New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

showdown of the super chisels

Posts

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#26

Re: Form and structure of abrasives

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Anyone else see a different reason why diamond may not be a silver bullet choice and appropriate for honing all steels?

Hi Bob

There are a couple of reasons.

One I suspect is that diamond may abrade the soft iron in the laminated Japanese blade too quickly, leaving the harder iron less well honed. Just speculation.

The other is one that I mentioned earlier, that is, diamond works well with all steel types. The upshot is that information about the ease of sharpening each steel is lost, and that this is a very important part of the equation. M4 steel holds an edge several orders better than O1 steel, but if all you have is an oilstone, there are no prizes for guessing which you will want to re-sharpen. Re-sharpening is as important as edge holding in my book.

Regards from Vegas

Derek

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#27

Re: Good one Charlie, but ...

CStanford

See that's the whole point - you guys are gazing at the navel and missing the rest.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#28

Re: Wow

TomD

Les, when we talk about differences it gets pretty vague.

At one level, there is no difference in the work with most any chisels you might choose. If I could pick the set of cold chisels, I am sure I could find one that would never hold me back in my task of being an internationally recognized cabinetmaker, vs the best Japanese chisel made.

If I was looking at a job on a Japanese worksite, I think, even without prejudice to myself or my tools those cold chisels would hold me back significantly. Chopping dovetails is not a huge issue in the search for dominance making studio furniture, but if I was doing piece work, it would be a significant factor.

FWW did a set of test on edges, and one of the criteria they came up with was measuring the length of blade wear experienced by the chisels in the test. But think of this. As blade wear increases the footprint of the worn area increases in area, so the amount of work required to wear it also increases. This argues to me that the linear change in length probably understates results significantly. So they found differences in the order of 15%, if memory serves, but that squared might be closer.

It is fairly easy to game tests. Let's say you want to sell folks on a chisel with a lot of vibe in the shaft due to some sculpturing. By choosing the exact energy transfer that is most neutral to that effect, you would get a better responding chisel. A lot of stuff is highly frequency dependant. This would make the chisel being sold more efficient that others in the test, particularly if they were as prone to deflection. This would then bias results while the overall test would appear to be straight and fair. There are a lot of tricks of a similar kind that can be played. So overall I trust the market more than the marketing, though they overlap.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#29

Re: don't you run out of

Bob Hackett

Last time I ran out I ordered some extra virgins and now I`m all set.

Only problem is they all look like Popeye`s girl friend. :D

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#31

Re: showdown of the super chisels *LINK*

Peter Evans

Perhaps a first step might be to do a Meta study of chisel tests. By the time you had organised all the data and analysed it, you might have as good an answer as you are likely to get.

The Cochrane Institute website provides some pretty good ideas on how to go about it

Cheers

Peter


http://www.cochrane.org/cochrane-reviews

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#32

Yeah, but somebody else's navel.


Re: showdown of the super chisels

#33

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: showdown of the super chisels

#34

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: showdown of the super chisels

#35

Re: showdown of the super chisels

CStanford

Lars, do your test. Just hone them on the media meant to be used for each particular steel. It wouldn't invalidate the results one whit IMO.

More crucial would be the hollow grind, flat grind, convex grind paradigm.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#36

Science and craft

Warren in Lancaster, PA

When we tell others about a technique we use it is nice to offer a scientific rationale for its effectiveness. It helps them understand the technique and it helps them apply it. But the lack of a rationale does not suggest that the technique does not work. The truth is that science generally lags craft.

Here is an example. People were smelting iron for several millennia before oxidation reduction reactions were understood. I'm sure the workers came up with some spurious explanations for what was going on, but in fact they were producing iron and improving efficiency without scientific understanding. The science lagged the craft.

Here is another example. We often skew the plane when planing the face of a board. I know I was doing this before reading about it. We can find some scientific explanations, but a scientific formula predicting the most effective angle to skew the plane would be extremely complicated. On the other hand I have seen bright kids discover the optimum angle in minutes.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#37

There is a better way to go about this

Patrick Gibbons

One aspect of scientific experimentation is repeatability. What I would propose is not strictly a controlled experiment but would give more meaningful results. A number of woodworkers, and the more the better, would commit to putting three same chisel brands and sizes to test. They would sharpen and use the chisels in the way they are accustomed to. They would quantify their results. I would even have them build the same project, not perform specific tests. This would be, in my mind, real-world tests with more meaningful results. It would probably be good to have each woodworker make the project three times each using a different chisel. The chisels would be evaluated overall, not just its steel.

