New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

Posts

Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#1

Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

wilbur

The February issue of Popular Woodworking, which should be out on the newsstands by now, includes an article I wrote on Japanese chisels. Stephen Shepherd was kind enough to talk to me regarding traditional western methods of laminated tool construction when I was writing it, and so I'd like to thank him for his help.

I should also mention that Joel Moskowitz and Kari Hultman let me quote them for the article as well, and my thanks goes to them, too.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#2

It is a great Article

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It was refreshing to discover an article so rich in technical details. I found it well written and no words wasted on frivolous facets of the topic. I came away with a better understanding of Japanese style chisels. Still don't like the style but I appreciate them better.

The following is in no way a criticism of the article, but rather my skepticism run amok. It is oft stated that the hollow on the back of the chisel is to make back flatening easier. I'm skeptical that this reason is the whole story. I think we are dealing with the equivalent of the "nib" on a saw.

1.The Japanese are not into instant gratification. This hollow may enable easier flatening at first but would there not be a larger price to pay as the bevel was ground into this hollow?

2. Ease of flatening would be as relevant to a western chisel. Hollowing the back of a chisel is easily accomplished on an abrasive wheel. So if it is a good idea why didn't Western tool and/or cabinet makers do it, then or now? Has anybody ground a hollow on the back a new chisel? Seems it would be easier to just grind it flat to begin with.

3. Could it be that this hollow had some historical beneficial role in the manufacturer or use of the chisel that has been overlooked?

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#3

Re: It is a great Article

david weaver

The hollow is shallow, with regular use it mostly works its depth out as you go, often being honed away too fast rather than not fast enough. You have to remember where the tools intended for craftsmen were tempered, and that they were still sharpened with a silica based stone, often in the case of average craftsmen in japan, with subpar quality stones.

It takes extra effort to grind the hollow into a chisel, it's a consideration for the craftsman.

We think nothing of lapping the back of a chisel with modern abrasives, even if it's rc65, but even we would probably have a different perspective with a set of kings and a 1" wide chisel rc65. If you were working with subpar natural stones 100 years ago, or working with extremely expensive stones that were expected to last a lifetime, either for quickness or for economy, you'd want to minimize the time a super hard steel spent on a silicate abrasive.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#4

Re: I agree

TomD

The hollow back makes sense but I don't buy the making chisels easier to sharpen thing.

What does make sense is that the hollow will make it easier to sharpen the chisel in use. Again, back in the 70s, there used to be articles on sharpening western chisels that suggested the back was not worked during sharpening, and also the dominant idea was that the bevel was only worked in one direction. It is hard to realize how much the world has come together in sharpening since then. Japanese chisels are worked equally on the bevel and the back. And they are worked in both directions on the stone. The back is 100% hard steel, the bevel about 30%. The only way to make it so that the sharpening is anything like side for side is to remove a ton of the metal from the back. And they do that by means of the hollow. This makes it possible to get the awesome edge.

This makes the hollow into a customer advantage, while the idea that it makes the chisel easier to flatten is an advantage for the maker, not very professional.

The back flattening idea does not make sense since Japanese chisels are power ground, and they can easily be flattened in the making, but are hard to flatten by hand. The back is power ground flat on the edges and in the hollow, so just setting it up to grind the whole thing flat is not a problem, and they do in fact make chisels with flat backs.

Obviously over time the hollow ads a ton of grinding to the equation, even if it is spaced over a longer period of time.

In the west the easier to sharpen explanation goes back to a time when anyone coming back to here from Japan, would talk about how the Japanese did not teach or give reasons for things, which is kinda anti Zen, so that all made sense. So in addition to the explanation not making sense, it doesn't make sense there would be an explanation.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#5

Re: Japanese power grinding

TomD

http://www.youtube.com/watch?NR=1&v=RKx4ZaRCsKc&feature=endscreen

You can see the cuts on Japanese chisels are made on round wheels. They could grind to any level of accuracy required.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#6

Re: On the other hand

TomD

There are arguments in favour of the standard explanation:

1) it exists, and while I don't believe it, if it isn't true, why is it there.

2) it is true that a hollow makes flattening easier. Even if there are a bunch of reasons why that is kinda silly.

