Re: Confused by the Burr
TomD
Various things can happen to a burr. The phrase wire edge comes from when it is produced so excessively that it appears on the stone like a pin when it falls off. Or some people physically detach it in a similar way to bending a wire back and forth until it breaks. And some methods do not really produce one, and then some other people will strike the tool into wood say, to break or tear it off.
Reed is saying that if you bend it back and forth to detach it, the surface left will not be as smooth as your sharpening efforts were headed to. And he in addition says that by bending it back and forth the steel work hardens, which one might imagine would make the edge less tough. So he recommends wearing it away on the stones, and Roy refers to that as a Japanese sharpening technique, which it probably is, but also every other culture on earth. I think most woodworkers with experience would agree that the sharpest edge comes from grinding the burr off in the process Reed suggests, though many woodworkers do not need that level of edge, and are happy with other techniques.
The burr is produced I think, by sharpening till the area sharpened includes the edge, at which point there is an area at the edge that does not get enough pressure to cut, and folds up. This is the burr or wire edge, though those are terms to describe particular forms the foil at the edge takes, depending on how long you go at it, and many other factors.
It is not necessary to produce a discernible burr, and it may not form if one uses power tools for sharpening, or sometimes micro bevels, or if one uses a method that is process oriented and does not require the burr to form in order to move onto the next grit. Burrs waste steel and time, because one has to overshoot the optimal condition in order for one to form.
One of the better ways to avoid forming burrs is to have a pro way of sensing the edge is sharp. Then you just stop at that point. So for instance if you shaved your arm, you could just sharpen and stop every so often to test for razor sharpness. I don't consider that a good method, and it takes a long time to describe the one I prefer. But the shaving test is one people understand. With a knife, one normally uses it till it dulls a little, then hones until it tests sharp, that works great. The problem with woodworking tools is we need a test that also tells when a tool is sharp from a stone that will not make it shaving sharp. So you need two reliable edge tests.
The other method that is pro and commonly used, as mentioned, is a process method. There are lots of these, but constant stopping to strop or steel on the kill floor, or by barbers, or by leather workers. They keep on top of it, and since they don't have planes to take apart or adjust, it is pretty easy for them to keep honing. Or in the case of the barber the client would get a rough shave if the barber did not sharpen for every client. He only needs to do some major work when the razor edge thickens too much. The same is true of the scythe, they would sharpen it every few minutes, then stop every now and then to draw the edge out thin on an anvil. So again, they keep on top of it.
So you don't need to sharpen until you feel the burr, and certainly not a large, one. But it is a reliable method of ensuring one does not move on before the edge is ready. That is a cause of a lot of grief when sharpening, because if you didn't get down to the edge with the coarse stones, it will take for ever to get down to it with the finer ones. More likely one will give up, or start thinking about buying some new stones. 