Re: Please enlighten me
Bill Tindall
The gallery I spoke of has furniture spanning more than a 100 year time period with these frail drawer pins . Even though they were less expensive to make, according to Alan, they would not have persisted over such a long time span if, by and large, they didn't hold up.
Maybe someone will do the experiment. Make a mahogany pin of frail size and see if it can be readily sheared off. It certainly can be if I made it for I usually wind up undercutting the pin with a chisel nick while clearing out the waste.
In a glued up drawer none of the pins can be stressed independent of the others. If the glue fails, as on a mid 1800's piece I have, then stress on the drawer from working it can be concentrated on one pin more than another. This could lead to pin deformation and eventually failure, especially in the case of oak on mahogany. The probability depends on the probability of glue failure, a can of worms I shall avoid opening.
The bottom line for me is I would not use frail dovetails because:
1.When it comes to parts of a piece of furniture that are not seen the design decisions are based on engineering and not art. My interior dovetails convey robustness, were they to be seen.
2.When the drawer front and side wood are similar in hardness I think it is easier to make larger dovetails.
3. I am usually dovetailing something inspired by American Furniture. If there is no engineering reason to do otherwise larger dovetails look more at home on the piece.



.....sweet dreams.



