New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Confused by the Burr

Posts

Re: Confused by the Burr

#26

Re: The "burr" as an indicator

CStanford

Ummmm, are we supposed to know who Steve Elliot is?

Re: Confused by the Burr

#27

Of course not . . . *LINK*

Steve Elliott

Here's a link to the information Bill was referring to:


Blade Wear Profiles

Re: Confused by the Burr

#28

Re: Of course not . . .

CStanford

OK

Re: Confused by the Burr

#29

To your question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tony,

Good question. One everyone has in the early going. In most cases, you want to go back to your primary stone--it'll end up saving you time and stress. The finish stones seem to get more glory in discussions, but the MVP on your team is a real good first stone, especially since you're not doing mechanical hollow grinding (that's right, isn't it?).

However, no matter what anybody tells you in this thread, you'll be tempted at some point to use a fine stone to short cut the sharpening process. Not only because you figure you'll save time, and it'll be 'one two nothing' to just go back to the finish stone. But also because there's that feeling of 'I really hate to nuke that beautiful edge I just put on my iron--I'll just fine-tune it, and it'll be good again'. In this situation, 4 things can happen, and 3 of them are bad:

1. It works! Because there wasn't much wear on the blade--not many feet had been planed. Yay, I win!

2. It works! Because you leaned the blade over a bit, feeling for the edge, and put a little steeper micro bevel on the blade, taking it from, say, 30 degrees to 35 degrees. But. Next time when you start feeling for the edge, it'll take 40 degrees, and pretty soon the plane doesn't cut any more because you're out of clearance. Plus, you now have a big grinding job on your hands (esp. without a mechanical grinder), cause all that steeper and steeper beveling has to be ground off the iron--you need a 200 g diamond stone, and you'll be tempted to use the Sellers method.

3. It works! Because you got tired of working on the bevel side, and said to yourself, "self, I'll just turn this blade over and work a little from the flat side of the blade." Hey, that's getting real sharp! But. Now you have a 5 degree back bevel on the iron, which will grow in length with additional sharpenings, and you begin to notice very short planing windows, cause there is significant and growing loss of clearance. Again, you build up a big, big grinding problem, because sooner or later, all that fudging has to be ground off, to get your original iron back. Where's my 200g diamond stone?

4. It kinda works, but not really. You work and work...and then work some more with the finish stone, testing as you go, but (as Lars said above), no burr develops. It feels a little sharper to your finger, so you say, 'well, finish stone burrs are difficult to feel, maybe I don't need one'. But then if you try a newsprint cutting test, or somesuch, it won't do that either. Because some of the wear on the bottom of the blade (see Elliott link below) is still there, even though you've brought up a nice polish on the bevel, and it looks pretty good. Blade will not be sharp until you abrade away all the wear, and get down to virgin steel, and that could be an hour on a finish stone. The primary stone would have gotten down to virgin steel in 15-20 seconds.

Because of the above, it is helpful to understand what is happening as the blade dulls. Steve Elliott has done a great job of methodically photographing the stages of dullness, and published it. Take a look at this page, and especially the second graphic down, entitled "Progressive Edge Wear from Planing Cherry". Whatever stage of dullness you're at, that entire lower arc of the dulling blade, and some of the upper arc also, has to be abraded away before the wear is gone, and you're at virgin steel:

http://bladetest.infillplane.com/html/wear_profiles.html

When Charles says, "There's nothing like a fresh edge", that's what he's talking about--the first stone has removed the wear, the finish stone has re-edged the iron, and now it's really sharp.

So mostly, and with plane blades especially, you want to go back to your MVP stone, your primary stone, and get the wear off the iron.

As Bill Tindall suggests: Steve Elliott's website has a lot of depth on edges and bevels and sharpness and dulling--he is a careful worker and does not overstate his findings.

Hope there is something in here that helps!

Wiley

Re: Confused by the Burr

#30

Never really bought into that one...   


Re: Confused by the Burr

#32

Re: Confused by the Burr

david weaver

I've never used the TFWW stone. I would imagine they are the same as the old type, as they were selling for about $100 at the time, right? Anything else that size sold as washita is about $20, just low quality soft arkansas stones.

Norton probably got those washitas from the same place the original pikes were mined (I don't know when pike and norton got together, maybe there was common ownership the whole time?).

Re: Confused by the Burr

#33

Re: Confused by the Burr

joel moskowitz

This might not have anything to do with anything but when I was a kid and the only irons we had were random stanleys the solution for doing any extensive planning was to sharpen up a bunch of blades and swap them out as they got dull. This way you kept the planing momentum going and didn't have to stop to sharpen. there was also less of a temptation to push a blade to tearout dullness. It's also a lot faster to sharpen 5 blades at once than one blade 5 times.

