Ah, to see the level of craziness in ourselves.
Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
Posts
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#27Re: It is a great Article
jack curtis
It is possible to get a very effective, razor sharp edge, without sharpening anything other than the bevel. I have never heard a western source describe the hand sharpening of a western chisel as the process of sharpening the surface of the bevel to the best ability of the stone involved, and then the sharpening of the whole back surface, to the same degree, with every sharpening. But this IS what the Japanese tools, and the swords, are supposed to be. They are not giving up cutting power by only sharpening half the edge or messing with the geometry
I always feel like such a nag or scold when I repeatedly tell westerners that there's no way I'd ever stone just the bottom inch (100 mm) of a blade nor would I ever consider hollow grinding one.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#28Re: Western vs Eastern laminated blades
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Hi Wilbur
Since you speak of Nova and samurai, this reminds me of other examples, such as a gennou. The outside of a gennou is harder than the inside. Again we see the coming together of hard and soft. This is not done for the economy of the steel in my logic; it is done as part of the overall design. The soft inner core offers a way of reducing he vibration created by the hard outer core.
Someone mentioned existentialism. Perhaps this is a way that the Japanese toolmaker sees life and tools. In other words, that life and tools combine their parts to form a whole, yin and yang.
The hard cutting edge of the Eastern blade is quite unlike the lamination of the Western blade. It is not simply a matter of saving money on quality steel. If you could build a Japanese blade without concern for cost, it would fail for the steel used would be too hard too sharpen and too brittle to last without chipping. If cost had never been an issue, would the Japanese then have designed blades differently? Would we have had laminated blades?
I believe the design is deliberate, not simply about economics (although they have largely disappeared in the Western toolmaking world because they are uneconomical to manufacture in mass). The Japanese laminated blade today continues a tradition, and the tradition must be understood as the sum of parts.
Western laminations in the past probably have more to do with costs, or if not it followed a different design path, or both. The tool steel layer is hardened to a much lesser degree than the Japanese tool lamination, and its design is closer to a non-laminated blade. Being so, it is more easily and commonly hollow ground.
What do you think?
Regards from Tremblant
Derek
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#29Re: Western Economy
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I have no doubt that for something like a broadaxe the cost of the steel was a big consideration in making a tool with only a steel strip at the cutting edge. However with a chisel the bevel with both steel and iron comes into play in sharpening at the very least. In the absence of 18th century references to the contrary I think the craftsmen would have chosen the laminations had cost not been an object, that they were getting what they wanted.
In the 18th century, they had trouble forge welding cast steel. In the Seaton chest inventory there are cast steel chisels that have no weld (solid cs) and other chisels that are laminated with another steel. The solid cast steel chisels average 5 pennies apiece, the laminated are 4 pennies, not a huge difference. Later they worked to perfect lamination with cast steel.
Somebody suggested earlier that traditional chisels were made without a bevel so that they could go either way after heat treatment. Well, not laminated chisels.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#30Re: Significantly?
TomD
Planes get tapped out to maintain thickness, since the blade is the wedge. I'm still not sure we are on the same page on chisel geometry.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#31Re: Western vs Eastern laminated blades
TomD
"Since you speak of Nova and samurai, this reminds me of other examples, such as a gennou. The outside of a gennou is harder than the inside. Again we see the coming together of hard and soft. This is not done for the economy of the steel in my logic; it is done as part of the overall design. The soft inner core offers a way of reducing he vibration created by the hard outer core."
Is there any evidence of that? There are many ways in which hard and soft steels do not vary, for instance in stiffness. So I wonder when I hear about these claims. I also think back to studies that where done on putters that indicated that what people though was softness in the hit (something that would be way more important in golf than in chiselling) was actually an acoustic phenomenon. I have a lot of ideas that have never been substantiated with science, so I am not asking this confrontationally. I am just deeply sceptical about these kind of explanations.
