New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

pin less leg vise *LINK*

Posts

pin less leg vise *LINK*

#1

pin less leg vise *LINK*

Lars Parrington

I'm finishing up a roubo build and thinking of trying to make something similar to this pinless leg vise that Richard Maguire posted about. It seems like it might be a bit easier to fabricate then a St. Peter's cross or chain-type pinless vise. I have some old f-clamps with smooth (non-serrated) bars that seem to work along the same principle.

Here's what I'm thinking: The parellel guide at the bottom of the chop would be replaced by a stout steel bar (round or maybe rectangular cross section). That bar would pass through a bushing set into the leg. It seems like the key features are a bushing with a length approximately equal to the width of the bar (too long and it wouldn't bind). The other key feature might be micro-adjustability of the angle of the bar, allowing the bar to be set just off from perpindicular to the chop so the shaft binds in the bushing when the chop is parallel to the leg.

Anyone have any insight or seen something similar in real life? It seems like a pretty neat idea. I'm just not sure it would be great in practise.


http://www.theenglishwoodworker.com/?p=206

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#2

Re: pin less leg vise

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Lars

My understanding, from reading Richard's descriptions, is that his bar acts like a large hold down. That is, as the bar angles slightly in the hole, it wedges itself.

It seems easy enough to try out. Richard has a very good reputation.

There are other options.

Benchcrafted have just released a St Peter's Cross. This gets glowing praise from Chris Schwarz.

I have no experience with these, but I have installed the AYS Leg Vise Chain Adjuster. My review is here:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/AYSLegViseChainAdjuster.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#3

Re: pin less leg vise

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have used a leg vise for 35 years. I wonder why you would want a vise like in the video. When the fellow tightens the vise onto a block of wood there is a bit of slop in the vise so that the bottom of the vise becomes actually closer to the bench than the top of the vise. This is just the opposite of what is wanted. It means that a board in Maquire's vise will be clamped tighter towards the screw than at the top of the vise.

With a traditional vise, we put the pin so that the bottom is farther out than the top. This insures that the tightest gripping is at the top of the vise, where it is most helpful. When we are sawing tenons, as an example, the gripping is right at the top, nearest to where we are sawing. If the piece is gripped down near the screw, it is much less secure.

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#4

Re: pin less leg vise

Lars Parrington

Warren, that is my main worry with this vise concept. I think Richard tries to explain a way to work around it, although I agree his video is not very convincing. As I see it, the idea is to design in a slight angle between the bar and the chop, so that the two are not quite perpendicular. The bushing will try to hold the bar horizontal, and so this slight angle would tilt the chop to be closer to the bench at the top then the bottom. That is when the vise is free. When clamping pressure is applied, the chop would be pulled closer to parallel with the leg, forcing the bar to angle up, and causing it to bind in the bushing.

I'm not convinced that this will actually work in practise. For one thing the magnitude of the slight angle would be limited by the amount of play in the threads between the vise screw and nut.

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#5

Re: pin less leg vise

Lars Parrington

Thanks Derek. The chain vise is a clever idea. I like that it is easy to adjust the slop in the mechanism, which seems important in any of these designs in order to keep the chop parallel to the leg when it is clamping.

It seems maybe a bit more difficult to fabricate then the other two, so I don't think I'll end up using it. I'll be fabricating this myself, so I think I'll either go with Maguire's idea or make a St. Peter's cross.

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#6

Re: pin less leg vise

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Lars, did you watch Richard's video?

He appears to have a very functional leg vise, notwithstanding the slight off-perpendicular setting of the chop.

The practice seems to outweigh the theory.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#7

Overcoming mechanical adaptations

Bob Hackett

One of the things you seem to be worried about is either bending over/crouching down to move a pin or adjusting a lower link with your foot.

think for a minute about what you may be sacrificing in order to gain a bit of convenience.

Two things that come to mind are; A- you lose the flexibility to adjust the vise exactly the way you want it. These "labor saving" devices lure and then chain you into working the way they work best rather than what works best for you and, B- one of the very admirable things about the old way of doing this is that it takes wear and the need to adjust for it into account, plans for it actually. What are your modifications going to do besides slip or jam when they begin to wear. Beyond that, how do you plan to rebuild/ repair/refurbish them once the wear makes the diminished level of function intolerable?

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#8

Indeed

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Coming up with alternatives to the strut-and-pin on a leg vise is quite a fashion now. I've been watching this development, bemused. If you have a bad hip or spine that makes reaching down to move the pin painful, then it might be worth looking at an alternative; although, for such a case, I think I'd encourage looking at an L-shaped Wilton vise or the like.

