New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Chisel Testing

Posts

Re: Chisel Testing

#26

Re: I fail to see how poking fun...

CStanford

You're the most erudite guy on the forum by the way. Buncombe. Jesus. Just wonderful.

Re: Chisel Testing

#27

Japanese Chisels

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I had not foreseen a discussion of Japanese chisels when I wrote about testing. I have never owned a Japanese chisel, but I have have been reading about Japanese woodworking since 1973. I think it is helpful for those of us who study historic woodworking or are reviving the craft to read about the Japanese craftsmen, their attitudes, tools and techniques. I bought the Odate book almost 30 years ago and have read it a number of times.

I pulled out the Odate book last night because some were talking about hardening chisels to a certain Rockwell hardness, as if we were trying to get the chisel as hard as possible. Heat treatment is a two step process: we harden (quench), then we temper (soften by heating). I would say we temper to a certain hardness. My recollection was that Odate mentioned tempering. In fact he gets the English terms mixed up, but clearly describes both quenching and then heating again to soften. Odate's tempering temperature is 170 C (338 F). Moxon suggests around 440 F for edge tools, deliberately making a softer tool.

I would be very interested in seeing pictures of 18th century Japanese chisels.

My hunch is that not all of the elements that we expect to see today (turned handle, end ring, fat tang, hefty tapered ferrule, hollowed back) are more than 200 years old.

Re: Chisel Testing

#28

Re: Chisel Testing

Mark Nowicki

Buck also made chisels for K-Mart. Those can be had for a buck at any garage sale.

Mark

(not happy having to go to Australia instead of skiing)

Re: Chisel Testing

#29

It reminds me of wine

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't drink so when the wine list is presented with its descriptors I entertain myself reading about "oaky notes" with "hints of raspberry" all in an effort to get $10 for a glass of spoiled grape juice, attacked by microbes in a bucolic valley somewhere.

Re: Chisel Testing

#31

Re: which reminds me of scotch

david weaver

.. I will drink wine from time to time, like twice a year if it is the most red and dry thing I can find. Maybe once a year. I never feel like it was worth $15 or $20 for a bottle - you drink it, it's marginal, you pee your money out in a few hours.

Scotch, on the other hand, tastes like a burnt peat bog, I wouldn't give it the benefit of being marginal though I work with some people who think the world of it.

I won some off-branded laphroaig single malt at work a couple of years ago. So I brought it home and swirled it around and a glass, but when I drank it, it tasted like creosote or something. A visiting scottish friend said the brand was not a real brand, and instead it was a low priced bottle that had been filled with $50-60 scotch - he identified it as laphroaig right away (after some research he was right, it was a low priced private label that laphroaig was using to sell scotch without diluting their brand).

Anyway, as a black coffee (no sugar) drinker and as someone who can appreciate a straight shot of crown from time to time (if I win that at work, also), it struck me as something I could only describe and like if someone else told me what to say about it. Otherwise, I'd call it smoked feet flavor.

It's interesting to go out and read the reviews of it, because gets 2 stars in public reviews while everyone glows about laphroaig. According to the scot (who buys, holds, and then sells barrels of scotch as investments), the cheap stuff is the fine stuff without concessions. Paying an extra $40 must make it seem older to some people. We sent the bottle of scotch with the Scot so he'd have something warm to drink as he crossed the country - he was very pleased.

I know there are some people who genuinely like scotch, but I wonder how many others say they like it just because it's something reserved for people with money to blow.

Re: Chisel Testing

#32

Good one, Tom


Re: Chisel Testing

#33

Tempering temperatures will vary

Patrick Gibbons

According to the carbon content. A temp of 440f will get a higher carbon steel in the 60's for hardness and a lower carbon steel perhaps in the 50's. Unless the two smiths are using the same steel, a temperature difference doesn't tell anything about which will be harder. Also how hard did the metal get in the quench? Water or oil hardened? Temperature is just one of many variables.

Re: Chisel Testing

#34

Re: Japanese Chisels

Schtoo

Warren,

I can't recall what I saw here; http://www.dougukan.jp/contents-en/ with regards to 18th century chisels, but there were some a lot older than that, and they were pretty rugged.

Almost everything they have there is from at the earliest 1850 or so, anything prior being used up, recycled and used up again. Not enough iron to go around, so it was relentlessly re-used and there's very little chance of finding any kind of tools from that era, and equally little actual historical evidence saying what the tools actually looked like.

