Hear, hear!
Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat
#26
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Hear, hear!
Re: Sharpening..
david weaver
The worst part is you'd read every word of it, the longer it was, the more angry you'd get, and the harder it would be for you to resist reading.
...cue "i wouldn't read it at all statement, I don't know how I know all of the details in your previous sharpening posts" 
Re: The joint's a-jumpin'
david weaver
If mine went out, I'd be a lot less nice, too.
But for now, it feels like I'm having a conversation with my mother...one that I've had 1000 times before on the same subject.
Re: Sharpening..
CStan
It would be like watching a train wreck unfold from a distance. It appears to be moving in slow motion and you just cannot take your eyes off it.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: Sharpening..
david weaver
That sums up about every conversation that the two of us have been in. I don't remember it any other way except for the marples thread months ago, and even at that, there was enough other traffic that it was still a slow train wreck. I just got to watch without spending any for fuel since the two of us actually agreed.
At least that's my point of view as an avid slow train wreck fan.
Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat
CStan
One item, just something, please, to back up your opinion that he's a huckster.
I'll bet Peter Follansbee doesn't think he's a huckster.
Re: Remember in "The Quiet Man"...
CStan
Well, we've done that for sure but I think 'ole Stephen was poking a stick at us with the topic he selected.
When I saw his post, I laughed and thought his sense of comedic timing impeccable.
Oh, and don't ye be thinkin' otherwise
Re: Sharpening..
CStan
Let's focus on Sellers, shall we?
Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat
david weaver
I don't know if peter follansbee talks about the discontentment of others and the ills of society that have resulted as a result of departure from craft, which is sort of goofy reasoning to me in the first place.
If he's providing content, presenting an ill, and then offering a solution, I suppose it's the same thing.
It's just so much easier to tolerate when you don't attempt to sell someone into thinking the sale is the result the solution to something negative, as opposed to a stand-alone positive thing.
I'd put peter in the same basket with tools, perhaps he's a lot more frugal yet than sellers, because he's not using power tools as far as I know. the most negative thing I've seen peter say is "it doesn't make sense to spend two hours trying to figure out how to fake a panel with a router that takes 1 hour to carve." that's hardly negative.
I like peter's blog quite a bit actually, it's the only one I ever read. Good pick.
Re: Sharpening..
david weaver
we're in the wrong thread for that...this is stephen's thread 
Charles and David
Stephen Shepherd
This is fun why don't you two guys show up tonight and continue this discussion in the CHAT ROOM.
Stephen
Re: Charles and David
david weaver
here i opened this post and thought for sure that we were about to get scolded.
It'll depend on where I am and what I'm doing. If i'm awake, I may show up, but warning that I don't do anything interesting when it comes to cutting mortises, I just get out a mortise chisel and follow the method presented in robert wearing's book.
I thought we were going to talk about mortises
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: You were right, Charles
david weaver
Charles and I are good for business about the same way Tiger Woods is good for publicity at a PGA event.
Except neither of us is as good at anything as Tiger is at golf.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Nice parry
Re: I haven't been to chat in ages...
david weaver
I think if charles and I would show up, we'd have a failure to perform. It's already been my max effort to actually repeat things on threads. I hate repeating and clarifying about as much as I hate to stop in the middle of work and check it. But I can't avoid that, either.
Charles might have a fixed air conditioner by then and be real rosy....well, rosy might be pushing it. Maybe quiet.
This is why I have a hollow chisel mortiser.....
roger lance
less controversy
.
The chat room is always open
Ellis Walentine
I suggest that if you and Charles need to air your differences further, that you do it there in real time, or via e-mail, or somewhere besides the public forum. When I come up for air here, I will be parking this thread in our off-site parking lot. Please, let's keep it civil from now on.
Meanwhile, everyone is invited to the chat tonight, and constructive participation is welcome.
Thanks guys.
Ellis
Re: Charles and David
CStan
Well, the hucksters who were working on my air conditioner have finished and the house is cooling by the moment. The proof is in the puddin' I suppose.
I'm about to start dinner - we're tired of eating out. I'm going to run to the store for the ingredients, get a nice bottle of wine, and have something that resembles a civilized evening. You guys will have to do it without me.
Re: You were right, Charles
TomD
"Except neither of us is as good at anything as Tiger is at golf. "
For any of us, that pretty much doesn't need to be said. I think the risk of being misled in that direction is pretty small.
Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat
TomD
"That's huckstering. Lots of people do it, like I said below, it's not bad on its own. It is the objection to industrialization and productivity at the expense of craft while reaping a better life due to the increased disposable income from industrialization.
It happens all over the woodworking world, including one-off furniture makers. "here...looky...industrially produced furniture is ruining everything. I will make you a piece of furniture in the traditional way, and you'll pay me for something the middle and upper middle classes never would've been able to afford if we all did traditional woodwork".
Same thing. Huckstering."
I don't really see those as contradictory or particularly huckstering. Who says positions like arts and craft, or modern day craft against industrial views are absolutes. Mostly this kind of thing is only at the margins, it is pretty much impossible to be pure. As you say. These stances are reactionary they are the less than 1% reaction to the dominant culture that forms them in the first place. The world is full of relaxing nature walks that start with a miserable drive on some expressway, burning a lot of gas.