New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

showdown of the super chisels

Posts

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#51

Re: Science and the Craft

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I do have an ancestor who got the death penalty for witchcraft in Connecticut. In 1651 a man was shot and killed by a teenage boy. It was an accident during militia training. The boy was found guilty of homicide by misadventure and his father paid a hefty fine. Three years later they decided my ancestor had caused the death through witchcraft and deservest to dye. I wonder if they returned the fine to the actual shooter.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#52

I saw it...

Schtoo

But thought it must have been someone else...

My concern with diamonds is not that they don't work, because they obviously do.

The problem is that every single person that is convinced that diamonds are the best because they cut the fastest completely disregards the idea that putting a fine edge on a blade is, perhaps, not all about cutting...

The problem with such a massive jump, especially with diamonds, is the concept of polishing a poop. You can do such a thing, but you probably shouldn't and it does not change the fact that it came from someone's back passage and it still stinks and will continue to stink, no matter how shiny it might be.

I'm not one to tell anyone what they should or should not do with their own stuff, if you want to rub it on the street outside to sharpen it, be my guest.

Just don't be surprised if I think you're a fool, don't be surprised if I don't agree with you and don't be surprised if I take issue with you if you start calling folks who don't agree with you as being somewhat dim witted or missing the obvious.

Stu.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#53

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: showdown of the super chisels

#54

Eureka!  A new polishing media!

John in NM

Finely ground coprolite - David, we're going to make millions! :D

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#55

I can see the post now

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Dateline February 1, 2154

Laura Parrington, great-great-granddaughter of Lars Parrington, announced today the completion of a series of tests begun by her great-great-grandfather that attempted to rank the best chisels, best sharpening methodologies, optimum lighting conditions for good chiseling practice, and ideal music to play while doing work involving chisels.

"This project started out just to test a few of the chisels currently available when Great-Great-Granddad - we call him Grrrrrrrrrranddad in the family to make it easier - decided to tackle the project. Someone suggested testing each chisel with different sharpening methodologies, which added more complexity and thus more time. Then he was urged to test the chisels on different woods - soft, hard, Australian - which added yet more complexity. And, soon after he started, the Great Chisel Race among the makers really took off. We blame Lee Valley for a lot of this. Their PM-V11 was bad enough, but when they introduced PM-V15 the next year, other companies felt the need to keep up. I think Lee Valley's up to PM-V210 now, but we had to stop adding new chisel steels at some point, especially after Stanley introduced the Plasma-Jet Chisel, which had the potential to render the whole test irrelevant. Fortunately, they had to pull it off the market just a year later, in response to complaints about consumer safety; I think it was the photos of tailless cats who had inadvertently rubbed against the user's legs at the wrong time, startling them into pointing the chisel at the floor, that really did it.

"At any rate, this project became a family duty, and I am pleased to announce that we're finally done. Our results:

"1. Most chisels do just fine.

"2. Different sharpening methodologies all boil down to this: you're using abrasive grit to remove steel. Each method has its benefits and its disadvantages.

"3. You need enough light to see what you're doing. As you age, you need more light. Usually.

"4. If you're cutting Australian woods with a chisel, you need at least a carbide tip, and you might see if you can find one of Stanley's Plasma-Jet chisels - they're still available on the black market.

"5. Oddly, the best music turned out to be from some 20th century band called "You Too," or something like that; recording technology has changed so many times over the years that we've lost the original documentation, but they apparently had a musician who called himself "The Edge," and this somehow or other contributed to better chisel work. We asked around, and finally found a quantum-mechanics guy who said it had to do with subatomic vibrations or something.

"We are darned glad to be done, and I can finally take up the hobby I've wanted to pursue for years, now that I no longer am burdened by spending every evening and all weekend testing different combinations of chisel, sharpening method, lighting, music, and woods. I'm going to watch every episode of Downton Abbey, in sequence, from the first one way back in 2010 right up to the current one. And, of course, they keep coming out, so I'll be happily occupied for years."

---------

Edit: I mean no disrespect to Lars Parrington here - the project sounds interesting. And I intend just to tease Guillaume and some other folk; one of the commonest problems of any project is "project creep," the tendency to expand the original goals until the project becomes unwieldy at best or unachievable at worst.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#56

Re: A new acromym

david weaver

"certain not-uncharacteristic loquacious extemporaneousness"

I like it.