3) It requires the user to thin the chisel significantly over it's life, and that is beneficial to do as the chisel gets shorter. Though this does not explain a hollow on other tools like planes.

4) There is a Japanese belief in the idea that conditioning of the blade occurs with long sharpening using the user's preferred stones. This idea sounds ridiculous to non master craftsmen, weekend warriors, and it doesn't really get discussed much. Above my pay grade. In this case it does not mater whether we believe it, so long as they do. But anyway, if that is a common idea, then leaving the chisel with some working in room, yet removing the excess would make sense.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#7

Re: Should have said...

TomD

in my first response to Bill that I don't buy the making chisels easier to flatten bit. I do buy that it makes them easier to sharpen.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#8

Re: It is a great Article

wilbur

Hi Bill,

Thanks for your kind comments on my article. I really appreciate it.

Regarding your questions:

1. The issue of what to do with the hollow as the chisel is sharpened is pretty commonly asked. The figure on page 32 and the last paragraph before the "Handle Without (Much) Care" section are meant to address this. Basically, both the back and the bevel of Japanese chisels are worked on sharpening stones as you use the chisel, so the flat area behind the cutting edge is maintained.

There's a more detailed explanation of this, and why the situation is different for Japanese plane blades here: http://giantcypress.net/post/931326880/hatful-of-hollow

2 and 3. There is some evidence that western toolmakers took advantage of having a hollow on the back side of a chisel, although not to the same degree as Japanese toolmakers did. I referenced Joel Moskowitz in the article. His write up is here: http://toolsforworkingwood.com/store/blog/243 . He says,

In traditional western tool manufacture (which isn't practiced much these days) grinding the cutting bevel and any side bevels is done after hardening the iron. What the tool maker does is harden the iron, and then check which side has warped a little concave, and then put the bevel on the other side. This gives a subtle concavity that achieves the same goals, abet less noticeably than a purposely hollowed Japanese tool.

Unfortunately most modern western tool makers grind and harden in giant batches and have lost the craft that practices the above procedure. The result with a lot of western tools are backs that are bellied which makes for very hard conditioning.

Ray Iles, who explained all of this to me, still practices the traditional procedure on his plane irons. Ashley Iles (run today by Ray's brothers Barry and Tony) don't do this on the chisels they make but they intentionally grind their MK2 beveled edge chisels and their American Pattern Chisels very slightly hollow for the same reason.


Regarding Tom's comments about the hollow making the chisel easier to flatten vs. easier to sharpen, I think this is a matter of semantics. The concept of sharpness being the intersection of two flat surfaces is generally accepted. If there is something that makes the back of a chisel or plane blade easier to flatten, that will make it easier to sharpen as well.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#9

Significantly?

wilbur

The hollow on the backs of Japanese tools are really not that deep to the point where I would describe the thinning of the chisel over its life as being significant. My 12mm Japanese chisel has a hollow that seems to be 0.015" deep at most, and I think that is an overestimate mainly because I can't accurately measure that with the tools I have at hand. My largest Japanese chisel has a hollow that is deeper, but still is only on the order of 0.025" or so.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#10

Re: Should have said...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

First off, great article Wilbur! I wish I had a chance to read it before having dinner with you last week (Rob Lee gave me a copy a couple of days ago) - missed out on a wonderful opportunity to discuss it more fully with you. I'll raise an area of interest in a second post shortly.

Many thanks for a terrific day.



in my first response to Bill that I don't buy the making chisels easier to flatten bit. I do buy that it makes them easier to sharpen.

Hi Tom

In my book flatten is not the same as sharpen. Smooth = sharpen, but I do see the process as aimed at sharpening, so we are just splitting hairs.

My way of looking at the hollowed back is that it is simply the equivalent of a hollow ground bevel. One removes all the unnecessary steel, and then flattens and smooths what is left behind.

Regards from Ottawa

Derek

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#11

Western vs Eastern laminated blades

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I cannot recall reading a comparison of Western and Eastern laminated blades in Wilbur's article. The topic came up during dinner with Wilbur last week and he did not correct me (however Wilbur is a very courteous individual, so may not have done so anyway).

