Re: that's correct
I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
Posts
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#52I think I understand
Ron Harper
Yes i can build the chest on chest, complete with mouldings in the manner of the 1720 s. probably not in a manner that will allow me to buy new Ipads for my family. Yes I agree with that.
Most of the guys making a living with hand tools are building pieces with fewer parts. As somebody ( too lazy to go back and see who) pointed out. You would very quickly learn what it would take to run a sustainable bench made furniture business with hand tools, make the adaptation, or go out of business.
Again, the majority of us on this forum do not need to worry about "production" many of us are like the trout fisherman who uses a fly rod. Yes we do bring home some fish to feed our family. But that really is not what it is all about.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#53Cause we like him
Ron Harper
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#54
Bill covers the waterfront
David Barnett
While he's certainly paid more than his fair share of hand tool dues on sharpening, line-and-berry inlay, dovetailing and M&Ts, he also has ideas that occasionally cause others to bristle (I know I do, as well). Now Bill certainly doesn't need an apologist, and frankly, has little to apologize for other than sometimes making one or more of us uncomfortable with our long-held and usually unchallenged opinions.
For example, he prefers modern glues to older glues, believes Big Lumber is far better at kiln drying than smaller 'boutique' mills, as he calls them, and even more so the hit-and-miss air-drying amateurs, whom he largely dooms to failure.
He also favors polyurethane, and sprayed polyurethane at that over oils, oil and varnish wiping mixtures, shellacs and French polish, even holding that he can spray a finish that cannot be visually distinguished from rubbed oil (I differ).
He likes diamond. I like diamond. So I almost forgot that one.
He has an abiding appreciation for machinery, both industrial and for consumer woodworking, and like Mark Hennebury, is dubious of a hand-tools-alone approach meeting the needs of most who do woodworking for a living, but is open to exceptions and open-minded and curious about other ways of doing things.
He also has an abiding appreciation for craftsmanship and design at all levels and is the first to unabashedly admit he falls short of other's talents and abilities and give them full credit for theirs.
Most of all, while he respects expertise, he thinks things through and arrives at his own conclusions, states them, and accepts when he is wrong. So while I don't always agree with Bill, and sometimes think he's a bit brusque, I read what he posts and find it thought-provoking.
For awhile, Bill posted more to the main message board than here as he felt more people made things over there, a loss to those of us who spend most of our time on Hand Tools, and I'd hate to see him return to that pattern, as he's offered a shot in the arm to bench plane users with his perseverance in getting the articles on chip breakers translated and presented on this forum and also, his recurring threads on what people are making.
Yeah, sometimes Bill's a bit terse and blunt but he aims for the bullseye and that comes with the territory, so I say we keep him around. 
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#55Prosyletizing
jack curtis
I suspect that if machine tool woodworkers were in the minority, they'd be prosyletizing, too.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#56Re: The romance of the hands
jack curtis
I think Krenov enforces Mark's argument, given that he was very well off, at least at the start of his life.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#57
I second that
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#58Re: Why hand tools (sorry, rather long)
hennebury
Trust me....we are light years apart.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#59Another violation
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I have failed to limit myself to chairs. I have failed to limit myself to tiny things like Bill's "good friend who is an excellent woodworker". And now this evening I find that I am in violation of the 100 part rule because I have spent the day working on a piece of furniture that has too many parts. I don't think an amateur in Tennessee should be telling us what kind of work we should accept or how we should do it.
My son has inherited a desk that has been in the family for seven generations. Apparently neither the young farmer that originally bought the desk nor the maker was aware of the 100 part rule. There are 99 parts in the upper drawers alone, and the lower drawers have cock beading and line inlay.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#60Yeah but you really do make beautiful stuff
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#61Re: Another violation
Marhk
Is there some celestial, unwritten rule that encourages "experts" to be boorish, condescending and generally obnoxious with rude replies on these boards? Why can't people have a logical, spirited argument without attacking the motivation or reputation of a fellow contributor?
Perhaps we all in this new year should resolve to avoid personal attacks. Stick to the facts of the argument. The other person has a point of view, attack it, disagree with it - BUT, above all, respect it!
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#62The trouble is...
John in NM
"As hobbyists, I believe we should embrace the spirit of John Brown's remarks."
That is the proselytizing that rubs a lot of us yankees the wrong way 
I'm sorry to say I did not make it all the way through the gentleman's article. About one third of the way in I decided he was wasting my time - I've read similiar opinions ad infinitum on various forums - and so moved on to more interesting things.
I would not try to talk Mr. Brown or anyone else out of their way of living, and all I expect in return is the same courtesy extended to me. I use machinery to save me time, time that is in short supply both in the near term and the long term. I congratulate those who are at one with the wood or whatever, but I'm in a bit more of a rush
I cut a lot of mortises on a routine basis, the only difference to me between the hollow chisel machine and a mortise chisel is that one is faster than the other, and also more prone to inconvenient failure. I put up with the latter in order to gain the former.