"Someone mentioned existentialism. Perhaps this is a way that the Japanese toolmaker sees life and tools. In other words, that life and tools combine their parts to form a whole, yin and yang."
That does not sound much like existentialism, which is kinda reductive. As opposed to ++.
"The hard cutting edge of the Eastern blade is quite unlike the lamination of the Western blade. It is not simply a matter of saving money on quality steel. If you could build a Japanese blade without concern for cost, it would fail for the steel used would be too hard too sharpen and too brittle to last without chipping. If cost had never been an issue, would the Japanese then have designed blades differently? Would we have had laminated blades?"
I am not entirely sure that is true, since there are other ways to make steel easy to sharpen, for instance one could simply differentially harden the materials, which is also very much in their method. One does not have to laminate iron in there.
"I believe the design is deliberate, not simply about economics (although they have largely disappeared in the Western toolmaking world because they are uneconomical to manufacture in mass). The Japanese laminated blade today continues a tradition, and the tradition must be understood as the sum of parts."
I think that it is unlikely that every aspect of the product is there because of some rational quality control or engineering thinking. I think there are likely some fairly random elements. Cost could be one of those, but it does not have to be present in where we are today. Lamination is just so much a way of business in blacksmithing, and welding, that to say it is done for only one reason is not likely to be right.
"Western laminations in the past probably have more to do with costs, or if not it followed a different design path, or both. The tool steel layer is hardened to a much lesser degree than the Japanese tool lamination, and its design is closer to a non-laminated blade."
One thing they did not have was the Japanese stones. The Japanese tools work in concert with the stones.
" Being so, it is more easily and commonly hollow ground."
We know that they did use wheels to grind, but I do not all that often see antique tools that have hollow ground edges. A fairly common scene is someone working an axe on a large wheel, but the result was a convex edge. I don't want to over claim, on this, but I just don't see that many examples, I guess razors, and scythes are hollow ground. A large number of the tools are flat and convex.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#32Re: Western Economy
TomD
My farm left the family for a while during the depression when the owner lumbered it off. The owner kept the house and used the property for recreation, but he was a lumberman by profession, and we have recovered a dozen or more axes and bits from that period, or perhaps an earlier history. Some of these have been buried on the beach for a very long time, and they suffered no adverse effects of weathering. We also think they may have been lost in such numbers because the axes got thrown into fires to burn out handles, if that is actually something people do, I never quite understood it. I could see them burying the bits in the wet ground then building a fire over the eye only... Anyway, the iron works better than the steel for corrosion, heat treating, possibly the retention of the handle, though the head also splits. I think we agree on little but cost is the ultimate common ground, that does not make it a reliable explanation, just the one around which people most commonly can agree.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#33Re: Western Economy
david weaver
Could very well have been sharpenability. I have no idea how shops were outfitted beyond a sandstone wheel or a large sandstone rub stone.
Is there anything written about it? Cost may not be the consideration that it's talked up to be, though I don't know the difference between 5 and 4 pennies to someone working in the late 1700s.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#34Hardness and toughness
Patrick Gibbons
My Mora example above implied some points I want to spell out here. A laminated blade will allow increased hardness and still maintain toughness. Presently, Mora uses a laminated blade on their knives intended for carving. I believe this is to utilize the benefits that a laminated blade has for working wood. Increased sharpness with no loss of toughness. This is an example of Western laminate blades made for their inherent benefits. I've read the sources that argue that laminated blades were made to offset the cost of more expensive carbon steel. I think we all know first hand that labor is more a cost factor than material. I'd expect forge welding to be more labor intensive than forging a single piece of carbon steel. Also sharpening a laminated blade is easier than sharpening a single blade of increased hardness. My guess would be that Western laminated blades were purposely made for reasons other than cost. It was pointed out above that solid cast steel chisels sold for more than laminated chisels. I would also point out that Bailey all metal planes sold for more than woodies or transitionals. One always pays more for the latest technology. That doesn't make it necessarily a marked improvement over the older technology. Many still feel a woodie is a better plane to use.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#35Re: Hardness and toughness
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I think we all know first hand that labor is more a cost factor than material. I'd expect forge welding to be more labor intensive than forging a single piece of carbon steel. Also sharpening a laminated blade is easier than sharpening a single blade of increased hardness. My guess would be that Western laminated blades were purposely made for reasons other than cost.
