We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I'm reading through the Landis book and learning a thing or two along the way.
As far as the WWing clubs, I'm now in Manhattan, KS. We hope to be back in Lubbock, TX within a year. The Caveat to attending any sort of club is that right now I'm not driving.
Don't need a pretty bench, just one that functions. Hopefully I'm not missing the point, but I'm thinking about making a smaller (shorter length and slightly less depth) of whatever form I choose.
I can stand some but now for extended periods. I sense that two benches might ultimately be called for. Then begs the question: what operations can be done sitting and what can't really be done sitting? I'm thinking that cutting joinery and chisel work can be done about as well sitting. I'm also thinking that planing is more of a standing operation. So what do you guys think?
I have lower back problems that manifest when I stand for any prolonged period. I've learned to do many things seated, but planing with anything larger than a block plane is pretty much out of the question.
However, having said that, there is a video of a master Japanese craftsman making a jewelry chest showing that he did darn near the whole thing sitting on the floor, including thickness plane the wood. I can't post the link right now, but I will when I get home. You won't believe what he can do without standing.
Much of this can be done by people with physical limitations. Ya just gotta figure it out.
The will hold a lot of material in the downward direction, but if you rack them, they could fail. That said, mine have been great. In the pic above with the plywood beam in it, one can see the typical Japanese version they sometimes use with benches. They are a lot stouter, and are able to take a lot of thrust. There are many versions of the same thing in the US, used in timber framing shops. Timber framing is mostly where the idea of a "Japanese bench" comes from.
You are probably right, but I have a Workmate, Sir, and it is no JFK. Making a bench might be hard for a person of limited lifting capacity, but using one would be great because every ounce of input will get to the workpiece.
A friend of mine made a set of these 26-27 years ago, and I thought they were the flimsiest things I had ever seen. He has a small specialty hardwood lumber yard and handles fairly decent sized slabs, so they have gotten a good workout.
Last summer I noticed that he was still using that same set all this time later, so there must be something pretty good about the design.
One can do a lot of woodworking operations from a seated position. Japanese planes work well from a seated position. the action is a bit like the controlled power one gets from working with a spokesahve, or drawknife. It reminds me of how one should open a router collet, most people will grab the two wrenches and pull them apart, and when the collet gives the hands fly apart, sometimes getting hurt. A better way is to place the two wrenches so they are like the hand brake on a bike, and squeeze with the hand. This encircling action is very powerful. Japanese makers for some scale pieces work from the floor on a low bench. Even in "factories" of several decades ago where Dennis Young apprenticed. He made chairs though, so the bench was a little different. Since Japanese planes are a lot easier to use than western ones, except for the grip, I would recommend them. Alternatively wooden planes with handles, just not metal ones. A Japanese jointer weighs under 2 pounds while my Record, not the heaviest, weighs over 7.
I'm figuring out the top because if I reckon if I get it to function them the base will follow. Sounds reasonable to me at least. Still thinking eventually I'll build a more traditional 'standing' bench for planing.
So here's what I'm thinking are the requirements:
1. the dimensions should be (a) as wide as arms reach by (b) a minimal lean forward to reach for the depth.
2. I'd like the top to be thick enough to use my holdfast so between 2-3 inches (IIRC).
3. dog holes spaced a holdfasts reach along the back and close to each end near the front.
Does it sound like I'm on the right track? Anything you think I should add?
If that works, then I'd need to find out the best base structure to put under it. It would need to have the front open so a lot of the traditional structures won't work.
For Gramercy holdfasts, I have found that 3/4" dogholes in 8/4 (planed to 1-7/8" thick) rock maple (Acer saccarum) work. 3" would be better. Much thicker than 3", and you will want to relieve the holes at the bottom (by drilling up with a 1" diameter bit on the same center as the 3/4" dog hole, until the remaining height of the dog hole is 3". For woods of lesser robustness, you will need thicker wood to keep the dog holes from wearing out. As I mentioned earlier, holdfasts and bench dogs do not work in solid core doors. You don't need to make the whole bench top from 3" rock maple, however, just the parts where you are going to put dog holes and are going to perform heavy duty planing and chopping of dovetails and mortises. For stiffness, you might want to make the back edge thick, as well. The thick part of the bench top, at the front, should be as wide as the deepest reach of your largest hand screw, if you are planning to use hand screws to hold items to the top of the bench. On mine, I just filled in underneath the door, behind the oak dog hole strips, with a screwed and glued strip of tulip poplar to provide the necessary thickness.
Before figuring out where your base is going to go, you also have to locate your vises, especially if they are to be hung on the bottom of the bench top.
One more bit of advise: Locate your vises and your base before you make any final decisions on dog and holdfast hole placement. Holdfasts must clear your substructure. If you get a dog hole, even if you are not going to use a holdfast in it, in the wrong place, stuff will fall into it. If it is blocked by the base or a vise, you will have to fish it out from the top or blow it out with compressed air. It always ends up in my face when I do that. If a dog hole is over a vise mechanism, then screws, brads, small parts, etc., will find it, and will jam up the vise works. Don't install more dog holes than you think you will really need. If you find later that you need one some place you don't have one, you can always drill it later. If it's in a thin part of the top, you can glue a block of maple to the bottom of the top to bring it up to the necessary thickness for a holdfast. I will warn you that some people find minimizing the number of holes in the top of their bench to be an exercise in futility. If you only have one hole, and you drop a small round object anywhere on the bench top, it will roll across the bench, find the hole and drop through into a large pile of shavings.
Re: If I get the top right, the rest will follow? *LINK*
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
It occurs to me that, if you're working sitting*, the shepherd's crook holdfasts could be an issue - you might find your knees hitting the portion of the shaft hanging below the bench. Or it may not; a lot depends on how much lower-body flexibility you've got. If they'd be in the way, the Jorgensen hold-downs might be a possibility; see link below.
As to legs: unless you're bolting the bench to the wall, you need to consider rigidity. One approach that might work resembles a classic office desk, with two boxes, one toward each end, rigid in themselves and firmly fastened to the top. You could/probably should even screw a panel across them at the back to tie the two boxes together. I would think that this would give plenty of rigidity.
Or, you might consider metal legs. These don't get talked about much, because they're not fashionable, but you might be able to get good rigidity with less width than wood.
I should comment on design approaches. I've done plenty of design on the fly over the years. There are times when this works out well; there are times when it sure, sure doesn't. I think you want to have an idea of the design of the legs - not necessarily final, but moderately clear - as part of the thinking, before you start on a top. You don't want to get stuck, waiting for perfection of design; but you don't want to spend more time than necessary back-tracking because you didn't think about something, either.
*I can't remember if you've mentioned working sitting down here, or only on the conversation you've got going over on WoodNet.