New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

showdown of the super chisels

Posts

showdown of the super chisels

#1

showdown of the super chisels

Lars Parrington

all the recent talk on chisel steels has got me hankering for some hard data. so, i'm thinking of doing a little chisel testing experiment. the idea is basically to do a chopping test in typical chisel review fashion, but with a focus on the chisels that we collectively believe to be made of the best steels.

i'll go into details of the test below. i'd love to see your suggestions on what to do differently, which chisels to include or exclude, etc. but, most importantly, i'm looking for volunteers from those amongst you who own or who sell any of these chisels. i'm hoping you'd be willing to lend them to me for a couple weeks while i run the test. i don't own almost any of these chisels, so without volunteers the test cannot go forward. i promise to return them promptly, and treat them with respect.

now, on to the details. here is a preliminary list of chisels to be tested:

1.) veritas pmv-11

2.) japanese hap steel -- funmatsu-nezumi

3.) japanese hss steel -- iyoroi hss, or tfww hss

4.) japanese white steel -- koyamaichi or fujihiro

5.) japanese blue steel ?

6.) vintage western laminated steel?

7.) vintage cast steel? -- warren's recently tested chisel?

8.) control group chisel #1 -- marples blue chip?, narex?

9.) control group chisel #2 -- veritas 01

10.) control group chisel #3 -- lie nielsen A2

the vintage category is the one i know least about, so i'd especially like to see some recommendations there. bob hackett, i saw your offer about lending vintage chisels, and may take you up on that.

i intend to sharpen all the chisels on machined steel honing plates, using 15u followed by 0.5u diamond pastes. i will aim to grind all the chisels to a 25 degree bevel angle and then sharpen them with a 30 degree microbevel using an eclipse jig.

the actual chopping would be done using the same wooden mallet for all chisels, even the japanese ones. i'm thinking of chopping through white oak or ash. ideally, i would use all 1/2" wide chisels, but in reality i'll probably have a mix. so, for the wider chisels, i will prepare some 1/2" thick stock, and set up a simple jig to allow me to chop through it while always using the same part of the chisel's width.

i'll stop after 10, 20, 50, 100, 200... chops to look and test for sharpness. paring end grain pine does not seem very quantifiable. perhaps something like steve elliot's string cutting test would be a better fit here? or maybe microscope photos. i was experimenting with that earlier today. see image below. i'm open to suggestions.

image of two of my recycled-planer-blade hand plane blades, butted up back to back. the bottom edge is freshly sharpened, the top edge has seen some use, but not a ton. magnification is 75X. photo taken by holding a point and shoot up to the microscope eyepiece.


img

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#2

Re: showdown of the super chisels

Schtoo

25° with 15u diamond paste, followed with 0.5u diamond paste at 30°?

No thanks.

Stu.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#3

Re: showdown of the super chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I certainly agree with Schtoo. Many of these chisels were not designed to be abraded with diamonds. Our 19th century chisels were developed for use with oilstones; the Japanese chisels were developed for use with waterstones. If you want to get the most out of your tool you have to know your steel and your stone and your wood intimately. You have to know the optimum pressure to use on the stone, and the optimum mallet blow to use when chopping a certain wood.

In a recent discussion someone claimed that a certain Japanese chisel that was used by an expert improved over time as a result of repeated careful use. Perhaps many scoffed at this, but in thinking about it I recalled noticing that a Stanley chisel that I now loan to neighbors performed much better thirty years ago when I was using it seriously. So a few days ago I got out an old Marples chisel that had mediocre edge retention. I did some testing with it, sharpening it as soon as I noticed a fall off. Surprisingly the retention gradually improved as my testing went on.

There are many subtle phenomena like this that we struggle to explain with science. Difficult though it is, we are constantly trying to make models to fit what we observe. There is a model that a tool is sharpened to two intersecting planes and that the finer the grit, the better the edge. The reality is very much more complicated.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#4

A difficult task

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

One could dovetail a life time of drawers in the time it would take to statistically establish quantitative differences between the metals listed. And in the end many would not believe the results. I hate to discourage science but I have been in this comparison game for more than 10 years and have come to the conclusion that it is futile.