While it might be interesting, I don't know how worthwhile all this would be. But then it could be said that 100 craftsmen preferred X brand chisel overall.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#38

Steve Elliott might be some help

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bruce,

I don't know, and guessing wouldn't help. My own single experience was with a Mosaku plane blade versus something less than 15 micron on a metal plate--I seem to have shut out the key details, as it was stupid in the extreme. This was 5-6 years ago. I got ragging at the edge which was visible to the eye.

I can't be dogmatic about it. It's possible that I let the edge catch the plate, though I don't think so. The thing is, I don't want to go back and replicate the experience.

Steve Elliott might have some experience with Japanese steel versus 1/4 micron paste, as part of his experiments.

Wiley

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#39

Re: Yesssss... no!

Lars Parrington

thanks david. very interesting posts!

the diamond paste i have is the water based norton / saint gobain stuff from tools for working wood. any idea if it is mono or poly crystalline?

my understanding from your post is that it would be desireable for the 15u paste to be polycrystalline, but that the crystal structure is less important for a very fine paste like 0.5u. is that right?

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#40

Re: Subsurface fracturing is related to particle s

Lars Parrington

"Stu goes from 1,200 grit (15µ) paste to 60,000 (.5µ) paste"

what?!? he seemed pretty opposed to exactly that regimen in his posts above.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#41

Re: Setting up a chisel test - ideas for discusssi

Guillaume Dery

I think that you should consider adding a few more stones to your sling in order to kill the whole flock of birds.

1. Run the test as you described with all chisels sharpened with diamond

2. Run the test with all chisels sharpened with waterstones

3. Run the test with all chisels sharpened with oilstones

4. Run the test with all chisels scary-sharped

This would help you isolate best steel / sharpening method combination as well as prove and/or debunk the theory that sharpening medium X is the best for steel Y or at least give us some hard data on the effect of differing sharpening mediums on different steels.

Additionally, this would have practical value to many. Some people have sizable investment in their chisels, others in their sharpening media. It would be beneficial to see if ideal paring is achieved and may certainly help inform future purchasing decisions (either of tools or of sharpening media).

Just a thought,

Guillaume

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#42

Re: Setting up a chisel test - ideas for discusssi

Lars Parrington

yikes! that sounds like 4X as much work!

there certainly seems to be a strong desire for a test to see if edge-holding performance is dependent on the abrasive-type used in sharpening. however, i believe that should be an entirely separate test. i would certainly be interested enough to read the results from that test, but i'm afraid i don't find that question so compelling as to want to run the test myself.

that said, i do have a set of norton waterstones, and would be happy to incorporate a small subtest, comparing the edge life of 1 or 2 chisels sharpened on waterstones with that of the same chisels sharpened with diamonds. i would run that subtest before doing the bulk of the main testing, because if i did find a substantial difference, i would want to modify my experimental procedure for the main test.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#43

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: showdown of the super chisels

#44

Re: Sorry Stu! My bad! Mea culpa! What was I think

david weaver

The rest of us were waiting to see an explosion when Stu found that.

24 hours with no sleep!! :O

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#45

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: showdown of the super chisels

#46

Re: Science and the Craft

Bob Hackett

Oops, wrong Craft.

Never mind.

For a minute there I thought Warren may have grabbed his black cat, put on his pointy hat, climbed onto his shop besom and flown off to the woods for some New Moon working. :D

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#47

The post belongs in the Archives

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'll be with a bit of appropriate editing Ellis will put it there.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#48

I'm skeptical

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am not skeptical of Wiley's data but rather the conclusion that Japanese steel can't be exposed to 15 micron diamond without apparent edge fracture. It makes no sense to me based on my experience with diamond abrasion.

I have a Japanese chisel from Japan Woodworking. It might be their least expensive white or blue steel; cost about $40. I will repeat this experiment on this chisel with a 15 micron diamond plate (EZlap) and 15 micron loose diamond.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#49

Maybe a little

Steve Elliott

I've had chipping occur with Japanese chisels on a medium grit diamond lapping plate. I've also had fine diamond (1 micron paste) on cast iron work without problems.

I prefer water stones for Japanese chisels. For some reason it just feels like the right combination. I always hone chisels freehand and although I think fine diamond would produce an edge plenty good enough for the work I do I still like the feel of freehanding on water stones.

For plane blades I've developed a jig I like that uses a cast iron plate and diamond paste. It would work with either oil or water stones but there's less mess with diamond paste and a few drops of mineral spirits or WD-40.

Re: showdown of the super chisels

#50

I come to the opposite conslusion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" I suspect is that diamond may abrade the soft iron in the laminated Japanese blade too quickly, leaving the harder iron less well honed."

The harder the abrasive the less likely there will be differential abrasion of hard and soft regions, for it will abrade them all equally. It will be the softer abrasive that will abrade away the soft regions faster.