New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Don't think I can build a Roubo

Posts

Don't think I can build a Roubo

#1

Don't think I can build a Roubo

Tony Wilkins

Watched the Schwarz video on building a Roubo and have a problem. Since I can't lift a full gallon of milk, I really don't think I can manhandle around that big lumber - especially the top.

That means I either give a Nicholson a go or buy a commercially available bench. Of the true woodworking benches out there, I'm not fond of the Lee Valley design and I do like the look of both Lie Nielson benches. Are there other good options out there? Don't want a metal base. It needs to be about 33 inches tall.

So what would you do if you were me?

TIA

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Nicholson who?

Jack Guzman from Maine

When I built my bench I never heard of Roubo or Nicholson.This talk of Roubo benches is fairly new.Why not just design your own style of bench? Something made of fairly light materials. There are a couple good workbench books you can look at for ideas and build your own style.

I built a bench for the local 19th century village museum. I made the top with 2" thick poplar . That bench incorporates a wooden tail vice and leg vice and is nice to work on. That bench is not very heavy but it works fine. I made the legs of 4"x4" red oak so it is stable.

I think people are starting to think they have to stick with known styles for a bench to work but that's not so. A workbench is just a handy surface to do your woodworking on. Build a table you don't mind beating on and go to it.---Jack

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#3

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

The fashion in recent years has been to build a bench that is thick, long and heavy. I built one as well. Well, I did need a new bench, but there was also a lot of vanity in it as well. The fact is, I managed very well on my old bench for nearly two decades. It was a small, spindly thing, but very rigid, and could withstand all the abuse one might level at it. The secret to its rigidity was that it was bolted to the wall.

My old bench was way past its due date, and anything that worked better would have been satisfying. And that is the point: If you have physical limitations that make bench building difficult, then focus on your priority. I think that is woodworking, not bench building. Build a bench that gets you woodworking. Or buy one.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#4

Indeed- work bench considerations

Bill Tindall

Before one chases that latest fashion in a workbench it is well to consider the origins of the fashion being chased. A good assumption is that someone doing woodworking professionally, or a community of woodworkers doing work, is not stupid. I would presume that standing at a bench for 10 hours a day preparing 75 lumber parts for a chest of drawers provides plenty of time to consider improvements to what is at hand. Even if the Master is too conservative to make a change, the Apprentice likely isn't. So over time a functional bench design will have evolved in a region, suited to the work done and materials available. The evolved design will depend on the kind of work the shop did, how they did this work- including personnel, tools and technique - and the material readily at hand.

If you aren't intending to recreate a Roubo shop and wear a funny hat this, or any other, named brand bench may not be the best choice. And, it is presumptuousness for anyone to advocate a bench design without providing the detailed background for how it evolved and was used so that the perspective bench builder can determine how the design fits with their situation.

There are some exceptional Period Furniture makers in our area, including a Cartouche winner. None employ a Roubo bench. Given the variety of benches employed one would conclude that the details of bench design are highly personal, or in cases unimportant, and that building exceptional furniture is not predicated on first building a currently fashionable named brand bench. The bench details may influence the efficiency of what you build, it will not affect your ability to build, if that is the focus.


For example, pictured is the bench used by Mack Headley Sr. in his famous Winchester VA shop. Hundreds of pieces of Period Furniture were built on this bench.

That said, there are those for whom building the bench is the objective, not building furniture with it. The Roubo, with its complex joinery and massive parts, is a worthy challenge to these woodworkers.

The bottom line is to examine why one is building a bench, and what one intends to do with it, before setting out to gather information about what to build. For those wanting to build furniture, an experienced woodworker in the neighborhood (or taking a class) could be a more useful source of advice than any book or magazine. To that end, after working a week at the bench pictured I returned home and modified my bench some to accommodate a feature I found useful. Interestingly, my home bench developed through experience working at it was otherwise nearly identical down to the vise.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#5

My bench is no Roubo, but it works

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

My bench is a solid core door sitting on a plywood box (the box design to have cubbyholes for tool storage), bolted to the wall. The front edge even has hinge mortises in it. Circumstances have not permitted me to make much furniture, but I've planed/shaped/messed with lots of boards on it in the course of the work on this house.

Is it my ideal bench? No, it started out as a temporary bench, until I had time for a better one. But there's a glue splotch on it that my 40-year-old son put there when he was 15 - so it's served me faithfully for more than 25 years now.

