New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Paste Wax Options Question

Posts

Paste Wax Options Question

#1

Robert Tutsky

Paste Wax Options Question

Robert Tutsky

I am planning on making some jewelry boxes and will be applying paste wax buffed out as a final finish. I used to use Briwax but it has an aroma that some find objectionable. What wax is there that has a nice aroma like lavender or just something pleasant.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#2

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Robert,

I can recommend Orange Wax, which is an English product sold by Lee Valley:

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=20086&cat=1,190,42950

No petroleum distillates in it. Carnauba, beeswax, and citrus oils. Leaves a soft citrus smell at the wood surface, but doesn't fill the room with it. I can't compare it with other non-petroleum waxes, because it's the only one I've used.

I rub it out by hand, and it leaves a nice gloss and no fingerprints, on cherry, for example.

Wiley

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#3

Robert Tutsky

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

Robert Tutsky

Hi Wiley,

Thanks for the reply. I have come across Howards wax before and thought it might be a good choice. Actually it might be better than a flowery fragrance anyway. I think I'll try it.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#4

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

TomD

I like that stuff also, but it does have a scent. LV also sells they version of Renaissance wax, such as Krenov used, it is museam approved, and does not affect the product waxed, which can be good or bad.

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=20090&cat=1,190,42950

You can also make small amounts of wax in a baggie in the microwave, combine a safe oil and grated wax in the baggie, a tsp at a time, and heat to melting point, then mush them around. I'm sure it is possible to burn down the whole block doing this, but so far not problems here. I make lip gloss for the girls this way, combining safe ingredients in the baggie.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#5

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

TomD

Actually, some of the more volatile materials will disolve the wax without heat. One just grates the wax up, and adds solvent to the wax. Here is Kirby's recipe

http://books.google.ca/books?id=nPYDAAAAMBAJ&pg=PA61&lpg=PA61&dq=ian+kirby+wax&source=bl&ots=hSBezBrgY6&sig=tL-4nr2cfcorK3aJoB_JnkRCuB4&hl=en&sa=X&ei=pLqqUL9EhYbJAdnkgPgD&ved=0CCAQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=ian%20kirby%20wax&f=false

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#6

Re: Paste Wax Question...Wiley...

George Allchin in Lowell, Mich.

Wiley,

I use alot of cherry in the things that I make. What kind of surface prep prior to wax application? Just rub in the wax till it won't take any more then buff? What kind of protection for the wood is obtained?

Thanks

Work safe,

George

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#7

Robert Tutsky

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

Robert Tutsky

Thanks Tom for the read, quite informative. In the past I have french polished finishes on my boxes then applied Briwax and they looked like jewels but found the process tedious. So i am going to try Hydrocote Resisthane Plus. Just applied it to an old tool as a test and it worked out great. Personally, I didn't mind the Briwax odor but a few folks found it objectionable, so a wax without strong solvents would be my choice. My latest tactic is to wash the wood with a thin shellac cut then apply Hydrocote Resisthane Plus with a final buffed out wax. I was just looking for a wax that had a pleasant fragrance to it. Somewhere I read that there was a wax that had a lavender scent to it. I am interested in trying a product like that but can't find it.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#8

Robert Tutsky

Re: Paste Wax Options Question *LINK*

Robert Tutsky

Wiley,

You might be interested in this... 11 oz tin rather than 5 oz for about the same price.


http://www.ebay.com/itm/Howards-Citrus-Shield-Premium-Paste-Wax-11-oz-/370531890045?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&var=640013936548&hash=item56456bf37d

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#9

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

I've always prefered Trewax over Briwax,Butchers, Bison, Minwax or Johnsons mainly because it is harder and less yellow but also because it has much less of a solvent smell.

Robin

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#10

Robert Tutsky

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

Robert Tutsky

Thanks Robin for your thoughts. Like I mentioned above, I won't use Briewax because of the lingering "stink". I wonder if I use a wax that is neutral in respect of aroma and add a fragrance oil to the mix (maybe just a few drops of a aromatherapy oil, just a thought). Ideas, further thoughts, directions?

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#11

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

Darren Brewster

Does the scent actually linger or is it bad just when applied? I use Minwax paste wax, as it is cheap and available everywhere around here, and it has no lingering scent that my family can detect.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#12

Robert Tutsky

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

Robert Tutsky

Darren,

I used Briewax on a cabinet and any clothes placed in the drawers have a strong unacceptable odor to them. And this is after 12 years. If the odor was pleasant it wouldn't be a problem. I never used the Winmax product. I think that a solvent based wax might be a problem for me. Thinking of adding my own fragrance to the "whatever" wax I intend to use.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#13

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

Bob Hackett

The lavender scented wax would most likely be Goddard`s. Don`t know if they are still around. I have two tins left from my father`s shop.

