Re: Western vs Eastern laminated blades
TomD
"Would you hollow grind a laminated Western blade (chisel or plane)? Typically, this is considered inappropriate for Eastern laminated blades since there is a danger of affecting the temper of the hard tool steel. Some also speak of reducing the support behind the hard tool steel layer for the latter. I have done so, but only with a (wet) Tormek."
You are right to say that, but the concern is largely nonsense. First there are HSS Japanese tools, and some of the art steels are mildly HSS like in nature. It is only a mater of skill, and if a person can't handle, say, dry grinding a Japanese chisel, they really don't deserve to use them. The Japanese sell a ton of water wheel type grinders, if they though hollow grinding them was a step in the right direction, they would be well equipped to do so.
Reducing the support of the hard tool steel layer is another mater, that could have some effect. Again, if one deserves these tools, if one cuts and does not pry, probably no biggie.
My main thing about grinding them is any deviation from what these tools are designed for is probably missing the point. They are beautiful pieces of craftsmanship designed to work in a specific way. One can choose to use them at tent pegs, but one might miss out on a bit of the joy of using them. Nobody over here really needs them. If you just want to mess them up why use them. There are things where the idea is to turn the thing to one's ego and use, and things where the idea is to mold oneself to the discipline of the thing. You can probably win a Karater fight by just shooting your opponent, but you might loose something in the process.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yP1vSIOmCc4
Relevant bit starts around 2:15
In my understanding, the rational behind the design of Western and Eastern laminations is different.
"Eastern lamination is designed to ensure that the tool steel layer holds the sharpest edge for the longest period of time. It does this by paring a hard and brittle cutting layer with a soft iron (i.e. not steel) backing to act as a shock absorber. This combination is a deliberate design of steels that complement each other, not an accommodation to cost of materials (i.e. price).
The question is whether this is the case for Western laminations, or whether it is about pairing a cheaper steel with a more expensive steel, with the emphasis on cost rather than design, per se?"
I don't really buy the shock absorption idea, I doubt that happens to any significant degree, or at all. I also doubt that the Japanese were completely uninterested in economy, or the westerners completely uninterested in fanciness, or quality, as in general their tools are more fancy looking and the work they undertook as demanding or moreso.
I think the main lessons are probably in blacksmithing, without going in it in detail there are certain things that work well in blacksmithing, like making eyes with a broach, rather than drilling. And in particular there are interesting things that happen in heat treating when tools are made in laminated form, it actually changes how the quench works. If you just know how this stuff works it falls a little more into place. To an uninformed person, a frame and panel may look decorative, but we know it is driven by wood movement.
Of course with the blacksmithing side of things baked in, they were still influenced by other things, and in pursuit of different things. So it is all in there somewhere, but i think the method of work is probably a big factor. And it is hard to get a final answer because I do not know that we have the info required or maybe it is out there still for someone to dig up...
Just another thought. I think the Japanese smiths did certain things because they could, because of the sword building heritage. Part of their pride. People come along and invent fanciful practical reasons for what they did, because that is what westerners do.