I used my grandfather's leg vise for years with the strut-and-pin, and never found it an issue. Indeed, on my list is to get it back in service; my existing face vise is not terribly good, even though it's a Name Brand. The design's all wrong.

And, when I do put it back in service, I'll be using a strut-and-pin, although I may make the strut from an old bar clamp in the parts bin that's bent and missing its foot, rather than from hardwood (the traditional material).

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#9

Re: Overcoming mechanical adaptations

Lars Parrington

Good advise. I will definitely keep reliability in mind as i build this thing. Actually I'm kind of ready to be done with this workbench project, so building a standard (with pin) vise for now may be a good option. I could always graft on a chain or cross system later.

Bob, would you elaborate on what you meant by "adjusting a lower link with your foot"? I'm only familiar with the vise design that involves moving a pin by hand.

Derek, when you upgraded your vise to the chain system, you made a new parallel guide without holes. Was there some reason the original, holey parallel guide wouldn't work with the chain system?

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#10

Downsides of the pin are overrated

wilbur

Warren's analysis is perfect.

I find that the pin in my leg vise sits in one spot the vast majority of the time. Because there is a little slack in the mechanism, I can easily clamp boards form 1/2" to 1" thick without moving the pin at all. There should be no surprise to this. The mechanics of a leg vise are pretty much identical to a wooden screw clamp, if the final tightening is done with the screw towards the jaw opening.

To me, the St. Peter's cross, etc., are very neat solutions to a problem that doesn't really exist. If gripping is really a problem, glue a piece of leather to the vice chop.

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#11

foot adjustments

Bob Hackett

Two versions I have seen and used involved foot adjustments. One used a threaded rod just like the one above that had a rather large plywood disc epoxied around the nut this disc and threaded rod took the place of the pin and lower brace. You adjusted the disc to fetch up to the face of the leg by giving a kick to get it spinning. Usually only required a kick or two and allowed you to position the work with both hands if you rough adjusted the initial opening properly. Once enough holding pressure was applied with the disc you had both hands free to reef down on the vise handle.

The second involved a steel bar pinned to the moveable jaw with teeth cut on the bottom edge which engaged a plate screwed onto the bottom face of the bench leg. Once again, you used your toe to lift the bar and make the adjustments. If you filed the teeth like a rip saw and the plate edge like a wedge then you probably wouldn`t even have to hold the bar up with your toe when opening the vise. I suppose a lever could be rigged up to hold the bar up while allowing you to keep both feet more firmly connected to the ground.

Come to think of it I also saw one fellow using a pair of pipe clamps to make a job site leg vise. The first one was used as a clamp between the leg of the sawhorse and the 2X6 he was using for the movable jaw. The bottom one had the clamping jaw screwed to the bottom face of the 2X and the sliding jaw turned around and bearing on the face of the leg. He also used his toe to depress the slider jaw spring assembly and allow the vise to close. I suppose you could just as easily unscrew the clamping jaw and replace it with a threaded pipe flange so you wouldn`t be constantly stubbing your toe on that lower handle.

You see a lot of interesting adaptations and inventive approaches in boatyards up here.

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#12

Why?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek, when you upgraded your vise to the chain system, you made a new parallel guide without holes. Was there some reason the original, holey parallel guide wouldn't work with the chain system?

Lars, there is no reason to cut off the holed parallel guide other than, as in my case, a statement of commitment. I had spent several months discussing and planning this design, and believed in it.

Why did I convert the vise? It should be recalled that I had upgraded my bench and face vise, the previous one being a Record 52 1/2 quick release. I missed the ease of adjustment, and I was used to a range that was wider than a few inches, as one gets with the holed parallel guide.

I cannot speak for the others (other than to point out that Chris Schwarz will replace his parallel guide with the BenchCrafted CrissCross, which is another statement of belief), however the AYS version works very well, and I would do it again.

I do not agree that these leg vise adjusters are fashion. They are as much fashion as the Moxon vise - just an old tool rediscovered and their value recognised. Are they essential? Are they even necessary? Of course not. But they make life easier at the bench, and if that is important then get one. If not, then pass.

Two things that come to mind are; A- you lose the flexibility to adjust the vise exactly the way you want it. These "labor saving" devices lure and then chain you into working the way they work best rather than what works best for you ...

Bob, I do not follow your thoughts. "Flexibility" is exactly what you gain with a pin-less adjuster. There is no restriction that I can think of. Perplexed ...

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#13

Re: Why?

