New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Alternative "Moxon" Vise

Posts

Re: Alternative "Moxon" Vise

#51

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Alternative "Moxon" Vise

#52

Good fun

Ron in Kokomo

I very much enjoy the time talking with you. I need to ask. Are you sideways because Shannon is all hand tools? That would seem odd on this forum.

Hope you get some time in the shop today. I am stuck at the beach :)

Re: Alternative "Moxon" Vise

#53

Re: Oh, there's a dark streak, all right, ...

Patrick Gibbons

When I was in school the assumption was always that the idea, or argument, could stand or fall on its own merits. One never got personal with whomever you were talking. But the idea itself was fair game and subject to the harshest of attacks. You wrote a paper, presented an argument, you had better be prepared to defend it. Any creation is the same. The trouble begins when the creator mistakes criticism of the creation as criticism of the creator. The work is judged so that the worker can improve. Otherwise, no learning occurs.

Re: Alternative "Moxon" Vise

#54

Re: Oh, there's a dark streak, all right, ...

Patrick Gibbons

I forgot to mention that sometimes an unconventional stance was taken for the fun of seeing how far you could go. Once again, just like a project. You make something to explore its possibilities even if it is later rejected.

Re: Alternative "Moxon" Vise

#55

Re: You crashed my dictionary, AGAIN!


Re: Alternative "Moxon" Vise

#56

Re: Oh, there's a dark streak, all right, ...

david weaver

Following the method honestly is a good way both for the criticizer and the criticized to learn something and sharpen their analytical skills.

Pretending to follow that method (attacking the idea instead of the presenter of the idea) is the essence of internet trolling. Good trolling is no deviation from the method, pretending to never be frustrated, but that's rare.

Re: Alternative "Moxon" Vise

#57

Amen...

Ron in Kokomo

Do not come around here with a bunch of crap that you cannot defend. There are really good guys here who will cut up your post in the spirit that you just described. A little like grad school classes in philosophy. Honest inquiry is welcomed and encouraged. Declarations of truth get much more rigorous examination. I love it.

Re: Alternative "Moxon" Vise

#58

I sit here, deconstructed...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...although disarticulated may be the more accurate term*, and humbly accept your corrections, David. I'll do my best never to use the terms wrong again. This frees me up to make different mistakes.

And, to answer your rhetorical question: 58 years in California. Born in Oakland** 64 years ago, less two stints in the Midwest (and a little on the East Coast), three years each.

*Isn't "deconstruction" an early phase in remodeling?

**And, in spite of Gertrude Stein's condescension, Oakland does have a there, and kind of a nice one when I was growing up.

Re: Alternative "Moxon" Vise

#59

I have to agree with David

Bob Hackett

I think few people who put themselves out there as instructors have as much faith in the abilities of their students as they really should. I know that when I was receiving training to teach other people every class stressed teaching to the lowest common denominator. I quickly abandoned that approach as soon as they turned me loose into the real world and my students have always exceeded expectations because of it.

The light went on for me while visiting with my two brothers who are accomplished bowlturners (they tell me I used to be an accomplished bowl turner too). My older brother is also a very good spindle turner and after much practice there`s not much Bill can`t do with a skew chisel. He`s spent many hours trying to make me proficient as well with limited success. When my younger brother Tom decided to take on the skew chisel Bill and I were expecting much the same results as I had with it. We were both very surprised when Tom took to using the skew with vertually none of the problems both Bill and I had starting out. Seems Tom had watched a couple of videos the day before and didn`t realize that using the skew was supposed to be difficult. He had a basic understanding of how a chisel cuts from his bowlturning experience and until we told him of the potential pitfalls and I demonstrated a few catches and runaways (a specialty of mine) Tom had no idea why using this chisel should be any more difficult that using any other tool. Lesson learned on how to not complicate things.

Just because I or someone I know finds a technique or concept difficult to master doesn`t mean the person or persons in front of me needs to find it difficult as well. Many times I have demonstrated what I thought was an advanced technique to rank beginners only to have them immediately duplicate what took me many hours of practice to master. At they end of the day when I asked them how they feel about this the most common response has been "You made it look easy so we assumed it would be easy and it was". Years later I have successfully applied this "expect success" approach to teaching everything from Army basic training as a DI to working as an instructor in woodturning and metalworking classes as well as other more esoteric things.