New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

Posts

Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#1

Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

Eric in Los Gatos

Good day all,

I'm in the process of learning to hand cut dovetails (And other joinery as well. I'm in free fall off the cliff.) and have decided that a fret saw will be my weapon of choice to remove the bulk of the waste. I tried the aluminum version of their fret saw as WWIA in Pasadena and was pretty darn impressed. My expectation is that I will use this saw almost exclusively for dovetails. My question is whether or not it is worth it to go with the titanium version? I know that it will be better (But by how much?) and I'm not afraid of the price. My goal is that this will be the last fret saw I will ever have to buy so I don't want to look back and wish I had gone with the titanium version. I think that, having tried it, the aluminum will provide the performance and accuracy I need but I'm left wondering if the titanium version will make longer sessions easier. While we're at it if any of you have any thoughts on what I size is best I'd love to hear about that as well.

I'm thinking that, if they are open to the public, I might just drive over there next week when I'm on vacation. I'm only half an hour from Santa Cruz in the mountains.

Thanks as always for your collective wisdom.

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#2

I have neither experience or opinion on it...

John in NM

But I can't resist pointing out that you seem to have answered your own question :D

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#3

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Eric,

Derek may have used the titanium model, and maybe he'll chime in, though he's on the road right now.

I have the original 8" aluminum--'original' meaning without the lever tension feature. Would've bought the lever tension, but it was not an option at the time. This early Knew saw is head and shoulders over the variety of fretsaws I had used before. They've since added improvements, and I think I will order the lever-tension kit and retrofit mine.

You raise two questions: which size, and titanium vs. aluminum. The 8" is so light that you don't even notice that it has weight, and I like being able to use the saw with the blade in-line with the frame--that way, I can 'aim' with the frame, and know which way the teeth are cutting. So I would get the 8" again, if I had it to do over--whatever extra weight there is, is inconsequential. With shallower saws, I had to twist the blade to saw waste from the interior sockets, which introduces a little guesswork, and that guesswork translates into cutting a little fatter than necessary.

Since the price is not decisive, if I were you, I'd write or call Knew, and confirm whether the titanium frame gives a more highly tensioned blade (they imply it does). If so, I would go for the higher tension. Don't think the weight difference of titanium vs. aluminum will be noticeable, but higher tension is always better.

It'll be the last fret saw you'll need, based on my experience with the 8" aluminum. It's about the 5th fretsaw I've had, and the last.

For what it's worth, I saw dovetails with a dozuki, which is 0.012" thick, which means I need a fret saw blade no thicker than that. The one I use is an Olson scroll saw skip tooth No. 2 (20 tpi, thickness = 0.012"). If you use a western saw with thicker blade, typically with 0.020" plus set, you can use a heavier fretsaw blade, with fewer tpi.

I've bought from these people, and they're reliable:

http://www.sloanswoodshop.com/scroll_saw_blades.htm

Wiley

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#4

Pros and cons re their fret saw vs coping saw?


Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#5

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it? *LINK*

Chuck Bjorgen

I can't comment on the aluminum vs. titanium models. However, I recently bought the standard aluminum 5-inch saw for $49. It was strictly based on economy but I now wish I'd gone for the $95 model with the lever clamp and swivel blade clamps. Whatever you decide to do, while it may be the last fret saw you get, it won't be the last blade. I'd definitely recommend looking at the link below for scroll saw blades. Knew Concept's owner, Lee Marshall, will sell an additional dozen blades when you buy the saw but he won't sell additional blades without a saw purchase. Says he doesn't want to compete with guys like Ben. And Ben is a good guy, I agree.


Ben Fink's Woodshop

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#6

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#7

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#8

alternative

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'd suggest a used band saw. This multitasker will be more useful overall and the cat's whiskers for dovetail waste removal. Removing waste with a fret saw is tedious at best. I would prefer just chiseling it if I didn't have a band saw and even with a band saw it is not much faster than chiseling it out.

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#9

Re: Saw blades for metal?

Bob Entwisle in NJ

David,

On the off chance that I someday acquire an unobtainium batcage fretsaw, what blades would you recommend for metal?

Bob in NJ

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#10

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it? *LINK*

L Robins

Slightly off topic , but just another idea. Dave Anderson at chestertoolworks.com makes a gorgeous bow saw that is about the same price as the titanium that would work very well and be slight more traditional.


http://www.chestertoolworks.com/bowsaws.htm

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#11

Dovetailing with the saw

McKay

I have really enjoyed the KC saw over the german type and the standard Stanley saws that I have. However, when cutting dovetails over an extended period of time, I find all of them have the same problem. (actually MY problem) I find that holding that style of handle really hurts my hand. I have had the same problem with the "gentlemans" style of dovetail saw. I would like to figure out a way to put a saw handle on that would allow me to cut with my hand in a vertical position like my LN carcass saw.

