New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Directions for making dovetail marking devise

Posts

Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#1

Directions for making dovetail marking devise

Bill Tindall




I did not invent this tool. Someone, to I am forever grateful, from WoodCentral sent me a picture of a similar devise. The hard part is getting a notch in a piece of metal or thin piece of wood. Picture 3 shows how I do it. I capture a piece of brass strip in a slot and then using the miter fence saw it out on the table saw. The slot in the wood is sawed with band saw. The screw clamps the strip in the holder. Tilt the saw blade XX degrees and saw away.

I had on hand a thumb screw. I drilled an undersized hole in a piece of hard maple and just screwed it into the maple to hold the brass piece in place. For the second one I made I screwed a brass screw into the end of the maple piece, cut its head off and added the knurled nut and washer to hold the brass strip in place.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#2

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

Howard Pollack

Bill-

Is the size of the dovetail changeable by turning the knurled screw or is it a single-size marker? If it does change, what is the mechanism like? Thanks. -Howard

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#3

size variable

Bill Tindall

There is a deep vee cut in the brass strip. After loosening the nut the brass strip can be slid up or down to adjust the size.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#4

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

John Pappas

Here is picture of my jig which inspired Bill. I rough cut out the "vee" with a hack saw, and then filed to the exact line. I made the block by laminating two pieces. Before gluing up, I cut a small grove to hold a threaded rod.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#5

credit to its inventor-P. J. Pappas

Bill Tindall

I got the following note from P. J. Pappas. I will take the liberty to post if for him.



Thanks for calling it a wonderful device. I tried posting something this morning on WC, but I am having trouble while on WC. Computer seems to be ok otherwise. I am really puzzled. I might also like to suggest something when marking out dovetails.

1. Mark half pin on left.

2. Divide space from right edge of that half pin to edge of board.

Those marks represent the right edge of each pin.

3. Mark the pins, aligning the right edge of jig to tic mark. I

like that better than aligning to a center mark for the pin.

Look at this attachment for a moment. To me, I see a series of "pin/tail" sets.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#6

A version of your jig in wood....

roger lance


as Tommy Mac would say, "Easy peezie".

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#7

Very  nice


Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#8

Re: A version of your jig in wood....

roger lance


Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#9

Re: Great designs

Bruce McCrory

Both designs look great!

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#10

About dovetail marking and dovetail markers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Some will argue that we are going overboard on dovetail angles and placement, that is, it is only a functional joint. I view this area as another detail in the overall design package. Neither more nor less. And so, if we are looking at dovetailing from a design perspective, then position and form are also important for the complete aesthetic: where we place the dovetail, the number, the slope, the width at the apex .. all are decisions that are made in keeping with the piece under construction - modern, classic, whatever.

In an earlier thread you offered up a template for deciding the placements of the dovetails. Can you say more about this now? And how you use this marker in this process?

I find it an interesting design with compromises that move away from the features I prize. For me these include the ability to vary the width at the apex of the triangle (placement/spacing of the dovetails aside). A second feature is the ability to scribe (with a pencil) a single line beginning at one corner on the face side, and ending at the other corner on the edge side. I keep on hand a few markers in different ratios so that the angle of the slope may be varied.

What I see in this marker is a one that will meet the first factor, but not the second. Slope is a separate issue.

For my own use I have four markers I made from brass angle, and these comprise slopes of 1:5, 1:6, 1:7 and 1:8. For the size drawers and thicknesses I tend to use most, the 1:7 ratio tends to work best. My dovetailed dovetail marker is 1:7. All of the markers allow for marking one side without lifting the pencil.


The board that the markers are resting on is a jig of sorts. The groove is positioned for a 3/4" thick drawer front. I can use the board to position a 1/4" plough plane blade. I prefer to use slips on thin drawer sides, so the groove is only for the front. It does allow me to mark the sides and rear as well.

What do you think about the width of the dovetail apex? Do you treat drawers differently from carcases? For example, a minimal apex for drawers and a wider one for carcases, or would you work for absolute strength with equal pins and tails (or something between)?



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#11

Details on how slot and angle were cut?


Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#12

Re: About dovetail marking and dovetail markers

William Duffield

For those (perish the thought) used to dovetails measured in degrees: here's a rough approximation for Derek's ratios and one other often seen on router bits:

1:4 14°

1:5 11°

1:6 9-1/2°

1:7 8°

1:8 7°

I think 14° dovetails are particularly ugly, as are 1:1 pin to socket width ratios. Maybe that's because I used a P-C jig to make my first dovetails. One cannot argue with the strength of 1:1 layouts, but for almost any application I can imagine, a more esthetically pleasing spacing with narrower pins is plenty strong enough. At the other end of the spectrum, however, I am uncomfortable with single entry or London pattern dovetails, unless it is for an exact reproduction of an original that used them. In all other cases, I prefer spacing like Derek shows in his final pic of the through dovetails in the drawer back.

