New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

Posts

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#26

Is their coping saw a good alternative?


Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#27

Request clarification

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

Thanks for sharing your experience! But could you clarify something:

"Three inches with the 45 degree tilt is plenty for dovetails and it is much, much stiffer than the 5" flat titanium model."

Does this mean that,

-The shallower frame is inherently stiffer? (3" stiffer than 5" stiffer than 8")?

-The angling itself somehow stiffens the blade?

Also, do you find a difference in blade tension between the aluminum and titanium models?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#28

Re: Request clarification

Eric in Los Gatos

Wiley,

The basic design architecture of the three saws is the same so the shorter the legs of the frame the stiffer they will be. That's the qualitative view. Will that be noticeable in the real world? Possibly but I doubt it. Particularly for what we do. Might get a higher note when you ping the blade if you tighten it as much as you can. :-)

Merry Christmas, all!

Eric

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#29

Re: Request clarification

David Charlesworth

Wiley,

Yes a shallower frame will be stiffer.

The ability to set blade at 45 degrees does not create extra stiffness but does allow dovetail waste removal from wide boards with a shallow frame.

I have not had aluminium frames to try but the 3" birdcage titanium frame is the stiffest I have seen and it takes a good high tension.

best wishes,

David

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#30

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

TomD

I think the fretsaw approach does help newbies, though over time getting the chiselwork down is probably more useful. One of the things about chiselwork is that while people spend a lot of time talking about chisels, and which ones are best, there are few enough opportunities to practice that part of the craft in many large projects. Then if one insists on sidestepping the few opportunities one does get...

I agree with Derek, in space frames Ti is not the lightest option. It is lighter than steel, and tougher than aluminum. It excels when some flex is actually an advantage as in providing compliance on a bike frame, or when some toughness is required, as with framing hammers (though they do not magically outperform their 30 percent reduced weight).

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#31

Images of frame depths

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

As I wrote earlier, and noted by David as well, the 3" frame should have sufficient depth for the average dovetail. Here is a comparison of the 8", 5" and 3" (in this order) .....




Regards from Perth (New York bound)

Derek

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#32

One more consideration on frame depth

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

There have been some interesting posts in the last couple of days about frame depth. David Charlesworth discussed the greater stiffness of the shallow frame, and Derek posted photos of the three depths.

I'd like to bring up one other consideration, which leads me to the 8" depth, despite whatever tradeoff there is vis a vis stiffness of the frame. This is not intended as an argument to convince anyone else of what they should do, just a reason for why I prefer the deeper frame.

To begin with, an advantage of sawing dovetail waste in the first place, is that when you go 'tails first', you have the drawer sides ganged in the vise for sawing. Either two of them, or four of them, and they are sawn all at the same time. Once the drawer sides are sawn for the tails pattern, then you can leave them in the vise, pick up your fretsaw, and saw the waste with the sides still ganged. In doing this sawing, typical setups might be two thicknesses at 3/8" each, for 3/4" total depth of sawing, or else 4 thicknesses of 5/16" or thereabouts, for a total of 1-1/4" or so. What marks are made? The near side will be fully marked with the pattern, the tops will be marked with pairs of parallel lines for the pin entries (or else just single lines if the pattern calls for single entry pins), and the far side of the ganged assembly will be marked only with scribe lines. In fact, only the outer face of one drawer side will be fully marked--the others will bear only the scribe lines.

The two sawing operations--sawing the pattern and sawing the waste--will be done while looking at the near side. There is no need for a mirror or some such device on the far side to see how it's going over there. Provided you maintain a sense of level. To do this sawing, the work is positioned sorta high, so that i can lean over a bit and finish the pattern cuts pretty much at eye level--to maintain a sense of when the saw is level to the other side. To do the waste cuts, I find it an advantage to approach with the saw frame horizontal and in-plane with the cut both left-to-right and front-to-back--again, because I'm going to do the sawing without looking at the back, aside from maybe one spot check.

So the deeper saw frame is a continuous reference to the plane of the cut, both laterally and in depth. When I do the waste sawing with the frame over the work, it feels a bit more awkward in that I'm watching the kerf develop in one plane, while my reference to level is the top of the frame passing above the work in a parallel plane. It's more intuitive to me to do the ganged sawing, if the frame, the saw blade, the kerf are all in the same plane. Your mileage may vary.

