New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

Posts

Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#1

Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

roger lance

I've just begun the process of working stock for a simple dining room table....and I'm using my LV scrub plane for the first time to take down those high spots before taking the board to the power jointer. My initial impression of the scrub plane is that it is a wonderful tool....it takes care of removing stock quickly....I'm liking it a lot....and there are some BU planes in the drawer awaiting their trial runs which are scheduled for later in the project....should be a fun build....


thanks for looking.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#2

scrub planes are useful tools

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

There are some who argue that they're "carpenter's tools," a phrase that carries with it a certain amount of disdain. But I like mine (a Stanley). Another of those tools that may sit by quite a lot, waiting; but that makes a big speed difference when I need it.

Some time, I want to try the modified jack approach - a jack plane with serious camber on the iron and a very open mouth - to see how it compares with the scrub. But it's one of many, many little projects on the list, so it may be a long some time.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#3

Re: scrub planes are useful tools

roger lance

Before this scrub, I used a jack with admittedly a small camber.....there's no comparison to the scrub.....every time I have a project, I go through this sequence of stock preparation so the scrub will see use.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#4

A carpenter's tool ??.....

roger lance

Having grown up as a carpenter's son....and having spent a long, long time around home construction, I can only think of a very limited use of a scrub plane by carpenters and that was to give beams the appearance of being hand hewn in homes where that look was desired.....where else might a carpenter make use of this tool ?

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#5

Re: A carpenter's tool ??.....

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The people who say that are probably thinking of lining walls or reducing lumpy framing members (such as when you have several studs stacked next to each other, and one sticks out a little in the middle) - stuff that, nowadays, a carpenter would use a power plane for.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#6

Michael Donaldson

Re: scrub planes are useful tools

Michael Donaldson

I use have two Stanley #5's. One has a straight iron and tight mouth, the other has a wide mouth and seriously cambered iron. I have used my 'Big Mouth Jack' quite a bit and really like it. When I was making my work bench, I used it to remove a lot of material from part of the top before I glued it together. I liked that I could really hog off the wood and still keep things flat. Never used a scrub.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#7

I don't understand the need...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This style of plane is one I use a lot for quickly mowing off parts that need mowing off. I bought a $20 #5 and ground a major camber on the blade. Seems to do anything I have asked of it. That said, I have never used a "real" scrub plane. I convinced myself that there was no need to buy this specialized tool. Is there a capability that a "real" scrub plane has that a modified cheap plane lacks?

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#8

Re: I don't understand the need...

Lars Parrington

i haven't tried out such a modified #5, but i can imagine some advantages of the real scrub, none of which are really that important.

-- the real scrub plane takes up less real estate on your shelf or toolbox.

-- it's much lighter, which could be nice if you're using it a lot.

-- the iron is the right width for the task, there would be some extraneous metal on the jack plane's iron to sharpen away each time.

i picked up an old stanley scrub at an auction back in august. it makes me smile every time i use it. the speed at which it removes material is sooo satisfying.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#9

What I observed....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

is that it cuts just as well right off the grinder as it does with a more refined edge. I can't remember when I last sharpened it. If all my planes were this immune to sharpening angst I would likely employ them more often.

Although Warren dismisses this application I use it regularly to begin to remove twist before power jointing a reference face. Next most common is a step between draw knife and coarse plane.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#10

Re: I don't understand the need...

roger lance

Well it may just be a want more than a need.....today was the first time ever that I've used a scrub....and like Lars, it put a smile on my face.....and it satisfies my question of "will I use it?".....so it stays.....having driven the same pickup truck for 26 years, I don't understand why people need a new one....but that sure hasn't stopped the world from selling a lot of trucks each year.....I bet they keep on making scrub planes too.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#11

Re: Mine's a....

Edward in Vancouver

Beat up "handyman" #4 with some serious camber to the iron. Can't see myself buying a new scrub, but if I ever saw one at a flea market, yeah sure, I'd pick it up.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#12

Re: I don't understand the need...

roger lance

Bill....I'd guess that there is not any real advantage that a "real" scrub has over your modified 5.....but I have to admit I'm not anywhere as good on a grinder as you probably are so my putting a big camber on a blade would probably not go all that well....so I'm probably better off with a store bought prepared blade....it did occur to me though that this scrub will come in handy for me when I prepare rough stock and go directly to the power planer with it instead of the jointer because the stock is so wide.....I'll be using the scrub and then follow that with my old 5 with the slightly cambered blade which will help flatten the rough surface left by the scrub.....ways of working.....

