New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

Posts

Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#1

Michael Donaldson

Sharpening:  The next chapter in the saga

Michael Donaldson

So after my previous confession on this forum relating to my...um...infrequent sharpening, I followed some of the advice I was given and looked up Paul Sellers sharpening technique. I noted that he used diamond stones, which I have had a lot of interest in for a long time, and that his technique seemed fairly easy, and was consistent with edges I have observed on tools I have been given by master craftsmen (my bench chisel was a gift from Bob Smalser). So I figured I would give it a try sometime in the future...

Well, I went to woodcraft today, and they were having a sale of 15% off everything in the store, and I could not resist the DMT continuous diamond stones. For the first time, I actually want to get home and sharpen something! When my wife finds out I spent over $200 at woodcraft today perhaps I can use my very sharp hand tools to make myself a dog house...

Re: Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#2

Re: Sharpening

roger lance

Don't forget to say, "But honey, I saved $30 !!" Might make your doghouse stay shorter....maybe :D .

Re: Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#3

Re: Sharpening:  The next chapter in the saga

Arch_E

Well, after I sharpened a few kitchen knives with my new water $tone$, my dog house time got cut way down. :)

Re: Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#4

Re: Sharpening:  The next chapter in the saga

david weaver

I don't know what the continuous stones are, but generally, I would avoid buying anything DMT or diamonds in general from woodworking retailers. Even at 15% off, they'll be higher than you can find them new on ebay or amazon, or at knife supply places.

If the sellers method works for you, that's all that counts. Every method works, whether it's the hand grinding method that sellers has, the methodical work-up through the grits that some folks like, or microbevels or implicitly doing that with one coarse stone and one very fine stone, lifting the item being sharpened just slightly on the fine stone (that's just microbeveling, without the guide).

The only key no matter what method you use is experience.

Re: Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#5

Re: Sharpening:  The next chapter in the saga

TomD

I was mentally doodling the other day, and thinking that these days one can very nearly never lay down a hard and fast rule for anything. Partly it is stuff like that the internet opens one up to many solutions. But with something like sharpening where a person might at one time have had access only to a few stone types, today there are so many products that there is always a method or product to complement any approach taken.

Re: Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#6

Michael Donaldson

Re: Sharpening:  The next chapter in the saga

Michael Donaldson

The one (only) thing I know for sure about sharpening is that there are a very large number of correct ways to do it. What I really want is one that I can use in my shop, which has no running water, and will work quickly. Being at the beginning of my sharpening journey, I figured I would make the significant investment in the diamond stones, and get really good at it.

On a side note, I am willing to pay a little extra to get my stuff from woodcraft (the only woodworking store in my area) because I want it to stay in business. There are a lot of things I could get cheaper from Amazon, but I try to support my local specialty retailers.

Re: Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#7

Re: Sharpening:  The next chapter in the saga

Arch_E

I really appreciate your buy-local attitude!

Here's a few facts on sharpening; I hope they save you some money....

Water stones are faster than oil stones but are a bit messier yet provide better feel and feedback

Not all water stones are equal.

Water stones provide a more refined cutting/honed edge than diamond hones but it takes more waterstones to do this than diamond stones; and WS will last longer with heavy-handed honing than DS.

Not all diamond stones are equal.

Once you "arrive" at the point of repeatably getting edges sharp, the secondary issues will become more important to you--like dish resistance, wear resistance, tactile feel and feedback, soaking vs. non-soaking, length of pre-soaking, ease of flattening, how often during sharpening you must reflatten, how hard or soft the stone cuts, how much noise the stone makes, and how many stones it will take to achieve what you want.

Hence,THIS IS A VERY PERSONAL ISSUE--choose, use, and enjoy what you can afford.

Re: Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#8

Re: Sharpening:  The next chapter in the saga

CStan

Lord God, please help this man avoid the morass in which is he about to become entangled.

Re: Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#9

Re: Sharpening:  The next chapter in the saga

david weaver

Maybe a statement like that opens the doors to stop hearing ridiculous things, like "how long it takes to hone A2". I hope that nobody who uses aluminum oxide hones, which is probably the vast majority, sees that and believes it.

You're right, everyone has to talk like a politician if they don't want direct disagreement. If you say something definite, it's certain to get stuck right away.

Re: Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#10

He could turn to women and booze....

roger lance

both significantly cheaper :D .

Re: Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#11

Re: Sharpening:  The next chapter in the saga

William Duffield

Whoa, Charles! We try to refrain from such subjects as religion and politics here. But if we followed that rule strictly, we wouldn't be allowed to discuss sharpening.

Re: Sharpening: The next chapter in the saga

#12

Re: He could turn to women and booze....

CStan

Without a doubt.