Re: The romance of the hands
cstanford
He did not own a bandsaw but did use one at the lumber yard to rough out arm blanks for bending. You're right.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Re: The romance of the hands
cstanford
He did not own a bandsaw but did use one at the lumber yard to rough out arm blanks for bending. You're right.
Re: not so grim
cstanford
What, Jack, you mean you don't have a 2013 Yukon in the driveway with the works?
Man, you're a real loser.
Can I be one too?
Jeez Charles..
david weaver
...I haven't seen a bigger setup in a while than this:
"Man, you're a real loser.
Can I be one too?"
Re: It is of course...
cstanford
There's no doubt in my mind that a whole lot of machine use is carefully edited out of some of the pictorials posted on this site and many others on 'hand tool' pages.
Things occasionally slip through what is usually careful editing: I recall seeing a Hammer tablesaw that surely was inadvertently caught in a pic or two. Hard to believe that sort of machinery is sitting around gathering dust. "Hand tool" projects become a lot more viable with that sort of capability lying around loose, like it doesn't care. I'd say that most hand tool projects fail in later stages because of the lack of accuracy in four-squaring and hand milling parts on the front end. If you substitute machinery at this stage then you're way ahead of the game - this is what machines do best and it's damn hard to do by hand. And this is fine, nobody is being asked to wear a hair shirt. Just be honest. You have been. A lot of others have not I suspect or at least present shades of gray with regard to all of this. They may even be kidding themselves into believing the machines aren't really playing that large a role in the backend success of the project. They are.
Re: No Cost House - Have to Share
david weaver
Threads like this always get people cranked up, but the best thing I have see in the whole thread is that you made your house out of free materials.
Have you ever shared any details in posts? That's a topic that I think would be interesting, even if a lot of us are already in "store bought" houses.
Re: No Cost House - Have to Share
Jack Guzman from Maine
That was almost 30 years ago,though I'm still working on it. I was a mechanic . I learned as I built. I could probably tell of the building process in a new thread sometime.I never thought about it. It was recycling at an extreme with alot of trial and error.---Jack
Re: Jeez Charles..
cstanford
It's a joke, you fool.
Re: not so grim
cstanford
Just to be clear - what I wrote below was poking fun at Mr. Hennebury not you (but through your post).
Your life sounds utterly fantastic to me. I envy you in the strongest sense of the word.
Re: not so grim
hennebury
Hi Jack,
You are right of course it can work for a certain few in certain situations,
How about along with the nice photos of the work we have an idea of how long the job took and how much one got paid, (a thing that never seems to be discussed) because without that it there is no way to understand what woodworking really is.
Doing good work is not difficult; it takes knowledge, experience, skill, dedication, commitment and time.
I believe that most woodworkers would be ashamed to tell how little they actually get paid and how long they work.
Many who have nice shops and do nice work have an alternate income from on source or another, and their woodworking " business"is really just a glorified and subsidized hobby.
I dont have a problem with any of that, i would however like for people to explain their situation, so that we can understand how they are able to manage.
Doing great work and not explaining your situation is of little value in my opinion.
If you are doing great work and posting the photos of you work on the forums for all of the other woodworkers to see it would be nice to understand how you manage to do such fine work.
If you have a wealthy client that has kept you in work for the past 5 or 6 years, or if you husband or wife supports you and your are losing money on every job. Or if you have found a good balance where you can live like most and have found how to earn a living and pay a mortgage. This is the stuff that makes it real.
Just posting photos of nice work, with no context does nothing for me, anyone can do nice work in the right circumstances.
I worked for years and every year was a struggle, to a point where my insistence on doing good work was
was little more than a self indulgent hobby. It took all of my time and cost me and my family a lot.
My opinion at this point in time is that with very few exceptions fine woodworking is not a viable career, it is and should be a hobby. Maybe I am alone in that opinion, but i would like to hear from everyone else to get a broader perspective.
Last year I spoke to a small bunch of students who had completed a woodworking program at the local college and of course they are all going out full of hope, I believe, totally unprepared for the reality of the world that they are stepping into. Most of them got jobs dressed in full has-mat suits scraping lead paint off of old windows. Because they couldn't find any fine woodworking shops that actually build fine furniture to go work in. They get paid $13 and hour. They don't get to use to many of their fine tools or freshly learned skills in that environment.
The fact is they will probably never get to use any of their tools and skills in any place of employment, and if they want to pursue fine woodworking will eventually have try their own shop.
So how about we let them know what to expect.
