 1 micron blade, unstrapped, was plenty good. Stropped, I think it would pass most peoples' test for sharp. The 1/4 micron stropped blade sliced the morning paper slightly more smoothly--that's all I know for sure. Steve Elliott found that 1/4 micron cut thread with slightly less effort than 1/2 micron, but he didn't strop either of those edges--they're tested right off the diamond.

Practical difference in any of this, as it applies to planing wood? I doubt it. But if there is any benefit in sharper, I want it.

Wiley