Would I like to build another? Sure, some time. But this one will keep serving me for a while yet.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#6

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

roger lance

Tony.....I'm sorry to hear that you're having some physical issues.....but given your honesty about not being able to lift a gallon of milk, perhaps a Roubo is not necessary for you....its massive top and stout legs were intended to withstand the forces of heavy planning and grunt work that were done on benches at its time and place in history.....I suggest that you look at Scott Landis' "The Workbench Book" (should be available at your library).....Landis does not advocate any particular bench style (as does Schwartz).....and there are numerous specially built benches illustrated were their makers were dealing with particular situations (I found these bench solutions to be very interesting)....I think that you will have to define for yourself what kind of woodworking you will be doing and then imagine a bench with features that will accommodate that work.....the LN benches have received very favorable reviews but other solutions are out there. I have to modify what I've said to say that if your heart is set on a Roubo, then that is another matter that might not be satisfied by the purely functional approach....a man should feel good about his bench.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#7

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

Tony Wilkins

Hearts not set on a Roubo. However, I have been influenced by Schwarz' book somewhat. I'll see if I can get the Landis book.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#8

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

TomD

A gallon of milk weighs 8.4 pounds, I am told, and an 8 foot 2x4 weighs 9.6 pounds. If these are the limitations you are working with, you have your work cut out for you.

I own a lot of cast iron machines, there are few of them I can lift, and those that I can, I really should not have lifted. Get yourself an engine crane, or something, and then you can lift anything , and roll it around, depending on your layout. I'm medium strong, and as a result waited far too long to get materials handling stuff in the shop.

I don't really agree with most of the characterization of stuff in the above posts. There is nothing egotistical about big benches, etc... I was shaking my head while reading most of the responses. If anything, Woodworking benches should be heavier that they are. We may not see ourselves as the violent people we are, but we have the same needs for precision, and far greater needs for force than the metal working crowd, and they use metal and granite tables. Sure it takes far more force to cut metals, but it proceeds either by file, or scraper, or some huge machine. You don't see thos guys singing hammers, at least not in the machine shops.

The two methods that require the least energy to make a large bench are using the biggest stick you can find, and moving it with power. This is easy, because you don't have to do much to it. Depends on initial condition, but you just dress it, leave it on it's legs, and you are good to go. The other method is to assemble a top out of very small pieces, plywood is ideal. What most of us used are heavy pieces of wood that get glued up. There are many pieces of wood that need moving, over and over. And every clamp would be beyond your weight limit, every piece of wood also.

This is a weird, and cluttered pic. It shows my bridge crane, that I just finished using to raise a 200 pound sewing machine head to my second floor. So part of the story is materials handling. But the other part is that the right hand side of the crane is supported by a beam that runs along the wall, and is a 5x8 beam made of 3/4" plywood, All the parts were cut out at HD on their saw, except the bulkheads in the beam were sized on my saw. All the parts are light, and even the beam is a little light, though over your limit. It feels solid, is dead straight and flat, does not move, and was quick and easy to make. Vastly better than a door. It is part of a Japanese bench that you can see one of the saw horses for, over by the orange box. You make your base, glue up your parts on the base, and you do not have to move it from that point. Of course you can make it any width you want, and add any vise, crotchets, whatever.


This pic that I got off ebay shows the front beam of a trimaran under construction. The loads on such a structure are immense. Yet look at how simple the design is, and how light the materials are. So if you make a bench out of 3/4 inch ply, with 3/4" ply bulkheads every foot, you have a massive structure. I like to pair up the bulkheads in the area I expect to mortise over, usually the right hand leg, so it is solid right down to the foot.


That said, there was a bench in Fine Woodworking, that got a lot of play a few years back, it was made of 2x lumber, and had some innovative thinking. I forget what it was called... That was easy:

http://www.finewoodworking.com/Workshop/WorkshopArticle.aspx?id=28530

Not too much heavy lumber there. Some good ideas, I would still like more beef, could be lightweight engineered beef.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#9

A little Krenov influence I see.....

