An older study with metallurgical approach
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Bill and all,
I wanted to say a bit about this older chisel test, and this is a pretty good place for it. Fine Woodworking used to bundle up some of its more interesting articles, and republish them in book form. One of those books is entitled 'Bench Tools', and was published in 1990 by Taunton Press. I checked, and this book is getting to be a collectors item, though there are still a few used copies available in good shape from half.com, ebay, and abebooks, for less than $10 delivered. This is a particularly good edition.
Anyway, there is an article in this book (starting p. 80) entitled "Testing Wood Chisels", by a fellow named Bill Stankus, which was originally published in FWW, March 1985, Vol. 55, pp. 44-48.
This test is interesting, because it sought to link the observed chisel performance, or lack thereof, to the qualities of the steel as revealed in some basic metallurgical tests. The author had a couple of metallurgical consultants do a destructive test of the chisels, cutting cross-sectional slices out of their blades, and mounting them for microscope examination and spectroscopic analysis of carbon content. Four variables were reported for each chisel: carbon content, hardness at the cutting edge (avg. of 3 tests), grain size, and inclusions such as carbides (present or not) and slag. 11 different brands, eastern and western were so evaluated.
Results:
1. All the chisels were W type steels (water hardening, unalloyed), except the Sorby, which was an S-type (shock resistant).
2. Eight of the eleven brands would give good service, based on edge retention. The ratings below, poor, fair, very good, excellent, are based on edge retention.
a. Sears (poor). The Sears chisel tested poor: it was made of 1050 steel (carbon content too low and no carbides), hardness 56 (too soft), though its grain size was fine.
b. Marples and Mifer (fair). The boxwood handled Marples and the Spanish Mifer brands tested 'fair': These two had good hardness, good carbon content with carbides, and took a good edge--but the edge crumbled as they dulled, the author attributing this to their relatively coarse grain.
c. Stanley, Footprint, Sorby, Hirsch, Spannsage (very good). These were all fine-grained. They were slightly softer than the Japanese chisels, and this was apparently why their edge retention was a bit less, along with the fact that only the Spannsage had carbides.
d. Iyoroi, Oiichi, Sentora (excellent). Of these, the Sentora was the cheapest, the Oiichi the most expensive, the Iyoroi almost as expensive as the Oiichi. All had hardness above 60, carbides were present, grain was fine to very fine. Only the Sentora had carbon content less than 1%, though it was very fine grained. The RC's were Sentora (60.5), Iyoroi (61.5), and Oiichi (63.5). The Oiichi was judged the best of the eleven brands.
My summary. First of all, when sample size N = 1, you can't generalize. However, it was notable to me that the RC's differed quite a bit among the Japanese chisels, and none were in the fabled RC65 category of JWW catalog fame. 63.5 makes sense to me because that's where you come out if you temper to 180C, the low end of tempering temperatures quoted by Hitachi YSS. RC was an important variable, and of course we are always told the RC of the steel we're buying. However, fineness of grain also appeared to play an important role in edge retention, as did presence or absence of carbides, and these we can't know without metallurgical analyses.
Wiley