New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

Posts

Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#1

Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Ron, this post is for you and you will find that I have no exceptional talents in this matter, but I do have lots of experience.


Let's start with the top. It has four boards. First I glued two together to make two pairs and then ran them through the planer to finished thickness. This step more or less cancels out any bows and humps in the pairs. ( I always try to thickness plane two or more rough- planed edge glued boards as a first step in making a wide panel. This step tends to cancel out wiggles in both pieces. Alternatively flatten on jointer. Not a practical option with these massive pieces. If the boards are flat to begin with I would just plane them to finished thickness and carry on. )

Now I have two wider pieces to glue together to make the final top. I lay these in the clamps and, without glue I snug the clamps to see what problems I have to contend with. I find that I can always make one near perfect joint so I never glue finished planed stuff more then one joint at a time. It is hard for me to explain all the tricks to coaxing the edges into alignment as the clamps are slowly tightened. But going slow is a key element. I want to correct any misalignment as the clamps are snugged. Once yellow glue grabs only steady pressure will move the joint. Bashing with a mallet is useless. Steady pressure works.

Sometimes I stand on the assembly as I snug clamps, or pinch the ends together with a clamp, or clamp against the bench. What ever is necessary to put pressure where it is needed to do some coaxing is employed. I consider it a disaster if the glued edge is more than 1/64 out of alignment. In the case at hand trivial scraping leveled the joint, but this assembly came together extraordinarily well (maybe because I fussed with it plenty knowing this strong stuff would not coax easily)

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#2

Thanks Bill

Ron Harper

I have pretty good success with this kind of glue up and I follow your steps pretty closely.

It is that bench glue up thing that you posted that buffaloes me.

Ron

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#3

Hand Tools

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have a young friend a mile down the road who has an $80,000 planer. It could plane a lot of bench tops in an hour, but don't ask for flat. I also have friends with nice 24 and 36 inch jointers, but the surface is not as flat what can be done with a hand plane.

If I am gluing panels from rough lumber, I do the gluing before flatting any of the faces. This saves labor. This is also what Nicholson suggested in 1812.

If I am doing a large job and get the lumber machine planed ahead of time, I get the stock planed 1/8 thicker than finished (more or less depending on the situation), so I have plenty of leeway to remove cup and wind and to get a nice surface. I also would glue these before flattening the faces.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#4

Re: Hand Tools

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I used to try to thickness plane to dimension before gluing up a panel, but what I really did was end up wasting a lot of lumber and getting a thinner panel than I wanted. Now I only thickness after glue up. It saves both time and wood.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#5

Flat panels are rarely essential

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are few situations where it matters if a panel is flat or twisted. This is a fortunate situation because it is difficult to keep a panel flat if there are humidity swings or the lumber has residual stress. What matters most for the things I make, and the way I make them, is that the panel be of uniform thickness around its edges. Let us examine some typical panel applications.



Table and case tops- These set upon, and are fastened to, a frame or cabinet top. The fastening part pulls the top to the plane of the frame. In the memorable case shown I was highly motivated to assemble the top from this figured board that had a crook in one end that bowed up well over an inch. "Planing it level" was clearly out of the question. Instead I finish planed it as is to 7/8" , jointed the edges and laid it on the clamps. This bowed edge aligned with the straight edge of the adjacent board and it stuck up about 1.5". I stuck a hydraulic jack on this section and jacked it down flat on the clamps by jacking against the ceiling joists of the shop, then snugged the clamps when the edges were aligned. When it came out of the clamps the straight piece partially cancelled the bow of the other. The result was a panel that bowed up on one end about 3/4". The top was finished and fastened to the table frame with clips. The clips where tightened to pull the top flat against the frame over the course of a month. If there is any wind in the final top it is not noticeable. The table has been in service 10 years.

Case sides- Again, minor wind will be pulled into submission by the framing and any minor cup is irrelevant.

Door and drawer bottom panels- Minor cup will be pulled into submission by the framing but it hardly matters because minor cup will not be noticed. Wind in the panel can be a problem if it pulls the frame out of plane. This is a larger problem on inset doors than overlay doors.

Work bench tops- My bench is 42" wide and it is cupped up 3/16" in the center. It once was flat. It may have some wind along its 7' length. I never checked it. In the 30 years I have used the bench its imperfections have not been a problem.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#6

a disagreement with your approach

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"If I am gluing panels from rough lumber, I do the gluing before flatting any of the faces."

