New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Posts

(Message Deleted by Poster)

#1

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#2

Re: Handmade Houses

roger lance

David.....I also have that book (but am unable to find my copy at the moment).....and I also bought it back in the 70's.....wonderful pictures and interesting reading.....the subject was of interest to me as my father was a home builder/remodeler and I grew up working with him on week ends and summers.....when This Old House first came on TV, I was drawn to it because of my dad and my building experiences and I was a little amazed that they were putting a camera on the workings of their main carpenter, Norm Abram, and were following him as he worked on rehabbing a building much as what my dad was doing.....years pasted and I was making my living in lines of work other than construction but my interest was still there and Norm was now doing a show on making furniture and there was a room in my basement that I had intended for a shop.....so my shop formed based on a power tool model.....now I come to this forum with that background.....and I have an increasing interest in and use of hand tools.....but my shop will always be blended.....no one should have to apologize for how they got to be as they are.....there are a lot of very educated, smart people on the hand tool forum....and I believe it is where the action is as forums go.....lots can be learned here and a little can be given back.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#3

A dream unrealized

Ron Harper

I have dreamed all my life of building my own timber frame home. I believe that I have the basic skills

needed and the ability to fairly quickly learn those that I do not have.

I am 67 years old, and I have by no means "quit" or started thinking of myself as an old man, but a realistic assessment would indicate that the optimum time for this achievement has passed. So, I join you and Charles in expressing my envy and my admiration for those who have done this.

I met an artist in Gatlinburg who had done this by dragging floating logs of a lake where he was living. Awesome.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#4

Found my copy !!.....

roger lance

and before I tore the house apart looking for it....which is a good thing.....it helps promote the domestic tranquility.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#6

Yes, indeed

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...that was one of the books that inspired me, although I will confess that, in our recent remodel work, I've tended to more newly purchased material, for a number of reasons. However, I do find that my younger son, now in the process of refurbishing a house (his first house purchase), is inspired, if not directly by this book, by the spirit it expresses. His work is marvelously creative.

I'm not sure it's a continuum as such, but, certainly, there are people who use hand tools for all their work, once the wood reaches their shop (and some who do green woodworking and use hand tools pretty nearly from the time they sight the tree that's going to turn into a project); people who use power tools almost exclusively and wouldn't be sure what to do with a chisel if you put a sharp one in their hands; and most folks, who blend hand* and power tools in just about an infinite number of gradations. It's all woodworking.

*I'll draw the line in a slightly different place from David: while I agree that hand-held tools, regardless of power source, require a very different working method than stationary machines to which the work is taken, I also think that tools powered by the muscles of the worker require a different working method/skill set than hand-held tools powered by electrons, air, steam, or other technologies.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#7

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#8

Good one... Remember it R squared


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#9

Re: Handmade Houses

john Veerkamp

I also bought that book when it was first out. I'd forgotten that Betty was co-author. Lots of ideas and inspiration in it.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#10

Re: Handmade Houses

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Hobbits don't need bathrooms?

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#11

Re: Handmade Houses

TomD

The problem I had realizing that dream, was finding the property. It just proved impossible for me to find a piece I would be willing to commit to for ever, and yet not end up in some place too far from everything, or get taken out with a speedway. I have noticed on some of the shows from California that people now regard the rural properties as too far, as they move more into the towns, not sure if that is valid, just something I noticed on that listings show, through to tapes about luthiers. But where I live, I went looking and ended up in a narrow property with a two story double long garage, fairly urban, though lots of water. The places I was looking at for my dream property took a toll Hwy up the... lot lines.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#12

Ellis Walentine

Hmm. Pun noted.

Ellis Walentine

David Pye's The Nature and Art of Workmanship was one of my most transforming reads when I was getting started in professional woodworking, after college in 1970. Pye's distinction wasn't between hand vs power tools exactly, but rather about skilled vs controlled processes, which tend to divide along those lines. It was a frame of mind that informed countless design decisions over the next forty-odd years and still continues to do so.

Ellis

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#13

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#14

Re: My point exactly

William Duffield

My impression (it's been quite a while since I read it) is that Pye's "risk" applies to ruining the work, but not so much to ruining the worker.

Risk to ones health and the environment is also important. In some cases, the powered tools, with the application of a bit more power and technology, can actually reduce these "absolute" risks. The first obvious example is the SawStop, the operation of which still has risk from airborne dust and kickback. But it presents less risk than some handsaws for digital amputation. Other power tools, which inherently create ample airborne dust, with the addition of attached, effective dust collection with automatic start, flexible dust hoses and hepafilters, can also substantially reduce health risks. On the other hand, hand scraping and hand sanding processes both raise significant amounts of fine particles, so the arguments one often reads or hears regarding drastically increased safety to you lungs for hand tools, can be a bit exaggerated.

David points out one other oft brought up point regarding planes being "only" jigged chisels, but this is also grossly oversimplifying. A chisel, no matter how skillfully guided, has negligible control in preventing tearout. A plane can be equipped with both a controlled mouth opening and a chip breaker, which are both effective at this function. If we want to split hairs, I guess we could argue that the chisel can also prevent tearout by turning it around when confronting contrary grain direction, or elevating it until it is being used in scraping mode.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#15

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#16

Re: Handmade Houses

john Veerkamp

Old fart brain re authors.!

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#17

Re: A plane is a machine

TomD

"David points out one other oft brought up point regarding planes being "only" jigged chisels, but this is also grossly oversimplifying. A chisel, no matter how skillfully guided, has negligible control in preventing tearout. A plane can be equipped with both a controlled mouth opening and a chip breaker, which are both effective at this function. If we want to split hairs, I guess we could argue that the chisel can also prevent tearout by turning it around when confronting contrary grain direction, or elevating it until it is being used in scraping mode."

A point I often make is that everything is a mold for something. So with a chisel, it is a mold in many regards, but it can be used in such a way that workmanship of certainty exists. For instance a 3/4" chisel makes a 3/4" cut. A straight chisel makes a straight mark. This may not immediately sound like much until one sees a set of carving chisels. And chisels have many other aspects of certainty, I can probably come up with 6 or 10, if pressed.

As far as planes are concerned, they are machines. And they have certainty identical to a table saw. The sole is the fence, and the blade is the blade. They have certainty in making things flat, or knocking off high points. They have certainty in cross section when doing stuff like molding. But they can be used in risk ways, flat plane making a circle like a round table, or just knocking off the excess while working to a line. I have done heavy work where it was a step down from a hatchet.

On the other hand, try shaping the bow of your boat with a 4 inch disk grinder. That is workmanship of risk. In fact most hand tool woodworkers know it only too well and shy away from grinding altogether.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#18

Re: Sartre

TomD

I always considered it as a branch of the Sartre en soi, pour soi. In theory the distinction is neutral, an identification of states. In the case of risk vs certainty it is a description of the degree to which certain tools or methods are open to creative input or the results are determined by the tool or process. The illustrated method was a machine that drove a chisel by means of a lever. It had elements of certainty, and elements of risk. The pattern carved was under the control of user but it was still a machine, with determined multiplication of user force, arc, fixturing, gouge section, gouge bevel, etc... Very useful distinction, but as with the en soi, pour soi, for the most part no pure examples.

Re: (Message Deleted by Poster)

#19

Re: Handmade Houses

Bruce McCrory

Hobbits in movies and books don't need bathrooms.