Re: Design considerations
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
I think I will be ill if I hear another time about how drawer dovetails are a design consideration. It is nice to see them neat and nicely proportioned, but much more important are things like stock selection, overall proportion, the scale of various parts, thickness of stock. And mouldings, turnings, hardware, carvings, scroll work, inlay. Things that are actually seen on the outside. The charm and character of the piece, the warmth of the finish, the usefulness and durability.
Delicate pins were used here in America in the late 18th, early 19th century, especially on the more dainty pieces of furniture. They do break and like William I have had to restore broken pins on antiques. It is hard to get a feel for the strength of various joints unless you have seen how they fail.
Hi Warren
Since you replied to my comment, I should return the favour.
I should point out firstly that I do not consider the topic to be "drawer dovetails are a design consideration" (your words). It is, instead, that dovetails are "another detail in the overall design package" (my words). There is a difference.
There is indeed the aesthetic component to consider. Keep this in context. Choose a dovetail profile to compliment the design of the whole piece. For example, the military chests I built about a year ago were more robust than I would use for a modern chest, but being a modern design still were quite slim ...

And I agree, stock selection, proportion, etc etc of the drawer should not be treated with any more or less importance than the care one gives to the dovetail in the drawer. That was what I wrote in my original post.
There are other design considerations than the profile.
The drawer image I had posted was "designed" also with their spacing (closer on the outside, increasing the strength of the construction). This is an issue that Krenov held so dear - incidentally, he offered 26 pages in "The Fine Art of Cabinetmaking" to the topic of dovetails, their design and integration in a drawer. So far no one has commented on this area, or on this aspect on the image - perhaps it was too subtle to be noticed. Here it is again ...

Regards from Perth
Derek