Wiley

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#33

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

CStanford

Great point. Actually, a really great point.

No doubt there are those looking at these saws who have otherwise been seen in shopping and honing threads looking for chisels with 'the best steel to stand up to chopping,' then in honing threads expounding and/or exploring edge longevity at this angle or that angle, again, 'to stand up to chopping.'

Then they just pitch the whole bloody thing out the window to saw out dovetail waste, which happens to be activity in woodworking most commonly associated with chopping with a bench chisel in hand.

So, what they're left with when they need to pare (they ain't chopping, remember, they're using a titanium fret saw to remove core waste we're told) is a chisel ground and honed at too high an angle (if other posts are to be believed), with overly hard and/or chewy steel that takes longer to hone, when what they need is a low angled chisel made from plain high carbon steel that takes touchups rapidly as one pares their way to a good fit.

A post for every occasion it seems - "these saws are the bees' knees" and "I use them to saw out my dovetail waste." Then somewhere else on the same board or maybe another forum, "you won't believe how well this chisel's edge holds when I chop dovetails, and I did eighteen drawers' worth last week."

We're sawing waste with a $400 fret saw one week. Chopping it with chisels the next. I guess technique changes to suit one's latest shopping adventure.

Must be fun.

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#34

It's a potential solution to a problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The reason that I don't fret saw out the waste is this very issue of knowing how the back of the cut is progressing where I can't see. Dip below the scribe line and it is start over with the drawer sides, for there is no way to fix it. Hence, the person doing this cut only occasionally may tend to over compensate and the waste will be less removed on the back side, leading to as much chiseling as if it was just all chiseled out to begin with. Or at least that is where I wind up with my small frame fret saw.

No doubt persons doing these cuts routinely get good at nearly kissing the scribed base line which leads to minimal chiseling. But I don't dovetail drawers often enough to be this confident of the cut I can't see. If the larger frame leads to a better feel of how the saw is oriented it could make fret sawing the waste more practical for the occasional dovetailer. Personally, I say screw it and band saw it away. The blade teeth can be used like a power chisel to nibble waste up to the base line.

But if I didn't have a band saw I would just chisel the waste away, for it is not slow to do so.

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#35

Re: One more consideration on frame depth

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

So the deeper saw frame is a continuous reference to the plane of the cut, both laterally and in depth. When I do the waste sawing with the frame over the work, it feels a bit more awkward in that I'm watching the kerf develop in one plane, while my reference to level is the top of the frame passing above the work in a parallel plane. It's more intuitive to me to do the ganged sawing, if the frame, the saw blade, the kerf are all in the same plane. Your mileage may vary.


Hi Wiley

I work the same way as you do, that is gang-sawing the tails first. When it comes to sawing out he waste I must admit that I found holding the fretsaw at 45 degrees confusing and it was difficult maintaining a straight cut line. The answer is similar to filing teeth on a saw - one needs a reference for horizontal. I quickly learned to watch a mark at the end on the handle. In this way one can monitor the saw and the saw cut simultaneously.

A longer frame, even one made of titanium, will be less rigid than a shorter aluminium one. The advantage of the KC saw is that it achieves great rigidity, which creates the control often absent in older fretsaws. I have been able to compare an 8" with a 5" frame, and now prefer the 5". I am sure that a 3" could be even better.

Somewhere I have photos of the method above, and will post them when I can find them.

Regards from Sarasota

Derek

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#36

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#37

Picture of sawing using a reference mark

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

This how I began using a mark to reference the angle of the blade:

In the picture below the eye (yellow line) goes to the knob, which is orientated for vertical (red line) ...


I found that it took only a short while before a reference was no longer needed as muscle memory developed.

Regards from New York City

Derek

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#38

Re: Rigidity more a function of depth than materia

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Almost broke down and went to Harbor Freight last Sunday, but Sarasota's too seething a metropolis compared to sleepy little Venice this time of year. Heard there was a commotion at Siesta Key. You do realize that it's not a 'clothing optional' beach now, right?


Hi David

That WAS me - actually Lynndy who seemed to attract attention - down at Siesta beach. We were walking along, as we always do on the beaches of Perth, sans any clothes. It was sunny and warm - about 75 F and moderate humidity. Lots of cheering folks. I just figured that they knew about my dovetailing ...

