New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Get rid of tablesaw?

Posts

Get rid of tablesaw?

#1

Get rid of tablesaw?

Joe shelton

My TS takes up too much room to suit me, but I'm having a hard time turning the corner on it, too. Have any of you forsaken your TS? Did you do so because of space considerations? Were you just gravitating to hand tools? If I finally let the saw go, would I also finally be happy? And is there really a Santa Claus?

Joe

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#2

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

roger lance

Joe....I know this is the Hand Tool forum, but I can not think of any tool that even remotely comes close to having the capability of a tablesaw. Period. All the major tools in my shop (except the lathe) are on mobile bases including my tablesaw which is located in the center of the shop. Often, I have to move the saw to set up for other operations (the shop has limited space)....its not a big deal because of mobile bases. You did not say if your saw is on such a base; but before I parted with my saw, I'd consider a good mobile base and being able to push the saw into a corner until I needed it as a solution to my space problem. I hope that you find true happiness and Santa is good to you this year.....but losing your saw may not be the path to nirvana.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#3

There is a Santa Claus. And, very probably.

James Watriss

I use my TS regularly, so this will be pretty disingenuous for me to argue. But it's worth considering. Chop saws handle cross cuts well. Band saws that are well tuned do ripping very well. Track saws are better for plywood anyway... No in/ out feed, easier to move a saw than a sheet. Routers for dados provide more consistent depth anyway.

I keep my Saw Stop and Delta contractor saw because or three man shop has ample room. If I were to move into a small space, the table saws would go. Even if I was doing sheet good work. Getting my contractor saw choked my basement shop and killed my ability to work. The work table I used on a recent job proved to be much easier than a table saw for sheets, and more versatile.

That's the pro side of getting rid... There are so many available workarounds, and it saves a lot of space.

That said, my out feed table is a full width x 8 feet, and is a great work surface on its own. And the micro-adjuster I made for the vie semester fence allows me to adjust the cut in by .002" increments, which allows me to be really precise when I'm dialing in production work. And, it's paid for.

I won't now, but I might someday.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#4

I did

Ron Harper

Table saw jointer and a whole bunch of routers. I have not for one second regretted it.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#5

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

JimG

I did also. I got a festool saw and work table, a powermatic bandsaw and dewalt sliding miter saw. I sometimes miss my TS, but I honestly cannot come up with a good reason why. I did it for space, as I really wanted a bandsaw for resawing, but just did not have the space for both.

JimG

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#6

seems like an easy decision

Bill Tindall

the table saw takes the place of an apprentice to saw stuff for you. Without the table saw, or apprentice, you will not be able to make nearly as much stuff. Families, friends and charities will have less stuff that you have made. I would quite woodworking if I could not have a table saw and jointer and at least access to a planer.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#7

Personal preference

Ron Harper

Tony Konovaloff, Roy Underhill, Peter Follansbee, Adam Cherubini, and a host of others seem to do OK without them.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#8

Re: Personal preference

TomD

", Roy Underhill, Peter Follansbee, Adam Cherubini, and a host of others seem to do OK without them."

Fair point, but isn't that a bit like saying 22" arms, who really needs them? Lance Armstrong, etc... Do fine without them. Those guys you mention couldn't move wood through a shop if their life depended on it. In fact recent research shows (or perhaps we always new?) that the cabinet shops of yore had access to sawn boards in relevant to cabinetmaking sizes, at local establishments the way we have crap on a rack for framing, at the local reno store.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#9

Tom!!

Ron Harper

I ain't interested in "movin wood through a shop" . I did not think this was a trade site. I work wood because i love it. I do NOT enjoy shoving sticks through machines. My preference. Yours is apparently not the same. OK by me. Come see me. I'll buy you your choice of beverage and we will talk about wood.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#10

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

TomD

"My TS takes up too much room to suit me, but I'm having a hard time turning the corner on it, too."

My dad had a saw, and it was one of the first tools I mastered. Later a friend set off across the country, and left me a General 10" cabinet saw, which is a big saw. I used it for a while, then I got kicked by it, and a few years later I moved into my current shop, the biggest part of which is a 14x42. A big saw is a big barrier to free flow, so I got rid of it for about 13 years. Recently I bought 2 smaller saws, neither of which is really operational. But eventually I hope to have an Inca saw for certain things, currently it is not properly rigged for dust, etc...

