New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

Posts

Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#1

Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

Bill Tindall

I am not fond of minimally finished walnut so I always stain it with a mineral pigment stain. But I am making something that will have holly string inlay( a first) so it can't be stained as I have done in the past or I will loose the holly contrast, I suppose. Plenty of stuff is made with holly inlay so there must be lots of experience out there. What are the finish options?

Specifically the inlay will be line and berry

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#2

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#3

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string in

roger lance

Bill....I'm no expert in this area (probably in no area).....but I've seen where the string inlay is first carefully coated with a layer of shellac using a fine artist's brush....then the field can be stained and the holly would be protected from absorbing the stain.

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#4

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string in

roger lance

Bill....try contacting Steve Latta who is an expert in string inlay....he teaches at a school in Pennsylvania and often writes articles in FWW....perhaps there is an e-mail address....if anyone knows, its him.

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#5

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string in

TomD

He has a video on the underhill site, possibly 2, I would imagine he covers that there.

http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/video/3100/3109.html

not in that one as far as I could see.

http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/video/2800/2811.html

or here

http://www.pbs.org/woodwrightsshop/video/2800/2810.html

nor here

Yeah, I think the other episode was 2003. But anyway, the answer is likely shellac.

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#6

Steve uses shellac

Bill Tindall

I have his video on line and berry and he doesn't mention a finish. However, I have heard him say that his line and berry spice chests are finished with shellac.

I got a schedule from a Period reproduction shop. They follow shellac with burnt umber glaze to richen up the walnut. Apparently the shellac seals the holly and keeps it from taking the glaze. I will need to experiment with this approach.

I tried a treatment with caustic. It made the walnut an unpleasant shade of brown and made the holly lesser brown. I didn't like it.

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#7

Not in my shop

Bill Tindall

Here are the facts.

Contrary to what I expected, significant amounts of chromate stay as chromate rather than converting to the benign form of chromium when it is applied to wood. It raises the grain. Next step is sanding and chromate dust is one of the few proven carcinogens.

Because of the paranoia about chromate the legal and regulatory zealots have become involved and there are many onerous regulations on storing and using chromate. Should a neighbor not like you and find out chromate is being used next door life could become unpleasant.

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#8

Re: Not in my shop

roger lance

I can't imagine any neighbor of yours not liking you.

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#9

I don't have any

Bill Tindall

or at least any I can see from here.

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#10

David Barnett

Not my cup o' tea, either.


Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#11

Re: Steve uses shellac

Roger Myers

Bill,

Another vote for shellac.

I do a lot of line and berry inlay of holly and walnut and generally finish with Seal Coat... First coat or two thinned 50%, followed by several stratight from the can. When I do feel the need to dye the wood (seldom in the case of walnut), I paint the strining with a coat of Seal Coat right from the can using a fine high quality artist brush.

I'm not sure how to post pics on here from the iPad and I am not near my pc, but if you go to my wordpress site you should be able to see several pics of holly on walnut finished this way... Look for the pics in the post about the family boxes. Site is strathamwood.com/wordpress

Roger

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#12

Re: Steve uses shellac

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That's some really nice work, Roger! Very good process pics, too.

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#13

Re: Steve uses shellac

barryvabeach

I have done a fair amount of string inlay, with both mahogany and walnut in the field. After several different attempts, with limited success, I find that the best approach for me is to complete the piece and sand it, stain the field, apply shellac to the field, then the top coats of finish. When everything is dry, I then cut the slots for the string inlay, then glue in the inlay, trim it flush with chisels and card scrapers. There are some areas where I have trimmed too deep and removed some of the stain from the field, in those areas I tape off the inlay, and using an artist brush, apply the stain, shellac and finish to the field. When that is done, I take off the tape, and I use an artist brush to apply shellac to the inlay, which should prevent any stain from migrating onto the inlay, then spray finish on the whole piece. This is a photo of a sideboard I am working on. The inlay on the drawers was done this way. Mahogany veneer, medium walnut transfast dye, blonde shellac, then several coats of water based top coat.


img

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#14

Re: Steve uses shellac

roger lance

Welcome Sir !.....beautiful.....beautiful work !!

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#15

Re: Steve uses shellac

Bruce, a MN Galoot

That's a very nice piece of work.

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#16

Re: Steve uses shellac

Barry Vabeach

Thanks Bruce and Roger, I have been working on it about a year and a half, and am almost done - just need to finish the cock beading on the doors, and the top. I made tons of mistakes, the miters on a number of the inlay corners aren't exactly right, and would look pretty weak on a jewelry box or spice box, but the good news is with a piece this large, you just see the overall piece, not the many errors. Barry.

Re: Finish options for walnut with holly string inlay

#17

Re: Steve uses shellac

roger lance

Barry....Welcome to the discussions....see the tread below about people making things and showing their work, you've done just what we want to encourage....as to mistakes in your work, there are certainly mistakes in my stuff and usually I'm the only one that knows about it....but I seem to look at those flaws when I see an old piece I've done....must be part of the creative process that we are all drawn to....looking forward to updates as you bring this piece to its completion.