Bill Tindall

I dismissed his "saw horse" design until I used them in Finck's shop. The very next thing I did upon getting home was build 4 of them. I foolishly thought they are too flimsy and built the first from 5/4 oak. Their beauty is their agility, which requires light weight. Promptly built a second pair from 3/4" oak. I am surprised these have not gained more popularity. My favorite aspect is that they can be gathered in the crook of the elbow and toted to where they are needed while carrying what may go on them.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#10

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

TomD

I was at Lowes the other day, doing the kid program with my daughter. And it is housed in the lumber bay. Every time I go there, I get depressed about the lumber quality. I remember back when they brought out that article, and for maybe 5 years after, we could go to HD and get lumber that could be worked into a sailboat spar from the 2x rack. These days it is all crap. But that is an ideal opportunity to use the plywood, beams I was talking about.

Also I watched the video. That bench is cool, though one might tire of all the adjustments, if one had to go back and forth between functions, as often happens in work. Love to see the companion video where he explain jointing with a block plane... :)

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#11

Re: A little Krenov influence I see.....

TomD

Yeah, mine are really old, and have been rebuilt a few times. I biscuit jointed them. Something that still bothers me. But at the time I was interested in seeing how strong a BJ could be. They have held up remarkably well. At one point they spent 9 months holding up the main hull of my small trimaran, and me, while I was building it.

Here are the first 6 sheets of ply folded up. It got a lot larger, and the two of us were in there working on it at times. You can see the Krenov saw horse under the deck jig.


Here it is all grown up:


I also used my Japanese hand plane to plane the shears on that hull, and anything else that came up. It went right through fiberglass, plywood and spruce, and never needed to be sharpened the time I was in the shop. Though at the end it was dull, but still cut. Plane cost about 15 bucks to make. One of the reasons I don't buy the Japanese tools are just overpriced stuff for wankers line. Can't think of anything else that would have worked any better.

Here I am tapering the sail batten, this is a lot later, and the plane has been sharpened, maybe the sole has been capped. The planing beam, which is 2x on edge, is now in the top of one of the Krenov uprights with the crosspiece removed, and the other end of the beam is against a wall. The batten is held in place with a wedge and rope system. Worked great.


Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#12

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

Jim Ritter

The bench I think you are remembering is called the "New Fangled Workbench" by John white FWW Nov/Dec 1999. That might be a good alternative. I've often been tempted by that one but realize it might be on the light side for what I do.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#13

Re: Dimensions

TomD

What size did you build? Mine are pretty big, something line 36 x 24 x 18, at a guess. 3/4" maple.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#14

The Landis book

Tony Wilkins

Got the Landis' book (quick to download on Kindle while sitting in a hospital bed). I'm reading it right now (just finished Roubo chapter) and enjoying it.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#15

Re: The Landis book

roger lance

I thought it was a very well written book.....I especially liked a bench a young man built from plywood cut offs that he got at his place of employment.....he laminated those pieces of plywood into a massive top....that bench was so large in would take over my whole shop....lol....enjoy your read....let us know if anything strikes your interest.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#16

Re: Dimensions

Bill Tindall

32 high, 20 wide. I built them like Finck's and they have worked out fine. I used a wedged through tenon on first effort but I carry them all over the place and the changes in humidity loosened this joint. Round two I glued the tenon. I have had hundreds of pounds of lumber on them. I am just amazed how handy they are.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#17

Have you considered carving?

Bill Tindall

This branch of woodworking requires a minimum bench, wood and tools. There are many techniques to pursue- figures, relief, etc. It is popular where I live. We have a club just devoted to carving.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#18

What do you want to make? *LINK*

wilbur

Hi Tony,

Before committing to a bench, given your description of your limitations of being able to lift things, I would think about the type of projects that you want to make. If you can't lift a gallon of milk, my guess that many basic furniture projects are also going to be difficult.

The reason this is worth thinking about is that the project determines the type of bench that works best for you. I built a Roubo, and it works great for me. But it may not be an ideal bench for marquetry or carving, neither of which I foresee doing very much of. If you were to get into instrument making (violins don't weigh very much), you might be looking at a different type of bench altogether.

By the way, you mentioned in an earlier thread that you were thinking about a Nicholson instead of a Roubo. Nicholson workbenches are great, too. The construction is a little more involved than a Roubo. Joinery-wise, a Roubo is probably the easiest to build, but the pieces are quite large. A Nicholson will give you the stability of a Roubo without the weight, but the construction is a little more involved. And this is coming from someone who ruled out a Nicholson when thinking about workbenches because I thought it wouldn't be solid enough for me. Then I saw one in real life, and realized I was completely wrong about that.

One last thing: there are many ways to make a workbench a solid work surface without a ton of mass. I was able to immobilize a temporary workbench that was nothing more than a poplar beam on sawhorses with a 1x4. See the link below.