I have given my opinion, i am just one person, so the more opinions the more realistic and balanced understanding of Fine woodworking as a career will be.
I started off with hand tools only, then progressed to more machinery in an effort to survive and get things done faster while still doing the best quality of work that i could do.
I could hardly recommend for people to give up their machines and handplane and handsaw everything for a living, that is to me insane and would be most insincere.
I accept your criticism, will mend ways
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
I have a good friend who is an excellent woodworker. He makes stunning clocks and small, one could say tiny, cabinets. I learned in casual conversation that he had largely converted to hand tools, Japanese style. What he makes is small and has few parts. And, he doesn't feel the need to proselytize his conversion to others. He never motivated me to vocally comment on his woodworking choices. His work speaks for itself.
Mark and I made a factual response to your post, each pointing out that the choice to pursue hand tool purism places substantial limitations on the kind of woodworking this choice necessitates. I used the example of what it would be practical to build and Mark the sort of living one could expect. Mark further went on to say that it is fair game to point out these facts. Our responses are fair game for this Forum and we believe they provide useful information to the undecided.
Hand tool enthusiasts seem to have the need to proselytize their choices. Mark was bolder than I in being critical of this proselytizing but in general you may find that it becomes tedious and annoying to the unconverted. That said, as you correctly state, this is the Hand Tool Forum. Accepting the fact that hand tool enthusiasts have the need to proselytize, the rest of us should quietly accept this situation on the Hand Tool Forum.
However, there will be occasions when the enthusiasm of hand tool purists leads to overselling or misrepresenting its merits. You all need to accept the fact that this situation will lead to others challenging your beliefs in order to provide the undecided with an alternative view.
Re: should be a hobby..
david weaver
Out my way (or in central PA where I grew up), we have a lot of people who have chair shops (mennonites) or small production makers of furniture (mennonites or amish). What they make I would call amish furniture, because it's almost distinctly country amish. Not offensive in so much as a lot of furniture called rustic is, but not exactly shaker even though they use the term for some of their makes. It's like rounded over shaker.
Anyway, from time to time there will be a young amishman or mennonite near where I grew up who will take commissions on furniture when they're starting out. If they don't get cabinet commissions for something they do over and over or something like kitchen cabinets, they usually go to trim. (this is the guys working by themselves).
I know a couple of guys who are amish cabinetmakers, but they only do kitchen cabinet type work for pay, and before they were able to get customers doing that, they made mouldings and other trim carpentry wares. They only do anything that doesn't resemble either of those two things as favors on the side (like they may make 4 or 5 tables for someone they know, only in a batch, though).
They are already working for very little compared to what we'd expect, and making stuff that is good quality, but "fine" would not be the definition I use, it's more practical.
The skilled few local guys (in finish work, etc) are doing restoration and repair work instead of building.
There is just too much price pressure, unless you do the very finest work and have a good book of high $$ customers.
Here is a line that some friends of mine gave me, I kid you not. They used the one of the amish cabinetmakers above (they know him very well, because he comes over to watch TV) and he made 5 of them oak tables with leaves to extend to 10 feet, $400 per table with fairly chairs. The chairs they left unfinished...here's their line as to why. "we didn't let ___ finish the chairs because he wated $10 each to finish them, and we found a mennonite guy who would do it for $5". They the mennonite chair guy stained and polyurethaned for $5 each...can you believe that?
How can you even deal with that?
People can't take loans to buy furniture. They can take loans to refinish a kitchen and their friends are a lot more likely to notice trim in a house or cabinets. Naturally there is going to be more price room in something a buyer can take a loan out to buy.
Also, I have never seen either of the amishmen use hand tools, and they spray their finish. They have them, but they don't use them. All of the furniture and chairs that are still made as I referred above are made in medium sized production shops that employ amish and mennonite (and are amish or mennonite owned). They are completely mechanized. Pneumatic tools in the amish shops and electric in the mennonite shops.
Re: Jeez Charles..
david weaver
What's with the nastiness charles? I doubt anyone on here didn't realize that.