This whole silly thread seems to be an escalation of another below. Why don't we all go make something instead of wasting time on this? I have yet to see any of us here who use both kinds of tools bash someone's effort that was all made with hand tools.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#63Re: Krenov had it right
TomD
Well the reality is that it is not a living to do good work. So at what point is it sensible to reduce the quality in order to continue to make a bad living. Krenov had it right. It is a job for amateurs, in the vast majority of cases. Then there are others, who are lying their way into the pockets of the rich. And then there are people who can't make a living. You can't automate your way out of the problem. It looks like a glider chair factory when you do.
The famous woodworkers, mentioned are mostly famous by definition for something other than their woodwork. They are media starts, writers, teachers, artist, etc...
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#64Re: The romance of the hands
TomD
"Just to clarify this for others, though I know you know this, James Krenov used machines in his woodworking profusely."
"profusely", as in extravagantly or greatly. I think that would be an exaggeration. He used them for the first 1/3rd, and somewhat in the making of joints. He often used them oddly, as in feeding wood by hand into spinning milling machine bits. If you re-read his chapter on his machine selections, there is a great deal of thought given to not divorcing himself from the material or method. By selecting machines of greater worth, or less separation, or the choosing of certain machines for certain things only. Most of what we know in print about his methods was written fairly early in his career, at a time when very little hand work was being advanced and when a person would have felt bullied into some kind of relationship with power tools. Particularly given his industrial arts education.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#65Re: posers
TomD
"Not asking anybody to do anything. Just don't snarl at hand tool advocates on a hand tool site"
It is not a hand tool only site. This could be a place where people who do 99% of their work with power come, just as much as the reverse.
I've been at a lot of marginal stuff for 40 years now. I always try the hard way. What one notices is that after a while people discover the activity, who say they are bowhunters, flyfishermen, free climbers, trad climbers, soloists, bicycle only commuters, motorless sailors, and hand tool woodworkers. They blather on about how hard core they are instead of actually doing anything, and the sharp end of the spectrum is the ideal place for them because they have a ready made excuse for not doing anything. And what is more, for many people it is hard to tell the difference. At times a good success rate in bowhunting was about 5%, then you take the guys who subtract the aids of one sort or another, that are legion, and you are down to a pretty thin wedge. So how to tell the poser from the person who is not.
Or I could of mentioned sailing. Who really does what I do, never takes a sailing lesson, designs and builds their own boat, does not have a motor, then teaches themselves to sail it with virtually zero instruction, on a very open water lake with constant squalls. It isn't practical, natural, and it is probably anti-social. Meanwhile, I live by the water, in two places, and have never seen a sailboat without an auxiliary, but apparently there are lots of no motor sailors. In my case I did have a motor, but it got stolen before the boat got wet. Serendipity. They came for the motor...
I don't give a toss about making blanket boxes for the spawn, let them discover their own adventures.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#66Re: A bandsaw, right, & 10" TS, 10" jointer-planer
TomD
Maybe from the fact that he had his machines in a separate room, which is just good practice if you can find a way.
If one looks at the giants, for want of a better word, of the craft revival. Krenov, Castle, Maloof, Frid, Nakashima, Carpenter, Fortune, etc... All folks who are revered for lifestyle, artistic contribution, some penetration beyond the woodworking hobby, skilled hands. They all used hand tools, and tons of power tools. The whole hand tool woodworking is an all hand tool thing, is relatively recent. And so far, I am at a loss to ascribe any noteworthy achievements to it. Meaning I know of no great artist/craftsmen, or anything else, from it.
Basically the whole thing is driven by consumerism. The biz finally grew to a point, in tools, and people and magazines, where it became practical to lead people through the whole machine thing, then get them to reject those and buy a few hundred other tools. That's what it was about. There is more money in hand tools, particularly given where machines come from these days.
Krenov became student oriented, and his last book is basically a rejection of his first four, and he grew to feel for people who could not make a living, I guess it got old just telling them to live off their wives. College of the Redwoods, had a bench room and a machine room. In Krenov form.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#67Re: I accept your criticism, will mend ways
TomD
"You really should visit a museum or two with a decent decorative arts collection if you think that hand tools are a per se limitation to building, well, anything. Hit a couple of museums here then go to Europe and check out a dozen or so Medieval churches. Attitude adjustment."
You're late to the party, I don't know anyone here who has such thoughts about limits. Hand tools are always the least limited and most essential, there are no machines without hands to scrape the machines to make them. As just one example. Where do you come up with this stuff?
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#68Re: Thanks Bill not much mending needed
TomD
"I absolutely agree with Mark that it is very unusual for a craftsman to be able to support his family with commissions or sales of fine furniture as his only source of income. That is truly a very sad commentary on our culture."
If you take Giants of the Craft, say Nakashima, or Maloof. Until recently they would not even show up in books on modern furniture, or they would be on one page, one chair amid hundreds of others. The reality is that even our best guys have pretty nearly zero penetration in the biz, while alive. Now they are there in a collecting way, but they virtually did not influence culture. The rest of us count not at all. So part of the reason why we don't have an impact is because we are not designers. That is the side you go up through. The idea of the hands on dude who makes his own designs, is lovely, but pretty ridiculous. I guess I buy it, but the culture does not. Fingerprints are something you wipe off. And judging by the past, the hands are nameless, the designers like Sheridan are remembered. Ultimately woodworking, is just labour, anyone can do it, that is why it is a pleasant hobby. They don't remember Picasso for his dexterity cleaning his brushes.
