New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

Posts

Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#1

Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

John Lucas

I do not recommend the tool roll listed below to store your carving tools. I pulled it out today and found rust on every tool that was in there. Apparently it absorbs moisture. I spent a couple of hours cleaning the rust off the tools and re-establishing the edge on the ones that had rust on the cutting edge. What a pain.

Anyone have a good idea on how to store your carving tools. I may have to build a box or tool cabinet of some sort.


http://www.woodcraft.com/product/2001621/1643/25-pocket-deluxe-canvas-tool-roll.aspx

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#2

Re: Tool roll causes rust

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

It's possible the issue is less the tool roll itself than your environment. Do you live somewhere that's humid this time of year, and, if so, is it this year?

Lee Valley sells some foam treated with a chemical that emits rust-preventing vapors. Rolling some of that into your tool roll might help.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#3

Re: Tool roll causes rust

John in NM

Store the roll + chisels in a box with a low watt light bulb (on of course :D), or one of the many desiccant products available.

I agree with Bill that it is just the nature of the season more than the roll itself. You could try treating the roll with a rust inhibitor as well, that might help.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#4

Jesper, Denmark

Re: The root cause is.......

Jesper, Denmark

Temperature swings and relative humidity. As the fabric insulates somewhat, tools stay cold and water condenses on cold tools. The fabric creates a miniature cold environment and keeps the moisture in.

The principle says that an RH <50% is safe, so if your shop environment meets that, all you need is to keep the roll somewhere with good aircirculation. If you cannot guarantee that environment, locating the tool roll on something that generates just a little heat will solve the problem.

If you have significant temperaure fluctuations daily (>10-15°F) and RH>70%, nothing except a protective coating will stop your tools from rusting.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#5

Re: The root cause is.......

Bill Tindall

I agree entirely. While it is possible that some sort of fabric treatment enhanced the rusting it is more likely just a humidity issue as Jasper describes.

If I keep my shop less than 60% RH I don't get any rusting. Much above that value and I get rust.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#6

Re: The root cause is.......

Patrick Gibbons

Joel at Tools For Working Wood gave a great suggestion I've used. Put a wad of cloth into each pocket. I put a little oil on them, not a lot. Chisels in my tool rolls have so far been ok.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#7

Re: Tool roll causes rust

John Lucas

I know that humidity is my problem but the fabric enhanced the problem. Those same tools have been stored in a plastic tool box for 2 years and in the same location on the bottom shelf of a workbench. I didn't have any problems then. Apparently the fabric holds moisture and then is in direct contact with the steel.

It is a very compact way to store the tools but I don't think I'll use it anymore.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#8

Re: Camelia oil

TomD

I keep a few tools in permanent storage in canvas or leather rolls. For the most part though, I avoid them. Any tools, up to perhaps jointer size, I fear are subject to rust I lightly coat with camelia oil. It takes very little to spread and the end result is not a goopy tool if done right. I just has a little shine, and I never get rust after the coating. I bought a second bottle about 5 or 10 years ago to have a spare, but I have not used it yet. I have the original 4 ounce bottle from LV around 1980. I have tried some more potent sprays and such, but over the years have reverted to Camelia oil. The Japanese use a lot of expensive metal in a far more toxic to metal environment than I do.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#9

Olive oil alternative?

Bill Tindall

These vegetable oils, as well as animal fats, are all similar in the chemical sense. They are all esters of some organics acid and glycerin. Unlike petroleum oils the vegetable oils will all be compatible with finishes and probably glue so coating a tool will not have any adverse effect down the road in joinery or finishing.

The organic acid constituents of these oils are all similar , except in their ability to react with oxygen. Those that readily react with oxygen make useful cured films and hence are used for finishing- linseed, tung, walnut, etc. Some react less and "cure" to a gummy coating- most of the cooking oils. While the "curing" would be good for rust protection it would leave a sticky film on tools.

A few , Camelia and Olive, are essentially unreactive so a coating on a tool will not become sticky. Olive and Camelia are chemically almost identical. Tool rust is probably not an important issue where olives are grown. While this oil became widely used as a lubricant for diamond "cutting" on cast iron, it would not have been widely used for tools so we lack any historical data on its efficacy.

If I needed to coat a tool and didn't have Camelia on hand I would check the kitchen and try some Olive. I expect it would work identically.

In the unrefined state these oils contain a trace amount natural antioxidant. Whether there is enough of it there to affect corrosion is unknown to me.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#10

Re: Tool roll causes rust

david weaver

Make something that keeps all of their steel and edges out of contact with anything, and make a mineral oil and beeswax mix (1/2 of each) to rub on them.

If they're used often, you could just use the mineral oil.

For a while, i got the bottles of camelia oil, but after finding light mineral oil to do just as well and cost 1/8th as much if you get it at a horse store or kitchen food place, I wouldn't be buying any more bottles of camelia oil.

Adding a little bit of wax makes the protection a bit longer term, and mixing the beeswax with oil makes it easier to apply.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#11

Re: Camelia oil

CStanford

Any sheer oil will work - canola works fine. No need to spend the equivalent of $85/gal. on camelia oil.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#12

Re: Olive oil alternative?

