New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Confused by the Burr

Posts

Confused by the Burr

#1

Confused by the Burr

Tony Wilkins

As I decipher sharpening, I thought I was understanding developing a burr and then honing it off. However, there is a discussion on sharpening on this video from The Woodwright's Shop that confuses me.

http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/video/2600/2608.html

At about 8:20 or so, they talk about the burr. I'm not sure if I'm really understanding what John Reed Fox is saying about the burr. Can someone break it down for a Newb please.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#2

Re: Confused by the Burr

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

I had not watched this video for a long time, so it was interesting to hear the comments again. OK, it goes like this ...

When honing a bevel, you use a succession of different grits. Let's say, you start with a 1000 grit waterstone (coarse, to establish a clean primary bevel), move to a 5000 grit (medium, to smooth over the edge achieved), and finish on a 12000 grit (polishing the edge to a finish smoothness). With each grit, the work - honing - completed on one side of the bevel pushes steel over to the other side of the bevel. This is referred to as a wire edge, or a burr. This wire edge cannot be left there as it prevents the edge of the bevel being a clean join of two sides. It must be removed, and so one hones the back of the blade as well. Honing the back of the blade will remove most of this wire edge. Some of it will be abraded away, and some will be pushed back to the bevel face side. And so you then hone the bevel face some more to remove the wire edge on that side, and then the back to do ditto ...

Each time you hone you create a wire edge. And it must be removed before you can use the blade. A higher grit stone (e.g. 12000) will create a finer wire edge than a coarser stone (e.g. 1000). Consequently you can expect to find a wire edge each time, but it will be finer. Some find it difficult to detect the wire edge off a high grit stone. I recall a demo I did at a woodshow about 6 months ago, and was interested that some could not feel the wire edge off a 5000 stone. I can feel one off a 12000 stone. The point is, it will be there, and for some it is a good idea to look at it with a magnifying glass or a lupe.

Now to the video. There are two strategies one may follow when removing the wire edge: Method #1 is to remove it after each successive stone. Method #2 is to remove it only at the end.

The advantage of removing the wire edge after each stone is that the presence of the wire edge alerts you that you have honed across the bevel face. Without doing so you may leave the edge unhoned and end up just polishing the edge, not "sharpening" it. I like to do it this way, and it take no time at all to remove the wire edge - which, when you do on the back of the blade, you ONLY use the final polishing stone. The downside of this method is - as stated in the video - you can "work harden" the edge (cause it to become over hard, and thus brittle) when the wire edge gets pushed back-and-forth.

The advantage of removing the wire edge at the end only is that you avoid the risk of work hardening (which is not something I have noticed). The disadvantage is that you lose the "signal" how well the edge is being honed. Note that you are forced to use this method anyway when you use a honing guide if you do not have sufficient blade projection.

Hope this is clear.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Confused by the Burr

#3

Re: Confused by the Burr

TomD

Various things can happen to a burr. The phrase wire edge comes from when it is produced so excessively that it appears on the stone like a pin when it falls off. Or some people physically detach it in a similar way to bending a wire back and forth until it breaks. And some methods do not really produce one, and then some other people will strike the tool into wood say, to break or tear it off.

Reed is saying that if you bend it back and forth to detach it, the surface left will not be as smooth as your sharpening efforts were headed to. And he in addition says that by bending it back and forth the steel work hardens, which one might imagine would make the edge less tough. So he recommends wearing it away on the stones, and Roy refers to that as a Japanese sharpening technique, which it probably is, but also every other culture on earth. I think most woodworkers with experience would agree that the sharpest edge comes from grinding the burr off in the process Reed suggests, though many woodworkers do not need that level of edge, and are happy with other techniques.

The burr is produced I think, by sharpening till the area sharpened includes the edge, at which point there is an area at the edge that does not get enough pressure to cut, and folds up. This is the burr or wire edge, though those are terms to describe particular forms the foil at the edge takes, depending on how long you go at it, and many other factors.

