New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Snipe Hunt

Posts

Snipe Hunt

#1

Snipe Hunt

William Duffield

I've been sticking mouldings* on and off for several years, sometimes with a tablesaw and router and lots of sandpaper (Ugh!) and more and more often with my hollows and rounds. However, most of the recent mouldings have been architectural trim for Victorian gingerbread (another Ugh!), and my methods have been less than satisfactory to me. The customers don't mind the 30-30** quality, as they are going to cover them with lots of paint anyway.

In the quest to improve my process and the resultant mouldings, so that I might apply them to fine furniture, I have recently begun a quest to improve my tool set. While I've owned a half set of English middle pitch hollows and rounds for many years, and also rabbets, ploughs and side beads, they're's just not sufficient for what I want to build. I've studied Don McConnell's videos (produced by Lie-Nielsen), followed Matt Bickford's Musings from Big Pink blog, searched the reputable old tool dealers' offerings on both sides of the pond, and recently received Moldings in Practice from Lost Art Press. I need a pair of snipes bills and a pair of side rounds. However, the Schwarz Effect has kicked in with a vengeance, and once esoteric, misunderstood and undesired wooden molding planes have vanished from the face of the earth. I can still remember, a few years ago when I had no idea what they were useful for, a friend walking beside me and picking up a pair of snipes bills off a gravel and grass parking lot and paying a trifling amount for them.

I've recently contacted Larry Williams and Matt Bickford, who both make snipes bill and side round planes. As if their prices were not dear enough, their lead times to make me some new ones range from several months to a few years.

I'm beginning to think I'm desperate enough to try to make my own, but then I'd have to find some seasoned quarter sawn beech, acquire plane floats, and harden steel in sizes beyond the capacity of my minuscule forge and propane torch.

Can anyone offer suggestions to where I might turn for an easier, quicker solution?

* You have to delete the "u" if electrons die in the process.

** 30 MPH @ 30'

Re: Snipe Hunt

#3

Re: Snipe Hunt

Tom Colligan

Bill, FWIW, I located this pair (320968831668) by a British seller and put a bid on them. Help yourself, Tom.

Re: Snipe Hunt

#4

Re: Snipe Hunt

Patrick Gibbons

Making them myself has always appealed to me and other woods besides beech can be used but the time element is always a big problem. Have you looked at The Best Things? They sell quite a few moulding planes and may have what you're looking for. I believe they are www.thebestthings.com.

Re: Snipe Hunt

#5

Re: Snipe Hunt

William Duffield

Thank you, Tom, but I'll pass on those. I now understand what Don McConnell was talking about in his video about the difference between newer and older models. If you notice, the eBay pair cut a quirk with a flat bottom. This is clear in the sixth picture in the listing. This is OK for architectural work that is painted, but for traditional furniture moldings that have a clear finish, you need snipes bills that cut a sharp pointed quirk. I suppose these could be modified to cut the desired profile, but that would be a lot of work. The same issue is found in side beads and, of course, in router bits.

Re: Snipe Hunt

#6

Re: Snipe Hunt

roger lance

Haven't heard the term "snipe hunt" since "Spin and Marty".....a different reference entirely.

Re: Snipe Hunt

#7

Re: Snipe Hunt

William Duffield

Thanks Craig, I'll look into the H. N. T. Gordon planes. A bit of a departure from English and American tradition, but that hasn't stopped me before.

Re: Snipe Hunt

#8

Re: Snipe Hunt

Roger Myers

Bill,

I too tried to find a vintage pair from all the usual suspects and had no success finding a pair that I felt would do the trick. Too many issues with the boxing and general condition that made them unsuitable. Since these need to really be able to cut clean and crisp, and preferably be able to start a cut in just a scribed line, I finally ordered a set in cherry from Matt. Wait was a few months, but well worth it. They are well made and work perfect. A lot of money for planes you don't use often, but they are worth every penny in my opinion.... Not a plane I would want to tackle as my first molding plane if I was setting out to make them.

Roger

Re: Snipe Hunt

#9

Re: Snipe Hunt

William Duffield

I checked Lee Richmond's website, and he doesn't currently list any. Unlike OldTools FMM, it might not be up to date. I'd better drop him an email.

Re: Snipe Hunt

#10

Re: Snipe Hunt

William Duffield

Thanks, Roger, an impartial, positive review from someone whose opinions I trust is always appreciated before pulling out the checkbook. At the rate I finish projects, a six month or so wait is probably not going to be a problem. The moldings go on last, anyway.

Re: Snipe Hunt

#11

Terry Gordon

David Charlesworth

Anything from Terry Gordon is likely to be beautifully made and work very well.

I fancy a pair myself.

best wishes,

David

Re: Snipe Hunt

#12

Re: Terry Gordon

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David, I agree. I had a play with these a few weeks ago at the Perth Woodshow and, like all Terry's planes, they are executed beautifully ..


I shall purchase a set one of these days. I did buy one of his 1/2" dado planes, which was making perfect grooves in very hard Jarrah. This is the quality of his work ...



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Snipe Hunt

#13

Re: Terry Gordon

William Duffield

Thanks for the recommendations David and Derek. If it were only a matter of price and quality of design, construction and working ability, the H.N.T.Gordons would be hard to reject. I haven't inquired on Terry's lead time, however, because there are a few other things that concern me.

I am not averse to using nontraditional tools in my shop, as my stable of Veritas planes can attest, but in front of the public, when they might actually be trying to understand 18th Century life and furniture, beech and boxwood are preferred. I smile when I imagine myself dressed in one of those pouffy shirts, shoes with big buckles and a three cornered hat, trying to explain (or even pronounce) gidgee.

Personally, I can appreciate acacias, having spent some time in warmer, dryer climates, but the need for their armament is lost on people from the Mid-Atlantic region. If you look at ecological niches, the closest equivalent native species are the hawthorns, and they haven't really needed their huge thorns since the Clovis people ate the last of the mammoths.

Finally, a question for those more familiar with Terry's planes: In front of the wedge is a light colored block, pinned to the body of the plane. What is it made of and why is it there? Shouldn't it be sufficient to seat the wedge against the plane body? In his bench planes, I see that it may serve as a wear block. It is adjustable?

Re: Snipe Hunt

#14

Re: Terry Gordon

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Finally, a question for those more familiar with Terry's planes: In front of the wedge is a light colored block, pinned to the body of the plane. What is it made of and why is it there? Shouldn't it be sufficient to seat the wedge against the plane body? In his bench planes, I see that it may serve as a wear block. It is adjustable?

Hi William

That is a brass strike block, which is to release the wedge.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Snipe Hunt

#15

Re: Terry Gordon

William Duffield

…which, I guess, explains the lack of the striking whatever you call it lump on the back of the wedge, found in traditional moulding planes (and usually abused).

Re: Snipe Hunt

#16

Moses Yoder

Re: Dying electrons

Moses Yoder

Technically the electrons don't die, they just go on to a happy life in some other place.

Re: Snipe Hunt

#18

Re: Philly Planes

William Duffield

Thanks, Craig. Those look really nice, too, and in the same ballpark, price-wise, as the other builders. It's good to know that those inspired by Don's DVDs and Matt's new book and blog, will be able to satisfy their need to stick mouldings and apply them to their furniture creations.

What encourages me even more is the hope that these developments with inspire others to venture beyond the unadorned but solid craftsmanship of Shaker and Stickley.

As for me, I've already pulled the trigger and ordered a pair from M. S. Bickford.