Hi Patrick
That was my point, above.
Regards from Mont Tremblant
Derek
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#36Re: Western vs Eastern laminated blades
wilbur
I can see that a case can be made that in terms of design vs. economy, one could say that the laminated construction of Japanese tools was more a choice of the former, and the choices involved in making laminated western tools was more a choice of the latter. But without having access to the thinking of western and Japanese blacksmiths from back in the day, it's hard to say.
Aside: it would be really cool to find a diary of an American toolmaker from the 1700-1800's.
My guess, again, is that the incentives for toolmakers back then to adopt this laminated construction were multifactorial, not an either/or. And either way, laminated tool construction provides benefits to either Japanese or western tools, at the expense of being more difficult to manufacture.
One other point I forgot to mention in regards to the hardness of the tools: there are traditional ways of hardening carbon steel to the degree that Japanese tools are hardened that were known in the west. I think quenching the tool in brine as opposed to water will do this. (Stephen?) What does seem to exist in Japan more than the west are naturally occurring waterstones that can abrade steel that is hardened to that degree. So if western laminated tools were not hardened to the degree that Japanese tools were, it may be an accommodation to the sharpening methods available at the time, and not because of an inability to harden the steel to that degree.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#37Re: Significantly? *LINK*
wilbur
Tom,
I linked to this before. Here's what I mean.
I don't think that tapping out is enough to maintain the wedge fit as you use up a Japanese plane. To me, the purpose of tapping out a Japanese plane blade is more for maintaning the flat behind the cutting edge as you sharpen and bring the edge closer to the hollow.
Differences in Japanese chisel and plane hollows
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#38which raises a question.......
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Comparing apples to apples, namely carbon steels, is a Japanese steel hardened to Rc 65 or whatever is the case more abrasion resistant than a western steel hardened to Rc60 or thereabouts? I have never seen this topic discussed.
Overall tool hardness is not the primary factor in abrasion resistance, but rather the nature of the carbides that form and are maintained during the heat treating process. So we can not just jump to the conclusion that because the Japanese chisel is harder that it will therefore be more abrasion resistant.
That said, as I understand the situation Japanese steel for tools is higher in carbon. This could, but not necessarily, lead to more iron carbides being formed than in a western steel with a lower carbon content. This, in turn, could impart more abrasion resistance.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#39Re: which raises a question.......
wilbur
One other thing that helps is that the forge welding process makes those increased number of carbides smaller and more evenly distributed. That plus the hardness, I think, are the major factors that contribute to the edge life of Japanese steels.
I am going to hazard a guess that the grain size of the carbides made with the forge welding process in high carbon steel is on the order of what you get with CPM technology. There's one reference I need to check when I get home, but the grain size of carbides in Damascus steel swords (read: high carbon steel, lots of hammering in their construction, like Japanese tools) seems to be on the order of a micron or so. My understanding is that the grain size you can expect in, say, CPM 3V is about 1-2 microns.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#40Re: Hardness and toughness
david weaver
I think we are talking about very separate periods in terms of costs. The late 1700s vs. the mid to late 1800s (or later).
Coal was an established fuel in the US in 1850, but I'm not sure if it was in mid/late 18th century, or if most steel was still forged using charcoal.
I'm sure iron was a lot cheaper in 1850 than it would've been in 1775, normalized for income.
As far as toughness, I don't know what was done with most vintage chisels, but I don't think cabinetmakers would've challenged the toughness of an all-steel chisel. I'm no cabinetmaker, but I've never had any chisel fail aside from pounding mortises into hard maple plane bodies, and trimming cocobolo in an infill plane. The failure from that was only at the very edge of the chisel, something on the order of a tenth of the way to the lamination.