Most any wax can have it`s scent altered or adjusted by the addition of essential oils. I`d look into making my own if you wanted something really pleasing that customers will associate with you and your work.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#14

My preference

James Watriss

I use Myland's. Briwax is, I'm pretty sure, made with toluene or xylene. It's neurotoxicity, and a sensitivity can develop over time. Gives me wicked headaches.

Myland's uses turpentine, beeswax, and carnauba.

I've also known at least one carver who made his own mix of beeswax, carnauba, and turpentine with a double boiler. Very careful ventilation is a must, obviously, but you can tailor the proportions to your liking.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#16

Re: My preference

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I walked into a friends shop in 1987 while he was using Briwax. One whiff told me it had a nasty solvent and wasn't anything I wanted to fool with. I get nauseous from toluene xylene naphtha and others.

For making paste wax, you can just leave a lump of wax in a closed container with turpentine or mineral spirits for a day or two and it will assume a paste consistency. Shavings of wax dissolve faster. If I were in a hurry, I would melt the wax in hot water (melts considerably below water's boiling point) and then add the solvent away from the heat source.

Robert, hard to believe you put up with this smell for 12 years and are still using the product. I have never put any finish on the inside of a case or a drawer or a box. If I had a drawer that was smelly I would put it in the sun on a hot day.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#17

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

Tony - Memphis

There was a gentleman at WoodCentral that made his own lavendar scented wax. I can't recall his name or any details. You might search the archives. Also saw this:

http://www.amazon.com/Lavender-Wax-oz-Town-Talk/dp/B003QTLBA0

Never tried it. I like the idea though.

Let us know what works out. I made the mistake of using a few pieces of man made materials in my dresser and the inside stinks a bit. I tried shellac to seal it, but that only helped a little. Nothing but natural on the inside next time. Oh, I know you can buy scented liner material too.

Tony

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#18

GI Johnson's . . .

steve mackay

Johnson's Paste Wax will shine and protect ANYTHING in the ARMY inventory to IG Inspection, spit-shine standards. Tough protection and wonderfull looks. When you're done, waste the rest on tools, machines for protection and smooooooooth operation.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#19

The perils of turpentine wax- a wax discussion

Bill Tindall

I make my own wax formulation. I take great pride in drawers that slide effortlessly and to achieve this feat, in addition to proper fitting, I shellac the insides of case pieces as well as the drawers. Then I add a polish of Carnuba wax. The result is a durable near frictionless surface.

In addition to woodwork this Carnuba wax is used on the jointer, table saw and planer. I prepare it by dissolving Carnube flakes in warm solvent(minutes), but if you are patient, a good cold solvent eventually(days) works.

Using one's nose to judge whether something is a hazard, or not, is hardly a reliable way to choose a wax solvent. Nothing you can buy at Home Depot is going to be a meaningful toxicity hazard given the modest and occasional exposure the typical woodworker will experience. All these solvents are used in massive industrial scale where workers are exposed daily with no ill effects.

If one can get past the notion that an occasional whiff of petroleum solvent is a problem the best wax solvent, at least for Carnuba, is xylene. Its advantage, and disadvantage, is that it volatilizes rapidly so a thin film of wax quickly hardens. But it hardens in the can after a year or two and needs to be resolvated on occasion.

For those that wear respirators whilst fueling the car (gasoline is about half xylene and closely related molecules) turpentine could be considered, though there is no reason to believe it is more safe to use as a wax solvent. It was recommended to me as a less volatile solvent so that my cans would not dry out as fast in storage. Big mistake!

Turpentine is a mixture of many chemicals, all of which are less volatile than xylene and some of which are way less volatile. Consequentially, the last bits of turpentine are difficult to be rid of by volatilization, for better or worse.

Indeed it is less volatile than xylene so the storage cans do not dry out in storage, ever!. And If you wax the runners of a cabient and the drawer it doesn't dry out here either, at least not for weeks. Instead of a smoothly sliding drawer the partially dried wax becomes a tacky adhesive. Furthermore, upon exposure to air the turpentine oxidizes to an unpleasant odor (same chemistry as oil going rancid) which gets captured inside the drawer. It took several weeks to recover from the mistake of formulating Carnuba wax in turpentine.

When applied to my metal surfaces it similarly took forever to dry and harden. Eventually threw out this batch and returned to xylene.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#20

Massive industrial scale

James Watriss

I think you'll find that operations on large scales are required to have safety precautions to match: Vent hoods, respirators, etc... And there are definitely workers who develop sensitivities. Don't kid yourself. OSHA regs and MSDS binders were implemented for a reason. And I've worked in a variety of industries that took chemical exposure seriously.

It's not just a smell issue. It's a sensation I get in the back of the mouth before the onset of the inevitable headache.

Once you can get past the pro-industry PR nonsense and talk to people who have dealt with this nonsense, you'll get why I say that this crap is no good.

I still have to use certain chemicals periodically, but I'm a lot more cautious about it than I used to be.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#21

After 12 years it ain't the solvent!

