Re: Get rid of tablesaw?
TomD
"My TS takes up too much room to suit me, but I'm having a hard time turning the corner on it, too."
My dad had a saw, and it was one of the first tools I mastered. Later a friend set off across the country, and left me a General 10" cabinet saw, which is a big saw. I used it for a while, then I got kicked by it, and a few years later I moved into my current shop, the biggest part of which is a 14x42. A big saw is a big barrier to free flow, so I got rid of it for about 13 years. Recently I bought 2 smaller saws, neither of which is really operational. But eventually I hope to have an Inca saw for certain things, currently it is not properly rigged for dust, etc...
I did not miss the saw when it was gone, much. But I think how much one misses a TS depends on the other tools one has, the type of work one does, and the time pressure one is under.
I do not believe in leveraging a TS to do everything. I think it is not ideal, and can be dangerous. But like any danger, that can also be managed. So when I tossed the TS, I did not notice it was gone because I have a large bandsaw, a planer, and a jointer. I also like to cut joinery by hand, or on other machines in the shop, etc...
Production wise, I missed it for some second side finishing, ripping strips, and mortise work.
Also, I found many things to fill the space with, so ultimately that is not a reason to get rid of a TS. That is a discipline issue, and one will slip as far as one's habits allow.
"Have any of you forsaken your TS? Did you do so because of space considerations?"
Space was a certain part of it, as was safety, dust, and the fact that modern saws in the US and Canada are not designed for the work we do. I would never have tossed a Reinhard.
"Were you just gravitating to hand tools?"
No I was 20 years into hand tools, at least, at that time. i was heavily influenced by Krenov who had power and hand tools, and did not seem to have his work suffer from the split, though it is possible to get seduced by power tools, and to take too many shortcuts.
" If I finally let the saw go, would I also finally be happy?"
The fact is this is now a fad. Somewhere woodworkers are meeting and declaring before the group how many days they are TS free. I think you will be happy if:
- You make a real decision based on your needs;
- These days, getting a saw back in the shop can be 60 bucks. With auction sites. It isn't going to be saw stop equipped, but it might be better than one that was. So given you want space, getting a small saw for the type of work we do may not be a big deal. So you can try it getting rid of the TS without much downside...;
- As discussed it will depend on the work you do, and the other tools you have, and how big a deal this TS is. If it is impossible to move in your shop, and it is always dusty, etc... Then you will be more motivated than some;
- Also, i think one's personality comes into play. People approach work differently. I do hop around. If I got rid of a saw, I would immediately decide I needed to make a stripper canoe. And I did cut a lot of strips on the bandsaw, then finish them out with a Japanese strip plane. Lots of fun. But if you normally gad about with different stuff all the time, I would not get rid of anything that might later assert itself in the scheme of things.
-