My aversion to London dovetails is based on one repair job. It was a mahogany chest of drawers, and it had several other structural shortcomings that contributed to its failure, but what struck me most poignantly was that the pins had pulled out of the drawer fronts. To fix it, I used a router with a 1/4" straight bit, cut 2" long slots in the back of the drawer front where the pins had been, glued in blocks of maple, and chopped new pins in the ends of the maple blocks to fit the tails in the drawer sides. (The failure also cracked the drawer sides in several places, but that's an easy fix.)

So, this is just personal preference. If you construct your carcasses sturdily and fit your drawers properly, you probably won't have problems with London dovetails, even if, to my eye, they look wimpy.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#13

Re: Delicate, and very pretty...

Bruce McCrory

but are they strong?

I see me holding a drawer front and sox spilling out onto the floor. Although, end-grain joints are stronger than we tend to expect.

[Gorgeous wood!]

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#14

Cut with.....

roger lance

table saw and tenon jig with a backer board....in this case at 8:1. Making this jig reminds me of a TV show with Chef Gordon Ramsey where his "students" make versions of his dishes....there must be dozens of ways to make this jig.


Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#15

Re: Delicate, and very pretty...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi William and Bruce

Both of your question the strength of "London" pattern dovetails. I recalled that this came up in a topic a couple of years ago on the Oz forum. WoodWould (who writes the "Pegs and Tails" blog), noted ..

"Dovetail failure of an 18th century drawer – with, or without London pattern pins  is a rare occurrence. I've only come across possibly two or three cases in thirty plus years as a restorer/dealer of 18th century furniture. Link to one of them.

The failed drawers I encountered had suffered from terminal dampness, presumably having sat in some damp pile in Hereford, or a derelict house, or an attic room with an undiscovered leak. The finish is the first indicator – it goes a greyish colour, but if the chest has been subsequently restored, this type of water damage mightn't be readily apparent to anyone other than another restorer.

The chronic damp first softens, then dissolves and finally disperses the animal glue. Moisture also rusts the fine iron cut nails that secure the rear of the drawer bottom boards to the lower edge of the drawer back. The result of all this is, the first person to open the drawer (which is probably somewhat misshapen by now from all the damp) tugs unmercifully on the handles and one side of the drawer comes free. The bottom boards are no longer secured to the drawer, so they are free to move as forces dictate and the drawer racks, breaking the pins in the drawer front.

London pattern dovetails are well-founded and under normal circumstances, a well cared for COD will not suffer from broken dovetails."

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#16

Re: About dovetail marking and dovetail markers

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Derek and all,

You bring up some interesting points:

1. Type of marker. Your markers have the great benefit of marking over the top. Bill's open marker has the great benefit that you can visually center it over a single mark, and mark both wings of the V from one mark. It doesn't hide one wing (and its mark) when you line up to mark the other wing. Of course with single entry pins, this matter doesn't arise--do you suppose the London workers used them to simplify marking?

2. Strength. You got a couple comments to the effect that your single entry dovetails look delicate. Well, everyone will have their own aesthetic preferences--I like them. On the strength issue, I would like to put in my two cents that they seem stout to me for three reasons: (1) there are seven pins into that drawer side; (2) the individual pins are steep enough and long enough (3/4") that they get good grip and are fairly beefy at the big end (looks like 1/4" width); (3) the half pins are heavier yet. More generally, isn't a dovetailed drawer way stronger than it needs to be for purpose?--Why focus on strength? You showed heavier pins for the carcase join, to distinguish the two purposes.

3. Geometry, ratios, and design. I would like to show another drawer front, employing a single entry pin. This one was done by John and Thomas Seymour, noted cabinetmakers in Boston circa 1800. Here is a photo of the drawer, done approx. 1805-1810:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/7980034406/in/set-72157631520658723/

This is a 2-1/4" to 2-3/4" tall drawer, using just one interior pin. It's essentially single entry, as you can see. But the ratio is 1:5. I wonder whether the Seymours even thought about ratios.

Here is the piece that drawer is in:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/7980034661/in/set-72157631520658723/

I get fairly ill showing my project in the same breath with that of the Seymours, but to give an idea what this pin design looks like in a drawer you might make:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/7980034925/in/set-72157631520658723/

In making these drawers, I got an idea why the Seymours used that particular design. If they had added another interior pin, it would have gotten busy and crowded. But with the single pin, it would have looked (and been!) skimpy if they had gone with 1:7 or 1:8 steepness--the center pin would look tiny in between the two half pins. What I gather from the Seymour drawer: Design depends on context, and should not be constrained to rules of thumb.