That said , with a 10X lens you will be able to easily see differences among these steels as well as establish failure mechanisms, whipping vs deformation. It is whether these differences are relevant too others use of the chisels, or whether others will believe your results, where the problems arise. Nobody will junk their cherished set of chisels based on the results. The undecided contemplating a purchase could be swayed.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#5

Wow

Ron Harper

I would agree,that for the most part, knowledge is useful. But in some arenas you can cross the line into an area of diminishing returns. If Japanese chisel X is 3 percent better in your tests than Sheffield chisel Y, when they are both honed as they should be, will you be able to see a difference in the work? Unlikely. I

I agree with Warren that it would be a logistical nightmare to properly conduct such a test.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#6

Re: showdown of the super chisels

Lars Parrington

stu, are you complaining about the diamonds or the sharpening angles? or both? oh, and just fyi, i was actually intending to grind to 25 deg using some coarser medium, and then hone at 30 deg with 15u, followed by honing at 30 deg with 0.5u. which means the "microbevel" here won't be microscopic, rather it would probably extend all the way to the lamination line.

all, please provide suggestions if you have them. i am just trying to get all the chisels to roughly the same edge geometry here, and trying to ensure they start at roughly the same sharpness.

my choice of diamonds for sharpening was heavily influenced by steve elliot's discussion of sharpening plane blades. based on that discussion, it seems that some of most abrasion resistant steels in this test may not get as sharp as the rest of the field, if a more traditional sharpening media is used. however, i am flexible, can could switch to say, using norton waterstones coupled with a test for initial sharpness.

warren, i don't have oil stones to use with the vintage chisels, however if i do end up employing an initial sharpness test, perhaps it would be sufficient to get someone to send me the vintage chisels pre-sharpened on their own oil stones.

as far as edge geometry goes, clearly there's no point in comparing chisels with different bevel angles. 30 degrees seems like a good common ground to me. the choice of 25 degrees as the rough grind angle is fairly arbitrary and could be increased to 29 degrees if that is preferable.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#7

Re: Wow

Lars Parrington

"If Japanese chisel X is 3 percent better in your tests than Sheffield chisel Y..."

then i would conclude that they are equivalent, which to me at least, would be a pretty interesting result. i am hoping this test will provide some relevant data to prospective chisel buyers, a group to which i belong. there is a lot of hype about the steels and the performance of these chisels but very little comparative data available. are they only 3% better, or are they 3X better? i, for one, would like an answer.

try as i may, i can't hope to measure a 3% difference. even if i could, who's to say the particular chisel i'm testing is really representative of all chisels of that model? it could easily be out at one end of the bell curve. who would care about a 3% difference anyway? i'd like to be as scientifically rigourous and as accurate as i can realistically be, but what i'm looking for here are gross differences.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#8

Re: A difficult task

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Lars,

Listen to Bill on this--he's being realistic, not discouraging. My suggestion is to forget 'science' for the moment. If you want to do testing, obtain three of the chisels, and a few low-power lenses or scopes (a 10X, 20X, 30X), carry out the tests, and report anecdotal findings as Bill suggests--failure mode and relative edge damage. Report these. Then carry the project forward as far as you are motivated, but step at a time, and above all, don't be afraid of 'anecdotal findings'. It's almost impossible to get beyond anecdote anyway without a Kato and Kawai type comprehensive study. And what you find out with the lower power lenses will help you immensely in your sharpening! Heck, you could do this while making a project!

Regarding the diamond. My advice is never to apply diamond to Japanese steel. The steel is very very hard. My one experience, never to be repeated: diamond will shred the edge of Japanese steel, precisely because of the 'hard on hard' effect. 15 micron will catastrophically shred an RC64 white steel edge, and I would guess blue steel as well.

Wiley

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#9

I know this will @&$()/@& some people off

Ron Harper

I have a strong feeling that in the chisel list that you show, if you take what reviews have called the best option of all, and what reviews have said are the worst option and set those chisels aside; You will find that somewhere north of 95 per cent of the variance in performance will be found in the skill of the operator in honing and using the chisel of the ones that are left.

