New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

Posts

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#51

Re: Stephen, I've wondered about the tempering

TomD

"Stephen, I checked around and you remain the only person I've talked to who feels that their woodworking tools are not tempered."

I don't know how various people do it.

"Brine doesn't do anything magical to steel other than prevent gas pockets from forming during hardening"

anything like that increases the speed of cooling which is critical. Hardness is not merely that one cools, but how fast.

"Most steel is air or oil hardening and oil hardening without tempering is the tiniest bit softer in hardness than water hardening steel, or the same. Both are almost like glass without any tempering, and it is my belief that while some of your tools may be hard, they are not the hardness they would've likely had without tempering (66-68) unless they have either lost carbon or were not at the correct critical tempering."

This stuff is often explained as though it were one thing, but there are many paths. If one wants to create a manufacturing cycle that allows no tempering, that is an option. Varying stuff as simple as the starting temp of the quench, or the thickness of the part being quenched will affect outcomes.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#52

Re: brine quenching *LINK*

Lars Parrington

there's an interesting website (link below) that discusses brine quenching O1 steel. i think the idea is that as long as you get below the nose, you will achieve full hardness. the author is actually using brine because it enables him to slow down the quench once he's below the nose.


img

http://www.navaching.com/forge/heattreat.html

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#53

Re: Stephen, I've wondered about the tempering

david weaver

I agree, it increases the speed of the quench and which is important if the steel is very plain and requires a water quench.

Maybe the issue is that a blacksmith is quenching an item in brine and then pulling it from the brine before the center is cool.

Whatever it is, I can practically guarantee that none of the vintage irons are at theoretical hardness (in the 68 hardness range), because they wouldn't hold up to use at that. That's the confusion here, I guess. My experience is that most of the older irons are actually softer than the new air hardening or harder oil hardening steel irons, I'm looking to figure out why that may be. Evidence of any tempering color is long gone.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#54

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#55

Re: No intention of tempering? Really?

Patrick Gibbons

David, I thought water was a more severe quench than brine because of its lower boiling point.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#56

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

Stephen Shepherd

'Stephen, I checked around and you remain the only person I've talked to who feels that their woodworking tools are not tempered.' This is not the first time; I think the nib on the saw is used to start a kerf/cut, a twibil is swung and not struck and that milk paint is a myth.

Any other explanations why my laminated tools are better than modern tools [not including Japanese tools]? Let me know.

Stephen

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#57

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

david weaver

I guess in practice, they (laminated steel irons) aren't better. No carbon steel laminated plane iron will last as long in the cut of medium hardwoods as A2, and with good abrasives, the surface can't be discerned between the two.

The vintage chisels are good, but not remarkably better than any modern process good chisels that are hardened to the same spec.

After testing some plane irons, it seems to me that a lot of the discussion of western vintage tools, where great qualities are attributed to them, are based on not doing any quantifiable competition between the two. I planed 2000 feet of hard maple with a simple A2 iron before it would no longer cut. At 1000 feet, the surface was still plenty acceptable for a finished surface. While I like carbon steel, it doesn't match that no matter the hardness.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#58

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#59

Good info