New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

gluing up panels wider than your planer

Posts

gluing up panels wider than your planer

#1

gluing up panels wider than your planer

Lars Parrington

what is your prefered method for keeping the joint(s) aligned so as to minimize time spent flattening by hand afterwards? furthermore, how much effort would you expect to spend on the hand flattening? are you just taking a scraper down the length of the joint(s), or breaking out the jack plane and starting from there?

these are the options that seem obvious to me:

1.) tongue and groove. i like that it can be cut by hand. i worry about being able to see the joint at the end of the board and about the joint not closing tight on both sides of the groove. perhaps 2 grooves with a separate spline would eliminate the latter concern.

2.) biscuits. ear plugs required. with vacuum attachment on biscuit joiner, it could be quick, easy, and not messy. will have to plan out locations of any crosscuts in advance to avoid putting a biscuit there.

3.) nothing. my usual method, which i am hoping to improve upon. i've had some limited success by tightening the middle clamp first and working my way to the ends, torqing the ends of the boards to adjust the alignment at each clamp as i go.

i ask because i have a couple casework projects coming up that will involve 18" wide panels joined with through dovetails at the corners. i am leaning towards buying a biscuit joiner. i do have a matched pair of tongue and groove planes that could probably be made to work with a few hours of fettling.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#2

#3

John in NM

I get the boards as flat as possible, then glue them up and plane them down to smooth. I tend to spring the joint as well, so if I snug up the middle I can keep the ends pretty flush with no problems as I tighten the middle clamps.

I've never found that biscuit jointers were effective for alignment, I get better results with careful prep work than anything else. I've also seen a top with little biscuit shaped indentations. Top was sanded flat about an hour after being glued up, and the moisture from the glue had swelled the wood around the biscuit. When the wood dried out you could see the shape of the biscuits in the joint.

Tongue and groove? Sounds like more work than necessary to me, but I've never done one so that's just a guess.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#3

Re: I agree - #3

William Duffield

Further, the biscuit jointer just slows down the glue-up process, so the glue tacks before you can adjust the edges. The compressed, undersized biscuits don't swell up fast enough to actually insure alignment.

While tightening the bar clamps, I often use a pair of hand screws, preadjusted, to push the ends of the boards into alignment while I'm concentrating on the rest of the joint, but this only works if I've used a power planer to make both boards exactly the same thickness.

I used to have a biscuit jointer, and have used it to align boards for glue-up, but abandoned the practice when I found it didn't help at all. I don't even own one any more, but that's a story for another forum.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#4

yes for  #3

Bill Tindall

Agree with everything said, especially the uselessness of the biscuit joiner or anything else for alignment.

You will get the best alignment by starting with flat boards. Glue one joint at a time. I haven't decided if it is better to start at one end and work to the other tightening clamps while diddling with lumber to get the edges aligned, or to start in the middle. I do like to have the assembly near the edge of the bench so that I can force the last bit of edge into alignment as needed with a clamp to the bench. I never have more than 1/64 out of alignment on a joint and only that much is part of the joint. You will be able to easily scrape away any irregularity.

If you use yellow glue it has near instant tack and quickly develops impact resistance. You will not be able to hammer a misaligned joint into submission. However, the joint will have little shear strength for a few minutes. Applying steady pressure from a clamp or jack! will promptly force a joint into alignment.

A jack indeed. I once was highly motivated to use a severely warped board for a table top. I forced it flat against the clamps by jacking with a hydraulic jack against the ceiling joists.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#5

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

Marhk

#3 and a hammer.

As Frank Klausz once said "If it doesn't fit - get a bigger hammer!"

Although, once I used a DowelMax and was happy with the result. I agree - for some reason, biscuits don't work well for alignment (at least in my hands).

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#6

craigd

#4: Salt

craigd

Table salt works wonders to keep boards from moving during clamp up. The crystals don't dissolve in the glue and act like little bitty tacks. Only a tiny sprinkle here and there is needed.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#7

glueing up wide panels......

roger lance

I've found two things to be key to success: preparation of the stock and taking your time. Each board is as flat as possible and the edges have been accurately jointed....the boards should fit together very tightly without clamping before glueing (never appreciated the "spring" technique but YMMV). I love to use splines but in thick stock not 3/4".....and I'm down to using biscuits in mainly corner work where you are reinforcing 45* miters....I do not find biscuits of much value for alignment (more trouble than they are worth IMHO).....in terms of taking your time, this is not an Olympic event.....I just glue two boards together at one time and I use a LV aluminum straight edge to check for flatness as I tighten the clamps....nothing can pull a glue up out of flat quicker than too much clamping pressure.....I wait about 20 minutes or so with yellow glue, then the squeeze out has solidified to a point were it is easy to remove.....then glue on the next board....I like the LV straight edge because there is no need to panic if some squeeze out gets on it, just wipe off with a wet cloth....no rust issues. This way I get a nice flat panel that only needs a little adjustment with a #80 scraper (I like this tool)....and I keep my sanity.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#8

ok if it is tiney

Bill Tindall

Salt certainly will dissolve in water based adhesives and in the area where the salt dissolves the glue formulation will dramatically change, probably for the worse. If these areas are small compared to the total glue area no harm will be done.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#9

Re: #4: Salty biscuits  and soft glue

TomD

I have used that with sand. I also have used tacks that were pinched off so they had very little protrusions. This method stops skiding, but does not really allow a lot of moving around.