I also don't know when the major chisel makes would've moved toward mechanization for a large amount of the work on chisels, but presume many of the makers were highly mechanized by early 1800s.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#41Re: which raises a question.......
david weaver
You have to separate vintage japanese steel from modern japanese steel. I think there might be a bit of hocum in a some of the stuff for the vintage japanese tools, describing durability, etc, of sand-iron produced steel.
So has described the modern steels as superior when prepared correctly vs. tamahagane (sand iron steel) edge tools.
And there was a huge influx of English and Swedish Steel (still significant availability of swedish steel japanese tools) in the early/mid 1900s. There's likely a reason that specialty steels from europe were used.
There is nothing magical about a plain carbon steel japanese plane, aside from the steel being very good quality and the hardness being high. None of them are particularly long lasting in planing a medium hardwood compared to more highly alloyed planes. If there is an advantage, it's probably in the chisels, which we've discussed with regularity.
Hard steel does wear longer, though. You can see as much when comparing a hock iron to an O1 iron intentionally tempered softer (like LV's older irons).
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#42
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
Stephen Shepherd
Thank you Wilbur. I hope to pick up a copy of the article today, I can't wait to read what I said!
There is no economy in adding less than 10% steel in the overall mass of laminated tools, plane blades, chisels, etc. The cost difference in the 18th and 19th century between steel and iron was 5:1. There is the additional labor and costs associated with at least 3 heats to laminate the steel to the wrought iron.
The forging process undoubtedly improves the quality of the steel, but the real contribution that makes the tools 'better' is the brine quench. This hardens the steel more than and oil or water quench. Period end of story, no tempering.
There is no reason to temper the steel, it is a thin veneer and protected by the softer wrought iron, which can not be readily hardened. The exceptionally hard steel veneer is thin and easy to sharpen, not so easy to flatten the back.
Stephen
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#43Re: No tempering...
david weaver
Is there documentation that irons weren't tempered?
Even razors are tempered, because they are too brittle at the very edge if they aren't tempered, and they chip on the stones before they even get to hair. It isn't a one to one comparison, I'll concede, their bevel is on the order of 18 degrees. There are pictures of the effects, though ("microchipping") of razors that aren't properly tempered. Vintage razors are as clean of steel as any that I've ever seen, and are every bit as clean as the best japanese steel - they are also hard, but they were still tempered.
I don't have any tools older than 1820 (that I'm aware of), but none of them even at that point come close to untempered in hardness. Their durability is more comparable to high 50s hardness. They are really lovely hardness, but I'm surprised that any tool would be usable without a super blunt angle if it wasn't tempered.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#4418th century chisels
Warren in Lancaster, PA
David, a journeyman cabinetmaker made about a pound a week at the time of the Seaton inventory. That is roughly four cents an hour, and the difference between a solid cast steel chisel at 5 pennies and laminated chisel with a cheaper steel at 4 pennies would be 15 or 20 minutes labor for a craftsman. I think that if they had not had technical problems the cast steel would have been laminated as well.
I think both Moxon (1683) and Nicholson (1812) say that chisels were tempered to golden color, which is not particularly hard and would be easy to sharpen. I used an 18th century plane iron for some years; It was well tempered and easy to sharpen.
I think the 18th century woodworkers were getting the tools they wanted. It was not so long ago that some on this forum claimed that the double iron was invented as an economy move as well. A cheapening of the product. I can still remember blacksmith Todd Hughes telling them that they ought to try piercing a plane iron, forging a cap iron, making a nut and welding it on, and making a screw and then tell him how much labor it saved.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#45Steel wasn't made in the U.S. until the Civil War
Patrick Gibbons
Except for Disston. Steel was expensive to make before modern production and importing it made it even more so.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#46Re: 18th century chisels
david weaver
Thanks for the clarification Warren. To us today, it would probably be something like $20-$40 effectively for the difference in 4 or 5 chisels.