(doesn't work for chisels unless you really have a LOT of chisels)

Re: Confused by the Burr

#34

Re: Confused by the Burr

joel moskowitz

I don't remember the pri ing but I think it was a good bit less than $100.

The story is that I collect sharpening stones and when I was up in Littleton - where the India stones were made and the stone business was headquartered (all moved to Mexico).I asked the plant manager if he could get me samples of the two Norton stones I didn't have. The Lily White Washita and the Ruby Red Washita. He had never heard of the Ruby but confirmed the lilywhite. I asked him if he had any lying around that he could spare. He said no, but a smile came to his voice and he said "But we own the quarry". About four months later Norton reopened the lilly white quarry and for a few years we got stones (and so did a few other dealers). Essentially all the material came from the one quarry visit. They stopped selling the material because they decided that the cost of revisiting the quarry was too high and they ran out. HOWEVER of course they still own the quarry and I am the eternal optimist.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#35

Re: Confused by the Burr

Kevin Adams

Thanks, David and Joel, it's really a nice stone. I was tempted to buy 2 at the time when you announced they were ceasing production (again), but I just couldn't deprive someone else of one of the last lily whites. I find it to be fairly consistent in performance (no hard or softer spots like you mentioned with your vintage Pike), but you can soften up the pressure with the last couple of passes to get a finer edge.

David, is there any difference between the black and translucent from Dan's? Who sells the Norton black you mentioned?

Thanks again.

Kevin

Re: Confused by the Burr

#36

Re: Confused by the Burr

joel moskowitz

We do.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#37

Re: Confused by the Burr

david weaver

I got the norton black from joel. I've used it on tools some, but mostly as a step before a vintage translucent that I have on razors. Only on razors would a grit step that close make sense.

It is a pleasant stone to use, and it doesn't seem to suffer from the instant loss of cutting ability that other stones have. It isn't as fine as a dan's translucent, though.

It may be a more practical stone than the dans translucent, though. It's got just the tiniest bit of porousness on the surface, which may be why it doesn't tire out and stop cutting.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#38

Re: Confused by the Burr

david weaver

Joel, I can't remember if they were maybe $80 or something. My mind might be clouded by $100 because that's generally what a pike lilywhite would be on ebay on a given day.

About the same day I got my woodworker's delight for $15, a pike of the same size sold for $103, I think. I had them both on watch, and only bid on the woodworker's delight to $20 to have an early bid on an auction I didn't intend to win. I have a nice pike no. 1 that I like, and didn't want to replace it, either.

I think I've only seen one rosy red washita sell, and it was 2x6. I'd love to have one in 2x8 just as a curiosity.

I hope that the lilywhites come back up again at some point, maybe if there is enough of a resurgence in oilstones at some point. Everything seems to go in cycles.

As they go currently, $100 or a little more, I'm sure they would be less immediately if new ones were on the market, and the same problem might occur, just not enough buyers to go around.

I have been touting the virtues of oilstones on the razor boards for a while, as most razors are carbon steel and the ability to polish with an oilstone can really be taken advantage of. There are a lot of english novaculites, some of them very fine, even finer than translucents, and some softer than oilstones. I just put a charnley in the mail yesterday that had a surface like a mirror. I don't know why they are so popular but the translucents less so.

At any rate, a pike/norton washita makes a great stone to do the initial sharpening on a razor that's been out of commission for a while. A soft arkansas of the cheaper varieties....not so much. They remove metal way too fast.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#39

Re: Confused by the Burr - Old timers

TomD

"I use essentially the same kit oldtimers used. Or at least I think I do. Other than the hard rubber strop. I'm convinced they didn't just rub and rub and rub to their heart's content. I think they removed bluntness, then removed rag (most of it, at least) and then put the edged tool back to work or at least considered the deal done at that point."

Old timers weren't monolythic, so I don't doubt there were some of all types. One thought, though, is that they shaved, if at all, with straight razors, so super sharp was in their hands every day. Of course they did not necessarily sharpen those razors, most of the sets I have seen old timer use had several razors, and leather strops no stones at all. But the concept of sharp was not unknown to them.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#40

Re: The "burr" as an indicator

TomD

I don't think it is a leading indicator, since test before the burr forms up exist and are in use. And if the burr is excessive it is literally a trailing indicator. But sometimes a burr forms before I notice otherwise, and sometimes I hit it before I form a burr, it can be either way.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#41

Re: To your question - Presupposes

TomD

that honing is slow. I have been stropping a lot more tools using diamonds. It is winter in the wood shop, and I don't want wet hands, so it is off to diamonds, I haven't used sandpaper in a while.