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#13

craigd

Re: I don't understand the need...

craigd

This is why a scrub is "better" than a modified #5; taking split lumber to mostly flat, I want to be taking well over 1/8" deep cuts quickly (I can push a #40 1/2 faster than a #5), once close, then break out the #5.


Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#14

Re: Mine's a....

john sayles

There is a great deal of evidence that the modern scrub plane was indeed designed to be a "rough" carpentry tool. It was often used to size boards to width in lieu of ripping. Other indications that the tool was designed with the rough environment of the job site in mind are the absence of rosewood handles and the fact that even the sides are japanned.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#15

Does your wife know ...

Bruce McCrory

... you are turning her heat into hamster bedding? :D

I like your bench (in the pic.). Saw one very similar on a Galoot Forum site. How do you lock it to "beat down" to reasonable shape for more flattening?

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#16

craigd

Re: Does your wife know ...

craigd

No wood stove, no problem!

The bench is yet another roubo that has become so popular recently, I really like it. It is pretty light (100#), which is nice because I can move it around my small work area as needed to work on various things. I do have to chase it around when engaged in heavy plane-ing, draw knife work, etc so I let it slide up against a wall or brace my leg against a bench leg.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#17

Jack Guzman from Maine

another bench OT

Jack Guzman from Maine

Craig I love the grain in your leg vise. Is that Yellow pine?---Jack

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#18

Re: I don't understand the need...

Patrick Gibbons

Bill, a scrub is more optimized for the job. A single blade, no chip breaker, narrow width, major camber, light weight. I find I use mine a lot when a board needs to be narrowed more than a regular plane can handle with alacrity. It's faster and more accurate than a saw. This is also the use a carpenter would have put it to before power saws were common. I think many have used a jack or a smooth that's been modified instead of using a scrub, but that's still a dedicated plane for the task. I also use a jack with a camber for flattening when a scrub is overkill. I got along just fine before I got mine but I have never regretted I got it.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#19

Good looking bench, Craigd


Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#20

Modified jack

Ron Harper

It is what I use.. An old busted up 605. I find the extra weight useful

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#21

Re: I don't understand the need...

William Duffield

They certainly have a lot fewer fragile parts to get broken if you're working in the "wild." An anecdotal example of their usefulness: I few years ago we were replacing some wide white cedar planks on a tall ship, in the middle of winter in an unheated barn. The planer was a bit crude, missing the guides that keep the sides of the plank under the cutter heads that one finds on the planers most of us might use. We were taking off about a quarter inch at a pass, and a missed wedge on one trailing corner hung up on the next pass. Luckily, I had a Stanley #40 in my coat pocket (my jack wouldn't have fit), and I quickly planed off the offending wedge so we didn't need to manually back the plank out of the planer, reset the cutter height and refeed the whole plank through again. Sure, a slick would have done the job as well, but I didn't have a slick in my pocket. And, I had no problem adjusting and using the scrub without taking off my gloves. I also put it in my pocket when I'm helping a friend make lumber with his bandsaw mill.

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#22

Re: scrub planes are useful tools

TomD

The Carpenter vs cabinetmaker thing may reflect the fact that cabinetmakers bought wood from suppliers who prepared it with Cabinetmaking in mind, therefore they did not reduce wood. This would probably only be the case in cabinetmaking centers.

There is quite a variation in curvatures where scrubs are concerned with some being pretty close to jacks, while others are radically curved. This is a plane that begs to be made in wood.

http://www.wkfinetools.com/contrib/cSchwarz/z_art/scrubPlanes/scrubPlanes1.asp

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#23

Re: Had the same plane..

david weaver

..it's interesting in a sort of shock and awe kind of way, but I don't really remove wood any faster with it than I do with any large jack.

I eventually sold mine when the novelty wore off despite the fact that I don't use a power planer or jointer.

You may not come to that conclusion though, and if you enjoy it and use it, all the better.

I personally am a bigger fan of using a low-end japanese plane ground with rank camber and sharpened on a belt sander. It works really well and it gives you a pull/push alternation in dimensioning wood that's pretty favorable for hobbyist woodworkers who aren't in the shape to plane for an hour without a little change-up.

The lack fo the scrub appearance until way late in the game sort of implies that if you're using a lot of hand tools, there might be a better way to solve the problem.

* avoiding boards that are vastly overthickness

* sawing any edges that need to be reduced by a half inch or whatever

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#24

I'm sold on scrubs

Bruce McCrory

These are testimonials that I find trustworthy. If I could, I would use a scrub plane. 8)

Re: Initial impression of LV scrub plane....

#25

Starting with firewood?

Chuck Nickerson

I never thought to do that. I know what I'm doing in February.