New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Confused by the Burr

Posts

Re: Confused by the Burr

#51

Re: The OP's question - no advantage

TomD

Liked your answer. I think I answered his orginal question back a bit. In most cases people are going to leave the plane touch up late enough that they will want to go back a stone or two. I had a post here several months back about how quickly I could get a plane blade out of a plane and back in and cutting. And secondarily how quickly I could get it back in to a specific setting. I think it was something like 19 seconds, but I couldn't find the post, sot I probably am making that up a bit. At that rate, I think a person probably could just hone. And if so, what would be the advantage to putting it off until one had to go back to some coarse stones.

But yeah that isn't reality.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#52

Re: Confused by the Burr

CStanford

Implicit in all of this, if you've been working wood for longer than three months, if that to some degree or another one apparently never quits shopping for kit. Or shouldn't I suppose.

You guys seemingly have a bottomless pit of a budget for tools and an uncanny ability to ride several bandwagons simultaneously, whilst flinging money out of each as if there were no tomorrow.

Late 19th century kit, mid-to-late 20th century kit, then Lee Valley, Lie-Nielsen, premium Japanese kit... an array in A2, D2, PM(insert roman numerals du jour here).....I'm sure I'm missing others. It's amazing.

Count me envious of the tool expertise that apparently knows no bounds and the treasure trove of tools your shops must be, gracious, to barely mention the juggling act of keeping a vast kit like this catalogued, tuned, sharp, and at the the ready for work. Maybe time-management is the most miraculous aspect of it all.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#53

The OP

Tony Wilkins

Been plenty of good information in this thread for me. Going to have to go back and read through it and take some notes.

TomD - what your wrote about honing only more often makes sense to me. Probably past it on a couple of planes. Can you give me a sense on how often you sharpen (given all the variables) so as to just hone?

Thanks again for all the input to my quandary. I've been reading what I have in books and what I've found online that looks reasonable but that's still a lot of information that often is phrased differently or just enough different as to be confusing.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#54

Re: The OP

Tony Wilkins

Should have said that by 'honing only' in my previous response to TomD I meant going to the 6,000 grit water stone only and not back to the 1,000 grit water stone.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#55

Assumptions about my setup

Tony Wilkins

Wiley you are generally correct about my circumstances. My 'fine' stone is a 6000 grit King water stone. Everything else is spot on.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#56

not all of us have a bottomless budget

Lars Parrington

i could probably recite from memory the catalog of both veritas and lie nielsen, but have never been able to rationalize buying one of their tools. almost every tool i own has come from a garage sale or craigslist. usually in a bit better shape than this one, but not too much:




more pictures here

Re: Confused by the Burr

#57

Re: not all of us have a bottomless budget

CStanford

I can dig it. The core of my hand tool kit was bought from Garrett Wade back when they still carried Record and Marples stuff, both companies obviously gone at this point. Some of these tools were lost in a fire but replaced with the same models bought from everybody's favorite auction site.

I can honestly say I've never taken on a project quite like the one in your picture. Good luck with it.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#58

Re: not all of us have a bottomless budget

Lars Parrington

thanks. don't know if you followed the link, but that plane is all fixed up now. it was a project i did back in the summer. gets used almost every day.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#59

Re: Confused by the Burr

Sgian Dubh

Well Charles, I'm pleased it still tickles your fancy. You may have noticed I've tweaked it a bit since I first penned it sometime in or or near 1995-- there's now some mention of blogs and other online information exchange mechanisms which weren't discussed at all back in '95. Slainte.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#60

Re: not all of us have a bottomless budget

CStanford

I didn't follow the link... I'll go back and take a look.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#61

Re: not all of us have a bottomless budget

CStanford

That's an incredible transformation for sure. Nice work.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#62

Re: Confused by the Burr

TomD

"Count me envious of the tool expertise that apparently knows no bounds and the treasure trove of tools your shops must be, gracious, to barely mention the juggling act of keeping a vast kit like this catalogued, tuned, sharp, and at the the ready for work. Maybe time-management is the most miraculous aspect of it all. "

You are right about the huge waste of time keeping my Smithsonian of tools going takes, but the rest of it. Not so much. My granddad was a joiner, so it runs in the family to have some tools around, even if my dad didn't really have any skills. I have been at the serious side of the game since @ '79. I bought my first Japanese tools around then. If you look at the blogs with tools and fancy shops that some folks have up based on a few years, you can imagine what comes home over 30+ years.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#63

Faith in skills and self

Bob Hackett

If I let only the readily available tools and the preferences of my co-workers dictate how I choose to work I wouldn`t have been able to produce half of the things I`ve made. I also wouldn`t have had near as much fun and/or enjoyment making those things. Just because the guy next to you or the person you work for doesn`t have the skills to work as efficiently with as broad a base of tools and techniques as you do shouldn`t be cause to keep you from enlightening them as to the potential benefits of thinking, and working, outside their particular box.

When my bosses would criticize my latest choice in tools or process I would usually ask them if they were willing to put their money where there mouth was. Most folks at the top think money is king and they were next in line for the throne so they would take me up on these wagers. They soon found out that I rarely lose when betting on myself. Before they wised in that regard those side bets became a nice way for me to generate bonuses.

I used to actively seek out employment paid by either flat rate, time studies or piece work if the rates were honestly calculated. For a skilled worker with an active and creative mind there was always money to be made there. I never found any increase in pay by duplicating past efforts and attempting to be faster than the folks who came before. The real money always came from looking outside the present process and tooling. I`d always be thinking about different ways I could quickly and cleanly get from raw material to finished product. What could I eliminate, tweak, combine, retool or handle less in order to make things move more efficiently. Once I got to that point then the money increased for everyone and my process/technique became the new benchmark.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#64

Re: Confused by the Burr

david weaver

If what other people did bothered me as much as it seems to bother you - to the point of making straw scenarios that have nothing to do with reality...well, I'd probably not think about them.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#65

Uh Oh. Agree again?


Re: Confused by the Burr

#66

Re: Well...the world is ending...

david weaver

..in a couple of days, right? :D

I don't know about anything freezing over, but the ending of the world could be responsible for this convergence :b

Re: Confused by the Burr

#67

Send me your chisels

Ron Harper

If the world is ending, you will not be needing them.