I normally use nothing. I occasionally use biscuits. Biscuits do align wood, but there are several problems They reduce the gluing surface area, which maters on thin boards. If you glue them in, they can telegraph, if you don't glue them in they will do gross alignment. So one option is to glue the biscuits in with a little water, and use real glue on the rest. On thinck stuff like table tops 1.25" and up, you can do whatever you want, they won't show. Keep in mind it is an alignment thing. So do not use one every 3 inches to make your panels stronger. Panels are already strong, but if you use soft glue, the whites and yellows, you can come back a few years later and find everything is together, but the edge of the board is now raised along the glue line. It crept. Biscuits may help with that.

It is questionable how much one should force the materials together. It might be better craftsmanship to let them sit as they like, then either hand plane, or belt sand the boards so that they are a proper panel, yet in a relaxed position. The wood usually wins.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#10

Re: The real truth, it's the clamps

TomD

Arthur Overholtzer, the classical guitar maker of several decades ago fame, had a great tip he used in all his joints. He said to glue them up, but half tighten the clamps. Then after a few minutes, come back, and bottom them out.

If you think about it, let's say you have a 2" joint. The glue in the middle, if the surfaces are well saturated, has to move 1" to the top or bottom to seep out. And the tighter the fit gets, the more pressure it seems to take. But if in the first instance you just snug the joint as loose as you can (he was not a big believer in sprung joints, and there are joint aspect ratios where they are a bad idea), walk away, then come back, the glue has left the building and you can bring it up to clamping pressure, and nothing moves because the grease effect is no longer there.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#12

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

Bob Lang

For me it's butt joints, no splines, biscuits or tongue and groove. Two things are critical to minimize work later on (whether or not it will go through the planer, wide-belt or be fixed with a hand plane.

The first is to make the pieces as perfect as possible-straight, square edges and all the same thickness. The second is to create a good surface to set the parts on. I head to the scrap bin and rip some stuff an inch or so wide. The important thing is they're all the same size. Set those at a right angle to the bench and set the boards to be glued on top of them. That creates a level surface slightly above the bench top, but you can push/pull/use cauls if needed as you set the clamps. The goal is to be able to push the parts together without gaps or humps before breaking out the glue and clamps. I start in the middle and work out to each end.


Bob Lang

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#13

conclusions

Lars Parrington

thanks for all the feedback!

we've got 5 votes against biscuits and one sorta maybe. so, i guess i won't be rushing out to buy a biscuit joiner.

i ended up spending some time fettling my tongue and groove planes today. unfortunately, i don't think they will work well for edge gluing. grooving is fine and easy. making the tongue is a problem. it is hard to keep the shoulders of the tongue at 90 deg to the face of the board. also it is easy to get tearout on the shoulders (which will show in the final joint) if the board has reversing grain, as all of mine do.

2 grooves and a spline is looking like the best non-nothing option, particularly for wavy boards.

I don't think I'll be salting my edge joints anytime soon, though i could certainly see that being useful on other joints. At least on edge joints, my problem tends to be that the glue is too tacky, rather than not enough. As such, i found Bill T's comment pretty interesting, about yellow glue not moving under impact, but slowly yielding under clamp load. I've definitely wailed with a hammer on some misaligned edge joints with nothing to show for it except some nice dents.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#14

Rehearse

Ron Harper

Make sure you have all the clamps, cauls, glue, ...whatever you need very close to hand. Clamp the piece up dry first. Make sure all fits . Correct any problems. Then do the real thing.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#15

Re: Rehearse

don stephan

I like to use clamping cauls to maintain alignment, but I have the boards absolutely as flat and straight as possible and have the bottom cauls off the table so clamps can quickly be applied to them.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#16

Robert Tutsky

A practice I've done for years. Just works.


Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#17

My experience with splined joints

Patrick Gibbons

I made some panels a while back for a project I wanted to be period correct and so I made splined joints to put the boards together. I made the panels oversized to allow cleaning up the ends. The splines did not keep the boards perfectly aligned. Flattening was still necessary after glue up. Without splines I can generally align clamped boards with a dead blow mallet. The splines limited my efforts with the mallet. There were some voids visible in the ends where the splines did not fill the grooves. My skill level had a lot to do with the results. Splined joints were never used in the past for alignment but to provide more glue surface and reinforce the joint. Two years later the joints still look great and there is no swelling. I never did finish the project and the panels are still sitting in my garage. Except for one which I borrowed for another project. The panels were approximately 20" x 24".