Wiley

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#17

On the origin of the frail looking dovetails

Bill Tindall

We seem to be searching for what to call these things. London isn't widely know in this country or apparently England either according to one report. Wiley seems to have discovered or invented yet another term which has some functional merit. I'll call them as I see them, frail.

According to Alan Batty, who worked in an English factory making drawers, this style of dovetail was the solution to making a drawer side from hard to work oak and a drawer front from easy to work mahogany in the most time efficient manner. The dovetails were laid out by eye, not difficult when you are cranking out several drawers a day, the quota at this factory. The pin hole in the hard oak was cut efficiently with the saw and the remaining waste quickly pared out to the baseline with a chisel. This cost cutting procedure for working the materials of the day has then evolved into a design element in some quarters, or a signature of traditional English drawer construction in other quarters, for example Period reproductions.

This explanation reveals why the American cabinet makers never widely adapted this drawer construction for use with our easier to work wood drawer sides. One has to wonder if English cabinet makers had poplar and yellow pine forests whether this style would have ever been invented.

To my eye they look frail and I would never consider using them on anything but the most dainty of pieces.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#18

Get some popcorn and wait for......

roger lance

sunrise in Oz.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#19

London pattern dovetails

Steve Elliott

This week I've been installing a kitchen where the owner is storing furniture in the garage, including a chest of drawers with London pattern dovetailing. It's an old piece in mahogany with oval pulls, in a style I believe to be late 18th century though I'm no expert.

What struck me first was how nicely the dovetails were done. In a drawer 10" high there were 9 tails, equally spaced, with a half pin at the top and bottom of the side. The side thickness was 3/8" and the drawer bottom was done using slips. I didn't get any sense of frailty, just good workmanship.

To a modern eye the material used for the drawer sides and bottom (softwood, probably pine) were surprisingly rough, meaning full of knots and not chosen for grain that would be either especially attractive or easy to work. These days I'd expect to see it used to make a crate. Labor must have been much cheaper back then compared to the cost of materials.

The piece was being stored with the drawers stacked on top of the carcase so I couldn't judge how well they moved after so many years. A piece of molding on one side of the carcase had pulled loose and was hanging in the air--the owner apparently doesn't think of the piece as a valuable antique, just a useful chest of drawers.

The London pattern dovetails wouldn't be right for some pieces but in this case they seemed to exactly fit the style of the piece and they had held up for a very long time.

The kitchen I've been installing will probably be replaced in 30 years or less because it looks "so 2012" or doesn't work with the next generation of appliances. And they're spending a bundle for it. I had to admire the craftsman who made those drawers so long ago.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#20

Design considerations

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think I will be ill if I hear another time about how drawer dovetails are a design consideration. It is nice to see them neat and nicely proportioned, but much more important are things like stock selection, overall proportion, the scale of various parts, thickness of stock. And mouldings, turnings, hardware, carvings, scroll work, inlay. Things that are actually seen on the outside. The charm and character of the piece, the warmth of the finish, the usefulness and durability.

Delicate pins were used here in America in the late 18th, early 19th century, especially on the more dainty pieces of furniture. They do break and like William I have had to restore broken pins on antiques. It is hard to get a feel for the strength of various joints unless you have seen how they fail.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#21

Re: Design considerations

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I think I will be ill if I hear another time about how drawer dovetails are a design consideration. It is nice to see them neat and nicely proportioned, but much more important are things like stock selection, overall proportion, the scale of various parts, thickness of stock. And mouldings, turnings, hardware, carvings, scroll work, inlay. Things that are actually seen on the outside. The charm and character of the piece, the warmth of the finish, the usefulness and durability.

Delicate pins were used here in America in the late 18th, early 19th century, especially on the more dainty pieces of furniture. They do break and like William I have had to restore broken pins on antiques. It is hard to get a feel for the strength of various joints unless you have seen how they fail.

Hi Warren

Since you replied to my comment, I should return the favour.

I should point out firstly that I do not consider the topic to be "drawer dovetails are a design consideration" (your words). It is, instead, that dovetails are "another detail in the overall design package" (my words). There is a difference.

There is indeed the aesthetic component to consider. Keep this in context. Choose a dovetail profile to compliment the design of the whole piece. For example, the military chests I built about a year ago were more robust than I would use for a modern chest, but being a modern design still were quite slim ...