I have never seen this approach practiced by anyone else. I, and apparently others, find it impossible, or at least inefficient, to prepare the edge joints without a flat reference surface to work from.

For those watching from the sidelines, you will find it much easier to first get one surface flat by what ever means you prefer (most shops use a jointer). The surface does not have to be finish smooth, but it must be flat to reference from. (I may take a rough pass through the planer at this point, or not) Then edge joint referencing off this flat surface. Additionally, this flat surface is what goes on the clamp surface so the pieces aren't teetering about as the clamps are tightened.

Additionally....... The one case where I use a hand plane in preparing a surface is with twisted stock. I use a scrub plane to take down the diagonal corners to get the beginnings of a flat reference surface, then flatten further on the jointer. If the final panel will go through my planer I will glue the panel after jointing one surface level(and maybe skip planing the other), with this reference surface against the clamps, then surface the glued up panel with the planer. This is standard procedure for the shops I know of.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#7

One question....

roger lance

I really do not like to participate in these type of discussions as I'm able to acknowledge that there are many successful ways of doing things and that I'm not the center of the universe so my way may not be the "best" but.....for panels (and other parts), I'm in the habit of preparing the stock to ruff flat/square and letting it sit stickered over night (or longer), then go through the flattening process again and sticker over night, and then make sure that there has been no or very minimal movement in the stock....and then begin the glue up process. The stock does tend to move between these sessions.....so I'm wondering if you flatten all at once after glueing, don't things want to move?

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#8

Re: a disagreement with your approach

david weaver

If the lumber is decent quality, you can get close enough to check squareness of the edges, or better yet, plane both at the same time if they are 5/4 or so.

It might seem like a leap if you're coming from the machine tool world of having a dead flat face to reference at the start of every dimensioning activity, but it's not necessary to do what warren is describing. My panels change much more with the weather than the error in them from using rough lumber.

I didn't do what warren says at first because I was concerned I might get a mismatch with grain direction and have to fart around with thin shavings, but the whole double iron thing negated the need for that to be so critical (I still like to do as warren says and finish plane a surface rather than scrape. A card scraper leaves me grabbing piles of shavings to burnish the wood).

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#9

Re: Hand Tools

CStanford

Amen, brother.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#10

I'm boggled

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am reminded that this is the hand tool forum and this response is way out of line....but there are a lot of jointer owners here.......

If anyone can joint two pieces of lumber that don't have a largely flat side to go against the jointer fence and wind up with a good glue joint that will yield a glued panel that will average out irregularities in the two boards at this stage of panel preparation you are a better woodworker than I ( or most).

While I can not picture it in my mind I suppose there is some means of accomplishing this task with hand tool jointing when the board face is twisted and/or cupped. I won't argue with success but I just can't see how this can be done or why it would be tired as opposed to getting one face to reference from approximately flat first.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#11

Re: I'm boggled

david weaver

Tried with hand tools, I guess, because it's faster and it provides acceptable results.

I'm sure you've seen descriptions of matching a joint by putting both pieces in a vise at the same time and planing them. I guess you might be able to do the same thing with a power jointer (I don't see why you couldn't) if you clamp the pieces together.

Though I can't see why someone who machine dimensions wood would do that.

I do have to say that while I used to use power tools and join boards off of them, I have less trouble now using warren's method (though it does, of course, take longer to come up with a finished panel than it does to do the same borrowing time on someone else's large stationary machinery).

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#12

Another factor panel preparation-thickness yield

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Beyond getting the final panel sufficiently flat and the show faces smoothed there is another important factor in panel preparation and that is yielding the thickest panel practical from the lumber at hand. It is for this reason that panel preparation normally proceeds as I described it- prepare a reference face employing minimum material removal technique, then edge joint off this face and surface the other face off this face.

Let us take the worst case of a panel piece with twist. The optimum yield of thickness on the way to flatness is to nip off diagonal corners to achieve a reference face. This is the least amount of material to be removed to achieve flatness. It matters not how the panel piece is prepared in this regard. No other material removal process will yield a thicker piece and no other way will yield a finished flat surface. Hence, there is no disadvantage in time or material to remove this material as the first step. Furthermore, if the reference face is the finished face you know after this step what the show face is going to look like. Finally, this reference face will lay flat on the clamp surface resulting in an easier and more predictable clamping experience. What's not to like!?!