There was a great fudge/candy store on the main drag at Venice that is absolutely sinful. I could not resist.

You live in Venice? I wish I had known!

Regards from a freezing cold New York City (this is not the place for a warm blooded Australian!)

Derek

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#39

To the contrary....NYC is a great place for....

roger lance

an Aussie.....just don't go all Mick Dundee on us.....kids are packing more than switchblades these days. >(

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#40

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#41

Re: If I could ever chew through these restraints

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

I shall definitely contact you the next time we are passing this way. We have old and very dear friends in Sarasota that we always visit - more than our lives are worth not to do so. :)

You must check out their small restaurant - "Veg" - which specialises in vegetarian and seafood dishes (Gulf Gate Drive, Sarasota, as I recall). Ask for Marty or Maggie. They have won the vegan category for the past four year (ever since they opened). Better than fudge. :)

Regards from NYC

Derek

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#42

Re: Picture of sawing using a reference mark

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks! That's pretty heroic, posting graphically illustrated photos whilst on the road. Neat job of sawing too!

Wiley

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#43

An Aussie in New York City

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

an Aussie.....just don't go all Mick Dundee on us.....kids are packing more than switchblades these days.

Now that you mention it Roger .....

We were walking along the Lower East Side and a youngster came up and threatened us with a 6" hotdog (with mustard and ketchup).

Quick as a flash I whipped out a 12" Katz's pastromi-on-rye (with pickles), and said ...

You think THAT is a sandwich!?"...

Regards from Manhattan :)

Derek

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#44

Re: An Aussie in New York City

Bob Entwisle in NJ

No one in NYC would put ketchup on a hot dog.

Mustard and Relish, yes, ketchup, I don't think so. 8)

Bob in NJ

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#45

Re: An Aussie in New York City

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

So you doubt the veracity of my tale? I'm shocked! :D

Wait ... perhaps he was from out of town?

Regards from Manhattan

Derek

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#46

Doubt your veracity ??....no way !!....

roger lance

But I might start referring to you as Crocodile Cohen from the Southwest Territories !!

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#47

Re: Picture of sawing using a reference mark

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Wiley

Nothing heroic about it. I just happened to have all the tools with me. And an iPad. ;)

Regards from Manhattan

Derek

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#48

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

Bruce McCrory

Yeh, I have been following this thread, the only reason being I've always liked the gantry look for my next space odyssey; and this tool reminds me so much of .... ? .... Cranes! Aren't some C-clamps made the same way? However, I've seen no Starrett gauges of this starved, open air-look style.

And, to think, I thought Boeing Surplus Ti was robbery at $6/pound. My samples are only light straight edges and would require resawing to be converted to fret construction material.

But, those London DTs do benefit from micro waste removal. Perfect match with a KC ....

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#49

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

cstanford

I wonder what the boys in London used?

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#50

Re: Request clarification

Eric in Los Gatos

A little more clarification on the depth and angle issues from the man himself. (Not me!) With the thought of going to the source this week since they're so close I called to see if they were open and who should answer the (cell) phone but Lee himself! We had a great chat that went on for almost 20 minutes. At some point about half way into the call we got disconnected. He was (trying) to take the week off so at that point I figured I'd let him go and then he called me back! One of the things I find most appealing about woodworking is how incredibly nice and helpful everyone is. I won't get stared about how much fun WIA in Pasadena was.

Anyway, we talked about a bunch of things. We shared my thoughts and perspectives on his saws. As you might expect he totally understands tool lust driving my desire for the titanium version. He said that I would definitely be able to tell the blade tension capability differences between the various depth saws. Addressing Wiley's point about coming in directly from the side and using the visual cue to keep your cuts straight his thought is that using the top surfaces of the new aluminum blade locking nuts provides an adequate reference but acknowledges that you mileage may vary.

For any of you who are being sucked into this as I am you should know that they are currently out of titanium. They will be getting some soon but there's no immediate gratification from the source.

So, gun to my head, I think I'm not brave enough to go with the 3 inch but will go for the 5 inch titanium model because I can.

Thanks again all and thank you Lee. I'll make it over there soon.

Eric