It is not necessary to produce a discernible burr, and it may not form if one uses power tools for sharpening, or sometimes micro bevels, or if one uses a method that is process oriented and does not require the burr to form in order to move onto the next grit. Burrs waste steel and time, because one has to overshoot the optimal condition in order for one to form.

One of the better ways to avoid forming burrs is to have a pro way of sensing the edge is sharp. Then you just stop at that point. So for instance if you shaved your arm, you could just sharpen and stop every so often to test for razor sharpness. I don't consider that a good method, and it takes a long time to describe the one I prefer. But the shaving test is one people understand. With a knife, one normally uses it till it dulls a little, then hones until it tests sharp, that works great. The problem with woodworking tools is we need a test that also tells when a tool is sharp from a stone that will not make it shaving sharp. So you need two reliable edge tests.

The other method that is pro and commonly used, as mentioned, is a process method. There are lots of these, but constant stopping to strop or steel on the kill floor, or by barbers, or by leather workers. They keep on top of it, and since they don't have planes to take apart or adjust, it is pretty easy for them to keep honing. Or in the case of the barber the client would get a rough shave if the barber did not sharpen for every client. He only needs to do some major work when the razor edge thickens too much. The same is true of the scythe, they would sharpen it every few minutes, then stop every now and then to draw the edge out thin on an anvil. So again, they keep on top of it.

So you don't need to sharpen until you feel the burr, and certainly not a large, one. But it is a reliable method of ensuring one does not move on before the edge is ready. That is a cause of a lot of grief when sharpening, because if you didn't get down to the edge with the coarse stones, it will take for ever to get down to it with the finer ones. More likely one will give up, or start thinking about buying some new stones. :)

Re: Confused by the Burr

#4

Re: Confused by the Burr

CStanford

I'm less a "honer" than I am a "bluntness remover." What's the difference? For me, reality.

I remove bluntness on a No. 2 Washita, a Pike, (an old, thick one), IMO the best all-around stone one could own. A blue collar, no-BS stone if ever there was one. My stone is not consistent, it has rough patches that remove steel faster. I love them. I use them. I think to good effect. I wouldn't change a thing.

Anyway, the burr off the Washy is unmistakable. I hone until I can feel it all the way across the flat side of the cutter (chisel, etc.) this means the bluntness has been removed. This doesn't take long - maybe ten or fifteen strokes. Then I simply take it to a black Ark (or sometimes, not) and alternate bevel and back another ten or so strokes. Then, you can just swipe the edge through the endgrain of a pine block (like you were trying to slice it in two horizontally) or swipe it on your jeans, hit it on a strop, the calloused heal of your hand, etc, etc. I doubt I ever remove the burr totally before going back to work and couldn't care less. Nor should you.

I've honed on ultra-fine media (super high grit sandpaper) and can't feel the burr. I'm squarely in the Maurice Fraser camp on this - stropping is not needed when using very fine grit media (8,000 grit waterstones, their equivalent, or higher). If stropping is still needed then, frankly, what's the freaking point behind owning the high grit (and usually much more expensive) media?

Warning, hyperbole ahead: Of course, non of this applies if you own steel that's not supposed to dull until you hit 95 years of age. And when it finally does it'll take 'til you're 105 to get it sharp again.

YMMV

Re: Confused by the Burr

#5

Re: Confused by the Burr

CStanford

Meant '...slice in two vertically...' when referring to erasing burr/rag using a block of pine.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#6

Re: Confused by the Burr

CStanford

I should have simply posted a link to Maurice Fraser:

http://antiquetools.com/sharp/

Re: Confused by the Burr

#7

Re: Confused by the Burr

Tony Wilkins

Great answers all and thank you. I'm reading through and digesting. I bookmarked that link CStanford.

Add a dumb question to this. Do you go to both stones every time or do you just go to the higher grit stone for touch-ups often?