Now suppose we simply prepare the edges and glue this twisted unflattened piece to another. What assurance is there that the orientation of this twisted piece will be such that when the overall panel assembly is flattened that the minimum amount of material will be nipped from the diagonal of this twisted piece? If you tell me that by skill and experience you can joint the edge of a twisted piece and its neighbor such that you achieve minimum material removal from each when the overall panel is flattened I will be astonished at your skill and experience and maybe clairvoyance. It is not something I could do, nor find advantageous.

One can go through the same mental exercise using a cupped board and come to the same conclusion. That is, the easiest way to prepare a panel that will result in maximum thickness yield is to first prepare a flat reference face from each board in the panel employing minimum material removal. As a bonus one knows what the show face is going to look like and clamping is more predictable.

Now if the rough lumber pieces for the panel are already flat a reference face is already at hand and one can proceed by any means. But even in this case I like to see what my show face is actually going to look like so I will take a hit and miss pass over it before proceeding.

David, I am not trying to convince you to prepare panels different from what you are accustomed to doing. But if there are bystanders following this discussion consider the merits of the panel preparation procedure I have described. Try it, and any alternative, then arrive at a conclusion that works for your situation. the end..........

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#13

Re: a disagreement with your approach

cstanford

"I, and apparently others, find it impossible, or at least inefficient, to prepare the edge joints without a flat reference surface to work from."

It is neither impossible nor inefficient.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#14

Re: Hand Tools

cstanford

Dead. Smack. Right.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#15

Re: Another factor panel preparation-thickness yie

david weaver

I don't think most of my lumber has been *that* bad, but whatever thickness a lot of my panels come out, that's what they are. If for some reason both sides can be seen (like on the side of a bookcase) then i will do an A rate job on the outside and a B rate job on the inside.

If I had a piece with so much twist it would affect the ability to glue it to another one, then I would probably not use that piece for a panel.

I don't want to sway anyone to do anything, but for the few people who are going to use only handtools, they'll end up doing it my way, and the people who use power tools will get close to finished thickness and try to glue their panels exactly the same time they surface all of them. If I have a case or a chest and have to do four or five large panels, that's not realistic. Sometimes I only have a half hour or an hour to do something and that might be working one panel that came out of clamps and edge jointing two rough boards to put in the clamps.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#16

Thickness yield

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Machine methods do not come close to the thickness yield from hand planes. Here are two reasons that are easy to understand. 1) With a hand plane it is easier to localize the stock removal; one can take only the high spots and not have to take a pass over the whole surface. 2) A hand plane is capable of much thinner shavings as one approaches flat. Sometimes it is helpful to get the most thickness out of a board and of course sometimes there is plenty of thickness to be wasted away.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#17

Re: O.K., edges are "trued"

Bruce McCrory

I was thinking ya'll were arguing over flattening a face, or leaving it ruff before gluing.

Bill's hydraulic persuader has to be easier than my 2x, 4x cauls and a few hundred pounds tension in twisted rope. But then, his was just walnut; and only one warp. ;)

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#18

I am in the middle.

Ron Harper

I am with Roger on the thicknessing in stages to deal with the almost certain movement. Honesty requires saying that I rarely thickness the wood for large projects by hand. That was apprentice work in the old days. But, if i go in stages, and cut good edge joints, my panels glue up pretty doggone flat. Bill makes a very accurate point, perfect flatness was rarely found in the days when all work was done with hand tools. If I see folks wandering amongst my furniture pieces with straight edges, they will not be invited back. My last table top was 3 ft square cherry , three boards. It may be out of flat by a 64 th. cannot see it without a straight edge. At glue up it was only a 32 nd thick to allow for smoothing with my new Old Street smoother. I do understand that a lot of folks work the way Warren describes. I understand it. I just have always done it another way. I also agree with Roger that there are many ways to remove feline fur.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#19

Plus, when I thickness a panel by hand,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I rarely, if ever, am concerned with the final thickness. Actually, I shoot for the max thickness I can get and don't really worry what that thickness is, especially when it will be the top of something, like a dresser or table.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#20

Re: Hand Tools

TomD

Part of the reason for what you report is that few people actually know how to use these power tools. The power tools will do it, but they do not always do it automatically. Just as moving planes around on boards does not make them flat, there is a process that must be followed. Some progress will be made in either case but flat is not automatic. And until recently we did not have any general agreement of what could be done. I posted myself blue in the face, but few people got it until David Charlesworth did his tapes, even thought, as with breakers, the info was out there in many places. Even after the tapes, there were a number of residual myths.