Bob Hackett

Well for starters one of these devices locks you into having to use the vice only with the jaws parallel, unless you go to the trouble to disconnect them. More than once I have been glad to have the ability to clamp tapered work in a leg vise or adjust the jaws to focus more clamping pressure in one area of the work or another.

I personally think slaving the jaw to open and work only in parallel mode negates one of the minor benefits of having a leg vice, the adjustable jaw factor. It`d be like welding up the jaw on an Emmert pattern maker`s vice so it could only be used with the moveable jaw parallel with the edge of the bench.

I look at a leg vise with adjustment in the bottom slide as being very similar to an oversized handscrew clamp. Their double screws and adjustable jaws make them far more versatile than a simple, fixed C or K body clamp.

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#14

Re: Downsides of the pin are overrated

Jim Ritter

I never thought that the pin was that big a deal. As a boatbuilder I use a wide verity of dimensions. Moving the pin was just part of a good vise. Then when I started on the chain adjuster I realized how much better it could be. It is easily adjusted for the top of the jaws to close before the rest of the jaw. If you only work with wood between 1/2" and 1" you don't need it as others have said. If any one has any questions for me fire away.

Jim

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#15

Re: Why?

Jim Ritter

Hi Bob, just read your post again. I agree with you completely. However the screws available in today's market are quite a bit different than the old ones. I have several old leg vises and screws. The old screws were double lead which means they were fast and they had almost a ball and socket joint at the handle to take full advantage of being out of parallel. Two winters ago I was putting a long bench with 4 leg vises in at our community boat shop. We bought the screws from Lie-Nielsen. They are very nice, they even have roller bearings at the handle flang for a very smooth action and feel. They do not like being out of alignment however. With a bunch of amateurs at the shop we needed something reliable so they wouldn't screw up the works. The chain adjuster was the result. If you can find an old screw, buy it for the real out of parallel work.

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#16

Re: Why?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well for starters one of these devices locks you into having to use the vice only with the jaws parallel, unless you go to the trouble to disconnect them. More than once I have been glad to have the ability to clamp tapered work in a leg vise or adjust the jaws to focus more clamping pressure in one area of the work or another.

I personally think slaving the jaw to open and work only in parallel mode negates one of the minor benefits of having a leg vice, the adjustable jaw factor.

Hi Bob

The chain adjuster has not altered the side-to-side taper of the chop. The fact is, it did not taper much before. It set, and still sets, pretty square. It's a modern leg vise :) . With the chain, the angle of the chop is adjustable with the turn of a screw (that tightens/loosens the chain). In other words, you can, if you wish, increase clamping pressure in the manner you described.

I now understand that the flexibility for you is the ability to clamp a taper. The flexibility for me is to use the vise to clamp for edges and hold wide boards face up at an angle without needing to adjust the parallel guide.

I do agree that there is a benefit in being able to clamp a taper. Originally, when I was planning my bench build, I was going to use the Veritas double screw vise for this reason. It then became a matter of priorities, and the leg vise won out because by then the portable Moxon double screw vise was on the scene.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#17

All excellent examples, Derek

Bob Hackett

Of why it`s more important to consider what your own real world needs are rather than what someone else feels you may need or is trying to sell you on.

I think another good point you bring up is that a combination of purpose made devices are usually far more useful than any single "silver bullet".

This is one of the things I really enjoy about conversations here, these different perspectives, when respectfully presented and discussed, allow us all the opportunity to distill something useful out of the exchanges that takes place.

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#18

Re: Alternatives to Clamp Tapered & Beveled Stock

William Duffield

For clamping non-parallel, and non-flat stock, there are alternatives to the patternmakers vise and to the moveable pin leg vise. I have built auxiliary jaws that drop right into the wooden chops I have attached to the metal (cast iron) face vise found on many woodworking benches. These appliances work for Record, Jorgensen, Colombian and Eclipse vises, to name a few.

For clamping tapered stock, when the taper is horizontal:


You'll need some 3/4" dowel stock and a 3/4" cove bit (core box bit) for your router. Cut a vertical half circle cove in the front chop. Cut a matching cove in the pivoting jaw appliance and glue in a section of dowel.


For clamping tapered stock, when the taper is vertical:


Cut a horizontal cove in the rear chop. Cut a matching cove in the tilting jaw appliance, and glue in a section of dowel.


For clamping tapered and beveled stock, for example a tapered leg for a bow front table or sideboard:


Use both of the auxiliary jaw appliances you just made.

For clamping round stock:


For clamping smaller diameter stock, these blocks are reversible:


They drop right in, and hook on the left side. The hook keeps long, heavy stock sticking out the right side from from pulling them out of the vise jaws. As I noted, they are reversible, in case you want to hang something out the left side of the vise insead of the right side.