I really believe that almost all of the chisels that are widely known in woodworking have metal in them that more than meets the needs of a woodworker.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#10

Re: showdown of the super chisels

david weaver

Warren - that was probably me.

Where I saw it was a blacksmith's comments that sharpening on a very fine natural stone increased the hardness of the edge (and he said it had been quantifiably proven). I thought that was an interesting comment on a plane iron because as the iron wears, such a hardened surface would be quickly worn off of the cutting edge.

It's one of those things where I'll believe it when it's quantified by someone. After doing one previous plane test with a modern iron, I'm convinced that an experienced user could literally plane a greater distance with ease if there is any merit to the statement.

Many things exist that don't seem reasonable to me at first, I'm glad to yield to proof. I haven't, though, found the claims that japanese irons last much longer with natural stones to be true. Maybe it's different in lower wear woods, but in medium hardwoods, it's all been the same.

I scoff a little (scoff might be too strong) at some things like that, as either sam takeuchi or Stan covington had told me they've met japanese master craftsmen who believe if if their tools are sharpened by synthetic stones, that they'll be ruined and they'll have to throw their tools away.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#11

Re: showdown of the super chisels

Schtoo

The angle is ok for the specified task. Most chisels in the list (of which I own more than half) will be quite happy with that kind of angle, and it's a standard chopping angle.

I know you're trying to simplify the sharpening process for yourself, but as Warren very correctly mentioned, you're going to sharpen some (all) of these steels with a method they were never intended to be sharpened with.

Stu.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#12

Re: You don't have to worry too much..

david weaver

..about 3% difference. I haven't ever had any chisels from sheffield that could get that close to any of my decent japanese chisels.

There will be something quantifiable, the question will just be how much real use (which is really the only realistic measure) will it take to get there.

I've always been less than enthused at accelerated wear things, like banging a chisel an inch into hard maple or something with a miniature sledge. It doesn't necessarily describe what real use is like.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#13

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: showdown of the super chisels

#14

Setting up a chisel test - ideas for discusssion

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

..then i would conclude that they are equivalent, which to me at least, would be a pretty interesting result. i am hoping this test will provide some relevant data to prospective chisel buyers, a group to which i belong. there is a lot of hype about the steels and the performance of these chisels but very little comparative data available. are they only 3% better, or are they 3X better? i, for one, would like an answer.


Hi Lars

There are a number of aspects to consider here.

The first (to get it out the way) is the nature of research - I write this for a general audience, not you specifically. Research, technical or otherwise, to be useful - read "scientific" - must be reproducable by others. This means that the methodology is laid out for others. Further, that the method used to test one variable (= chisel) must be the same for all variables.

It is with this last item that we start to run into problems (or not - so how do we deal with it?). The issue is that each steel has an optimum method for preparing the blade's edge. Some steels are recommended to have a 25 degree cutting angle others 30 degrees. If we do this, are we comparing apples with apples? We may decide to go with the manufacturer's recommendation because that is what they sell the chisels with, and that the comparison should be based upon what you get at a vendors' counter. I would support that. I know that Bill would argue otherwise, that a higher cutting angle represents a weakness in the steel. My argument would be that a higher cutting angle has pros and cons - what would be anticipated would be poorer paring and better impact resistance/chopping - and that these would be reflected in the results of the testing, per se.

The second variable, one under discussion, is the method of sharpening. Not all steels are recommended to be sharpened the same way. Whether we agree or not, we need to present the steel in such a way that it is optimised for a comparison. This was a problem area for me in the 2008 (?) FWW chisel test. I recall all blades were ground and honed to 25 degrees, laminated Japanese bench chisels and A2 LN chisels included. So, waterstones, oil stones, diamond paste or mesh - we need to settle on the importance of this and accept/reject that differences in sharpening media could in leave us with an uneven playing field.

Further, one size does not fit all when it comes to honing media. Using only diamond may achieve a sharp edge for all steels (nothing abrades better than diamond), but an important variable is omitted if we do not concurrently assess the ease at which a steel is honed on their chosen media since not everyone has or will wish to use diamond. One possible research project could simply be the steels edges under a microscope after being honed on different media.