TomD

I also wonder at times what is in camellia oil, can it really all be camellias? It could be mineral oil or olive oil with just the right combination of viscosity and perfume for the intended service. I find it lasts so long for me and is never a problem with things like glues or need to hand wash because it is the perfect viscosity, etc... But the back up bottle I have checked and even it is not exactly the same as the bottle I am used to. I would not prefer oilive oil because it is heavier. The better grades that rub into the skin, if light enough, would probably be pretty similar. I do have a vat of olive oil that is used for heat treating, and I live in fear that it will tip over and spill all over the concrete floor. When that happens I will be able to just dip my tool on the floor as required.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#13

Re: Camelia oil

TomD

One doesn't pay the extra, which can economically be referred to as the same as a pack of Canadian cigarettes per lifetime, because it does any better job keeping things rust proof than other oils, but because of what it doesn't do at the same time. I also have to consider what oil I most want to spill on my bench, because sooner or later it will get there.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#14

Re: Tool roll causes rust

TomD

David, what are the normal weights one can get mineral oil in? I always just thought of the stuff one can get at a drug store, but over the years I have come across various references to the stuff sold at farm stores etc... as though one could get a full range of weights? When I say "can get" I am referring to what one normally sees as well as what some industry literature might be available. I don't have access to MSC for instance. Least not last time I looked.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#15

Re: Tool roll causes rust

david weaver

I've seen some that is not specified (which might be heavier than light mineral oil) and some that's labeled as light mineral oil. Both in animal and kitchen stuff. I went with kitchen supply because it was the same price as the animal supply stuff and specified food safe. ($12.50 a gallon here)

If I didn't live close to a city, though, I'd just look for light at a farrier's supply place or a farm store. I guess people like to shove large amounts through horses to loosen them up inside. Last time I saw light mineral oil for animal use, it was about the same price as the kitchen supply stuff.

As cheap as it is, I'd hate to pay to ship it. It would cost as much to ship as the stuff costs to begin with.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#16

Re: Tool roll causes rust

William Duffield

A while back, just after they came out, I bought a set of Lie-Nielsen bench chisels, with the L-N leather tool roll. I brought them home, wiped them down with camellia oil, put them in the tool roll and set them on a shelf in my shop. After a few days, or maybe a couple of weeks, I noticed a lot of rust on all the chisels. I removed them from the tool roll, cleaned off the rust, treated them with T-9 and hung them in a rack I built, on the same shelf, in the same climate uncontrolled shop. To this day, I have suffered no more rust on these chisels, but they still have "patina" marks from the rust they suffered in the tool roll. I only use the tool roll now for short term transport of tools to work and teaching sites, after I've filled up all my canvas.

I also learned a lesson about canvas tool rolls a long time ago. If you put the sharp ends in the pockets, you can't see which tool is which, so you have to pull them all out when you want to use them. Obviously, the tools also shred the tool roll, as someone else noted. I put the handles in the pockets. They're usually mostly the same, they slide right in, they all fit, and the edges are still protected when rolled up, and you can see which tool you need without taking them all out of the tool roll. For me, flat rectangles of canvas work almost as well as stitched up tool rolls.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#17

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#18

Indeed

Bill Tindall

We kept the large planer in the lumber shed. In the spring and fall the machine would be cool and the air could get warm and humid. Water would condense on the unpainted parts. If these were coated with T9 there would be no rust. It is the best antirusting coating I have used. I have never had anything rust that was coated with it. However, it leaves a sticky film on stuff.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#19

Re: Indeed

William Duffield

There are two ways to use T-9:

1) Spray it on and leave it if you are not going to use the machine for a while. When you want to take the sticky film off later, it dissolves easily in WD-40. So does cosmolene.

2) Spray it on and wipe it off, if you are going to use the tool immediately. This doesn't give as much protection, but still inhibits rust.

And, my best T-9 trick: Don't you wish it had a flip-up spray tube, like the one that you get on a WD-40 spray can? Well, the cap from the WD-40 fits the T-9 spray can, so when you empty a can of WD-40, pop the spray cap off and pop it onto the T-9 can.


Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#20

Re: Tool roll causes rust

CStanford

Baby oil is much lighter than the mineral oil sold as a laxative and it's also lighter than Norton's honing oil.

The perfume doesn't linger all that long and Johnson's is perfumed less than the generic brands FWIW.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#21

Fine Woodworking tests Camelia Oil

Bill Tindall

Visited a friend today to see how his Mahogany chest on chest was coming (very nice and nearly done). He subscribes to FW and had some issues laying about. One article tested rust mitigation products. Cameilia oil was nearly equivalent to no treatment in their test of A2 and cast iron. Some products were nearly 100% effective.

Some products were recommended with reservation because they smelled of "petroleum", oh my.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#22

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#23

Re: "Smells like... victory!"

CStanford

I can't imagine a scenario that would have me placing an order for camelia oil.

That said, how in the world did all of the hoopla get started? Classic case of bull$heet marketing? If it's this expensive it must be good?

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#24

Re: "Smells like... victory!"

david weaver

Probably comes from the desire of people do do one-stop shopping, and the retailer side of things knowing they need to have something that is worth their time to sell.

Not going to sell mineral oil, you can get that for $2 or $3 for a pint at the drug store, or $12-$14 a gallon at any kitchen supply or farm store.

Not going to sell anything you can get right at the hardware store (like old 3 in 1, or whatever), because you're not going to convince someone to pay you more for a product and ship it.

So you look overseas and get something that isn't sold here regularly, and there you've found a product that's available at a price you're willing to sell and that a consumer can't easily cross reference.

That's my guess. I don't know about FWW's test, I didn't look yet on the website, but I have found mineral oil (and before that when I first started, camelia oil) to be useful for short term, especially vs. bare metal. If they used an accelerated test, I'm sure it would penetrate it.

But I'll bet a lot of people have wiped planes with camelia oil, put them in disuse for a few months and then came back to find them rusty. Which is only a big deal with folks obsessed about the looks of their metal tools.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#25

Guilty......

roger lance

I'll admit I bought camellia oil....from Lie Nielsen....I thought "if they carry it....it has to be good".....I also have some T-9....if tools start coming up rusty, guess to which product I'll turn.