The issue is this:

Would you hollow grind a laminated Western blade (chisel or plane)? Typically, this is considered inappropriate for Eastern laminated blades since there is a danger of affecting the temper of the hard tool steel. Some also speak of reducing the support behind the hard tool steel layer for the latter. I have done so, but only with a (wet) Tormek.

In my understanding, the rational behind the design of Western and Eastern laminations is different.

Eastern lamination is designed to ensure that the tool steel layer holds the sharpest edge for the longest period of time. It does this by paring a hard and brittle cutting layer with a soft iron (i.e. not steel) backing to act as a shock absorber. This combination is a deliberate design of steels that complement each other, not an accommodation to cost of materials (i.e. price).

The question is whether this is the case for Western laminations, or whether it is about pairing a cheaper steel with a more expensive steel, with the emphasis on cost rather than design, per se?

Regards from Ottawa

Derek

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#12

Amazing

jack curtis

Tom, that was a great series of posts, and possibly the first I've read in woodworking forums incorporating the existentialism of tool making. And what's more, I think they accurately reflect why I've been so obsessed with Japanese chisels and planes. Thanks.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#13

Re: Significantly?

TomD

Well that is the least of my points, but you have possibly not understood the geometry involved. Which is that as the edge retreats to the hollow, the angle of the sole is adjusted to accommodate, which means to some extent it fans in an upward direction, and the reduction in edge thickness is greater than the planar retreat of a few thou. Can't hurt is all I can say about that.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#14

Re: Should have said...

TomD

"My way of looking at the hollowed back is that it is simply the equivalent of a hollow ground bevel. One removes all the unnecessary steel, and then flattens and smooths what is left behind."

That is my point over the last decades also. The hollow grind is the succinct explanation I failed to achieve. It is a different instance, however, because it is rarely all that precise, and the choice of grind is largely random. We hollow grind to say 6" or 8" diameter because that is what they sell, not because it is ideal. In knife making the better makers do choose their wheels and match them to the work. Having wheels from an inch to 16 inches is pretty common.

I also think that the principle of equal side sharpening is important to understanding Japanese nuance. It is also there for other Japanese edges outside of woodwork, and the western hollow ground bevel is a different mater there also, there is no balance between a solid back and a hollow ground bevel. If you look at Japanese knives, you can see a quite different expression of sharpening in them also.

I don't however buy that the hollow on Japanese chisels is for flattening, there are many flat things in Japanese metal work, including swords, from which this craft is drawn. So sharpening and flattening, while both enhanced, only the former really makes sense. And it is hair splitting, that is the objective for sure. :)

"Regards from Ottawa"

Hey, I can almost see you from down here on the lake...

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#15

Re: Amazing

TomD

Thank you for saying so. It is good to have some way of calibrating just how crazy one may have become, or not...

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#16

Re: It is a great Article

TomD

"Regarding Tom's comments about the hollow making the chisel easier to flatten vs. easier to sharpen, I think this is a matter of semantics."

Semantics is the study of meaning. Not as often suggested a situation of zero difference.

"The concept of sharpness being the intersection of two flat surfaces is generally accepted."

That would be a poor definition. One can have two planer surfaces that intersect, while they are not sharp. One could argue that only occurs when they truly do not intersect, but then the "sharp" ones do not truly intersect either. One can have curved surfaces, either simple or complex, that intersect and are sharp.

Flat surfaces will make it easier to get effective time on task when grinding on flat stones. This is a major factor for certain kinds of cutting power.

Also when working with an edge in a sawing type maner, a flat surface can increase cutting power due to the edge repeatedly hitting the same part of the cut.

" If there is something that makes the back of a chisel or plane blade easier to flatten, that will make it easier to sharpen as well."

What I am getting at is that when one sharpens one is polishing the surface. There are a lot of things that go into achieving perfection in that task, and the Japanese tool makers seem to think in terms of perfection. If you polish one side effectively to 10000, say a point where further polishing improves the surface no more, then to polish another surface that has 10 or 30 times the area would require the application of greater force, or much longer time polishing, or possibly will simply not happen. The hollow keeps the relative areas to be polished at each sharpening, as close as practical to the same size. And designs them so that the back does not simply hydroplane on the stone surface.

