New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

January- what are you working on?

Posts

Re: January- what are you working on?

#51

Re: Trivets = 3 = flummoxed

William Duffield

Living languages change. English changes very quickly compared to most other languages, maybe because so much innovation is done by people who speak English. (That advantage may be changing. I don't speak Mandarin, so I can't measure their recent linguistic advances.) That's why we all speak Latin: It's a dead language, and it doesn't change, and so everyone always understands what everyone is saying, all the time. :D

Other than the two shown here, all my trivets are cast iron antiques, but only half of them are limited to three feet; the others have four. Maybe this one is not linguistically incorrect, because one of its clear plastic bumpers on the bottom has gone missing after 15 years or so! :D

Back when I started building telephone switches, phones would actually ring* (a little hammer inside hit a bell) and you actually dialed them. No thumb taps on a flat plastic panel or beeping or ringtones. Now they bark, or play disco tunes or rap or imitate tweeting birds or any sound you want them to.

*If you delve even further back into telephony history you find that there is yet another linguistically correct meaning of "ring" as applied to telephone signalling. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tip_and_ring

None of this has anything to do with trivets, only communications and language evolution.

Re: January- what are you working on?

#52

Already learned that one

Ron Harper

Don't ever build around something till you have that " something " in your shop. Yes indeedy. Learned thst the painful way

Re: January- what are you working on?

#53

I would post something...

John in NM

But I used power tools to make it :D

Re: January- what are you working on?

#54

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: January- what are you working on?

#55

David Barnett

Boring? Pretty. Balanced. Quiet.


Re: January- what are you working on?

#56

Re: Your taste is showing, William...

William Duffield

Thank you for the complement on the trivets. Personally, I like the first one I built much better, but you'd have to pick it up and study the balance, and the joinery, and you'd have to have been to Rye (and stayed at the Mermaid Inn, whose foundations predate the Norman invasion).

http://www.oldukphotos.com/graphics/England%20Photos/Sussex,%20Rye,%20The%20Landgate.jpg

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/7/78/Rye_St_Mary%27s_Church.jpg

But even that one could have been improved. There's nothing to tie the color of the tiles to the color of the frame. Luckily, the purpleheart is dark enough that it doesn't fight with the tiles. Some subdued redheart might have worked a bit better.

My wife's cousin, who I had done some other work for, saw it and liked it, and we decided I should make something for her daughter's wedding. Since she knew her daughter's tasets much better than I did, I suggested she should find a tile or tiles, and I would set it into a frame. She was enthusiastic. She's always enthusiastic. She hunted down the right tile, and brought it to me.

And now for something completely different, something borrowed, something blue…

Well, the acanthus leaf motif is at least another millennium older than the Mermaid Inn, but this interpretation didn't inspire anything in me remotely related to the Rye trivet. What to do? I wanted to hand the tile back to her, and say something I would surely have regretted later, but this was Family, so I took the tile back to my shop, and thought about it a while, quite a while. Somehow, the trivet in the photo was the result of my efforts.

Re: January- what are you working on?

#57

Re: Question

Bob Lang

Both AutoCAD and SketchUp are ultimately faster and more accurate than drafting by hand, the advantage isn't so much in the initial drawing as it is in making changes, copies or turning one thing into something similar.

But it's not the kind of thing you can master in a couple of hours on a Saturday morning. Learning how to use either one is like learning a new language; the way it works is the way it works whether that fits your way of thinking or not, and it takes practice (practicing good techniques) to get good at it.

I prefer SketchUp over 2D CAD both for the price (hard to beat free) and for the ability to work in three dimensions. Once you get the hang of how it works it's much like playing around in the shop with hunks of wood, except SketchUp has a functional board stretcher.

Bob Lang

Re: January- what are you working on?

#58

Re: Question

William Duffield

I need to put more energy into getting good at SketchUp. I'm not as quick as I used to be at learning new artificial languages. The biggest issues I have with SketchUp are that it doesn't run on my iPad and the lines it draws are really fat. When working with subtle curves on furniture, I need really fine lines, and I need to be able to manipulate the curves very precisely. For Shaker and Stickley, and for workbenches, that's no problem, but I couldn't imagine designing something like a Maloof rocker using it.