Who needs a 400 lb. workbench when you have a 1x4?

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#19

Complex joinery??

Ron Harper

I agree with everything you said in your post except the line about complex joinery. This is a hand tool site. If one is ,or aspires to be, a hand tool woodworker, the joinery in a Roubo bench is anything but complex. Outsized? Maybe. Complex? No

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#20

Chris gets a bad rap

Ron Harper

He likes the Roubo and tells you why. BUT he also states clearly that there are other fine benches such as the Nicholson and the Moravian, even the Shaker, if you are not addicted to holdfasts.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#21

Don't let that stop you.

Ron Harper

From what I have read, you probably do not need a Roubo. Lots of good stuff has been built on Workmates.

A solid core door screwed to a frame of 4 x 4s is found as the bench in hundreds of shops. Was my bench for 10 years. Worked very well for me. Used a small vise. Veritas wonder dog, William Duffield's hold downs to hold my work.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#22

Function over fashion

Bob Hackett

Like you I have disabilities that limit the type and scale of work I can do. as a result anything not designed to accommodate those limitations is a compromise at best and a waste of time, money and wood beyond that.

I used a section of an old, used solid core door as a top for rough draft to decide what I really needed to meet the needs of the work I was still capable of. The fact that I got the door for free (dump find) allowed me to modify it without guilt or restraint. It surprised me to realize just how little I really needed in a bench to do the work I was still capable of. The bench top need be only big enough to securely hold the largest scale project you can undertake. The height is dictated by the most comfortable position while working on the tasks needed to move through your projects. Only you know what these parameters are and how best to meet them. Buying a bench from a big name manufacturer is bound to disappoint someone like you and me and I think if you really look at a purchase like that you`ll find it`s based more on vanity rather than necessity. I thought about it and the final conclusion I can to was I would be buying one of these benches to convince myself and my friends that I one day would be returning to full function and really would be needing one in the future. In reality it would have been a needless expenditure that would have limited me rather than help me do the things I was still capable of in a meaningful way.

I`d also like to remind you to join your local WWing club or guild and get more hands, eyes and minds involved in things. The only reason we are limited by our disabilities is because we refuse to reach out to others, communicate our needs and let them help us. Just because we can`t do it all ourselves doesn`t mean it can`t be done and we should abandon the project. It just means we need to seek out and ask for help. Once we let go of total control and learn to delegate and sub contract certain aspects by letting others take care of the things that are beyond our present capabilities all things become possible.

If we do what we are capable of ourselves, starting with design based on a real world needs assessment, we`ll end up with exactly what we need rather than settling for something that looks pretty yet falls short of filling our personal needs and requirements.

Others have made this point here but I`ll jump on the band wagon and remind you once again that the benches in both production facilities and most artisan shops that aren`t looking to impress customers with pictures bear very little resemblance to the pics in the books we all like to read and drool over. The benches that get used the most are usually far more stark and utilitarian. The folks who use them every day to make a living know just what they need to get the job done smoothly, simply and quickly and aren`t interested in complicating things by adding anything more than what is required.

Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#23

Very well said Bob


Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#24

Outstanding!!  A post for the ages.


Re: Don't think I can build a Roubo

#25

Re: Don't let that stop you.

William Duffield

There are a couple of issues with using a solid core door, none of them insurmountable. Im still using mine. I keep telling myself that some day, I'll replace it with three inches of hard maple, but…

It works fine with "my" hold downs, as long as you reinforce the threaded inserts with some epoxy. The door has a tendency to pringle on you, especially if you don't finish on the bottom surface the same as the top. If I'm flattening short boards with a hand plane, I tend to use the top of my SawStop, as it is flatter. If I'm planing long boards, then shims between the low spots on the bench and the board are necessary to get the board flat.

I prefer Gramercy holdfasts to the hold downs, and rarely use the hold downs any more, as the holdfasts are a lot quicker. However, dog holes and holdfast holes tend to wear out very quickly in particle board. I fixed that problem by ripping a 1x6 red oak board (from the Orange Borg) down the middle, gluing the faces together, drilling a row of dog holes in it and gluing and biscuiting it to the edge of the door. It's held up for over sixteen years with no problems. Note that if you want a couple rows of dog holes across the bench to back up your shoulder vise, the door can be sawn apart where you want the dogs, and a row of dogs in oak glued into the door.

I've never had any problems with mounting any vises onto the door.