New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Why Bismarck?

Posts

Why Bismarck?

#1

Why Bismarck?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have been having a little fun with these Inset planes by Lee Valley. It occurred to me to ask when horned planes began being referred to as Bismarcks. This appears to be the term used in Europe, and the link to a teutonic origin (although the one pictured is Danish). Bismarck as in Otto von or as in the battleship, or is there so other not-so-obvious explanation?



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why Bismarck?

#2

Re: Why Bismarck?

david weaver

Probably not the drink or the donut, nor the city in North Dakota.

Probably not the razor:

http://www.straightrazordesigns.com/dovo-straight-razors/professionally-sharpened-dovo-bismarck-pearl-6-8

And the razor is probably not named after the tool.

Interesting that a company in Solingen would be using the name, but you'd assume maybe that it was named after otto von bismarck?

Maybe not, it is a chubby razor as far as new-make straight razors go.

Re: Why Bismarck?

#3

Re: Why Bismarck?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

Those cut throats reminded me about stropping (since you often mention them together). I went back to stropping (after a 13000 waterstone) today, and I was amazed how sharp I got my chisels. Just plain horse butt.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why Bismarck?

#4

Re: the plain leather...

david weaver

... does wonderful things when it's clean. As holtzapffel says in his book, I agree (especially for razors where the function of the strop is critical to a quick smooth shave), in as much as a strop is harder, it is more useful.

I haven't used green stuff on leather in a while, I think bare leather itself, when clean, does a nicer job and leaves a keener edge, unless the degree of finish is not good (i.e., if you don't have a good finish stone, it helps, if you do, it doesn't if it's used on something soft, it just instead wears the edge in the same shape that woodworking wear does).

I can't ever keep leather clean in my shop, though, some little metal bits or dirt always end up in it.

The 13k is really a nice stone for a fine edge, it doesn't need a strop, but coming off of it and going to good bare clean horse leather makes a cosmic edge for paring chisels.

Every gentleman woodworker should purchase a couple of horse butt shells for use in various places around the shop. I believe I paid about $25 for 3 square feet of it, which has enough smooth stuff for 3 long hanging razor strops and a whole bunch of other stuff where it's a little wavy. Tools don't mind that waviness.

And to credit warren once more, there is a difference in how certain stones prepare for the strop, and a consideration for the hardness and alloy of the metal used. Arkansas stones and other types that leave wide flat grooves step up sharpness a large amount on a strop. Steels that tend to have a more persistent wire edge due to less than super hardness (like continental and US vintage tools) or alloy (chromium oxide) also benefit a lot for fine edges, and stuff like white #1 to super hard levels benefits a little less, probably because hitachi white does such a good job to begin with w.r.t. not forming much of a wire edge in medium and finer stones.

That's enough strop and razor talk (though I did shave with a bismarck identical to the one in that picture today. A quick smooth shave, stropped of course on a clean hanging horse butt strop).

Re: Why Bismarck?

#5

Re: Back to the plane..

david weaver

The question of "why a bismarck" was enough to get me to look around and try to find out, certainly someone is responsible for it.

It looks like the question has been asked several times and not given a direct answer. The best I could figure out was that the name was given to the planes by the English, and not by continental woodworkers, but that's only repeating what someone else said.

Whether it applies only to scrubs, or also to all continental planes doesn't seem clear from earlier discussions.

I have a couple of chinese bismarcks. I like them, they're comfortable.

Re: Why Bismarck?

#6

Re: Back to the plane..

TomD

I could see it being an English put down. Very common if one tries to be different. "look at Bismark over there with his funny plane". But that would not explain European use, as easily. Maybe something about the rampant handle.

Re: Why Bismarck?

#7

Re: Why Bismarck?

roger lance

Derek....the shape of that handle reminds me of the bow of a Viking ship or a rhino horn....but what would be the "bismarck" connection to that if anything??

Re: Why Bismarck?

#9

Re: Why Bismarck?

roger lance

Mess with a Viking....You might get the horns!!

Re: Why Bismarck?

#10

Re: Back to the plane..

david weaver

I haven't seen a group as quick to label other cultures as the old English.

Of course, that's largely in the past, as an English friend of mine put it, cultural put-downs and other less flattering things are a "national sport" in England. (he hasn't lived in England now for 30 years, and some of our younger English and Scottish friends, who visit about twice a year, seem to have no exposure to any such thing. PC reaches everywhere). Not that we were exempt from it in the US, either.

However despite the apparent decline in culturally-attached names, i could easily believe that someone English decided to label a german origin good with an associated german name to have it stick and then be repeated.

I recognize that plausible and factual quite often don't have any mutual intersection, though, and that believing they do starts a lot of old wives' tales.

That's still my best answer for a bet at Lloyds, though, the term originated in England and not from the Continent.

Re: Why Bismarck?

#11

Inset plane . . .

steve mackay

I saw those in the latest rag. Are they pretty "robust" ? Fairly "adaptable" ? I can imagine more than a couple applications I'd use them for.

That Horny Toad IS pretty cool !

Re: Why Bismarck?

#12

Re: Inset plane . . .

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

I've been having a bit of fun making planes with the Inset planes. However I do think that they have potential, especially for small detail areas, such as in luthier work (although I have no experience in that department). They are small enough to get into inside curves, such as when breaking edges. They are robust enough to take seriously.

I made a few other fun planes earlier on ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why Bismarck?

#13

Thank you . . .

steve mackay

You hit it on the head ! Well, actually not "luthier" but more "model & pattern". They do indeed tickle the imagination. Going to have to get a couple to play with. Would you say they could be usefull "as is" also ? Could you hang onto it like an Ibex ?

