New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

Posts

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#26

Re: note example

TomD

When one nips off the twisted ends with a hand plane, one does so by working only the parts that are high. Often when people attempt the same on a jointer, they think there is some way of doing that while working the whole board, which there is, but it is simpler to simply joint the same areas that would be worked in the hand plane example, but many people are not comfortable taking stop cuts on the jointer.

Getting a pattern such as was achieved on that board, does not ensure that the worked surfaces are co-planer. And the problem people have with jointers large or small is they often do not know what to do if they get a worked surface, but it is not flat. What next. A key indicator that they do no know what they are doing is if they think a larger tool would help. Of course larger tools help in a number of ways, but they are not necessary to get flat surfaces. They are great for working boards more than 50% wider than the jointer, for dealing with wider glued up surfaces that need jointing, or just for general productivity.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#27

Re: Another factor...  Oversymplified

Bob Entwisle in NJ

The oversimplification would seem to be not having identified the show side of the boards, and thus having a flat side and not flat side adjacent to one another for panel glue up.

Or am I missing something?

Bob in NJ

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#28

Re: Thickness yield

TomD

It is a mistake to believe that one takes only full passes on a jointer, this is one of the basic misunderstandings people have that stops them getting the best results from the tool. I would say that the majority of my passes on my jointer, are neither full width, or full length. Any more than they would be with a hand plane.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#29

Re: Another factor...  Oversymplified

TomD

Well that could be a problem, but if you take bill's example, you will note he often has reasons for starting with a given side. For instance removing cup, place the board concave down, or one might need to waste a bit of board and have a preference where that is coming from. With hand tools it can have to do with holding the work, or stopping it from deforming, or getting yield. So on that basis one may not get to choose where the first face is, it may be dictated, it is not merely a mater of attention.

So take a simple example. Cupped boards, where the cupping is all on say the non-pith side. But in gluing up the top one follows the often given advice of alternating the sides of the board to yield a flatter glued up surface (not always something I do, but it is a pretty common recommendation). That will dictate that flat sides alternate.

Another situation is book matches, they dictate a given reference of the sides, and also where the majority of the wood, would be removed. There are cases where the orientation is dictated.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#30

thickness planer to the rescue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the situation you describe I will then skip plane the reverse side to get it flat and parallel to the reference face, or even cleaned up depending on the need, using the jointed side as the reference against the planer bed.

In fact I often skip plane after producing a reference face on the jointer. Rarely do I have my jointer set up to make a cut perfectly 90 degrees to the reference face. By alternating which side of the board of a panel assembly is against the jointer fence any difference from 90 degrees is cancelled. Then it is on to the clamps.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#31

end nipping and jointed but not flat

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

How did we get into the nuances of jointer operation on the hand tool forum! Hand tool purists and workers of only flat lumber stop here.

There are two difficult jointer operations- flattening twisted lumber and taking a convex bow out of an edge or face.

To remove twist the board is teetered on the infeed table with an orientation that nips the most efficient amount from each diagonal corner. I likely have run as much lumber across a jointer as most of you, yet I find it difficult to strike the optimum teetering orientation to yield maximum thickness. What this forum has taught me is that sometimes a hand tool is best and this is one of them. Personally, I find a scrub plane for nipping these corners for most efficient thickness yield to be most reliable and not slow. Only a few passes are necessary to establish the plane(geometrical) of the finished face and then it is on to the jointer to clean it up.

Even more difficult is removing bow on an edge or face. The bow wants to follow the jointer bed and it as likely to get worse as it is to get better. The solution here is to start the lumber with the leasing edge already on the outfeed table, like would be done to make a taper. In this orientation the middle of the lumber is cut more than than the ends and the bow thereby removed. The middle could also be taken out with a hand plane, quickly. Because of this inconvenience one typically joints the concave side and then rip saws the other edge straight. (however, see Elliot's discussion above)

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#32

Re: Gluing up panels- the bottom line

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The bottom line here, as Tom pointed out above, is that the power tool approach can be, I would argue should be, no different than the hand tool approach. The goal is getting sufficiently flat and cleaning up the show face(s). Thoughtfully positioning the board on the jointer surface results in identical outcome as thoughtfully positioning the hand plane plane on the wood surface. Furthermore, at what stage, or how, the required wood is removed is immaterial to the final outcome, a cleaned up sufficiently flate panel. However, the steps to get to the final panel ready for finish may be more or less difficult or reliable or require more or less skill. I have pointed out several advantage for removing at least some of the required wood to establish a reference face prior to edge jointing and gluing.