It is possible to get a very effective, razor sharp edge, without sharpening anything other than the bevel. I have never heard a western source describe the hand sharpening of a western chisel as the process of sharpening the surface of the bevel to the best ability of the stone involved, and then the sharpening of the whole back surface, to the same degree, with every sharpening. But this IS what the Japanese tools, and the swords, are supposed to be. They are not giving up cutting power by only sharpening half the edge or messing with the geometry.

Now the fact is that one can get sufficient cutting power for many things we do in the west with exactly such half measures. And one can dispense with a little geometry and buff the edge at the back and get a ton of sharpness. But the Japanese tool is an ideal, and the way they do it is a means to that ideal, and it does not generally seem to be understood.

I would love to be in a position to shower praise on your article, but I have had to give up magazines until my stocks come back, if ever.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#17

Re: Western vs Eastern laminated blades

TomD

"Would you hollow grind a laminated Western blade (chisel or plane)? Typically, this is considered inappropriate for Eastern laminated blades since there is a danger of affecting the temper of the hard tool steel. Some also speak of reducing the support behind the hard tool steel layer for the latter. I have done so, but only with a (wet) Tormek."

You are right to say that, but the concern is largely nonsense. First there are HSS Japanese tools, and some of the art steels are mildly HSS like in nature. It is only a mater of skill, and if a person can't handle, say, dry grinding a Japanese chisel, they really don't deserve to use them. The Japanese sell a ton of water wheel type grinders, if they though hollow grinding them was a step in the right direction, they would be well equipped to do so.

Reducing the support of the hard tool steel layer is another mater, that could have some effect. Again, if one deserves these tools, if one cuts and does not pry, probably no biggie.

My main thing about grinding them is any deviation from what these tools are designed for is probably missing the point. They are beautiful pieces of craftsmanship designed to work in a specific way. One can choose to use them at tent pegs, but one might miss out on a bit of the joy of using them. Nobody over here really needs them. If you just want to mess them up why use them. There are things where the idea is to turn the thing to one's ego and use, and things where the idea is to mold oneself to the discipline of the thing. You can probably win a Karater fight by just shooting your opponent, but you might loose something in the process.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yP1vSIOmCc4

Relevant bit starts around 2:15

In my understanding, the rational behind the design of Western and Eastern laminations is different.

"Eastern lamination is designed to ensure that the tool steel layer holds the sharpest edge for the longest period of time. It does this by paring a hard and brittle cutting layer with a soft iron (i.e. not steel) backing to act as a shock absorber. This combination is a deliberate design of steels that complement each other, not an accommodation to cost of materials (i.e. price).

The question is whether this is the case for Western laminations, or whether it is about pairing a cheaper steel with a more expensive steel, with the emphasis on cost rather than design, per se?"

I don't really buy the shock absorption idea, I doubt that happens to any significant degree, or at all. I also doubt that the Japanese were completely uninterested in economy, or the westerners completely uninterested in fanciness, or quality, as in general their tools are more fancy looking and the work they undertook as demanding or moreso.

I think the main lessons are probably in blacksmithing, without going in it in detail there are certain things that work well in blacksmithing, like making eyes with a broach, rather than drilling. And in particular there are interesting things that happen in heat treating when tools are made in laminated form, it actually changes how the quench works. If you just know how this stuff works it falls a little more into place. To an uninformed person, a frame and panel may look decorative, but we know it is driven by wood movement.

Of course with the blacksmithing side of things baked in, they were still influenced by other things, and in pursuit of different things. So it is all in there somewhere, but i think the method of work is probably a big factor. And it is hard to get a final answer because I do not know that we have the info required or maybe it is out there still for someone to dig up...

Just another thought. I think the Japanese smiths did certain things because they could, because of the sword building heritage. Part of their pride. People come along and invent fanciful practical reasons for what they did, because that is what westerners do.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#18

Re: Do you love Iron?