Thanks for the clarification on the temper, too. That matches my experience on my irons and older chisels, though none are quite old enough to be 18th century.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#47Stephen, I've wondered about the tempering
Patrick Gibbons
The Rockwell c hardness for the laminated steel seemed to me to be about where the steel would be as quenched. If the steel has been normalized I would suspect that stress wouldn't be a factor. Having no experience yet with forging makes me dangerous as in I know enough to be ...
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#48
Re: Stephen, I've wondered about the tempering
Stephen Shepherd
Hardening
It is all in the brine quench. The basic three traditional methods of quenching are: oil, water, and brine. There are others but the three were in common use. Does anyone today quench in brine these days? No, they use water or oil and have no idea why they used brine.
Why the brine quench? To harden the steel to be very hard, even brittle, and had no intention of tempering as this was what was desired. It has the full protection of the wrought iron body to support the thin veneer of steel that has been forge welded [and work hardened] to produce the perfect combination for a cutting edge such as a plane blade, and chisel.
I have other laid steel tools that are tempered, a pick ax and a couple of drawknives. I have a late eighteenth century hoop driver that has a very hard work surface that resists a file. I have two early sickles with thin laid steel blades and they also require a rifle [water stone] to sharpen. I don’t think the sickles or hoop driver were ever tempered.
Many things made of steel do require tempering; springs, drill bits, augers, awls, etc. for improving their characteristics or to make them easier to sharpen.
My old laid steel tools don’t have any better steel than modern tools but because of their inherent nature they are harder than modern all steel tools, just because they can.
Stephen
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#49Re: Stephen, I've wondered about the tempering
david weaver
Stephen, I checked around and you remain the only person I've talked to who feels that their woodworking tools are not tempered.
Brine doesn't do anything magical to steel other than prevent gas pockets from forming during hardening (CW still quenches their water hardening tools in brine, the lack of use of brine has more to do with the type of steel that is common now than tempering methods).
Most steel is air or oil hardening and oil hardening without tempering is the tiniest bit softer in hardness than water hardening steel, or the same. Both are almost like glass without any tempering, and it is my belief that while some of your tools may be hard, they are not the hardness they would've likely had without tempering (66-68) unless they have either lost carbon or were not at the correct critical tempering.
We talk a lot about the durability of different steels on here and the perceived edge holding, but only through an actual test that tests use (and not abuse) and quantifies the results would we be able to tell. I have done a similar test (several years ago) between several A2 irons and a very hard carbon steel iron and thus far, I have not found any plain carbon steel irons that will last with a modern A2 iron in actual planing.
The same discussions exist regarding tamahagane, which only in razors have I seen quotes of 66-68 hardness. Even at that, they must be a trick to sharpen without chipping, I'd love to have one but they're $1,000 or so. These are modern razors made by iwasaki under ideal conditions and not vintage razors.
Re: Thanks to Stephen for his help with my article
#50Re: Stephen, I've wondered about the tempering
TomD
I always wondered how they got away with those big buckets of water, while I was forced to buy expensive oil for quenching. The large amount of iron in the weldment makes the whole thing behave differently than a solid piece of steel, as I was saying above there are a normal set of tricks of the trade in blacksmithing that account for a lot of stuff people either put down to economics or some technical explanation.
As far as tempering is concerned, when you build like this, you can temper the blade simply by using a double quench, and the heat sink in the bit, so to the average person's eye tempering may not appear to occur. For bizarre reasons the double quench is common in the making of Japanese swords. In the case of the Japanese steel it is pretty much maxed out Rockwell wise so tempering would be minimal. One can get away with making personal O1 tools without tempering them either. By diff hardening, and some extra care in personal use. I don't have to worry about some guy using it like a piton. I usually cycle it at cake temperatures just to make me feel like I am doing something a little "secret". I have a lot of steps like that.