While some seem to believe what has been described is controversial it is the standard practice in the shops I know of that employ a jointer and thickness planer. Which suggests, while this may not be the only way it is likely the most efficient and/or reliable way for these shops. Your results may vary.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#33

Big difference

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is a big difference between a flat panel like you are working with and one like I am used to working with. This morning I took a 6X30 piece of timber that had been flattened with a wooden trying plane. I put a jar of water stain and a smoothing plane on the bench. In 23 seconds it was smoothed and stained and, now dry, is ready for finish. I did not have to remove ugly machine ripple marks, which would have taken a lot more planing or sanding. I did not have to sand either before of after water stain to remove mashed up fibers ("raised grain") because the fibers were in great shape. And I have a surface which is much more lively than a sanded surface and requires much less finishing. I think it is odd for someone with little experience in hand preparation of stock to be making comparisons for us.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#34

Yes

Ron Harper

I can't believe those folks who say there is no difference in planed and sanded surfaces after finishing. I am 67 years old and my eyes are better than that.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#35

you have switched horses.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The discussion has been about how to assemble a sufficiently flat panel. My thesis is that preparing a planar (geometry) reference face on each board in the assembly as a first step, regardless of what tools are used, offers several advantages toward assembling a glued up panel that will have the easiest to prepare joints, the best show face, and the maximum preserved thickness. It is not a technique I invented , but rather adapted from seeing other do it.

For exactly the reasons you enumerated, I don't have a horse in the race of what the surface looks like as a result of the multitude of surface preparation possibilities.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#36

no

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Bill, you wrote:

Furthermore, at what stage, or how, the required wood is removed is immaterial to the final outcome, a cleaned up sufficiently flate panel.

I am arguing that the outcome is very different, that a flat panel prepared by a jointer machine is very different from one prepared by a trying plane.

You also say:

the power tool approach can be, I would argue should be, no different than the hand tool approach.

I suggested a historical technique, joining before facing, recommended by Nicholson in 1812 and which I have used for 30 years. And here you are, having never even attempted that technique, arguing that hand tool workers should instead adopt the power tool regimen. Those of us who habitually join wood by hand are not constrained by the skills or the concepts of those who do not.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#37

Give me a short lesson

Ron Harper

You have to make a 28 in sq table top 3/4 in thick before any edge beveling etc,

You have three 10 in wide 30 in long boards an inch thick that you want to use for the top. How do you proceed?

Thanks

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#38

Re: Give me a short lesson

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would never make a 3/4 inch table top. It would look like it was made by some old 20th century amateur.

Here is a simplified version

1)Lay out the boards and mark where you want to join them.

2) Plane an edge flat, checking with straightedge and winding sticks.

3) Plane adjoining edge flat.

4) Leaving the second board fastened in planing position, place the two flat surfaces together to check alignment. Using the straightedge vertically across the ends of the faces to see how they line up. If there is twist, they could be concave at one end and convex at the other.

5) If the two boards do not line up well, adjust the slope of the edge with the plane.

I would usually glue just one joint at a time, especially if the boards are far from flat. I have done several at a time. If the boards are pretty flat a square can be of some help, but remember that the winding sticks and straightedge are what assures a flat edge and a good joint. This does take skill; I have done thousands of these joints.

Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#39

Thank you


Re: Gluing up stuff strategy- panels

#40

Re: Give me a short lesson

Sgian Dubh

"I would never make a 3/4 inch table top. It would look like it was made by some old 20th century amateur."

Oh gosh Warren. You've just made me into an amateur, a dilettante, a bit of a playboy in the world of furniture designing and making. And here I've been under the misguided delusion for all these years of making a living in the world of furniture one way or another thinking, somehow, that I was a professional.

I'll have to remember in future to not incorporate table or cabinet tops in my designs that are somewhere in the region of 18- 20 mm thick, about the same as 3/4". Oh! Wait! I'll need to change the tambour fronted sideboard I've just designed and is about to go into production. Luckily I haven't yet purchased the wood, so I can make the top thicker-- I'll use 2" thick rough sawn stuff for the top instead of the 1" stuff I'd planned for. That'll save the day.

Actually Warren, don't take me seriously here. I'm jerking your chain because I suspect what I read is not how you intended it to appear, ha, ha. Slainte.