And I agree, stock selection, proportion, etc etc of the drawer should not be treated with any more or less importance than the care one gives to the dovetail in the drawer. That was what I wrote in my original post.

There are other design considerations than the profile.

The drawer image I had posted was "designed" also with their spacing (closer on the outside, increasing the strength of the construction). This is an issue that Krenov held so dear - incidentally, he offered 26 pages in "The Fine Art of Cabinetmaking" to the topic of dovetails, their design and integration in a drawer. So far no one has commented on this area, or on this aspect on the image - perhaps it was too subtle to be noticed. Here it is again ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#22

They can last

Bill Tindall

Once again, these kinds of opinion conversations are for the benefit of the undecided. For those that haven't settled on what size of dovetails to use the information exchanged may be useful.

There is a large gallery in Shelbyville, KY that specializes in English antiques and reproductions. The very early pieces have large dovetails while the later ones, as well as the reproductions, with quartered oak sides and mahogany fronts have the frail dovetails. The drawer bottoms in these pieces are often split and /or the dividers deeply grooved from a failed slip but the dovetails themselves are still sound. However, these examples only reveal that quartered oak sides and mahogany fronts can last. Who knows if, or how many, drawers failed and the piece was junked, or what the effect of using other woods would be.

There is no denying that if the glue fails a frail pin will promptly fail. This is not the case with a more robust pin. The conclusion would seem to be that if you don't consider the unseen parts of furniture an opportunity for a design element, then use robust dovetails.

Our club meeting was at a large, highly automated cabinet shop ($100,000 machines replaced unreliable labor). Their drawers were assembled with dowel pins. We were told their stuff was designed to last 15 years.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#23

Re: Design considerations

Tony - Memphis

Nice work! Funny, all this talk of ratios vs strength, etc..... the drawer I use daily in my bathroom vanity is butt jointed and stapled with those cheap white slides witht he nylon wheels. Been good and steady since 1998 (I didn't build them).

I'll just be happy when I can make a decent dovetail! I built a lowboy and did all the dovetails by hand (all half blinds). I was proud of them,b ut looking at them now, I'm not happy with the ratio. They look too much like they were cut using a router bit! Oh well. Next time...

Tony

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#24

Re: Design considerations

roger lance

Derek....as one of the least qualified people here to speak on this topic, I'll add some thoughts. First of all, your work is beautiful....the London dovetails look great....and as you have pointed out, this style of dovetail must fit in with the overall style of the piece....it is not meant to be ubiquitous.....and therefore; larger, thicker dovetails should be employed on other types of furniture (such as a campaign chest, etc). As to frailty, I'm not so convinced.....a long, thin piece of wood can easily be broken....but a short, squat, thin piece is not so easy to break....and given your drawer sides are 5/16 to 7/16 inch thick, the pins are short....also there are numerous pins (strength in numbers) and the half pins are robust....all of these joints would have to fail, to get the drawer to fail....it seems that the most dangerous time for this drawer would be at glue-up/dry fits....once the glue sets and with proper care, these drawers should last a long, long time. I do think the level of craftsmanship is higher/more demanding in making such thin pins verses thicker pins....it would seem you must be more careful/more attentive with your chisel work. As for myself, I'm lucky to like bigger, clunkier styles that call for thicker dovetails....but I also grew-up appreciating blondes and brunettes (redheads too) and saw the beauty in both.

Re: Directions for making dovetail marking devise

#25

Please enlighten me

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

"There is no denying that if the glue fails a frail pin will promptly fail. This is not the case with a more robust pin." ...

You may well be right, but I can't reason through the mechanism of how it fails:

1. Pin shear? Are we talking about the pins shearing off while still in the sockets? Look at the mass of wood shear that would have to take place for that to happen, for example in Derek's zero-entry pin drawer. In the case William Duffield described, I understood him to say that the pins had pulled out--meaning the pins remained intact and the drawer side had failed to hold them in. Would fatter pins have saved the day?

2. Direct pulling out of the sockets? Or twisting out? A 1:7 zero entry pin and a 1:7 'robust pin' of the same length have the exact same engagement with the drawer side--same length and steepness of frictional bearing surface. Same amount of force would be required to pull or twist them out of their housings, short of shear failure.

In the case of glue failing, the strength of the joint will depend jointly on (a) the number of pins of given ratio (not how fat they are) and (b) the depth of insertion, i.e., the width of the drawer sides. If the glue fails, it seems that thin drawer sides would become the weak link leading to pins twisting or pulling out of their sockets. Perhaps we should talk about 'frail drawer sides' rather than 'frail pins'.

Could others who have seen some drawer joint failure in the wild, explain the mechanism--what actually happens?

Thanks,

Wiley