Why hand tools (sorry, rather long)
Patrick Gibbons
I am a hobbyist. I don't make a living from woodworking. Using hand tools takes more skills than using machines. Machines, to me, are boring to use and potentially more dangerous. Bill, you mentioned a recent project you made that required machines for a speedy conclusion and you remarked that someone making multiples would be hard pressed to do it without machines. I made some beds a number of years ago that required hundreds of mortises which I hand chopped. My choice being to use hand tools convinced me that I can make projects more suited for hand work. So I only made two beds this way. My point is not that you're wrong (because you're right about that project) but that one can choose to build projects more appropriate to how you wish to build them. As hobbyists, I believe we should embrace the spirit of John Brown's remarks. What he says about machines is true. I'm not a purist. I use my table saw to rip and my drill press to drill accurately. I prefer to buy wood that's been surfaced because doing this by hand is tedious. But I would tell anyone starting out that they can get into the hobby with a small investment by buying their wood surfaced and learning to use hand tools. They will have more skill, more satisfaction and better product at the end of the day. They will not save money over buying furniture. I have never been able to build a piece cheaper than I could buy it, using either hand or machine. I find it interesting that some say that those who argue in favor of hand tool use are preachy. It sounds preachy because we Americans have a good, strong bias against elitism. And favoring hand tool use can sound elitist. So I want to put it in an American, anti-elitist context and argue that hand tool use is just good, old fashioned Yankee ingenuity. As an American, I want to do it better, cheaper and faster. The machine manufacturers are liars. They want me to shell out big bucks for foreign-made goods that don't give me a good return on my investment. By being self-reliant, I can build skills that save my money and give me better results. Ladies and gentlemen, we're not really that far off in our opinions.
Re: I accept your criticism, will mend ways
CStanford
You really should visit a museum or two with a decent decorative arts collection if you think that hand tools are a per se limitation to building, well, anything. Hit a couple of museums here then go to Europe and check out a dozen or so Medieval churches. Attitude adjustment.
Outright efficiency, or lack thereof, is way way down on the list of things that would keep a *mostly* or even pure hand tool woodworker from making a living at his or her craft. Lack of real talent, lack of a unique artistic vision, building a lot of 'me-too' stuff, and thing of this ilk would be main reasons IMO.
Anybody having something fresh to say in the medium really isn't that worried about how they tool up. The tools just become a way to express their design - no big deal, let's get this thing off paper and into wood. Getting wadded up about tools is for the rest of us who think that building a big Federal reproduction from a set of step by step plans (that has been done by others and done much better) is somehow going to lift us into big time woodworking or maybe get some oohs and aahs on a forum.
There are a relative handful of people doing world class reproductions and derivative designs (David Lamb comes immediately to mind). I've never seen one regularly participating on a woodworking forum. And the folks doing really original stuff are rarely seen either.
Substatial limitations
Warren in Lancaster, PA
I'm not sure you know what you are talking about when you talk about the substantial limitations of hand tool work. Frankly I would be shocked if you could turn out a chest of drawers as fast as a one man shop in 1780.
One of my customers is a large custom woodworking business, with a nationwide clientele and maybe 50 employees. Their trucks say "If you can imagine it we can build it." I am a small part of that equation because they bring to me the things they cannot build. Hand tools are just more versatile. And some pieces are just too big for their machines.
In 1926 the Philadelphia Museum of Art bought and removed the interior woodwork from a house in Lebanon County, Pennsylvania and displays it in the Pennsylvania Dutch room. A few years ago I got a job from one of my cabinetmaker friends making the mantle tree for over the fireplace for the original house. He delivered a piece of white oak 21"X22"X165". I had to cut a shelf and a moulding from the solid, like the original. The moulding was 5 inches deep and 16 inches high. I doubt your planer or your router table could handle 530 board feet of timber in one chunk. And I wonder which of your many power saws would cut a neat crosscut on the end of a 21X22.
On the left is the beam I copied as displayed in the museum
Thanks Bill not much mending needed
Ron Harper
If you go back through the history of my posts. You will be very hard pressed to find any proselytizing. I have said repeatedly.. I really do not care if you cut your dovetails with a chainsaw. I agree with you and Mark that the work speaks much louder than any posts on a web site. It has to be said that the overwhelming majority of the folks on this site do NOT work wood as the primary source of their livelihood. Mark is entirely correct in that that circumstance forces a very hard look at methodology and the resulting consequences. Jack very correctly points out that many have gone through that process and have chosen , for whatever reason, to use hand tools exclusively. They are not idiots.
I absolutely agree with Mark that it is very unusual for a craftsman to be able to support his family with commissions or sales of fine furniture as his only source of income. That is truly a very sad commentary on our culture.
I just got a little ouchy that several posts in the last few days have pointed out how impractical hand tools are. Seems unseemly on a hand tool site.
