New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Whew... Close Call With Disaster

Posts

Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#1

Robert Tutsky

Whew... Close Call With Disaster

Robert Tutsky

I had a close call today which could have been a trip to the doc.

We all work with sharp tools that can become dangerous if improperly used. One of the tools that we don't think about as being dangerous is the bench chisel. But a sharp chisel, especially a wide one can inflict some serious bodily damage. Working with one that is surgically sharp is a pleasure to use but it's use must be calculated.

What happened to me was that I had mounted two pieces of wood together with double sided tape to mirror carve them. When I was satisfied with the carve I found I couldn't pull them apart so I got the idea of prying them apart with a 1-1/4" chisel. Holding the parts I figured I could use the chisel to twist the faces apart but once that wasn't working I pushed the chisel into the pieces to pry them apart. Wrong choice. The pieces came apart okay but violently, thrusting the chisel forward just grazing my index finger. Had I been holding the pieces forward, say 1/4" further, I'm sure the chisel would have hit a bone. Whoa! Stupidity on my part.

I have in the past told my son to pay attention to any cutting edge moving in any direction to make sure no flesh is anywhere in the direction that sharp edge is going. That rule pertains to me too!

Pay attention to what your tools are capable of and STAY SAFE folks!

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#2

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

TomD

Glad you are basically OK. I always think a chisel is a dangerous tool. I tell the similar story of when I was newish and did all my sharpening by hand on the ground. So it was work to prep tools, and in particular hand grind out chips. I dropped a Japanese plane blade, which is a heavy sucker. I was brought up on scenes like the one where Dirty Harry gets shot and the surgeon is about to cut off his pants, and warns him that if he insist on taking the pants off that it will hurt. To which DH replies "for thirty bucks, let it hurt". So of course I stuck my foot under the falling blade. Got away with it too, until I notices a soggy feeling in the footbed of my sandal.

There is a concept in safety of unlimited geometry. Meaning it may be bad what happens if you stuff your finger into a spinning router bit, but it isn't unlimited in scope. But with a bandsaw, you could cut your head off, and people have cut their lower arm off, also with radial arm saws. The geometry of a chisel is pretty unlimited, you could kill yourself with one if you fell on it. While that may not happen too often, cuts to the finger that render it useless, or expensive, do happen.

With dangerous hand tools, power and push, one fundamental of safety is that it is harder to hurt yourself with both hands on the tool. So it is worth considering before leaning on a chisel if the same thing could be done with a mallet or a clamp or end vise.

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#3

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

Jerry Gibbs

I was at a woodworking school. There was a discussion re SawStop etc. The owner said they never had a table saw accident, but did have stitches because of a chisel. The instructors tried to keep the students free hand out of the line of fire. Jerry

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#4

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

archie

Glad you're not in worse shape! And, yes, our surgically sharp chisels do "bite." I, too, have learned that painful lesson of using something other than my hand as the vise!

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#5

A chisel and Roy Underhill......

roger lance

Glad you are OK.....Your story reminded me of a scene years ago on the Woodwright Shop where Roy was working at a bench that was typically littered with tools and project parts and Roy used a wooden mallet to strike some part on the bench which caused a chisel to go flying in the air inches from his face....I can just see that chisel rotating in the air and Roy watching it as it passed by his face and returned to the bench....sort of an ah-ha moment....could have seen some real blood there instead of the minor bleeding Roy is know for.

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#6

Glad you escaped injury

Ron Harper

Back in the old days on the Porch, John Gunterman and I frequently caused much amusement with

our mis-adventures. I once was paring the inside of a mortise

in a 2 X 2 cherry stile. The stile shattered and I got 13 stitches in left pinky. I violated the most important rule in the shop " keep everything that you want to keep behind the cutting edge"

BTW. I have a woodworker friend who is an ER doc during the daylight hours. He says the chisel is second only to the tablesaw in sending folks from the shop to the ER

Ron a Kokomo Galoot

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#7

the same chisel has sent me to the ER 3 times

Bruce, a MN Galoot

cutting my left hand in three different places. Back in rec.ww days, Steve LaMantia told a great story that taught the lesson "where's it gonna go when it slips?" I must be slow on the uptake.

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#8

Re: the same chisel has sent me to the ER 3 times

Ron Harper

Used to keep super glue in my tool tray. Did many minor surgical repairs at the bench. I am more careful now. But the super glue is still close by.

Ron

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#9

Re: Cut man in the corner.

TomD

Now that we have the internet, you can look up what the cut man is actually doing when he pushes something in the boxers eye to close up a cut. I assumed it was some giant styptic pencil. Turns out he just has some hard object, and is jamming the cut closed under force. Apparently this will close a cut that would not otherwise knit.

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#10

Thanks for the wake up !

steve mackay

We all need it and it's been awhile !

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#11

Re: A chisel and Roy Underhill......

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

It's a rare show that he doesn't lose some blood.

Work safe,

George

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#12

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

cstanford

Well, yes, we do think of bench chisels as dangerous contrary to the first sentence of your post. One slip and one is easily down to ligaments and tendons.

There's not a decent woodworking volume around that doesn't provide the urgent advice to always keep both hands on the chisel - to not use the off hand to hold the work while using the chisel in the other.

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#13

Robert Tutsky

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

Robert Tutsky

"Well, yes, we do think of bench chisels as dangerous contrary to the first sentence of your post. One slip and one is easily down to ligaments and tendons.

There's not a decent woodworking volume around that doesn't provide the urgent advice to always keep both hands on the chisel - to not use the off hand to hold the work while using the chisel in the other".

I stand corrected concerning safety advise for chisels. Personally though I haven't seen much information about chisel safety, most of the time the safety issues seem to be targeted to power tools.

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#14

True as far as it goes

TomD

"to not use the off hand to hold the work while using the chisel in the other."

Good point, though there are at least a few exceptions.

One is where you have some kind of braced cut say one has the index finger behind the workpiece and it can't hop out to cut the hand holding the piece.

Another is when the cutting action reaches the end of the stroke and can't cut into the body. There are squeezing actions with the fingers on knives, into the thumb, or there is the suicidal looking use of the draw knife, where normal flexibility in the shoulders precludes the penetration of the draw knife into the body.

The are curtain cuts that land on the body, normally the thumb but they have no power left, and they do not shear so the thumb catches them.

There are also certain calculated arcs with say a froe, where the angle cause the head to miss and jam under the foot. Western travellers were chilled to see Japanese carpenters do this with bare feet.

Then there is that whole cuthroat razor thing, though I digress.

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#15

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

CStanford

It's there and not complicated - one sentence will do: Keep both hands somewhere on the chisel at all times.

This usually entails having the handle of the chisel in one hand with the fingers of the other hand somewhere on the metallic part providing guidance or a check on the forward progress of the chisel as it moves through the material.

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#16

Re: True as far as it goes

CStanford

I didn't know froes and razors were now classified as chisels.

Interesting.

Re: Whew... Close Call With Disaster

#17

Re: True as far as it goes

david weaver

The disaster with a straight razor is much more likely to be blade damage than user damage (i.e., i don't have any concerns about shaving with the straight razor, but I do have concerns that at some point, I'll drop one and listen to part of the blade go pinging off, or accidentally tap the edge against a faucet when handling it with the same effect).