TomD

One thing I learned from blacksmithing (an area I have only slight familiarity with) is to value iron. I tended to associate iron, with cheap stuff that broke. Old stuff, from the iron age, dreadnoughts, and wrought iron architecture. But in blacksmithing iron is a magic material that does not burn up badly in the fire, is easily forge welded, and in use it is resistant to corrosion. It is also something, like many of the old things we have rediscovered the worth of, that is hard to get. So when you apply your 21st century mind to problems like why do they laminate blades. Do you think you would think differently about the problem if you loved iron. Are you thinking like someone in the past would have thought? Because when I hear this stuff discussed it often sounds like steel is good, and iron is bad in their minds.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#19

Re: Significantly?

wilbur

The geometry of the hollow in a Japanese chisel is such that the hollow is deeper towards the handle, and shallower towards the cutting edge. This negates the need to adjust the angle of the sole (back?) of the chisel as the back is worked in the course of sharpening.

The hollow of a Japanese plane blade is a fairly even depth front to back and left to right, which leads to the need to tap out as the edge meets up with the hollow.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#20

Re: It is a great Article

wilbur

"I would love to be in a position to shower praise on your article, but I have had to give up magazines until my stocks come back, if ever."

There's always the library, or your local bookstore. :D

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#21

Re: Western vs Eastern laminated blades

wilbur

Hi Derek,

I don't think the issue of engineering vs. economy in describing why Japanese and western toolmakers adopted laminated construction in their tools is an either/or thing. Clearly, there's some engineering benefit with either type of tool with this method of toolmaking, and there's some economic benefit either way as well, at least before the industrial revolution came along.

In terms of economy, you may have seen this already, but there's an episode of Nova that covers the making of samurai swords, which you can watch online.

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ancient/secrets-samurai-sword.html

The first part of this episode has a segment on the traditional way of making the very hard steel that is at the core of Japanese swords, and which would also be used in Japanese tools. The amount of labor and material it took to make a small quantity of this very high carbon steel was incredible. So I would guess that Japanese toolmakers had their eye (or at least part of one eye) on the bottom line as well when it came to figuring out ways to stretch the use of this steel.

To me, the real difference between Japanese and western toolmakers' approach to this forge-welded laminated construction of chisels and plane blades is that in the west, this method was dropped in favor of industrial methods of making chisels and plane blades from a single type of steel. The types of industrial methods that made making tools from a single type of steel did not lend themselves to automating this forge-welding process, and so this method of toolmaking fell by the wayside.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#22

Re: Western vs Eastern laminated blades

Warren in Lancaster, PA

One important advantage of laminated blades is the ease of sharpening. People often talk about O1 steel like it is the gold standard for sharpening ease; O1 is more like the copper standard. Steels like 1095 and Cast Steel are considerably easier to sharpen. Laminated blades are easier yet. And thin laminated chisels like were made 200 years ago are even better.

In the late 18th century a craftsman could buy five forged, laminated chisels for a day's wages. With today's pitiful manufacturing methods we get chisels machined from solid bar stock, and they are called premium chisels.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#23

Re: Western vs Eastern laminated blades

Patrick Gibbons

Derek,

The Swedish-made Mora knives make a laminated blade for some of their knives to allow the use of very hard steel that holds a sharp edge sandwiched between softer material. This laminated steel is used on their carving knives. Scandinavian-style knives have been made since Viking times and I believe the use of laminated steel is also a long tradition. I use this as an example of Western use of laminated steel. I would argue that it's not an either/or situation. Economy, ease of work and improvement to the edge were all factors for laminating. Non-laminated blades were preferred when blade thinness was desired. Without lamination, the blade has to be softer to maintain toughness.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#24

Re: Western Economy

david weaver

Every description I've ever seen about laminated western tools 200 years ago mentions the origin of the steel (England) and the need to stretch it (economy).

Probably also a matter of convenience for the maker, working mostly wrought iron in a chisel instead of high carbon steel.

Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article

#25

Re: the conditioning

david weaver

I'm still waiting on some metallurgical proof that the long sharpening does something that actually improves edge life. I have seen it said fairly often that smiths advocate natural stones for their blades, and claim that an appropriate natural stone will work harden an edge also.

I would like more detail on the process a typical craftsman would use to work harden the end of a tool. it would have to involve alternating back and forth between bevel and back and using a stone that burnished more than cut.