Bill Tindall

You must be smelling some degradation product of the wax, which is not unreasonable. Waxes have the potential to oxidize like oils and generate volatile products.

Trying to predict what a wax may be doing to generate odor years into service will not be possible from information you can glean from the can. Adding something that has what you perceive to be an acceptable odor is unlikely to last for years to cover up the wax smell.

Most people find shellac to provide a pleasant smell in closed objects.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#22

Re: Paste Wax Question...Wiley...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello George,

For cherry and maple, I generally use Jeff Jewitt's method of lightly oil with boiled linseed oil, followed by wiped-on shellac (super blonde, dewaxed flakes). Shellac made up with denatured alcohol straight from the Borg. The shellac is laid on in multiple thin coats, say l-lb cut or a little less. Then de-nibbed and deglossed by rubbing out with 3/0 or 4/0 steel wool and wax. I've used different waxes, usually BriWax clear or Mylands. This is done out of doors and I have not had the problems others cite, but then we have a quite dry climate here. That's for exterior surfaces. For rubbing out, the wax needs a lubricant, so I like a softer wax which self-lubricates. Then as time goes on, use a hard wax like the Orange Wax cited above for maintenance. If a hard wax is used when the piece is made for rubbing out, add a lubricant like mineral spirits.

[Variation which I once used on maple appearance surfaces......initial surface prep. is sanded-in BLO, heavily applied, with multiple sandings (100g, 220g, 320g), until the wood just won't accept any more oil. You pour on the BLO and start sanding it right in; sand til oil has disappeared; wait a couple hours or til next day and do again, this time with next finer sandpaper grade; quit after 320 or 400. This initial prep. fills the pores, and leaves oil about 1/16" deep in the wood. Then apply shellac and rub out with steel wool/wax. This yields an incredibly deep, smooth to touch, with satiny gloss. It's more work than I ever want to do anymore, but does yield a wonderful surface.]

For drawer interiors, I omit the oil, and apply the shellac in less than 1-lb cut, a few coats, right over the dry wood. Then denib with 4/0 steel wool or a very flexible scraper (LV sells these as 'super thin, superhard'--they're great). Nowadays, I will then wax with the Orange Wax or equal. In the past, I have lightly waxed with whatever I had (generally with petroleum distillates), with no ill-effect after airing. Interior drawer and case parts like drawer sides, runners, kickers, everything--are finished with shellac and rubbed-out wax, so there is minimum friction and drawers glide smoothly and evenly, no matter where they're pushed.

Here's Jeff Jewitt's articles on shellac finishing:

http://www.homesteadfinishingproducts.com/htdocs/shellac.htm

http://www.homesteadfinishingproducts.com/htdocs/padshellac2.htm

Caveat 1: I really don't know jack about finishing. Just start with whatever Jeff Jewitt says, or what I pick on online or in books, and make up the parts that aren't explained in the original sources.

Caveat 2: Jeff Jewitt says final prep. before finish is 180-220 sanding. Bill Tindall and most every professional I've ever read swear by this as well (and get great results). I don't do this. On flat surfaces, I finish over a planed surface or filed end-grain. Or sometimes scraped with the super-thin scraper mentioned above. My theory--which I can't defend technically, it's just what appeals to me--is to stay as close as possible to the clarity of the planed or filed or scraped surface. Or maybe I just don't trust my sanding.

Bill Tindall published a few months ago on these pages, some cherry finishing he did, which had excellent clarity and even color. He supplied details of the procedure.

Wiley

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#23

Agree...

John in NM

While some react badly to the toluene odor during application, the whole point of using a very volatile solvent in paste wax is for it to evaporate quickly, leaving just the wax. Most of the toluene in Briwax evaporates in a matter of minutes, and I would be fairly surprised if there were a noticeable solvent odor after a few hours.

Best thing to do is add a little pouch of whatever incense fragrance you prefer - I've never heard of wax with one added (not good wax anyhow). You could even build in a little aroma holder compartment or something.

Personally, I'd use shellac as Bill suggests rather than just wax. But that's just me.

Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#24

Re:Thanks Wiley


Re: Paste Wax Options Question

#25

Re: Massive industrial scale

Chuck Kettler

I appreciate your concern about volatile organic solvents. Fact is that there are employees who are exposed to solvents such as xylene and acetic acid on a daily basis and do not exhibit health issues. A lot depends on the person and their personal sensitivities, but operators, chemists and engineers at chemical production facilities would not be able to do their job if they spent their waking hours worrying about whether they were being exposed to excessive concentrations of solvents. Each and every plant has an industrial hygiene staff and they ensure that the levels in the work place are below the levels of concern for health. Folks who are sensitive quickly migrate their work career to a location that fits their comfort level. Chemophobia provides Good Housekeeping and a host of other magazines with fear mongering and paranoia inducing stories about the hazards of molecules that are buzz words to the public without the courtesy of a review by an industrial hygienist who will sift the facts from fiction. Bottom line, if you don't like a molecule stay away from it.