New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Directions for making dovetail marking devise

Posts

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#26

Re: Please enlighten me

Bill Tindall

The gallery I spoke of has furniture spanning more than a 100 year time period with these frail drawer pins . Even though they were less expensive to make, according to Alan, they would not have persisted over such a long time span if, by and large, they didn't hold up.

Maybe someone will do the experiment. Make a mahogany pin of frail size and see if it can be readily sheared off. It certainly can be if I made it for I usually wind up undercutting the pin with a chisel nick while clearing out the waste.

In a glued up drawer none of the pins can be stressed independent of the others. If the glue fails, as on a mid 1800's piece I have, then stress on the drawer from working it can be concentrated on one pin more than another. This could lead to pin deformation and eventually failure, especially in the case of oak on mahogany. The probability depends on the probability of glue failure, a can of worms I shall avoid opening.

The bottom line for me is I would not use frail dovetails because:

1.When it comes to parts of a piece of furniture that are not seen the design decisions are based on engineering and not art. My interior dovetails convey robustness, were they to be seen.

2.When the drawer front and side wood are similar in hardness I think it is easier to make larger dovetails.

3. I am usually dovetailing something inspired by American Furniture. If there is no engineering reason to do otherwise larger dovetails look more at home on the piece.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#27

Re: Popcorn, OZ, and oh, my!

Bruce McCrory

Derek, I hope you have as good a sense of humor as I think you have.

I had to Google "London Pattern Dovetails", and came up with the usual tavern suspects, besides the answer: "delicate, fragile." This, only after rebuilding my desktop pc, which never, ever, is a pleasure. Ever!

I am moving my latest comments to a new post. Because this one is about marking devices.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#28

Re: They can last

Sgian Dubh

Bill, finely wrought dovetails, ie, skinny ones with a single saw entry between tails, in quarter sawn European oak onto tangentially sawn mahogany drawer fronts tend to hold together well I believe, in part, because the the expansion coefficient of these two materials are very close. Shrinkage of tangentially sawn mahogany from 30% MC to 0% is about 5.1%. Quarter sawn European oak has a shrinkage factor of about 5.3%. Granted almost no drawer will experience MC values outside the 5% to maybe 14% range in normal service, so actual shrinkage is likely only a fraction of the numbers I've given.

I'm still puzzled by this 'London' dovetail nomenclature that's sprung up. We Brits, or at least all the ones I know apart from myself in the furniture profession, and living within, at most, 600 miles of London, England, and many furniture makers in London itself had never heard of that name for 'delicate' or 'fine' dovetails until you Americans, or somebody somewhere coined it.

Anyway, as to setting out dovetails and jigs and devices, if I'm going to go to the bother of carefully measuring it all out instead of just hash-bash eyeballing the job which I'm wont to do, then I like to set the gap between the tails at their widest part, ie, at the shoulder line to match the width of a convenient chisel as suggested in the doodle below-- a bit small but perhaps you can get the idea. This means you can whack the waste out pretty much in one pass of the chisel, which saves a lot of picking about in corners with chisels too narrow for a gap determined by rakes set out from the end of a board. Slainte.

Photobucket

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#29

Re: Bigger image to previous post

Sgian Dubh

This is a better image to see details. Ignore the last image which is the same but a bit titchy. I would have edited my last post to put this in, but I'd left it too late. Slainte.

Photobucket

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#30

New nomenclature-  "Delicate"

Bill Tindall

Sgian calls this style "delicate" and he should know. Seems to be a perfect name for it describes their distinguishing feature and the description is not as pejorative as "frail".

So, from now on let us use the accepted term "delicate" for this kind of dovetail.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#31

or "thin" and "thick" like .....

roger lance

Laurel and Hardy.... :D

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#32

or "feminine" and "masculine" if we.....

roger lance

want to get a little Freudian about it.... :( .....sweet dreams.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#33

Pin Failure

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Plenty of drawers with delicate pins are intact after 200 years. Failure in dovetails is most often caused by sloppy fit. Also tails can fail when the dovetail angle is too great because there is too much short grain at the edges of the tails. The pins are not affected by a larger angle.

How do delicate pins fail? Usually the thin pins are sheared off.right at their base. The half pins at the edge are more likely to split off with the split running with the grain into the drawer front. Here a more robust half pin in only slightly stronger than a thin one because the split occurs with the grain. So what we see is shearing off of the small pins coupled with splitting off of a half pin.