Bob Lang's teaching materials on using SketchUp for building furniture are the best ways I've found to learn it. It helps immensely to have a computer with two large monitors when learning it using Woodworker's Guide to SketchUp.

Re: January- what are you working on?

#59

Re: Question

Bob Lang

The native curves in SketchUp are rather clunky, in fact they really aren't curves but short line segments. They are also limited to arcs of circles, although you can finagle elliptical shapes.

But there is an alternative in the form of a plug in for Bezier Curves.

Bob Lang

Re: January- what are you working on?

#60

Re: Bezier Curves

William Duffield

Thanks, Bob. I think I found the needed plug-ins. I'll try it out.

Re: January- what are you working on?

#61

Re: Question

jack curtis

No question, Bob, which is why I've tried off and on to learn it. When I've used the online tutorials and Andy's book, it all seems clear; but when I try to apply them, it all returns to muck when faced with that blank page. Admittedly, SU comes closer than all the other CAD programs (not AutoCAD) I've tried.

I haven't bought your stuff because I don't plan to ever use it for furniture, but maybe the furniture skills will transfer; and I've certainly learned a lot from your drawings books.

Re: January- what are you working on?

#62

Re: CADD vs Sketching

Bruce McCrory

For the "one-off" it is easier to produce a pattern by hand drafting. Finding a printer that spits out 11x17 is hard enough. I could hand draft on a CAD plotted base sheet fast enough for many years. It was the disposable nature of plotted drawings that killed hand drafting in the same office.

I moved into AutoCAD many years ago and am pretty much handicapped to its format and imitators. Presently BricsCAD. AutoCAD is not user friendly. You can do a lot with only a few key commands, however. And as Bob mentioned, duplication is ACAD's forte'. I still copy files (drawings) I created in the mid 1990's.

SketchUp was its own, new company when I first tried it, but could never learn to use. It's a wonderful schematic imager. You can import DWG files to it, but I keep looking for the dimensions and callouts on SketchUp graphics.

There is an online free drafting program, DraftSight, that I played with for a while. I was not happy with it so hunted for about a year and settled with the above 2D clone.

Re: January- what are you working on?

#63

Open a sketch and work with it.

Bruce McCrory

Jack, manipulating a copy is a lot easier than starting with raw ozone. Give a copy a try.

I was stumped when I first built a drawing from scratch, ten years after classes--my only other time. I could create many drawings every day by copying or "saving as".

Re: January- what are you working on?

#64

Re: Open a sketch and work with it.

jack curtis

Thanks, Bruce, also tried that in SU to no avail, never could properly modify a shape, say to create a recess for example.

Re: January- what are you working on?

#65

Re: Never worked for me, either.

Bruce McCrory

Even though most I talked to said it was "really easy", SU just never seemed to like me. These are folks who built entire businesses using SU, from the best graphics and presentation work I've seen to detailed construction documents.

Re: January- what are you working on?

#66

Learning SketchUp

Bob Lang

There are a couple of steep hills to get over when starting out in SketchUp.

Then it gets easy.

Part of it is hand/eye coordination and getting the brain used to the way 3D objects look and behave on a 2D screen. It takes some practice to get there and you need to practice good technique.

The other is gaining thorough understanding of how things behave. If you know how to control the stuff you create, modeling in SketchUp is much like playing with hunks of wood in the shop. If you don't learn the basics, it's as if everything is made out of silly putty and covered with crazy glue, not much fun at all.

When I started to teach classes in SketchUp, I thought people could relate to pieces of furniture and we started with stuff you might make in eighth-grade shop class. Now, we spend the first part of the class playing with simple blocks. That "kindergarten" time pays off and people "get it" much sooner.

Bob Lang

Re: January- what are you working on?

#67

Re: Learning SketchUp

jack curtis

Thanks, Bob. I started by drawing a box of a house with roof, fine, no problems. Then I tried to add a foundation, eaves, doorway, pulled out front door, covered patio, and other such stuff; and all these added was a ruined house box. I'll try again, as soon as I recover from the last sessions.

I also have to admit that I have a grudge with the SU company. I resisted buying for months at $500, then they put it on sale for $400 at which point I leaped (lept?). Then a week after I spent $400 of my hard earned money that would have done a lot more for my project in materials, they announced that Google had bought SU and would be selling it for free. Talk about pi__ed. One of these years I'll get over this, real soon now. :)