Again, my use of hand tools is not virtuous, does not make my work better than anyone else's work, or any of that kind of nonsense. It is purely a matter of personal choice because I find it much more rewarding. I realize that, in my whining, I used some terminology that can be offensive to the power tool guys. My bad. I will endeavor to refrain from that henceforth. A reminder, I had a very nice power tool shop for 20 years. Made a lot of stuff. Enjoyed it immensely. Life has a way of causing changes. Still hope to visit your shop and learn about those complicated glue ups.
Ron
At least two AMENs
That is what I am trying to say
Re: I accept your criticism, will mend ways
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Even from this remote outpost of the civilized world I do get to museums, know people in their conservation departments, attend SAPFM meetings, visit reproduction shops, know SAPFM Cartouche winners on a first name basis(live less than 50 miles from one who has a dandy drum sander; in fact TN can claim 2 winners), have a good friend that worked in shop at Colonial Williamsburg, etc. I'll be in KY Friday studying English drawer construction at a shop specializing in English Period furniture.
Had you responded to something I actually said I would further defend it or admit my mistake. I look forward to posts of complex furniture that you and others make just the way it was done in 1720, more of less. I'm impressed by and admire someone building a chair like was done in 1720. I can't.
Another mantle picture 
Are my communication skills this bad?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
If you and Stanford think I believe stuff can't be made entirely with hand tools I need to vastly improve my communication skills. However, if you believe this choice doesn't result in practical limitations I expect to see some evidence to support the claim. Your example clearly illustrates my point. You apparently limit your work to what can best be done within your life style. Apparently you work on high skill parts, not the whole of complex furniture involving making a myriad of routine parts, inefficient and boring to make by 1720 processes.
This whole kerfuffle started when Mark and I pointed out that Ron's article writer couldn't make a living making chest on chests without forsaking his chosen life style. If Ron, or most likely any one else on this forum, wants to make a chest on chest (or pick you own example of something with a bunch of parts) with 1720 techniques he ain't ever going to get there. Ron is at peace with that limitation. He has told us so. I want to make a slant top desk with a complex gallery and 4 drawers (>100 parts). You all ought to realize I (and others) ain't going to get there with your chosen life style and accept my choices and methods of substituting machines for apprentices.
To repeat the point, you can pick a life style and what can be practically done will be limited. Or you can pick what you want to do and try to arrange a life style to do it. This statement should not be controversial but it is worth keeping in mind when planning next years work. I might need to take a class to get to my goal and Ron might need to shrink the number of parts in a project to get to his 2013 goals.
And I think David was joking back
Re: I accept your criticism, will mend ways
CStanford
Here's a Shaker low back chair I built entirely with hand tools. The parts for this particular chair (part of a larger set) I turned on a pole lathe, though not my own. Obviously, these are simple cylinders though the back posts have flats saw into them. The slats were ripped out by hand and boiled for an hour and put in a male/female former for a week. The chair is a mixture of red and white oak. The slats are QS white oak. All hole boring was done by hand. The tenons are 5/8" round and 7/8" long.
Active build time on this chair was about two hours - parts turned, holes bored, dry fit, then everything glued up. It took another 20 to 30 minutes to weave the seat. My wife wove the one in the photo. This chair was built as part of a larger set as mentioned. The only difference with the others is that the parts were turned on my Delta lathe which does save a little time if for no other reason than familiarity. The old bodgers working in Buckinghamshire could turn dozens and dozens of parts with their pole lathes in the time it took me to turn mine. I am more productive on my power lathe but only because I know it so well. I could spend a week with a good pole lathe and probably be just as fast (for me, that is, I'm not fast).
I'm doing a George III upholstered elbow chair soon (joined chair). This will be another all hand tool build since even in a mechanized shop most everything has to be done by hand on one of these anyway. You could rough out parts with machines but that's about it. Everything else is at funky angles, carved, dished, etc. and it's not worth building jigs unless you have a big order for them. And maybe not even then.
Re: Are my communication skills this bad?
CStanford
Sounds fine. Nothing wrong with mixed builds. They've been the standard for decades and decades.
Bill, I guess the question is why do you spend so much time on this forum? Aren't mixed builds better suited for the "Messages" forum?
Re: Are my communication skills this bad?
CStanford
Mr. Brown found himself out of work. I think he did a marvelous job getting back on his feet. If he became a zealot for handtools and a simpler lifestyle is it really all that bad? And it didn't take a whole lot of reading between the lines of his book to realize he was already working with hand tools a lot when he was building wooden boat hulls. He already loved wood and woodworking tools.
This man made a living working wood HIS ENTIRE LIFE. I can't believe we're skewering a *real* brother woodworker like this.