I did not miss the saw when it was gone, much. But I think how much one misses a TS depends on the other tools one has, the type of work one does, and the time pressure one is under.

I do not believe in leveraging a TS to do everything. I think it is not ideal, and can be dangerous. But like any danger, that can also be managed. So when I tossed the TS, I did not notice it was gone because I have a large bandsaw, a planer, and a jointer. I also like to cut joinery by hand, or on other machines in the shop, etc...

Production wise, I missed it for some second side finishing, ripping strips, and mortise work.

Also, I found many things to fill the space with, so ultimately that is not a reason to get rid of a TS. That is a discipline issue, and one will slip as far as one's habits allow.

"Have any of you forsaken your TS? Did you do so because of space considerations?"

Space was a certain part of it, as was safety, dust, and the fact that modern saws in the US and Canada are not designed for the work we do. I would never have tossed a Reinhard.

"Were you just gravitating to hand tools?"

No I was 20 years into hand tools, at least, at that time. i was heavily influenced by Krenov who had power and hand tools, and did not seem to have his work suffer from the split, though it is possible to get seduced by power tools, and to take too many shortcuts.

" If I finally let the saw go, would I also finally be happy?"

The fact is this is now a fad. Somewhere woodworkers are meeting and declaring before the group how many days they are TS free. I think you will be happy if:

- You make a real decision based on your needs;

- These days, getting a saw back in the shop can be 60 bucks. With auction sites. It isn't going to be saw stop equipped, but it might be better than one that was. So given you want space, getting a small saw for the type of work we do may not be a big deal. So you can try it getting rid of the TS without much downside...;

- As discussed it will depend on the work you do, and the other tools you have, and how big a deal this TS is. If it is impossible to move in your shop, and it is always dusty, etc... Then you will be more motivated than some;

- Also, i think one's personality comes into play. People approach work differently. I do hop around. If I got rid of a saw, I would immediately decide I needed to make a stripper canoe. And I did cut a lot of strips on the bandsaw, then finish them out with a Japanese strip plane. Lots of fun. But if you normally gad about with different stuff all the time, I would not get rid of anything that might later assert itself in the scheme of things.

-

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#11

Got rid of mine, sort of...

Denis Chenard in Ottawa

Had a contractor's saw that I attached a homemade outfeed table to. Originally I had a 50" capacity homemade Biesemeier fence clone installed. Well, it basically choked my less than 400 sf basement shop (with an irregular floor plan, which made things worse). So I sold it.

But I couldn't see myself without a tablesaw, for 4/4 stock and sheet goods it felt indispensable to me. Following the reviews at the time, I bought a Ridgid shop site saw. It has sufficient power for the aforementioned tasks, but it doesn't run as smoothly as a cast iron saw (that's to be expected), and the folding stand precludes installing an outfeed table. But even that saw seemed to find a way to be in my way in the shop, even when folded, so I banished it to the garage (to my wife's great pleasure, NOT!).

So I now have to go out in the garage for any sheet goods cutting, as I don't want to dull my bandsaw blades on man-made material. I found out over time that in order to have a straight cut on the bandsaw I need to keep the feed rate slow, so even 4/4 stock is brought to the garage if there's more than one or two cuts to make.

My chop saw is also in the garage for the same reasons. My wife is not impressed to say the least, she would very much like to be able to park her car in the garage, especially in the winter (for some reason she does not like brushing the snow off the car, can't get my head around that one...).

But now that I've established a foothold/claim in the garage/shop (she will kill me if she ever reads this), a fellow from the local WW association had a contractor's saw for sale, which came with a mobile base, extension table, Forrest WW II blade, and an Excalibur overhead arm for too good a deal to skip. Guess what I did?

Good thing we don't have a dog, otherwise I would't have slept in the house for a long time :D

Seriously, I wouldn't want to use quality hand tools on man-made materials. Even if I prefer using hand tools and solid wood, I can't see myself foregoing the use of plywood, MDF, etc. for the rest of my life. For those you need a tablesaw and a carbide blade.