For clamping diamond shaped stock, for example shaping or carving a cabriolet leg:


Use the v-blocks that you made for round stock.

These appliances happen to have been made for my Loxiliary Meta-Bench, but they work just as well on any face vise on any cabinetmaker's bench.

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#19

Excellent, excellent vise aids.


Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#21

Award winning idea

Bill Tindall

Have you ever submitted this solution to magazines "tip" section?

The problem with this post is that it is buried at the bottom of a leg vise post. Owners of modern steel vises are unlikely to read this deep into a leg vise post, what ever a leg vise is, and in fact I would never have found it were it not for Derek's provocative titled response.

I suggest you work with Ellis and see if it can be extracted and posted with a title that will attract modern vise owners, or just repost either here of on the main message Forum. This solution is too good to remain obscure.

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#22

Re: Award winning idea *LINK*

William Duffield

Nope, never went to a magazine.

I didn't invent these ideas. The jaw with the vertically pivoting axis was adapted from one made by Steve Latta, and his idea probably came originally from the often missing attachment to the Emmert patternmaker's vise, a reproduction of which is sold by Patrick Leach. (See link, but note that the Emmert appliance will not work with a regular woodworking face vise, because it has a center post that goes through a hole in the back jaw of the Emmert and is pinned in place so it won't fall on the floor.)

Of course, V-blocks are standard appliances for machinists. All I did was to adapt the ideas to materials I had on hand and the tools often found in a woodworking shop, and fitted them to the available vise and to the bench I was building at the time. They seemed intuitively obvious when I was building the Loxiliary Bench.

Here is a photo of Steve Latta's bench with the auxiliary jaw in place. He is laying out banding and bell flowers on a bow front Federal table leg. If the angles look a little skewed, they are. The beveled front face is up, and the leg is tapered on the bottom and inside faces. Steve only needs one tilting jaw because he is not going to decorate the side face of the leg. You can see one jaw of the F-clamp he is using to clamp the leg of his auxiliary bench to the top of one of the Hay Cabinet Shop Nicholson benches.


I have also built auxiliary jaws for my patternmakers vise that are also equipped with horizontal and vertical V-shaped grooves for holding leg posts at a 45° angle. These are very useful for carving legs that are symmetrical to the corner of the piece of furniture. I'll leave it as an exercise for the interested apprentice to figure out your own solution for the front legs of a Chippendale claw and ball chair, in which the outside side face of the post is typically at about 82° instead of 90°.

OK, I'll repost, to both Hand Tools and Messages forums, and maybe add a few more construction pointers. What details do you think might be useful, but not obvious, to someone wanting to adapt these appliances to their own vise?


Leach's Tilting Jaw

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#23

Tell us more

Bill Tindall

the directions for what is described were sufficient for me. But....

What are all those other holes for in the wood that is "permanently" attached to the vise?

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#24

Re: Award winning idea

William Duffield

There's no need to get Ellis involved in a repost. All you need to do is view the source code of the web page in your browser, find the text you wrote, copy the text, formatting, HTML, and links to the pictures you posted, and paste it all into the reply window. Since WebBBS doesn't parse what you pasted in, it doesn't know that there are embedded pictures, so you have to manually type the *PIC* text into your subject box. Just start copying with the <div>command and stop copying before you get to the </div>command.

Re: pin less leg vise *LINK*

#25

Re: Tell us more

William Duffield

They're dog holes. Sometimes, for holding wide stock or irregular stock on top of the bench, I find it useful to clamp with two dogs in the front vise chop and two dogs in the bench. The dog holes in the front of the vise are a bit less obvious, and less useful, but basically they are for clamping stock by its ends to the front face of the bench. They're not very useful for sawing dovetails, because the stock tends to be yanked from between the dogs on the pull stroke. They're not very useful for edge jointing, either, because the Loxiliary bench is too high to do that efficiently. To use this holding arrangement for working on the top edge of the stock, you might need another pair of dogs to support the bottom edge of the stock. Alternate arrangements for holding work against the front face of the bench are holdfasts driven into the legs, or a Moxon vise, or one end of the stock in the face vise and the other end supported by a deadman. My Loxiliary bench doesn't have a face vise. The metal vise is the end vise, and I use holdfasts or the Moxon vise as a face vise. Usually it is clamped to the top of another bench that is equipped with a face vise or shoulder vise, so I don't miss having a vise at the front corner.

The purpose of the intersecting horizontal and vertical dog holes is for a different holding mechanism altogether, which calls for a separate post, but which has also been mostly superseded in my practice by the use of Joel's holdfasts.