New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

Posts

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#26

Re: me, too..

david weaver

A lot of people probably bought it, and i'm sure they're still selling it pretty well....just not to us.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#27

Re: "Smells like... victory!"

CStanford

I actually wouldn't characterize it as an obsession. Fairly fresh rust easily transfers to workpieces. That's no good.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#28

Re: me, too..

CStanford

I remember when the stuff first came out and my question on the forums was what's so special about camelia oil, why not sunflower oil, or safflower oil, corn oil, soybean oil, etc. etc? Nobody could really respond beyond quoting the marketing blurbs from the suppliers and that "the Japanese use it." Whoopteefreakindoo I thought then and now.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#29

Re: "Smells like... victory!"

david weaver

Hopefully, that kind of rust doesn't exist on tools commonly used. Just their use should keep it off of surface that contact the wood (soles of planes, etc) because you'll incidentally use wax from time to time on them.

It's the cheeks that I used to chase the rust from. That and the chipbreaker, etc.

I always hated having a fresh thin layer of oil on them because each time you got your tools out, you either took that layer off or you had a dust magnet.

Wax works so much better, and you don't have to do it very often. Very thin shellac on the cheeks that never touch wood works even better yet. The sole can fend for itself on a plane that's used often, and after going through the same acquisition of a bunch of cheap bench planes when I started that a lot of folks do, if I had a plane at that point that rusted twice on the sole, I sold it until I was down to few enough that it doesn't happen because they actually get used.

I do have a friend who is obsessed as I described though with incidental rust on parts that don't touch wood. He doesn't use hand tools too often, and given his obsession with them needing to be visually perfect, he shouldn't have them at all. Like others, he put his planes away with camelia oil on maybe to get them out a year later and find rust, and then spend a lot of time taking the rust off, and repeating the process.

Maybe he could buy one of the new high $$ stainless planes, his wallet is super fat, anyway.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#30

Re: "Smells like... victory!"

TomD

Well it is a big deal if the product is claiming to be a rust preventative. Not my experience though. It is humid around the great lakes, and also in Japan. I find it very satisfactory. I would not say I think it is the best at rust proofing, but many of the products that claim high levels of performance are not something I want in the shop. As far as FWW tests are concerned, consider the source. It is kinda a variation on Thumper's rule: "if you can't say anything sensible, don't say anything at all". The absolute masters at setting up stupid tests.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#31

Re: "Smells like... victory!"

TomD

I do think there is something to be said for avoiding cast iron in hand planes at all costs. Can't think of a good thing to say for it, other than that some people have made some nice planes in it that would have been a lot better made in something else. Now cast iron, the good stuff in machine tools seems to have a place. Part of that place being under a jet of oil emanating from a recirculating system, and complete with an automatic oiling system.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#32

Re: "Smells like... victory!"

cstanford

I just read the article. Looked like the tests were reasonably well conducted. Here's the link. You need to be an online member.

http://www.finewoodworking.com/FWNPDF/011227030.pdf

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#33

Re: "Smells like... victory!"

TomD

I'm not picking on your perfectly reasonable choice of words, "but reasonably well conducted" covers acres of sin. I'm not an online member so I probably won't find out. You can do a fair test and completely misrepresent a topic. Either intentionally or otherwise. One thing they did for while was to get people with basically zero knowledge to do the tests. This is like Larry King's approach to broadcasting where he purposely did not read the books of guests, etc... because he said that he believed that it would impede his ability to ask the stupid questions his listeners would have in mind. I paraphrase. Their original approach was not to do tests. But they realized that tests were very popular, I suppose. So what do you do not to insult your bread and butter advertisers or destroy your credibility. You think very hard about some utterly meaningless, but reasonably well conducted tests.

FWW is like Eisenstein with Alzheimers. They will print stuff like a highly complementary review of a particular novel bench style, that is obviously copied from the pages of an earlier FWW publication. They have forgotten more than they will now ever know. Oh, and the book it originally appeared in is possibly the most important they ever published, particularly given what TP has since become.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#34

Re: "Smells like... victory!"

cstanford

Join on a trial membership. It's difficult to debate the merits and conclusions of an article with somebody who has not read it.

I think the methodology was simple and neatly done. I think the conclusions reached were valid.

Re: Tool roll causes rust *LINK*

#35

Re: "Smells like... victory!"

cstanford

I agree that FW is not what it once was, but even a blind squirrel finds a nut every now and then.

If camelia oil works for you by all means don't change a thing.