New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Chisel Testing

Posts

Chisel Testing

#1

Chisel Testing

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I tested a 19th century cast steel chisel recently. I made chopping cuts 1/2 inch deep on the endgrain of black walnut, Juglans nigra, using a 30 ounce dogwood mallet. I inspected the edge after 10, 20 and 50 cuts with a 30X loupe and 200X microscope. I saw no chipping or bending of the edge. I continued making cuts inspecting after every 50. At around 150 I had the feeling that I wanted to sharpen the chisel, but I kept going because I was still getting a good surface and no chipping or folding. After 500 chops the edge still looked good and it pared white pine endgrain very cleanly.

I then sharpened the chisel in order to cut some half blind sockets (pin board) for a walnut carcase. The sockets were roughly 5/8X 7/8X 1 1/4. After 7 or 8 sockets I again had the feeling that the chisel needed sharpening, but I kept going for the sake of the experiment. After 28 such sockets the chisel also pared pine endgrain nicely.

It was surprising to me how long the chisel kept doing its work long after I felt the need to sharpen it. In both cases I really could have kept going after my stopping point, which was already far beyond where I would have sharpened. The changes in performance were subtle. I think it is important to consider that when we test chisels like this we are not only testing the steel composition, but hardening technique, tempering technique, sharpening technique, and chopping technique.

Re: Chisel Testing

#2

Re: Chisel Testing

Ron Harper

Sounds like my Chas Buck chisels

Re: Chisel Testing

#3

Re: Chisel Testing

Patrick Gibbons

My bet is that the forging process is the main contributor to the chisel's performance, assuming proper hardening/tempering.

Re: Chisel Testing

#4

Re: Chisel Testing

CStanford

Warren, you're supposed to have paid $200++ per for a Japanese chisel that would perform that well. Didn't you get the memo?

Re: Chisel Testing

#5

Re: Chisel Testing

wilbur

There's no such memo.

Re: Chisel Testing

#6

Re: Chisel Testing

CStanford

Oh, yes there is. Metaphorically speaking.

Re: Chisel Testing

#7

Re: Chisel Testing

david weaver

No, there isn't. That rule exists only in trollaphoric speech.

Re: Chisel Testing

#8

Re: Chisel Testing

CStanford

Super. I'm so glad to hear it. And I mean that - acknowledgment that Buck, et al. produced these things by the 100s per day and they are just as good.

Now, maybe we'll hear less about ordering a set of chisels from Mr. Ichiban-san before he kicks the bucket at age 132 with the intention of taking all secrets with him to his grave.

What a joyous day today is going to be.

Re: Chisel Testing

#9

Re: Chisel Testing

CStanford

Maybe the best kept secret is whom one calls at Hitachi to order less than job lot quantities of steel.

Re: Chisel Testing

#10

Re: Chisel Testing

wilbur

I seriously don't know why you keep bringing up the "ordering a set of chisels from Mr. Ichiban-san before he kicks the bucket at age 132 with the intention of taking all secrets with him to his grave" trope. You are the only one around here that keeps floating that balloon.

Re: Chisel Testing

#11

Re: Chisel Testing

TomD

"My bet is that the forging process is the main contributor to the chisel's performance, assuming proper hardening/tempering. "

That is like saying harmonica playing is the main key to winning the Ms America pageant, assuming you look better than all the other contestants in a close up and a bathing suit. Or as Jesse James used to say "all that is left is everything else".

Re: Chisel Testing

#12

Re: Chisel Testing

TomD

"I think it is important to consider that when we test chisels like this we are not only testing the steel composition, but hardening technique, tempering technique, sharpening technique, and chopping technique."

And the wood that is being worked. In a butter cutting test, all chisels are surprisingly similar in edge holding.

Re: Chisel Testing

#13

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Chisel Testing

#14

Re: Probably wouldn't be so damned funny...

TomD

Yeah, Krenov is gone, that is the end of his cabinets, one can still find plenty of boxes to keep stuff in, if that is the level of analysis.

Re: Chisel Testing

#15

Re: Chisel Testing

CStanford

Seems like I recall a post by Derek Cohen waxing half poetic about some codger who was nearing the end of his days but found time to make him a special set of chisels, probably for a kadjillion dollars. Could have been somebody else. I DO remember the story though. Sounded like classic Japanese marketing to me then, and now. They probably paid some 95 year old guy to pose for a picture in front of a back yard forge and then laughed their collective a$$es off afterwards.

Re: Chisel Testing

#16

Re: Chisel Testing

wilbur

I don't recall Derek telling the story any time recently. I do recall you bringing up this trope in this forum recently, though.

I don't know why you keep bringing this up.

Re: Chisel Testing

#17

Re: Probably wouldn't be so damned funny...

CStanford

I think Mr. Tasai was 95 years old back in the late '70s. This scam is not new.

Re: Chisel Testing

#18

Re: Chisel Testing

CStanford

I do recall the story. Not sure if it was Derek. But I do recall the story. And it may not have been on this forum.

Re: Chisel Testing

#19

Re: Chisel Testing

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Seems like I recall a post by Derek Cohen waxing half poetic about some codger who was nearing the end of his days but found time to make him a special set of chisels, probably for a kadjillion dollars. Could have been somebody else. I DO remember the story though. Sounded like classic Japanese marketing to me then, and now. They probably paid some 95 year old guy to pose for a picture in front of a back yard forge and then laughed their collective a$$es off afterwards.

It was not an old codger. It was Stu dressed in a kimono. And it was not an old forge. Stu just looked a bit rough after all the sake.

Regards from Mont Tremblant

Derek

Re: Chisel Testing

#20

Re: Chisel Testing

Bruce Mack

I agree with Wilbur. Address the merits or faults of Japanese chisels rather than a vendor's

marketing strategy.

Re: Chisel Testing

#21

Re: Chisel Testing

CStanford

There's a little bit of larceny in all of us... including Stu.

Re: Chisel Testing

#22

Re: Chisel Testing

CStanford

Sure thought it was you Derek.......

Re: Chisel Testing

#23

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Chisel Testing

#24

Re: Chisel Testing

CStanford

Bruce, I think I made my point in my first post in my thread. Based on Warren's test it sounds like I can get elite Japanese chisel performance out of a $15 vintage Buck. The criticism is implicit in the comparison.

Re: Chisel Testing

#25

Re: I fail to see how poking fun...

CStanford

These blokes have watched The Last Samurai way too many times.