Re: Why Bismarck?

#14

Re: Inset plane . . .

William Duffield

Hey, Derek,

You have Rob's ear. Maybe you could suggest to him that he make a mini-inset plane, a bit smaller, 14 mm wide by 30.5 mm long. It would vastly simplify installation in any arbitrary block of wood.

Re: Why Bismarck?

#15

Re: Inset plane . . .

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William

I have no doubt that Rob has already read your comment. The question is, why do you request those measurements? Tell us more.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why Bismarck?

#16

Re: Inset plane . . .

William Duffield

That was a puzzle, mostly tongue-in-cheek.

That happens to be the size of the largest mortise that the Festool XL DF 700 (Domizilla) cuts. ;)

Re: Why Bismarck?

#18

Re: What is a Festool XL DF 700 (Domizilla)? 

William Duffield

It's a German hand-held power tool for doing mortise and tenon joinery. It cuts mortises for loose tenons. Rob carries some useful attachments for it.

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=69785&cat=51&ap=2

Here's Festool's intro video, but if you look for Half Inch Shy's blog and videos you'll find more informative info and less hype.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gOIT0tNNaBc

Re: Why Bismarck?

#19

Jesper, Denmark

Re:Never heard a plane called that and....

Jesper, Denmark

The Viking helmet with horns is a pure Hollywood invention. Viking helmets did not have horns. Think about it! One hit with a stick, and the helmet is gone.

As for the graphic resemblance, I see much more likeness to an old fashioned choo-choo train locomotive than anything related to Otto von Bismarck.

Re: Why Bismarck?

#20

Re: Thank you . . .

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

The inset plane is quite substantial, easy to hold, and is a serious plane in spite of its elfin appearance.

What I would like to see is a curved sole version or, better, a plane with a thicker sole so that one may grind in the curvature of choice.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why Bismarck?

#21

Re: What is a Festool XL DF 700 (Domizilla)? 

William Duffield

Of course, my suggestion was intended to be humorous. The insignificant advantages of cutting the recess for a tiny inset plane in one fell swoop are far outweighed by the absurdities of the economics. The tool itself sells for $1200 and the 14 mm cutter is another $56. Someone doing the very small scale, intricate work for which a violin plane is appropriate is most probably not going to be building the large architectural projects that would support the ownership of the Domino. Therefore, they wouldn't sell very many inset planes relying on the quick mortising of the Domino as an advantage. Hopefully, Rob found it funny, and hasn't started production on a complete line of inset planes to fit all the sizes of Dominos. ;) I'm sure he has something much more absurd in the works for an early April introduction.

The examples you have built, OTOH, are not a joke. They are beautiful, and I'm sure you will find them useful.

Re: Why Bismarck?

#22

Re: What is a Festool XL DF 700 (Domizilla)? 

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William

It is really I who should apologise to you as I was pulling your leg about the Domino. I do know what one is (although I do not own one).

Thanks for your kind words about the small planes. They were fun but a lot harder to do than full-sized versions, which I shall stick to in future. My eyes are not what they used to be (and neither is a lot of the rest of me :\ ).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Why Bismarck?

#23

I'd bet on that one too...

John in NM

Best way to test it of course, is to find out if that style is called a Bismark in Germany too :D :D :D I'm going to further the bet that they are not called that in Germany. I would also expect some pretty perplexed replies from actual Germans if one attempted to field such a question.

Can't help there, I don't know any German woodworkers, only astronomers.

Re: Why Bismarck?

#24

Re: What is a Festool XL DF 700 (Domizilla)? 

William Duffield

I figured you probably knew what one is. No apology needed. The question needed to be asked, and I was expecting someone to ask it, for the enlightenment of the general WoodCentral audience. Those among us who use mostly hand tools might not be familiar with this new technology.

I have owned the smaller DF 500 Domino for quite a while and use it constantly. I bought it as soon after it was introduced as I could afford it. I'm still kind of debating whether to get the XL Domino, but have just about convinced myself that the scale of projects that would make that monster practical are mostly beyond the capabilities of this old geezer's rapidly deteriorating carcass. My eyes require reading glasses in three different strengths, and intense work lights to attempt to see the details of what I'm building, but the 4x20 mm. tenon is still more my size.

I know two guys personally who own both models. The Domizilla is already earning it's keep in their businesses.

Re: Why Bismarck?

#25

Re: German Pancakes

david weaver

There are lots of things called "german" that seem to not exist in germany. In this case with a plane name, it might be the name even though we know continental planes exist there in huge numbers.

One of the documentaries put together by our PBS station was interviewing a chef about german pancakes that he was making. The people interviewed at a restaurant gushed about the "german pancakes" also.

And then one of the interviewees said they brought Germans to the restaurant, and they said "we have never seen pancakes like those". It seems they were only german pancakes outside of germany. otherwise, to germans, they were probably "oregon pancakes".

Then the chef said "They probably have nothing to do with germany, I don't know why we call them that".

Until they admitted that in the show, my wife (who has a dutchy background - PA dutch that is) and I (with a central PA german and german-swiss background) were both looking at the pancakes saying "that doesn't look very german to me". As opposed to potato pancakes - which would never fly in a restaurant intended pretentious people, as the one on the special was.

The german neighborhoods/areas in PA are (or were, the last generation seems to have split them apart finally) so insular that when you go to funerals, some of the people still speak only a PA german dialect (not amish people, and not mennonites)...the entire time. Despite the fact that they've been in the US for over 250 years. If we haven't seen something "german", it's probably because it's either new to germany or not german at all.