A third issue is that with chisels we are dealing with a tool that has two major functions, paring and chopping. Abrasion resistance and impact resistance, respectively. Are the results of the tests going to emphasise both areas, or a composite score, as a guide to "best", "preferred", "winner" or "loser"? Placing this is the real world, consider Japanese chisels: bench chisels are designed for chopping, and slicks are designed for paring. Ideally, one owns a set of each type to meet the range of tasks in woodworking. By comparison, the offerings of LN, LV and AI (to name just three) are dual purpose chisels. So ... do we create three distinct categories in this research project: impact resistance, abrasion resistance, composite score?

Note that Lee Valley has done considerable testing on the above with several steels: http://www.pm-v11.com/TestingIntroduction.aspx

Variable #4: The age and use of a blade. Do we include new or used blades? There are again pros and cons. New blades ensure that the hardness of the steel has not been disturbed by excess heat as a result of grinding, but good (?) used steel may have worn past that point of brittleness which many chisels experience when new. Or we may get new and just use them for a while. How long? Then what about vintage steels - how do we determine whether they are representative of the point they started out in life?

I have two views here. The first is a repeat of something I said to Warren about 18 months ago when completing my own testing of steel types, that is, the selection excluded chisels that were not available new to buyers. This meant that vintage laminated blades were not included.

Testing completed:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/ChiselBladeTesting-5Steels.html

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/ChiselParing.html

More recently I wrote that it would be an interesting comparison, modern versus vintage steels, if only to determine whether we are moving forward with the quality of our tools, or not. This could be the rationale for including a small selection of vintage steels.

That brings up item number five: how many chisels can one have in a test before it all becomes unwieldy - 5, 6, 9, 12 .. ?? I once compared 9 different steels for Lee Valley, and I must tell you that this was exhausting!

Affecting item five is item six .... do you choose to do a "blind" assessment or not. The LV testing above was blind, that is, even LV did not know the steels I was testing until later on. They were only identified with a number, and only one person knew that (probably asked for a raise before letting others knows which was which! :) ). I think that we have no chance of this type of testing, and this then places an emphasis on the methodology for collecting reliable results.

Item seven - what does one consider a reasonable method for testing the chisel steel? I presented a method for abrasion resistance and for impact resistance in my experiments above, as well as how I collected results, but others will have different ideas and these need to be heard for an agreed methodology. The overall factor is repeatability (both for inter-tester, and for between chisels). My testing was not a good method in one respect - the force I used was not controlled for others to repeat. Having seen the LV set up, I know they controlled for both. e.g. http://www.pm-v11.com/TestingImpact.aspx

Having written all this I wonder how much is really relevant! The fact is that there is enough testing to accept how the different steel types compare with one another. Again, see the LV results. This only partly tells the story. At the end of the day the best chisel is still going to be the one that you feel a one with. That is, the handle and its feel in your hand, the heft and balance of the total chisel ... and for some the quality of the edge may come in last! Of course, where there is a tie in these factors, the steel begins to mean more.

Over to all of you ...

Regards from Vegas

Derek

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#15

Re: Setting up a chisel test - ideas for discusssi

david weaver

LV's testing doesn't tell us as much as we'd need to know to get anything conclusive from it.

We see M4 and we see O1 and A2 in it, but we don't know what the rest of the steels are and we don't know how hard each steel is, even for the known steels.

There just isn't really enough there to grab on.

If someone here does a test and compares HAP, vintage and yxr-7 chisels from makers who have been using them for a while, then maybe we'll know a little more.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#16

Re: Setting up a chisel test - ideas for discusssi 


img

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#17

Re: Setting up a chisel test - ideas for discusssi

Lars Parrington

thanks for such a detailed reply derek. i had somehow missed your two chisel reviews. glad you pointed them out. i particularly like the pictures of paring end grain pine. you've convinced me that that can be a good way of testing for sharpness.

regarding your 7 items/variables, it seems to be #2 that we are all tripping over here: choice of sharpening media. what i am hearing from some people here is that the ability of a piece of steel to retain an edge is dependent on the abrasive material used to form that edge.