Re: Confused by the Burr

#8

Re: both stones for me *LINK*

Lars Parrington

1000 grit followed by 8000. if i try to go straight to 8000, the tool might look sharp, but fails to shave hairs. note that i only use 1 microbevel (or zero depending on how you count). perhaps with a multiple microbevel method, touchups could be done going straight to the fine stone. here's a link to an in-depth analysis of microbevel geometry:


http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/bevels.html

Re: Confused by the Burr

#9

Re: Confused by the Burr

CStanford

I go to the Washita for speed. Further refinement on the black Ark is often not necessary, or at least doesn't seem so. I think I may have had a typo in my first post. The Washita is a No. 1 Pike, not a No. 2 grade (not sure if there is even a No. 2). I believe I paid around $15 for it on EBay. Sump'n like that.

Sometimes I'll go to the Washita and then to a Wood is Good hard rubber strop to knock off the burr. I put a little dry AlOx powder on it from time to time.

Honing is variable. I have no absolutely engraved in stone (sorry for the pun) routine and am a little bit suspicious of those that do. Sometimes I might unconsciously put on a little extra pressure on the Washita and raise a bigger burr than was necessary or intended. In that circumstance I need the Arky to help flex it off and to just generally tidy things up - big burr equals craggy edge when it comes off. Other times, I'll stop at just the right moment with a really fine burr that will flex right off on practically anything. Let the burr tell you what to do. Who on God's Green Earth nails it everytime? I sure don't. When you don't, you have to do something different IMO.

If you take anything away, it's to keep the art in the process and to feel what's going on.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#10

Re: Confused by the Burr

TomD

It can be a lot more than 2 stones, but in my case I try to keep it to two. We just had the Paul Sellers related thread where he goes through 3 stones 1 buff. Some tools will not do a nice job without constant touching up, razors being one. Other tools take a long time to turn around, so one puts it off till it takes more work to get them back. I use convex edge drawknives, and I wait till they need at least a two step sharpening. But thinking about your question, given the convexity, it would be easier to strop them regularly.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#11

Re: Confused by the Burr

david weaver

The pike #1 is a really nice stone. It is miles above anything being offered as a soft arkansas or washita now.

There is a #2. I've never seen one in person. My pike #1 is a lot like yours, variable. On mine, the white spots are softer and more coarse like you'd expect on a washita, but half of it is darkish and fairly fine. It's a great chisel stone and it responds really well to a strop, better than synthetic coarse/medium stones.

Too much talk about washita stones on the woodworking boards drives up the cost of the name brand stones, though. (the pikes and the nortons).

I found a woodworkers delight a couple of weeks ago for $14. I don't know where those came from, but it looks and feels a lot like a lilywhite washita (the lilywhites go for monopoly money prices).

Re: Confused by the Burr

#12

Re: Confused by the Burr

CStanford

Lucked into it without a doubt, I did.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#13

Re: Confused by the Burr

CStanford

I also want to my point clear, the entirety of which might not be evident from my other posts: I'm more about the geometry of sharp than the polish associated therewith. Why? I hone freehand (excepting of course the built-in jig that a hollow grind provides). Excessive rubbing, for me, can just as easily put blunt what I just made sharp. I use essentially the same kit oldtimers used. Or at least I think I do. Other than the hard rubber strop. I'm convinced they didn't just rub and rub and rub to their heart's content. I think they removed bluntness, then removed rag (most of it, at least) and then put the edged tool back to work or at least considered the deal done at that point. Certainly if they felt some particular operation required an edge with more 'smoothness' (term very much intended), then they spent more time at the finest stone or at the strop, possibly not both but either/or. Probably the strop most times. In my opinion.

There is nothing like a fresh edge. I repeat, there is nothing like a fresh edge. Keep your stones at the ready. Go to them to remove bluntness. Often. Get back to work. Don't spend minutes and minutes on the edge with the intention of going hours between bluntness removal sessions. It's silly. No, it's stupid to work that way.

This is why these supposedly super steels interest me not one bit. They're like a loaf of bread you can't quite remember when you bought - you don't know *for sure* if it's fresh or not, maybe not even until you take a bite. I have no need for such products. They are anathema to a natural rhythm in the shop or at least what feels like a natural rhythm to me. Maybe you'll feel that way too.

Quick honing breaks (bluntness removal breaks, not polish-to-mirror breaks) will do wonders for your woodworking on several different levels.

Give it a try.

