I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
Ron Harper
Probably start a war.
http://tonykonovaloff.com/?page_id=1064
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
I love this post on Konovaloff's site *LINK*
Ron Harper
Probably start a war.
http://tonykonovaloff.com/?page_id=1064
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site
hennebury
entertaining, not in the least realistic, but entertaining.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site
Ron Harper
Works for Konovaloff. Why do you think it unrealistic?
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site
hennebury
Because I can do some basic math.
Mortagage payment, taxes, insurance, utilities,carpayment etc. x chairs per year?
It works if you are already wealthy and don't need to work. which kind of means, it doesn't work for the average person.
Woodworking is already the lowest paid of all trades, no you want to reduce that by making me rip and dress lumber by hand and take my time making works of art to sell to whom, the locals, the average neigbour?
What would you have to charge per chair to earn a reasonable living and support a family in this day and age.
explain the math to me.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site
Ron Harper
I understand that you may not want to do it that way. Konavaloff does, Fidgen does, Jim Tolpin does, for the most part, and a whole bunch of chair makers do. They have found it to be realistic. Again, for some guys it works. an acquaintance of mine just bought a CNC machine so he could produce product faster. I understand that. But, to me his material could be aluminum, plastic, or any other product. It is machine manufacturing. Much "woodworking" today is shoving sticks through machines. I do not find fault with it. I just do not want to do it any more.
It seems to work for chairs...
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Few parts and machines don't cut out much labor. Lots of people making a modest living making more or less hand tool chairs.
My recent chest of drawers had something like 75 parts. Anybody think they could find customers to pay for making it without a table saw, jointer and thickness planer? Anybody think they could make several for family before they died?
I have no quibble with folks that choose a life style and then adapt what they do in life to their choice. The alternative can be to choose what one wants to do in life and then adapt a life style to achieve it. I can do with out the preaching and unnecessary justifications of these choices.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site
hennebury
I would like to spend my days in woodworking bliss also. But lets deal with reality.
what woodworking needs more than anything is to tell the truth, and the truth is that the vast majority of people who try, will never earn a living doing fine woodwork! Having a successful fine woodworking shop is not the norm, its not easy, it is not just a matter of being interested, talented and dedicated. The general public, don't understand what is involved and wont pay for it.
You can try to educate the world, but that is a tough row to hoe.
A very small percentage of people will make it, the ones where all the stars line up perfectly... the talent , experience, the motivation the right time the right location the lucky break, some kind of alternative income.
The rest will close their shops soon after reality sets in, some will get the only decent paying woodworking job. teaching.
The truth should be told to all the new people that are interested in woodworking and considering a career in it.
For perspective; Take some of the professions and trades, doctors, lawyers, architects, plumbers, electricians, welders, mechanics, fine woodworkers.
I would guess that you can already pick the odd one out on the lifestyle scale.
if you followed a hundred people from each of these trades, how many of each trade would be able to support themselves with a decent lifestyle after finishing training. In the following years almost all would be able to get jobs earning a decent payscale, almost all that went into business would earn a good living except the woodworkers; almost all of whom would not.
Example: every mechanic, plumber, electrician etc. can go to any house in the neighborhood and quote a job at a $100 an hour and get the job. try doing that as a woodworker.
The guy that cut my tree down charges $125 an hour, said the job would be about $600 at the end of the day said it took longer so was $930, try quoting your neighbors like that. His equipment does not cost him any more than my shop and equipment cost me. The general public simply will not pay woodworkers anywhere near that kind of money for your time.
Do you think that James Krenov was making a good living in his basement in Sweden, before he became famous.
I would like to hear from woodworkers who can just go and set up a shop, hang up a shingle like any plumber or electrician and make a decent living selling to the general population doing fine work; I would like to hear how easy it is., and how many have done it.
Maybe take a poll and see how many have tried and not been successful and a how many have made it, just so we have some perspective.
I tried for forty years, so I would like to hear some other points of view.
I recently got a call from a Human resources company saying that a company was looking for someone with "my skills" a "master Cabinetmaker" they offered me $16.50 an hour to start.
I told them to F**K off that I started forty years ago.
Lets have some reality and lets hear what woodworkers actually earn.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: The romance of the hands
cstanford
Just to clarify this for others, though I know you know this, James Krenov used machines in his woodworking profusely.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site
cstanford
John Brown was like all of us. He owned a home and had a job - happened to be working in a boatyard but he made enough to incur the bills we all know and love. Then he was laid off - the yard he was working in converted to fiberglass and the wood guys were given a choice. He left. He sold his house, acknowledged being depressed after losing his job, saw a Welsh stick chair in a window and started building them. He bought some land and paid his bills with the proceeds from the sale of his house, built a small shop in which he also lived (his children were all grown at this point), and he made chairs for a living. I believe he was divorced but don't know this for sure.
The most memorable line from his book, of a nonwoodworking nature, is "I make enough for a simple life, no more." The shop had no electricity, only phone service.
Re: The romance of the hands
William Duffield
My understanding is the only power tool he used in his shop was a bandsaw. Of course, someone else with a sawmill roughed out the lumber from logs that he built with. Perhaps you are thinking of Sam Maloof?
Thanks David
Thought this was a hand tool site?
It is of course...
John in NM
The reality is that many of us use both hand tools and machines on a regular basis. Are we to attempt to hide this fact? Carefully edit out any mention of our use of machines?
Some jobs are simply done more efficiently with a machine, in other cases, a hand tool is more efficient or the results are more desirable for various reasons. Why fight reality?
No
Ron Harper
Not asking anybody to do anything. Just don't snarl at hand tool advocates on a hand tool site
I don't think anyone snarled at you...