I think it needs an acronym, to be used like:

"DB just injected a serious dose of CNULE"

Though that might be construed to be too close to "senile" when spoken, though we'd never confuse the CNULE for being that.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#57

Re: I can see the post now

Guillaume Dery

Point taken :)

At some point, it's jsut about making things in wood and as long as you get your tools good enough to get there, the rest is gravy.

I have to admit that my suggestion would have added a lot of time to the test but I am highly suspicious that apart from the time one takes to get a sharp edge, any sharpening methodology will work and not have any appreciable difference in real world use.

Being naturally efficient (read lazy) I figured I had a chance to pass the buck here and get someone else to prove and/or debunk.

You caught me.

Guillaume

PS: I actually laughed when I read your post

PPS: Don't hold your breath for me to run the test, I haven't even finished setting up my new shop yet (still tracking down 2 errant bins of tools))

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#59

Re: I can see the post now

Lars Parrington

i don't know whether to be proud that my grrreat granddaughter knows how to use a chisel, or embarrased that she uses such a primitve tool. where would she post the results? surely by then the hand tool forum with have moved on to a new set of arcane tools, perhaps discussing antique keyboards, or woodworking in only 3 dimensions. the future us might react to her posting of chisel results much as the current us would react to a study of which rock species work best for hammering.

hmm... on second thought, that rock species post probably would recieve some interest here...

well, in any case, it's looking less and less likely there will be any such chisel test, as unfortunately, no one has volunteered to send me any chisels to test with. still, i may go out and buy one or two just to satisfy my own curiosity. if i come up with any results worth sharing i'll pass them along.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#60

An older study with metallurgical approach

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

I wanted to say a bit about this older chisel test, and this is a pretty good place for it. Fine Woodworking used to bundle up some of its more interesting articles, and republish them in book form. One of those books is entitled 'Bench Tools', and was published in 1990 by Taunton Press. I checked, and this book is getting to be a collectors item, though there are still a few used copies available in good shape from half.com, ebay, and abebooks, for less than $10 delivered. This is a particularly good edition.

Anyway, there is an article in this book (starting p. 80) entitled "Testing Wood Chisels", by a fellow named Bill Stankus, which was originally published in FWW, March 1985, Vol. 55, pp. 44-48.

This test is interesting, because it sought to link the observed chisel performance, or lack thereof, to the qualities of the steel as revealed in some basic metallurgical tests. The author had a couple of metallurgical consultants do a destructive test of the chisels, cutting cross-sectional slices out of their blades, and mounting them for microscope examination and spectroscopic analysis of carbon content. Four variables were reported for each chisel: carbon content, hardness at the cutting edge (avg. of 3 tests), grain size, and inclusions such as carbides (present or not) and slag. 11 different brands, eastern and western were so evaluated.

Results:

1. All the chisels were W type steels (water hardening, unalloyed), except the Sorby, which was an S-type (shock resistant).

2. Eight of the eleven brands would give good service, based on edge retention. The ratings below, poor, fair, very good, excellent, are based on edge retention.

a. Sears (poor). The Sears chisel tested poor: it was made of 1050 steel (carbon content too low and no carbides), hardness 56 (too soft), though its grain size was fine.

b. Marples and Mifer (fair). The boxwood handled Marples and the Spanish Mifer brands tested 'fair': These two had good hardness, good carbon content with carbides, and took a good edge--but the edge crumbled as they dulled, the author attributing this to their relatively coarse grain.

c. Stanley, Footprint, Sorby, Hirsch, Spannsage (very good). These were all fine-grained. They were slightly softer than the Japanese chisels, and this was apparently why their edge retention was a bit less, along with the fact that only the Spannsage had carbides.

d. Iyoroi, Oiichi, Sentora (excellent). Of these, the Sentora was the cheapest, the Oiichi the most expensive, the Iyoroi almost as expensive as the Oiichi. All had hardness above 60, carbides were present, grain was fine to very fine. Only the Sentora had carbon content less than 1%, though it was very fine grained. The RC's were Sentora (60.5), Iyoroi (61.5), and Oiichi (63.5). The Oiichi was judged the best of the eleven brands.

