We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Frank and I made five benches for an article in Woodworker's Journal about ten years ago. (Wow, has it been that long?) Anyhow, Frank's tradition is Eastern European (specifically Hungarian) and his style of bench is the one that his father and grandfather were used to, and the only one Frank will use.
I really like Shannon Rodgers joinery bench. I do understand the issue of the vise chop mating with the side of the bench and I respect Derek's position. But, the other plus factors call for me to do it Shannon's way if I have the floor space when I move from my current residence.
I have 4 routers, two skill saws, two boxes of tool steel, pin nailer, stapler, pad sander, Stanley 55 . two #4 and a 603 plane awaiting rehabilitation, angle grinder, three drills,a jig and a bunch of dust under my bench. The point is that everything has to be stored somewhere and where ever that is nothing else can occupy the same place. If one has room and sufficient needs I think it could be a handy shop addition for holding and flattening wide dovetailing needs. Just not in my situation for the few times a year I dovetail anything wide.
The end trestles are attached to the top with countersunk lag bolts.
The front and back rails are attached to the end trestles with bolts and captive nuts. In the second pic, the bolt is in backwards, I'm just checking for length.
I agree that the Internet can produce "experts" with very dubious credentials. I would not put Shannon in this category. I think it is evident that the classic bench of whatever persuasion is primarily a device to hold wood for planing. It can do other things, but many of them require compromise. Shannon and our own William, among others, have built smaller benches that stand a little taller, to make some of the other operations more ergonomic ally efficient. Shannon is doing some carving and finds the taller surface friendlier. I seems a no brainier for me if I can afford the footprint on the shop floor. As Bill points out, there are other, time honored, ways to accomplish shop tasks. I am six foot tall and I also think a taller bench would make some mortising jobs easier.
It goes for things like people touting their ideas, all the way down to groups of people saying yes to invitations they don't want to attend and they realistically have no obligation to.
There's a buddyism on some of the forums (not this one, though) where people post work and everyone says "GREAT!". And it's not. And as soon as someone says it's not, the social club faction complains loudly about the "rude comments" that are really just honest comments.
I have 24 fluorescent lamps, a home made air cleaner and drop plugs up there. And forget the shelves too. They are all piled with stuff I use, used to use, never have used, hope to use, and forgot its there. I am about to be embarrassed into a reorganization and yard sale.
His other site is The Hand Tool School. It is chock full of technique videos. I am a power tool guy who has built a lot of furniture and other than a few chairs, hand cut dovetails , and smoothing planes was my involvement with hand tools as far as being a real user. I did almost no woodworking for the past ten yeasr due to a variety of circumstances. I am back in the shop with a vengeance. I have recently given away 4 routers a table saw with Biesemeier fence, a jointer, and a pick up load of jigs and fixtures. I am committed to doing my woodworking by hand except for thicknessing and ripping for big projects. I kept a bandsaw and a small planer. Shannon's technique videos combined with a bunch of stuff from the Schwarz provide a very useful refresher course for me. Would I build the pieces that he builds? That is not a part of my thinking at this point. So very much of that is so subjective and is based on influences of which we may not even be aware. I could not live with a house full of Krenov stuff. But I honor him for many things that he showed me and the standards that he set. I read icons of the craft for inspiration. Is Shannon in that league? Of course not, and he would be the first to say so. But right now, for where I am, I find him useful.
"If you haven't got anything nice to say about anybody, come sit next to me."
No, I doubt you've got that dark streak, at least not any more than the rest of us
One of the harder things art teachers have to impart is the emotional difference between critique and criticism, in both the delivery and the receipt. Critique is vital, but learning how to offer or receive it without it being understood as criticism takes people time. A lot of the fora you and David mention are populated by people who've never learned that distinction.
I grew up in a household where things were pretty much said, good or bad, right away.
Some unintentional negative reinforcement mixed in with stuff that's well received as a chance for improvement isn't the worst thing in the world.
We had a term for out-of-family folks who only had positive things to say, which was gusher. I see that's an official dictionary entry but I haven't heard anyone use it lately. A gusher was viewed as a nuisance, as if you were listening to a radio ad when you talked to them, because you wouldn't learn much of anything.