Often pins that come to a point are given a little more angle so that there is a larger cross section, like what you show for the Seymours. Without that larger angle, these pins would look weaker and would be weaker. Another common way of compensating for small pins is to have the pins slightly closer together, so more pins overall, and more total cross section area from the pin board in the joint.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#34

Related question about cockbeading

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thank you! That is most helpful. I would never thought about how the half pins and interior pins might fail differently. Here is a related question (I think). In the Seymour example, I could not see how they had done their cockbeading. So I fended for myself.

At the time, following directions I found somewhere, I used a full width cockbead on drawer tops and bottoms. Mitered the leading edge of the top and bottom beads to match the mitered side pieces. Cockbead was 3/32" thick. All of this involved planing the already-assembled drawer front top and bottom, and sawing rebates in the side edges, to receive the beads. Because I had decided to use full width beads top and bottom, the planing involved cutting down the original wood of the half pins by 3/32" or so. Gluing the beads into their places restored the original thickness of the half pins, but now the half-pins are laminated, and not the natural grain.

Well, the drawer front is cherry and the beads are cherry, so there is no dissimilar wood situation going on. But only later I learned that the old time practice was to use partial-width cockbeads, so that the top and bottom beads are the same width as the side pieces. So you have a seam in the drawer front top and bottom, but the half-pin is left in the natural wood, and is not cut down by the thickness of the bead.

Question: Is it better practice to use partial-width beads, in order to leave the half-pins whole? Or does it matter? Your opinion, of course. And anyone else's, too!

Here is the photo again, for reference:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/7980034925/in/set-72157631520658723/

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#35

Re: Related question about cockbeading

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The method you used, full depth cockbead on the top and bottom, partial width on the sides is certainly a very common one. Sometimes the side cockbeads are nailed with extremely small nails (and sometimes one of these side pieces is missing).

Instincts tell me that your drawer is not a weak or vulnerable one. Note that the center pin is pretty beefy at the back end (because it is slightly more angled) and that the pins are not too far apart.

Looking at your drawer partly open drawer you can see how thinner dovetails might fail. A child hanging on the drawer or an adult yanking on a stuck drawer causes a rotation in the drawer front. In this situation the half pins can split off at top or bottom and the middle pins come into play to prevent this. With a deeper drawer there is a larger moment (more leverage) and more vulnerability.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#36

Re: Related question about cockbeading

William Duffield

Partial width cockbeads are easier to install, especially to insure a consistent reveal all the way around the drawer front, since you can push it up against the side of the rabbet while the glue is still slippery.

Before the advent of table saws, it was also quicker and more precise to remove a rabbet for a narrower cockbead than the full width, since the rabbet plane has both a fence and a depth stop. All your cockbead stock can be prepared to the same width and thickness, and the only critical fitting is mitering the ends to length.

The cockbead is designed to protect the edges of either highly figured or veneered drawer fronts, which would be easily damaged in use all the way around, and is therefore prepared from straight grained stock, which is easily sized and to which the bead is easily applied.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#37

Hen house storage

Bill Tindall

Sometime in their life many old pieces of furniture found themselves out of favor and stored in the hen house. I would venture that a split half pin is a result of storage in the hen house and not failure due to stress in use. If the drawer side material responds to a change in moisture different from the drawer front the stress will be concentrate at the top and bottom half pin and splitting will be the failure mode. Because of the greater end grain surface dovetail glue will be more subject to shear failure than edge glue joint, and hence, ineffective at resisting a split at the stress point of the half pin stress from an extreme moisture change.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#38

full vs half width cock bead

Bill Tindall

For questions like Wiley's I look to the folks at the Mack Headley and Sons shop for guidance. They have been making Period furniture for 4 generations and the family ran an antique business to boot. When I took a class there we used full width cock bead, top and bottom, and half width on the edges. The removal of some of the pin is compensated by making a larger pin.

It just looks better, and for a veneered drawer the secondary wood beneath is covered up where it most shows.

It is not difficult to align in assembly. Three locating brads are driven into the drawer edge and cut off to yield three alignment dowels. I had no problem doing this kind of drawer first try , and may tries thereafter.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#39

Re: Delicate, and very pretty...

William Duffield

Isn't Hereford one of those places where "hurricanes hardly ever happen?"

Jack's description sure sounds like the sort of stresses that could have been put on the drawers I restored, except there was no indication of rot. Of course, lots of things short of standing in a swamp could cause the failure of the brads and the hide glue. Once the drawer bottom has failed, for whatever reason, a stuck drawer will be subject to racking.

So, I guess "WoodWould" is another pseudonym of "Jack Plane"?

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#41

Re: They can last

CStanford

Better get with it Richard - I think Chris Schwarz uses this term and is responsible for its dissemination across the internet. And, you know, he's an expert.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#42

Re: They can last

Sgian Dubh

I'd better mind my p's and q's then Charles, ha, ha. Slainte.