Nothing beats a fresh edge.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#14

Re: Confused by the Burr

Kevin Adams

David and Charles,

Any idea how the "newer" Norton lily whites that TFWW sold a few years ago compare to the Pike #2's? I have the former and it is my favorite, do-all stone as Charles says, but have wondered what the Pike would be like (and have looked for one without success so far).

Thanks for any further thoughts you both may have.

Kevin

Re: Confused by the Burr

#15

Very well said, Charles.


Re: Confused by the Burr

#16

Re: Confused by the Burr

Sgian Dubh

There's much sense in what you say Charles. I tend to be somewhat perplexed by the endless lengths many people seem to go to to get a getter sharp edge on their tools, often involving several stones (or some other sharpening system) followed by things like jeweller's rouge, flap wheels on grinders or bits of leather dressed with oil and powdered abrasives. I sometimes wonder a little bit if part of the process requires the chanting of mystical incantations, deep meditation and some of those incense stick things smouldering in the background just to create the right ambience prior to launching out on the whole daunting process. (That last sentence was meant as tongue in cheek humour by the way, not to be taken seriously.)

The reality is in my experience that the keenest edge is seldom needed for most work. A plane or chisel that's adequately sharp, quickly and frequently achieved through about a minute's work on a decent stone (or similar) and perhaps a bit of stropping on the palm of the hand will do. So, maybe there's a hint of wire edge or burr left here and there when sharpening this way, and the cutting edge doesn't get polished up to near perfection either, but the edge created is frequently good enough to carry on successfully: and anyway, as soon as the worker bashes the chisel into some wood, or the plane is used aggressively to hack down some recalcitrant wood, that wee burr that may have been left after sharpening is dealt with.

True, this level of sharpness may not be adequate for final preparation of the wood prior to any necessary scraping sanding and polishing, and a bit of extra honing is called for. But I've found that generally this is about the only time a little extra time and effort is required to take the cutting edge of the tool to a higher level. So, for me, most between regrinding touching up, honing or sharpening (call it whatever you like) of chisels and planes needs no more than a few strokes up and down an 800 grit stone, turning over and removing the wire edge on the flat side of the blade, a bit of flipping backwards and forwards on the palm of the hand, and back to work. I know the end result isn't perfect, but I don't need 'perfection', if such a thing exists, very often. I only need the cutting edge good enough for the job it has to do at the time, so the quicker I get through sharpening the quicker I get back to work. Sharpening has always been, and should always be nothing more than a mundane, swiftly achieved, low level, routine task in a productive furniture making environment.

There are good reasons why tool edge maintenance and sharpness may not be routine procedure, but none of those reasons equate to efficient furniture production in a commercial workshop, unless the commerce of that workshop involves, for example, regular teaching of inexperienced woodworkers how to undertake basic skills, including sharpening. There are other good reasons for sharpening to be relatively time consuming or an important task, but most of them revolve around non-commercial woodworking activities, eg, amateur woodworking, and there's absolutely nothing wrong with being an amateur woodworker. I've seen a lot of wonderful products come out of amateur woodworker's workshops made for the love of it (one way or another) without a thought given to making a profit on the job. And let's not forget that it's often amateurs who have the time and curiosity to explore the esoteric ends of furniture design and making subjects and techniques. They are often capable of pointing other woodworkers, professional or amateur, to new or revived information and techniques that serve us all well. Slainte.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#17

A very good point, worth remembering


Re: Confused by the Burr

#18

Where this otherwise ideal approach fails

Bill Tindall

When I settle in to dovetail a set of drawers I know I will be working on this task for some time and that no matter the steel I am going to need to sharpen several times the two chisels I will be using . Furthermore, there is continuity in the dulling as I go from one drawer side to another. The dulling is anticipated, I can feel it developing and I have prepared for it. It is, as you say, " a natural rhythm in the shop". The whole baguette will be consumed long before I need to worry about an expiration date.