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#18

Jack Guzman from Maine

Pipe clamps

Jack Guzman from Maine

When I do a panel glue-up I set up pipe clamps on the bench with the crank overhanging the front edge of the bench. I lay the boards to be glued on the pipes and set the depth of the clamp to close to touching both edges. Then glue. The pipes give a flat surface and alignment is easier after loose clamping by tapping downward. Depending on the wood,I sometimes lay a slice of wax paper on the edge of the pipe to prevent any staining.---Jack

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#19

Re: conclusions

TomD

You can install biscuits without a BJ. I have done it with a small chisel on occasions where the jointer wouldn't get in there. So you can try it out for just the cost of a few biscuits.

I use white glue quite a lot in woodworking. It is perfectly strong enough, it does take longer to dry, but that is better. Since tending towards TiteBind 1 for guitars, it now tends to be the glue in my shop. But I actually prefer white glue, when using that kind of thing. I have used hide glue a lot, but not for jointing boards of any length. White glue does not seize like classic yellow glue, which I don't have much use for, other than the titebond, it has a yellow tinge so I am not sure what camp it falls into. The LV brown glue is also very strong, and dries hard. It is not a terribly grabby glue. I can't remember, but I am not sure one can even do a rubbed joint with it. I can be a problem with certain woods.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#20

Re: Rehearse

TomD

I never rehearse. For one thing, a lot of my joints will only fit together once. I see these shows on TV where guys talk about the perfect fits in their M&T joints, and the tenon looks to fit as tightly as a kid falling down a well. I know this is going to bite me badly some day.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#21

Re: Pipe clamps

Lars Parrington

this is also my usual method. although, i don't tend to get much movement from hammering. maybe i'm clamping too tight at first, or too slow and the glue is too tacky by the time i get around to hammering. are you using yellow glue typically?

i also put some pipe clamps on top to keep from bowing the panel. instead of wax paper, i smear some paste wax on the pipes. it wears off quickly, so i put a fresh coat on before gluing any wood that might stain.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#22

longitudinal caul

Lars Parrington

this might be a crazy idea, but it seems worth a try.

i have an 8ft long roubo workbench. the top is oak, flat, 24" wide, and 3.5" thick. it it oiled, so glue doesn't stick to it. i am thinking of putting the boards to be joined flat on the workbench, and then placing an 8ft long curved caul along the seam(s). the caul is clamped down to each end of the workbench. then clamps are placed to push the joint together. these clamps will have to straddle the caul. so, the caul will need to be thin enough to allow that to happen, or have some slots cut into it.

caveats:

this assumes the boards are the same thickness. i might run a groove along the bottom of the caul so it can straddle the joint and stay out of the squeezeout. however, the squeezout on the workbench side of the joint would be a smeared-out mess, so i think i would actually set everything on some long strips underneath. some clamps along the edges of the workbench might be necessary to keep the panel flat.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#23

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

Curt Putnam

I am pretty much a novice at working with solid wood but I am having some success at gluing up panels for the dovetailed corner blanket chests I have been building. The larger panels are 36 x 24 and the smaller ones are 24 x 24. I'm basically using the techniques described by Bob Lang. Since I subscribe to the belief that glue is stronger than the wood, anything I do to the edge cannot make the joint stronger and will most probably make it weaker. I do believe in careful joint prep so I finish the edge with a fenced jointer (BU from LV)

For this set of chests I am working with 5/4 African Mahogany which was planed to 1" by my supplier so I'm basically working with S3S stock. The planing was a little rough. First I glued up panels to a nominal 12". Only work done was to insure that one side was flat enough to go through the planer. Then they all went through the planer and went to a depth that the Wixey gauge said was 0.90". Then I glued the now very flat 12" panels into 24" panels (as described below.) I'm now in the process of 4 squaring the panels after which I will hand plane the panels to final flat (and finish plane [and sand as needed] the inside surfaces.) Then dovetail and finish the outside surfaces.

I have a pair of old 2 x 4s notched at 6" intervals to hold my bar clamps. These are set crossways to the glueup table. I also made a pair of cauls out of 2 x 3 stock ripped in half and carefully jointed. The faces that face the stock are well glued. I put the bottom half of the cauls in between the bar clamps. The cauls are taller than the clamp bars and serve as the flat surface that Bob Lang mentioned. The glue up starts with brushing on the glue (both edges) and laying the boards on the cauls. Then I snug but do not tighten the clamps. Then I put the tops halves of the cauls on and clamp the heck out of them after making sure that I have the length alignment I want. Then I put F clamps on the ends and tighten those. Then I tighten the bar clamps working from the center out to the ends.

Works for me but YMMV.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#24

Re: Pipe clamps

William Duffield

I used to use sheet plastic to keep the iron pipes from staining the wood, but have "graduated" to short lengths of PVC pipe. I don't lose the PVC, but sometimes when I run out of short clamps, I have to pull one end of the pipe clamp off of a long one and remove one or more sections of PVC so I can get the clamp closed on a narrow glue-up. I'm not totally convinced my "improved" system really works much better.

Re: gluing up panels wider than your planer

#25

Re: Pipe clamps

Marhk

Used to be a thing called a shower or closet rod cover - thin plastic tube with a split so it could be slipped over a shower or closet rod. If cut into sections these work great to cover pipe clamps. I stopped using pipe clamps and don't use these anymore. Not sure they are still available. Try the Borg.