If you do want to know however, I'd send an email to the museum linked to above. If anyone will know, they will. English is quite alright, the main curator last time I was there spoke English fluently and they have a lot of information prepared in English as well.

I can't find anything online about tempering you can look at, but Tsunesaburo's print catalog does show the 'deep fryer' they use and a picture from my blog shows the heat treat station they have there as well.


At the back, hardening. In front (the green thing) the deep fryer for tempering and somewhere around there is a lead pot for steels that have tempering temperature beyond what the deep fryer is able to handle.

One thing to consider is that hardening and tempering isn't all these guys are doing to their blades. I'm still trying to work out exactly what they are doing after forging but before heat treat, but basically it's giving the blades a spell in a 'hot box' to allow the steel to be left very hard without being brittle or fragile. If these Japanese steels are simply hardened and tempered to the hardness they are normally done to here, they'll still be brittle and junk.

The only reason I'm not saying any more is because I'm waiting to get some education from a metallurgical engineer to help me better understand what's being done during this intermediate step. It's not some time hallowed secret, and it was likely known to folks making tools 1-200 years ago, but not done because it was unnecessary as the sharpening stones available were not able to cope properly with the harder steel, so in order to match the steel to the stones, they backed off the hardness which also meant the toughness increased. As it was not necessary to make the tools, the knowledge of it was likely forgotten about.

(That doesn't mean it's BS, only that it's not 'common knowledge' any more. It'll likely be turned into something stupid though.)

No need to add an extra step to the making as well as burn up time and fuel to toughen the steel up if it's not needed.

I hope that makes some sense.

Stu.

(Hoping I didn't just waste an hour on this to have it kicked back in my face. Again...)

Re: Chisel Testing

#35

Re: Japanese Chisels

david weaver

Warren - I checked with George Wilson to find out what they were doing as toolmakers, and everything you said pretty much matches up with it. Which isn't a surprise.

I won't try to quote George, I'm sure I'd say something slightly different than he'd say it, and he is pretty precise about everything, so I don't want to do that.

Re: Chisel Testing

#36

Re: Japanese Chisels

david weaver

For every troll who has never actually used any of the tools, there are probably 50 genuine readers. I can't think of a better place to get the information than Tsunesaburo and the other folks who analyze their products.

I'd be interested in the discussion of relaxing the steel.

I'm sure anyone who has used henckels friodur knives would think they were pretty good, but if we used the same terms that we do for woodwork (cryogenic treatment, which friodur stuff has had for a very long time), then it would be trolled witchcraft or marketing material.

Re: Chisel Testing

#37

I'll second black coffee and....

roger lance

Crown Royal (or some Jack when not flush).....only occasionally of course, except the coffee which is each morning....I'm starting to like you David.

Re: Chisel Testing

#38

Re: Where in Oz, Mark?

Mark Nowicki

Thank you Derek, but Sydney and Blue Mts area only this time. Taking the youngest kids as a grad present and those were his choices.

Mark (currently YUL to SFO SYD tommorow)

Re: Chisel Testing

#39

An open invitation

Bob Hackett

To anyone desiring to personally test a western laminated chisel and doesn`t have access to them I`m willing to LOAN one of mine for testing purposes. I can loan any one of the more well known names such as Whitherby, Swan, Buck,Butcher etc. I also have some lesser known names such as J Cam, Underhill, etc. If you have a specific brand in mind I`ll look to see if I have one.

I`m willing to do this one of two ways, as a loan of one of my own refurbished chisels or if you even suspect you might fall so in love with this laminated wonder that you can`t part with and send it back to me it after experiencing it`s virtues then I`m also willing to do a quick sand and de-burr on a serviceable piece of steel from my "bucket O rust" that you can handle yourself and then call your own after your testing is done.

In return all I ask is that you post your results, complete with pics, so we all can benefit from your experience.

If you choose to request one of my personal chisels then you will be responsible for shipping costs back to me. Please send it back with at least as nice an edge on it as it had when you received it. :D

Re: Chisel Testing

#41

Re: Japanese Chisels

CStanford

They probably leave them on the 'keep warm' setting while they have a smoke, take a leak, and maybe grab a little lunch. Surely, these poor chaps take the occasional break from administering the perpetual and ongoing mystery don't they?

Re: Chisel Testing

#42

Re: Chisel Testing

bridger berdel

"And the wood that is being worked. In a butter cutting test, all chisels are surprisingly similar in edge holding. "

as in a concrete cutting competition :)

Re: Chisel Testing

#43

Re: Japanese Chisels

bridger berdel

if you make it to Tucson, look me up.

Bridger