"I just got a little ouchy that several posts in the last few days have pointed out how impractical hand tools are. Seems unseemly on a hand tool site."
The all hand tool worker is pretty much a myth. Impractical for what? Even with an 090 chainsaw, it is getting to be a lot of work to get trees from the woods. And without my 090, or F150, it pretty much would not happen. I have hewn logs, it's slow. I have resawn by hand, and split stuff out. Practical, who knows, it was the only way to get those logs. It was good exercise and out of doors. You can only judge practicality against something. And hand tools are good for certain things, impractical for others.
"Again, my use of hand tools is not virtuous,"
It could, ask Al Gore. Or it could represent various virtues like perseverance. There is a hierarchy of skills, some people are lower, some people are higher. People who refuse to cross over, may well be in the middle. I don't personally have more respect for someone who makes worse hand planes than I do, and can't use a chainsaw, or my mill, or metal or wood lathe shaper, sewing machine, whatever. Because a person has mastered a chisel, or wait a moment, sidestepped that so they could buy a Ti fretsaw, does not make them more skilled.
" does not make my work better than anyone else's work, or any of that kind of nonsense."
Well it could. The fewer one's limits... though too many things can distract one from mastery also.
"It is purely a matter of personal choice because I find it much more rewarding."
I'm not sure this is my favourite side of you.
All that personal choice stuff is a cop out.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#69Re: Another violation
TomD
"Is there some celestial, unwritten rule that encourages "experts" to be boorish, condescending and generally obnoxious with rude replies on these boards? Why can't people have a logical, spirited argument without attacking the motivation or reputation of a fellow contributor?"
Maybe "experts" in quotes.
"Perhaps we all in this new year should resolve to avoid personal attacks. Stick to the facts of the argument. The other person has a point of view, attack it, disagree with it - BUT, above all, respect it!"
I respect people, and am mindful of the fact I might like them, or even be intimidated by their accomplishments if I met them. But their opinions? I see no reason to respect those. Write with the reader in mind, not yourself, and respect the person behind the opinion, but tear the opinion limb from limb if required.
There is little reason to hit the "post" button if what you have written is only going to help your personal cause and not help others. It may be tempting to put some outrage up there in the hope others will validate it, no mater how rarely. But it will be better for everyone in the long run if what is written it written in the hope it will help someone. Of course it may be useless, but at least one tried to help the other, not simply to get a pat on the ego (that probably will not come).
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#70Huh?
jack curtis
All Ron said was that he doesn't come here to discuss power tools or to hear a lot of criticism of those who use hand tools. Fairly innocuous as nearly as I can tell. I don't expect to see a lot of non-hand tool discussion here, either.
As to John Brown, I found it interesting that his grandmother correlated human heart beat rates and the tools we use, still thinking about this; but mostly it was a screed on how to live on much less than the rest of us. I find that good sense, especially when faced with no alternative jobs, etc. Sad in some ways, but we humans have this ultimately hopeless trend to try to survive and enjoy it; and there are so many more of us in this spot today. At least he kept working at what he enjoyed.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#71Wow
Ron Harper
Noticed that you graded a lot of our papers. Some one has to do it.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#72I had a friend who worked food service
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
and who told me that, in decent restaurants - that is, where the different staff members respect each other - the serving staff split their tips with the back room. After all, the best waitressing/waitering in the world won't make up for bad food.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#73Re: Huh?
TomD
"All Ron said was that he doesn't come here to discuss power tools or to hear a lot of criticism of those who use hand tools. Fairly innocuous as nearly as I can tell. I don't expect to see a lot of non-hand tool discussion here, either."
It still comes down to what a hand tool is. For me it is a lot of weird stuff, for others it is that thing that doesn't plug in, and needs to be dug out of a box every now and again, and stops working when the factory sharpness wears out. Both are legitimate perceptions of what it is.
"As to John Brown, I found it interesting that his grandmother correlated human heart beat rates and the tools we use, still thinking about this; but mostly it was a screed on how to live on much less than the rest of us."
Old people say a lot of weird stuff. My mother used to think the metric system would fail for cooking, because "we haven't changed the size of the egg". She was the female equivalent of a Rhodes Scholar, and still does academic work at 85. Old people just say weird stuff.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#74Re: Wow
TomD
Now that is a good squelch, I wish I had thought of that. People are always saying "that isn't an argument, that is just an ad hominem attack". Yeah try it, it isn't so easy.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
#75Re: Huh?
jack curtis
Old people just say weird stuff.
No dispute there, except to add that all people say weird stuff. For example, what's the female equivalent of the Rhodes Scholar? So these women get great, high paying jobs after their "program?" Or what?
As I get older I find I have problems understanding half of what's written here. Brown's grandmother's remark was still interesting, to me.