No surprise, the same level of competence, or worse, exists in the power tools field. A further problem with machines is that people assume they just do everything automatically. With hand tools the assumptions tend to be to the contrary, or did, that some extraordinary skill is required, as opposed to it being a technology.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#21

Re: I'm boggled - glad to help

TomD

"If anyone can joint two pieces of lumber that don't have a largely flat side to go against the jointer fence and wind up with a good glue joint that will yield a glued panel that will average out irregularities in the two boards at this stage of panel preparation you are a better woodworker than I ( or most)."

Well obviously you could do it with 4x4s. I also think that while this is probably not attempted with jointers, it would be common with table saws. Not something I would like to do but I have seen it done often.

"While I can not picture it in my mind I suppose there is some means of accomplishing this task with hand tool jointing when the board face is twisted and/or cupped."

Well an obvious example would be cooperage, and the many other activities that are done one inverted "jointers" freehand.

" I won't argue with success but I just can't see how this can be done or why it would be tired as opposed to getting one face to reference from approximately flat first."

Another example would be stuff like jointing soundboards on carved instruments. They are sometimes jointed from the splits, then a reference surfaced is raised and the guttering can start.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#22

Top thickness always concerns me

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The thickness of the top is a design element of considerable importance. The edge molding may look poor or not work at all if the top winds up too thin. I am typically trying to coax 7/8 thickness from 4/4 lumber.

I make tops last. I will diddle with test thickness to be sure my drawing predicted the most attractive result. Fortunately tops only have one show side and typically three show edges. The merit of getting the show surface largely flat before glue up becomes apparent. If after flattening this side there is insufficient thickness to make the top the lumber and labor to assemble this board into a top is not wasted.


The most spectacular tops are often derived from lumber sawed near knots, as in the example above. The lumber always distorts upon drying in these figured areas because the grain is anything but flat. It is a challenge flattening these humps and valleys, obtaining a good jointed edge, and preserving thickness. I can't do it without flattening one side before glue up.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#23

note example

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


It is a straightforward task to remove the high spots with a power jointer as seen in the example. Shavings too thin to be of any practical value toward flattening can be achieved. This is one of the most common operations one will find in a furniture shop. It is why wide jointers were invented and coveted by furniture shops. If removing cup, start with the convex side up. Same for the thickness planer.

While the jointer or planer are effective for removing cup and random humps and bumps only the jointer is useful for removing twist and it ain't trivial on the jointer. For this task I nip off the diagonal ends with a scrub plane to get started and then proceed to the jointer. Others more skilled would skip the hand plane.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#24

Re: Top thickness always concerns me

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I always shoot for 7/8" too, Bill, and I start with 9/8" so there is a bit to play with. A quarter inch is quite a bit. It's rarely let me down. It's easier to hit that mark when I plane by hand. Granted that is driven by need because I don't have a tailed jointer or a planer that will take a full-width cut on a 24" panel.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#25

Re: Another factor...  Oversymplified

TomD

"Beyond getting the final panel sufficiently flat and the show faces smoothed there is another important factor in panel preparation and that is yielding the thickest panel practical from the lumber at hand. It is for this reason that panel preparation normally proceeds as I described it- prepare a reference face employing minimum material removal technique, then edge joint off this face and surface the other face off this face."

I would prepare a face a lot of the time also, but that is the simple case, there are many cases. A simple example of which is that when one prepared the faces that need to be prepared, on the two boards to be joined... And they then have to be assembled so that the two faces that were flattened are on opposite sides. Now the fact that there is a flat piece adjacent to another piece that is not flat, may turn out very badly for yield. For instance, the rough piece could ensure that the high point on the board that now needs to be ground off, is at the joint, so even more material will be lost. But for utility work it may work out fine, or for work where the wood has abundant material or is near final or regular dimensions.