Re: "Smells like... victory!"
david weaver
Probably comes from the desire of people do do one-stop shopping, and the retailer side of things knowing they need to have something that is worth their time to sell.
Not going to sell mineral oil, you can get that for $2 or $3 for a pint at the drug store, or $12-$14 a gallon at any kitchen supply or farm store.
Not going to sell anything you can get right at the hardware store (like old 3 in 1, or whatever), because you're not going to convince someone to pay you more for a product and ship it.
So you look overseas and get something that isn't sold here regularly, and there you've found a product that's available at a price you're willing to sell and that a consumer can't easily cross reference.
That's my guess. I don't know about FWW's test, I didn't look yet on the website, but I have found mineral oil (and before that when I first started, camelia oil) to be useful for short term, especially vs. bare metal. If they used an accelerated test, I'm sure it would penetrate it.
But I'll bet a lot of people have wiped planes with camelia oil, put them in disuse for a few months and then came back to find them rusty. Which is only a big deal with folks obsessed about the looks of their metal tools.