I would recommend, if space is really at a premium in your situation, to get one of those small job-site saws (DeWalt and Ridgid both sell such a saw, haven't tried either, they didn't exist when I bought my saw, check the specs), with a couple roller stands you'd still be able to cut sheet goods on occasion yet wouldn't permanently use space in your shop.

A track saw would be a good alternative, I think, but I haven't used one yet so I can't comment on those.

HTH,

DC

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#12

Never...

John in NM

Power tools are just too useful to me. If I didn't have the space for them, I'd find a way to get some more space :D

Using a well tuned power tool, especially a vintage one, is as pleasant to me as using a well tuned hand tool.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#13

I got rid of mine..

david weaver

I got rid of mine and kept a bandsaw instead. It is so much more versatile and nicer to use in general, more intuitive.

The only stuff that I had where the BS won't work would be large sheet goods and crosscuts, but I have a makita 6600 for those. I try not to use sheet goods, anyway, unless someone is asking me to make something cheap (I try to avoid that, too).

If I get roped into making new kitchen cabinets for our kitchen in the next two years, the makita saw will do all of the sheet work fine, and the BS will do all of the sticking just fine.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#14

the point apparently was missed

Bill Tindall

People in 1720 did without table saws too, quite spectacularly. There is no denying one can, with sufficient skill and time, do without any power tools. However, the indisputable fact is that power tools will enable a woodworker to build more stuff per unit of time spent building. Hence, the power tool decision is easy to make. Is the primary objective to make stuff, or not.

There is a second productivity benefit. Some of the power tool operations are easier to learn. So, while someone is learning to saw, joint and surface plane with hand tools, the power tool user is learning other building skills- joinery, inlay, carving, finishing, veneering, etc.

For example: The chest of drawers I am building has 83 parts(I just counted them), and that is counting a glued up panel as one part! That is 83 pieces of lumber to manufacture to some specified size and thickness. Then add the time to do the joinery, inlay, finishing, etc. and let me know how long it might take the hand tool enthusiast to complete it working after their day job and weekends.

All the cabinetry, trim, many doors, and essentially all the furniture in our house, and to a lesser extent in daughters homes, I have made. Now I am working on granddaughter furniture. Power tools supplemented with hand tools made it possible.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#15

Re: the point apparently was missed

Darren Brewster

Is the primary objective to make stuff, or not.


I can't speak for anyone else, but that is definitely not my primary objective. Journey not destination and all that. As long as I have fun mastering skills while working up a little sweat I'm happy. Completing projects is an important, but secondary objective.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#16

No Sir .. I did NOT miss the point.

Ron Harper

We are different. Your last couple of posts are full of production language. I go to the shop to escape that sort of bondage. I am much more interested in using my hands and a few tools to make something others might enjoy. I am not in any particular hurry, unless one of the ladies in my life is tapping her toe at the shop door. I could not agree more with Tony Konovaloff

"What I make is for my client(whoever gets the piece). How I make it is for me.

I do not for a second suggest or believe that my approach is in any manner superior to yours. It is just me.

Ron

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#17

I guess its just another case of.....

roger lance

different strokes for different folks.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#18

Mine's gone

Paul M.

I did a happy dance when someone came to buy it off of me. I bought a Festool circular saw with a long guide for plywood work for cabinetry, and I feel much safer using that approach with the plunge saw. But I have not missed that awful tablesaw yet. It's been about 2 years now.

I have a couple of small bandsaws that get a good workout regularly, but I've ditched the tablesaw. I know too many people that have lost bits of themselves in tablesaws and I'm not keen to join them.

My power planer is also going away soon. I just built a workbench, and never used the power planer once. I was keeping it around just for help on the workbench, and then I never bothered to use it. I did all of the flattening with handplanes instead. So the planer is just another fear-inducing monster that must go.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#19

Re: Tom!!

TomD

I divide stuff into production and say, craft. If a person wants to have an interesting craft, which by the way can be power or hand tools, there are small scale ways of having a lot of interesting time in the shop. But then let's say the wife wants a new kitchen, or you want to build a 46 foot boat and cruise the world. You have to move wood through the shop or you will never finish. So even the most devoted user of slow woodworkig techniques can find themselves moving the wood. I accept no compromise in my craft work, but when the family wants a TV unit, and you know the TV are going to go through huge changes over 10 years, I am not going to go to the woods with a hand saw, and start harvesting wood...