I sharpened three things I don't normally sharpen, and one I haven't hitherto used Ds for. A sewing machine needle; a leather cutting round knife; a sikkin roller knife, and an olfa type craft knife. Every one of these got scrary sharp from a few strokes on the strop. Only the needle needed a few stroke on a diamond hone first. The tip was well bent over like a crochet hook, from deflecting into the hook of the sewing machine, where it left a nice burr. But once the rough hone had removed the bent tip, the strong had it sharp in seconds. And an examination of the tip indicated it was formed by the stropping into a cone like a sharpened pencil, so that is stock removal.

So added to all those tools that are easily kept running by frequent sharpening, as previously mentioned, we also have the effect of simply using a strop, or fine lap with a really aggressive polish that also leave a very fine edge. We would not need to or more stone, if our final one where simply capable of polishing and grinding at the same time. Or if not grinding, at least capable of rapid stock removal. And in addition to diamonds we have many power sharpening methods that do just that.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#42

not mentioned yet, the magnifying glass

Bill Tindall

I keep a magnifying glass at hand. Some might regard it a crutch but I find it reveals sharpening progress as well as problems that are preventing success. I can't recommend it more highly for someone learning to sharpen, or someone curious as to what sharpening is doing.

On a dull plane blade I find that the burr starts to form before the worn edge is completely removed. This observation can be readily seen with a 10X quality lens. This observation could well depend on the details of the steel for toughness of the steel has a lot to do with the behavior of the burr, toughness being a measure of whether something breaks or bends.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#43

Re: Confused by the Burr

CStanford

Love it. Never tire of it.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#44

Re: Confused by the Burr

CStanford

The story, plus the photo of you with the oilstone and little squirt bottle of oil, pretty much encapsulates the whole thing for me.

I've always looked up to you, even when sticking a gig in 'ya.

You're the Man.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#45

Re: Confused by the Burr

david weaver

I've seen accounts where japanese craftsmen were quoted as saying that the tools (I guess in amount and quality) should support a craftsman on site's behavior of sharpening the tools offsite and not stopping work on behalf of the customer to sharpen your tools.

My stones are in a machinist bench 4 feet from my ww bench, so it's not like I abide by that thought, but it was interesting - the idea that you want the patron to see you doing only work on their behalf, and never maintenance of your own tools.

From a purely functional discussion, abrasion resistant hard steel and modern abrasives make a nice combination. To get an edge that lasts a very long time and takes no more time to sharpen than it takes to do a somewhat soft carbon steel on oilstones...that's a nice boost. Especially in something like a bench plane where there's disassembly, reassembly, resetting involved each time you sharpen.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#46

Indeed

Bill Tindall

For anyone starting the accumulation of tools the choice of modern steel and modern abrasives should be considered. The cost difference of the abrasive will be no more or even less than a traditional route. I think it is still not widely recognized how blazing fast diamonds cut any steel and at a modest cost.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#47

The OP's question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

was whether, as a matter of typical plane-blade sharpening, to touch up on the finish stone, or go back to the primary stone. I answered that question, with some presuppositions about his specific context, and reflecting on my own 'just starting out' phase with no one around to show how. And also assumed his 'fine stone' is in the 8-10K ballpark, and not diamond.

You're a very advanced worker--how do you answer his question? Are you saying fine diamond (paste or fixed stone) will maintain plane blades indefinitely, if the blade is not let go too far? Since the OP does not machine grind, for him to do that would require the skill to keep a bevel flat indefinitely, by hand touch.

My answer for chisels (or needles, etc, that you mentioned) would be quite different. But that's another opera or two.

Wiley

Re: Confused by the Burr

#48

The myth..

david weaver

...that it takes forever to maintenance sharpen tough steel is one that seems to have permanent legs.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#49

cheap and quick

Bill Tindall

Hollow grind on a bench grinder, straighten the grind on a "fine" fixed diamond plate, refine with diamond on cast iron. Cheap and quick. The more abrasion resistant steels are easier to do because there is better control on the bench grinder. That said, for the average person making furniture these advantages are not so compelling as to obsolete traditional methods if the investment in these tools, techniques and materials is already paid for.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#50

Sharpening offsite

Steve Elliott

. . . not stopping work on behalf of the customer to sharpen your tools . . .

As an employee of commercial shops I've always done my sharpening at home, on my own time, at my own pace. I never want someone telling me it's good enough when I'm not satisfied yet.

My preference for abrasion-resistant steels follows from this. I try to minimize the amount of time I use edge tools when I'm at work because I'm accustomed to having the foreman look at me funny if he sees me with a plane.

These days I'm the foreman but habits die hard. The people I work with think a hand tool is a random orbital sander or a Domino mortiser.