My summary. First of all, when sample size N = 1, you can't generalize. However, it was notable to me that the RC's differed quite a bit among the Japanese chisels, and none were in the fabled RC65 category of JWW catalog fame. 63.5 makes sense to me because that's where you come out if you temper to 180C, the low end of tempering temperatures quoted by Hitachi YSS. RC was an important variable, and of course we are always told the RC of the steel we're buying. However, fineness of grain also appeared to play an important role in edge retention, as did presence or absence of carbides, and these we can't know without metallurgical analyses.

Wiley

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#61

Good: granite.  Poor: shale

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

And we need a geologist to weigh in here (oh, John in NM; calling John), but I don't think the geologists talk much about rock species, the reproductive rate of most rocks being extremely low.

Yes, who knows what will be happening halfway through the next century? But then, who could have predicted that there would be such a wealth of good hand tools being made brand-new at the opening of the 21st century? According to the predictions I saw in my childhood, we should all be using our flying cars, at least when the teleportation stations are closed, to get everywhere, and enjoying the ease of cleaning our all-stainless-steel houses.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#62

Re: An older study with metallurgical approach

Lars Parrington

sounds like a good test, thanks for the write-up. i have been thinking a hardness test would be interesting, although even if one had the machine to do it, it would be difficult to do non-destructively.

just requested the book from the library.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#63

Re: Good: granite.  Poor: shale

Lars Parrington

i suppose i should mention that i was kidding in the above post. i really don't have a very jetsonian view of the future. frankly i would be surprised if we were not still rampantly using chisels in 200 years. primitive tools are surprisingly hard to improve upon.

thinking of the nearer future, perhaps there will be a big increase in hand tool usage when we run out of oil.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#64

Correction #51

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I well remember the article. Footprint chisels got a great boost from the favorable review. #55 was a great issue but the chisel article is in #51. I will reread the article.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#65

Re: Correction #51--Thank you, Warren!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Sorry, it's too late to edit the text. Volume 51, not 55. March 1985 is correct.

Wiley

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#66

Re: Correction #51

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

And here I thought Warren was starting to number his corrections :D

Footprint has received far less glowing reviews in recent years. I'm not sure if there was a change in ownership, a change in management, or a decision to move down-market; but they don't seem to be the same chisels as in 1985.

At the time, a set of Footprint chisels went on my fantasy list. Too late now...my actual kit has bunches of old chisels, and my chisel fantasy list involves Ashley Iles or companies with names starting with "L."

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#67

I knew you were kidding

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but I agree that it's hard to improve upon the idea of a chisel. Improvements in metallurgy, refinement in shape; sure. But they're pretty unbeatable for what they do well.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#68

Good old limestone...

John in NM

Not as hard as granite but tough as nails when you have a boulder to break :D

Granite of course... bit hard to shape though.

Then there are the jade minerals, jadeite and nephrite, both have surprising tensile strength for rocks, though they are likely to be a bit expensive for a hammer.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#69

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: showdown of the super chisels

#70

Re: An older study with metallurgical approach

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A few notes. Stankus judged the Japanese chisels the best. With a few exceptions, his grading correlated well with hardness; the Japanese chisels were the hardest. His grading did not correlate with grain size or carbon content. The Stanley and the German chisels had finer grain size than the Japanese chisels, something we usually expect would affect the quality of the sharp edge. The Footprint, Mifer, and Marples had higher carbon content than the Japanese chisels.

Except for the Sears, all of the chisels could easily have been made harder just by having less tempering, so perhaps the manufacturer's idea of a good chisel did not always agree with Stankus. I have some chisels tempered around 190 C and some from the same manufacturer tempered around 225 C. I use both kinds regularly and prefer the softer ones.

Stankus used Japanese water stones (almost certainly Kings in that era) for his test.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#71

Re: I have a jade anvil

John in NM

Somewhere I have (or had) a block of jadeite from Alaska. Not the prettiest I've seen by a long shot, but it was a big piece that I was sure I'd find a use for one day :D May still be over at my mother's house, I stashed a lot of rocks over there when we moved, my wife had this annoying habit of tossing them out in the arroyo behind our old house!