2 years ago I got the opportunity to get a lot of beech to make planes. This is to make molding planes, and other planes. It is hard to think of a more hand tooly kind of objective. Over the years I have both hand ripped, and hewn large timbers. None of this is new to me. I've got to move that stuff through the shop. I'm talking about getting the wood to the condition it is when most people pick it up at the store.

I also think there are a lot of newbies out there. They should take the time to do everything by hand, and everything by other means, if they like. But there isn't much that is novel or new to me at this stage. Been at this over 40 years. It's cool to see people who are really turned on and digging in, for the first time.

Gotta consider though, that most of the hand tool icons who write and stuff, do not make their living at this stuff, St Roy is a communicator, writer, wood school owner, historical interpreter, communications consultant, and performer. He isn't a woodworker, even or particularly at the 18th century level. So moving wood through the shop whether with electricity of slave labour is not his thing.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#20

Re: Tom!!

Ron Harper

There are several guys who do this professionally with hand tools,because they want to. Do they lose a little time? Yes, but for some of them, not as much as you think. It is a choice they have made. If you are making one oiece at a time, the time advantage is way overstated, and there are many offsetting compensations. It is not a job for me. For a guy who has to "move wood through the shop" it is a job , paid or not.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#21

Re: Trade site

TomD

As FK says: "hand work is production".

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#22

Re: No Sir .. I did NOT miss the point.

TomD

"We are different. Your last couple of posts are full of production language. I go to the shop to escape that sort of bondage. I am much more interested in using my hands and a few tools to make something others might enjoy. I am not in any particular hurry, unless one of the ladies in my life is tapping her toe at the shop door"

Isn't that the point? What do you do then. I have suggested in flip side threads, that guys who want to deal with limited means, could just consider it a hobby, and never undertake the honey-do, stuff, or other big projects. Nobody has ever said at those times that was a good idea. So I think a lot of people keep their options open. If one suggests keeping the saw option open, people jump in and say they just work wood for pleasure, but if you suggest they then configure their activities for that, in the flip side posts, that does not sell either. These twin draws are what the guy deciding to toss the table saw may want to consider.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#23

Re: Got rid of mine, sort of...

TomD

In my case, living 15 years without one, or whatever, the thing that got me wanting one was working at my dad's where that is about the only thing we have. Then I did not resent it, and I saw how useful it is. That said, it is not as useful at my place, because I have everything most don't, and my hand tools are far better set up also.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#24

Another consideration...

John in NM

I became a much, much better woodworker after just a couple years of 40 hour weeks doing it. Production work was tedious and often less than challenging, but the practice was indispensable for both efficient problem solving, recovering from mistakes, and being able to estimate what is important and what is not.

I often perform one off tasks by hand rather than doing the machine set up to do the same. The only reason I know that the time is a wash is that I've done it both ways. I can think of no cases when I've skipped the TS like this though, it is simply too fast and easy.

Re: Get rid of tablesaw?

#25

Re: Tom!!

TomD

"There are several guys who do this professionally with hand tools,because they want to."

That is exception that proves the rule territory. And they say they do it without power tools. Do they have a car, do they harvest their own wood? Do they buy ready made tools. I started with my dad's saw, and made my own bench and planes, etc... pretty much with nothing. Someone in the 19th century would have had it easier, because their shop would have been fully equipped and they would have had people that they could at least observe working. Things have gotten pretty swell in the last 14 years, but home workshop folks are still biting off quite a lot. The most important power tool these days is the computer. Try all this stuff without that. It was a lot more "hands on" in the 70s.

" Do they lose a little time? Yes, but for some of them, not as much as you think."

Actually I have a pretty good idea. The reality is that hundreds of years ago, they had mill, they had suppliers that pre sawed, they had apprentices. Some jobs will be faster by hand, other will be very slow.

" It is a choice they have made. If you are making one oiece at a time, the time advantage is way overstated, and there are many offsetting compensations."

I think that is true for stuff like joinery, but for getting the wood out, it is slow back breaking work. Good exercise when one is in the mood.

" It is not a job for me. For a guy who has to "move wood through the shop" it is a job , paid or not. "

We all have parts we like more than others. But taking a 1/4 inch of wood off all the pieces to make a big table by hand, is a job also.