i suspect there is some truth there, and would posit that it has to do with subsurface fracturing caused by the abrasives. there is documented evidence that abrasives of varying size will cause subsurface damage in the steel. the depth of the damage is related to the grit size of the abrasive. it seems reasonable to believe that the depth of the damage may also be related to other properties of the abrasive, such as hardness or particle shape. see the attached image, from this page at brent beach's website.

i am still leaning towards using diamond abrasives for this test. it seems like it might be a good idea to add a mid-size abrasive, say 5u, into the mix, to ensure as much subsurface fracturing as possible is eliminated.

what follows is a brief respons to some of the other points you brought up:

#3 -- my intent is only to do a chopping test. it is hard for me to imagine significantly wearing a chisel by paring alone over the course of any real-life project.

#4 -- used versions of modern chisels would be ideal, for having been worn past any decarburized (brittle?) outside layer. but, i'll take what i can get here. i wouldn't want to intentionally wear the chisel any more than necessary, especially if it does not belong to me. as for vintage chisels, i think it would be great to include a couple just for kicks. sure, it won't be very repeatable or scientific. if they fair poorly, not much is learned. but if they come out on top, that would be quite interesting.

#5 -- 10 chisels would be about my limit

#6 -- this will not be a blind test. it just would not be practical.

#7 -- perhaps a slide hammer could be used for repeatable impact. but in the absence of a strong push for that, i will be satisfied just using the same mallet for all chisels.


img

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#18

Re: Setting up a chisel test - ideas for discusssi

david weaver

Here's another idea, if the abrasive is questioned, you could always start off at the beginning doing a test of durability with an oilstone for the vintage western chisel vs. the diamonds, and see where that goes. I think the difference in abrasives used becomes very little if the final abrasives are appreciably small.

If they are larger, there are definite differences in edge quality.

What wiley described is common in razors (microchipping) if the razor is too hard tempered and the abrasive is aggressive.

http://jendeindustries.wordpress.com/2011/10/30/shapton-16k-straight-razor-edge-chipping-controversy/

(you may have seen this already...I've gotten excellent edges on japanese chisels using shapton stones, they're just ugly and bright).

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#19

Re: Setting up a chisel test - ideas for discusssi

CStanford

You can change the results by side sharpening very hard steels too. For something in the low 60s just a few oblique strokes at the tail end could be enough to goob it up.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#20

Re: A difficult task

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Wiley, would 3 or 1 or .5 micron diamond have the same effect as 15 micron on a hard Japanese edge? Or would the chiping effect just be smaller?

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#21

Precisely why...

Bob Hackett

I took great pains to align the horn of my anvil with TRUE north rather than magnetic north.Makes a huge difference in the wear characteristics of the tools I forge on it.

The really critical edges get forged and ground during the proper moon phase of course. The heat treating involves quenching in the blood of 7 virgins during the proper planetary alignments and I NEVER hone an edge when Mercury is in retrograde. :D

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#22

Form and structure of abrasives

Bob Hackett

The only difference I can think of between oil stones, water stones and diamonds of the same particle size is friability and durability. Diamond cuts more effectively and for longer periods of time because the particles doing the abrading retain their sharp corners longer that the alternatives. The diamonds are more likely to create sharp bottomed grooves rather than round bottomed grooves and those sharp grooves create stress risers which lead to micro chipping of the edge in the steels which are harder and less ductile. If the steel were more ductile (and less hard) then it would deform rather than chip.

Anyone else see a different reason why diamond may not be a silver bullet choice and appropriate for honing all steels?

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#23

don't you run out of

Bruce, a MN Galoot

virgins eventually? Or doesn't it matter what brand of virgins they are? :D

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#24

Re: Setting up a chisel test - ideas for discusssi

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

I don't mean to imply that all the relevant testing has been done by LV and that, therefore, further testing is unnecessary. LV is just one source.

My main intent in posting was to outline guidelines for research for those interested in becoming so involved. Research furthers our knowledge, not just about what current manufacturers are doing but, hopefully, what past manufacturers did that was successful (or not).

Regards from Hell (leaving tomorrow for LA and then Sydney)

Derek