Re: Wow
TomD
Les, when we talk about differences it gets pretty vague.
At one level, there is no difference in the work with most any chisels you might choose. If I could pick the set of cold chisels, I am sure I could find one that would never hold me back in my task of being an internationally recognized cabinetmaker, vs the best Japanese chisel made.
If I was looking at a job on a Japanese worksite, I think, even without prejudice to myself or my tools those cold chisels would hold me back significantly. Chopping dovetails is not a huge issue in the search for dominance making studio furniture, but if I was doing piece work, it would be a significant factor.
FWW did a set of test on edges, and one of the criteria they came up with was measuring the length of blade wear experienced by the chisels in the test. But think of this. As blade wear increases the footprint of the worn area increases in area, so the amount of work required to wear it also increases. This argues to me that the linear change in length probably understates results significantly. So they found differences in the order of 15%, if memory serves, but that squared might be closer.
It is fairly easy to game tests. Let's say you want to sell folks on a chisel with a lot of vibe in the shaft due to some sculpturing. By choosing the exact energy transfer that is most neutral to that effect, you would get a better responding chisel. A lot of stuff is highly frequency dependant. This would make the chisel being sold more efficient that others in the test, particularly if they were as prone to deflection. This would then bias results while the overall test would appear to be straight and fair. There are a lot of tricks of a similar kind that can be played. So overall I trust the market more than the marketing, though they overlap.