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#12

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#13

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Eric

I cannot help with an answer regarding the new "birdcage" style as I have not had any input into the design of these (other than suggest they may be named after Eiffel) and not used one. When I return home, however, I shall know more as Lee Marshall is sending one to me. I shall then update my review of the KC fretsaw.

The original review is here:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/KnewConceptsFretsaw.html

A comment or two. Firstly, titanium is actually heavier than aluminium, although I very much doubt that you will notice this in a saw this size. Secondly, the angled blade means that a longer body is unnecessary. Indeed, I believe that a 3" or 4" is optimal for dovetailing. This has enough depth of cut (on the angle) for standard dovetails. Get the 5" to be safe. Thirdly, the birdcage design came about to save material for the costly titanium. The design is very clever, although I did say to Lee at the outset that I was not sure how well it would go down with woodies - that I thought it would polarise potential buyers. I am happy to report that it has gone over well. From reports, the new design is even stiffer than before. I do expect that the aluminium version is enough, and that the titanium is overkill, but that would not stop me getting the latter! :)

Regards from Perth (currently Sarasota)

Derek

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#14

Taking a different perspective

Bob Hackett

Why do most people want to modify each and every handle/grip on the tools they have in order to adjust their hand to a neutral or more ergonomic position?

If you modify the way you hold the work so IT is adjustable then I think you`ll find it involves a whole lot less time and trouble than changing all those handles and grips.

PS- If you make the thing holding the work adjustable enough those handles/grips will all work better regardless of whether you choose to work standing up, sitting ,kneeling or even laying down. Just the thing for those REALLY long days out in the shop. :D

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#15

No picture?


Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#16

Holy sawdust, Batman!

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

and here I thought it was a birdcage design. A batcage? Even cooler. Does that mean you have to hold the work upside down in the vise and cut while standing on your head, working only after dark?

:D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#17

Merry Christmas, Derek.......

roger lance

hope your visit is going well....Sarasota is a neat city, always liked it....when I grow up, I want to be like you and have companies send me their tools..... do I really have to have a world wide reputation in the hand tool universe before that would happen ???..... :D

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#18

Re: "I've fallen...  and I can't get up!"

CStanford

One of the best posts I've ever read on a woodworking forum.

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#19

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

CStanford

All of this stuff about using framed saws in the cutting of dovetails (even just waste removal) should forever be benchmarked against Frank Klausz's "The Saw." Google it.

Back to the KC saw: the little trussed bugger in the pictures I've seen is a pale, pale imitation of something really useful vs. $s expended when compared to what Mr. Klausz could do with his saw. (except perhaps for jewellry makers working all day at a bench as recounted in David Barnett's excellent post)

Nota bene:

I'm looking into producting a line Titanium mens' support hosiery to help with the varicose veins caused from standing at the bench too long cutting dovetails. I'll let you know when prototypes are available.

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#20

Re: Taking a different perspective

CStanford

There are very few people who don't hold every woodworking tool in their shop with way too much pressure - too much 'squeeze.'

Before I rearranged my embarrassingly crappy shop I had a sign over my bench: Relax Thy Hands.

It'll be up again in the New Year (same crappy shop though).

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#21

Thanks for the link, Chuck!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I don't really care for Olson (too dull), but had never found an alternative for wood.

Much thanks,

Wiley

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#22

Re: "I've fallen...  and I can't get up!"

david weaver

Looks like a WIA tool. I KNOW charles will be getting one.

I have one of the aluminum ones from early on when they were $40. You know what it doesn't solve? That fretsaw blades still require a faberge egg decorators hand.

I have been waiting for years to dump it in favor. I like the $10 zona fretsaw (which is just a made in the USA copy of the german type) better.

The $6 coping saw from home depot is fine, too, and the blades are a lot less fragile.

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#23

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

Eric in Los Gatos

All,

Wow! What great feedback. Thanks particularly to David.

So the consensus appears to be that the aluminum version will do. My quandary is having to decide whether to succumb to titanium lust. (I didn't mention this in my original post but I'm a mechanical engineer so I'm particularly susceptible to this kind of thing. Same reason I lust after Festools on the corded side.)

Not so sure about size. Derek's recommendation of the 5 in makes sense but Wiley's comment about being able to come straight in from the side is compelling too. Hmmm.

Still thinking about going there this week if they'll let me. I'll let you know how it turns out.

Thanks all for you recommendations and guidance.

Eric

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#24

True


Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

#25

Re: Knew Concepts fret saws: is titanium worth it?

David Charlesworth

Derek,

I suspect you will be wanting the Eiffel model, even if one cannot possibly justify the cost.

Three inches with the 45 degree tilt is plenty for dovetails and it is much, much stiffer than the 5" flat titanium model.

Happy Christmas to all,

David Charlesworth