John in NM
Not everyone will share enthusiasm for this particular article, simply because the author's work and lifestyle is not applicable to many of us. The article is basically an opinion that many people will not agree with - same as most other opinions 
Different people will naturally have different motivations for pursuing woodworking. One of those motivations can be making money, another can be producing useful furniture while one still has a few years ahead to actually use it. I see neither of these being any less or more credible than the desire to make art.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re read Bill's last comment
I have...
John in NM
And frankly, I'm a little mystified what the problem is. Mere disagreement should not be taken as an insult.
But you seem determined to be offended and argumentative, so I'll just let anything further pass.
Re: I have...
Ron Harper
John,
Why come to a hand tool site and tell us that use them how inefficient and impractical we are?
As I have said before, I really don 't care how you work wood. I just get tired of coming to a hand tool site and be told how table saws, planers, and jointers, and God forbid, routers are more efficient ways to work wood. There are other places for that kind of smugness.
Re: I love this post on Konovaloff's site
Edward in Vancouver
I've been reading the whole chain of posts, and there is a lot of good observations and opinions in there.
However, I must disagree with hennebury, IMHO the lowest paid profession are the cooks and bakers.
Yet, I can and do operate a "boutique" chocolate shop, where everything in the store is made by me, by hand.
One of my "trade secrets" is to get local schools to bring their kids by--after-school activities--usually 1 hr /week for 4 weeks. We make all kinds of chocolate stuff together. The kids quickly understand how much labour goes into a chocolate figure, their parents do not. About 1 in ten of the kid's parents come in to see us, after their kids told them (over and over again) of the various processes and techniques involved. The parents are now "educated" and can appreciate the difference between boutique stuff and drugstore stuff.
Face it, most people don't know the difference between knotty pine, and mdf covered with pine "foil", or why mechanical fasteners are inferior to wood joints, that it isn't "normal" to toss out dining room chairs after 5 years,--or why they were made from spruce in the first place.
Basically, the public can't demand good furniture if they don't know it actually exists........
A restaurant manager confirmed your statement
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I don't know anything about managing a restaurant. But, I have a boundless curiosity so when I got to chat with a manager I asked "what is the highest paid job in the restaurant", confident the answer would be cook. Nope! The head cook was some over minimum wage. I was floored. That person that juggles a myriad of orders for several hours straight and that the restaurant depends on for satisfied customers makes $10-12/hr. On the other hand his best waitress works double weekend shifts and pulls in $2K a week part time, and goes to college by day.
Re: A bandsaw, right, & 10" TS, 10" jointer-planer
William Duffield
Very curious. A very minor point: your references are to his second book, The Fine Art of Cabinetmaking, not to his first book, A Cabinetmaker's Notebook. That confused me for a bit, but you are correct. At that time, at least, in his personal shop, he kept and used a machine room full of the forked tailed apprentices. I can't currently find my copy of The Impractical Cabinetmaker, and I don't think I own a copy of James Krenov, Worker in Wood. His last book, With Wakened Hands only shows furniture and the tools and benches in the College of the Redwoods, so that doesn't help me figure out where so many of us got this mistaken notion. Some more research will be necessary. At this point I can speculate that some time after he wrote the second book he may have modified his personal practices (as many others have done, including Jim Tolpin and Bob Rozaieski, for example), and stopped using some of the power tools. Of course, they would still have been available to him at the College of the Redwoods. The possibility also exists that someone later wrote a piece that romanticized his practices to some extent. I'll keep looking, because this idea must have come from somewhere.
Re: I have...
hennebury
The only smugness that i have come in contact with is from some people who's exclusive use of hand tools is little more than an ego trip that they feel somehow makes them special, that adds some mystical touchy feeling immeasurable superior quality to their work. These are where we hear the terms like "pushing sticks through machines" when they refer to people that use machinery.
I have worked both with hand tools and machines, and to me they are all tools, neither one any more or less noble.
The job that i do is of import to me not the tools that i do it with. The quality of the work should speak for itself, it does not need a salesman standing next to it explaining why its so special because it was made with hand tools.
I will use the best tools at my disposal to do the best work in the most efficient way.
The rest is BS.
What i asked for is some truth and perspective about the reality of woodworking as a career.
I love hand-tools and have a lot of respect for the care and use of them, but i think that as a group on a forum which is used to educate new woodworkers I think that we owe some honest perspective to the realities of earning a living as a fine woodworker.
The facts are quite clear as I mentioned earlier, any tradesperson ( with the exception of cooks and bakers; thanks Edward) , be it plumber , electrician, welder, machinist, mechanic etc. can start their own business in their neighborhood and can expect to make a decent living charging $60 -$100 per hour,
Fine woodworkers cannot! in fact if you quoted your jobs @ $10 an hour you would not get most of the jobs you quoted.
not so grim
Jack Guzman from Maine
Your figures are correct---for you. It isn't necessary to have that much overhead and many people don't. I know quite a few that live around here in the Maine woods that live very basically and love the life. I do woodworking for the love of it. It pays the bills,but I don't do it for the money. I don't pay a mortgage,I don't pay rent. I built my house with discarded materials for no cost. What I'm trying to say is that your opinion is too grim. Reality does not have to be that grim. John Brown's world is not a fantasy. It is doable.People like him are necessary to keep the hope alive that we don't have to be slaves to money. We don't have to compromise everything just to survive. New woodworkers should be aware of this as well as the realities of life.
Your are right but only in the context of your own lifestyle. It's not the same for everyone. I do use power tools as well as hand tools because that is what works for me,not because I have to.---Jack