For persons that eschew machine surface preparation I would presume this same rhythm is experienced with a hand plane. But my planing is focused on fitting furniture parts. It involves at least a #5 and a block plane and may involve one or more other specialty planes. It may involve at most a few swipes of a plane across a surface or edge of primary or secondary wood, a show surface or not, and mild or wild grain. The demands on the plane's edge performance will range from trivial to demanding in the months long route to a finished piece. Depending on my hobby schedule it may have been days since the plane was last used, and for what purpose, long forgotten. Hence, a plane too dull to do the job at hand always comes as an unpleasant surprise. There is, and can not be, any natural rhythm to planing under these circumstances. I want a box of crackers that is good for weeks when the urge to snack on one or two arrives. Actually boxes of several long shelf life varieties are required depending on the need at hand.

For this situation I want the most abrasive resistant steel I can find so that these unpleasant interruptions to sharpen are minimized. My sharpening of plane irons usually consists of finding nearly every plane I own more or less dull and in need of more or less serious grinding to get that first wire edge.

Once interrupted it is about as easy to sharpen the lot of them and start over on the erratic road to dullness. A bench grinder becomes a practical first step in the process.

The bottom line is that the tools we use and the maintenance of them can not be divorced from the circumstances of how they are employed. Advice without this information is incomplete, and can be misleading.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#19

Don't forget the hat!

John in NM

Got to wear a proper wizard's cap to sharpen effectively, though of course, best results are obtained from purchase of the full outfit :D


Seriously though, I think a lot of the preceived complexity comes from the vast number of ways one can acheive the desired result - adequately sharp steel. Doesn't much matter which abrasive one uses, they will all work and once the blade is sharp it won't be evident which abrasive was used. I believe it is the number of options that make the task seem complex, not the actual task itself.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#20

The "burr" as an indicator

Bill Tindall

If you Study Steve Elliot's descriptions of dulling of a plane blade (his web site is must reading) you will see that to resharpen the blade that the edge must be ground back to remove the "flat spot". It happens that a burr begins (probably can begin) to form at about the point where this flat spot has been ground away. Hence, its appearance is a leading indicator that the initial grinding has been accomplished. Furthermore, its persistence to the end of edge refinement is an indication that some step in the refinement has been insufficient.

Personally, I pursue the fist step of edge restoration of something truly dull until I establish a burr. (I find this approach especially useful on kitchen knives. ) In edge refinement I abrade the burr ever thinner until it floats away or otherwise disappears on the final abrasive.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#21

Re: Confused by the Burr

CStanford

Wish I knew. I almost bought one of those stones from TFWW but some other bill needing payment must have intervened.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#22

Re: Confused by the Burr

CStanford

It's time for 'the post.' You know, everybody's favorite sharpening story.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#23

Re: Confused by the Burr

Lars Parrington

i wouldn't be surprised to find that i am sharpening to an unnecessarily high level. partial sharpening actually sounds like an interesting experiment. the reason i haven't tried it yet is that the extra time it takes me to reach a high level of sharpness is insignificant. it probably takes me 5 minutes to resharpen a plane blade, including getting the iron in and out of the plane. less than 1 minute of that is spent above 1000 grit.

yesterday, i spent ~1 hour flattening both sides of a 10" x 72" black walnut panel glueup using an old stanley jack plane. i stopped to sharpen the iron 4 times in that hour. each time it was visibly quite dull, usually with a small nick or two. standard carbon steel iron, sweetheart logo. even though 1/3 of my total time was spent sharpening, i probably spent most of the time pushing a dull tool and was lucky to avoid unrecoverable tearout.

this is why super steels are a compelling to me. i am just beginning to experiment with them. the planer blade i put in my smoothing plane 3 days ago is the first thing i've gotten to try that's better than O1. with a grinder to do most of the work, i don't see why sharpening has to take forever.

Re: Confused by the Burr

#24

any sufficiently advanced technology...

Lars Parrington

is indistinguishable from magic. -- Arthur C. Clarke

Re: Confused by the Burr

#25

Re: Where this otherwise ideal approach fails

CStanford

Strange post I must say.

Do you: 1) dovetail a whole case of drawers in one sitting without breaks; 2) take breaks but prefer not to have to do chisel touchups during the break(s); 3) something else?