New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

Posts

Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#1

Stephen Shepherd

Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

Stephen Shepherd

It is Tuesday and once again we plan to spend our evening discussing HAND TOOLS and related subjects. Tonight I thought we should talk about the mortise and how it is made.

The fun all starts at 9:30 o'clock PM Eastern Time and runs for one scheduled hour.

Just click on CHAT ROOM on the left and join in.

All are welcome, hope to see you there.

Stephen Shepherd

Host - Hand Tool Chat

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#2

Re: Charles and I peaked too soon!!


Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#3

David Barnett

Mortising? That's so last hour. 


Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#4

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

CStan

Why don't you send an invitation to Paul Sellers to join in and make this whole thing something worth tuning into?

I think he needs to clear his name with regard to this forum. He's accused in a thread below of being a huckster, presumably, because he chops mortises with a Blue Chip and makes his living, or part of it at least, running a woodworking school, writing books, and making videos and has the audacity to promote his school and, by extension, himself and his woodworking bona fides.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#5

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

david weaver

Most of those bits there were said only by you charles.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#6

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

CStan

You said the man was a huckster after you read his blog. Why?

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#7

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

david weaver

See definition below in our original thread.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#8

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

CStan

We need to bring more outsiders in on what has become incestuous little chats with all the usual suspects in attendance. These are mostly rehashes from other threads and 'same-old-same-old.'

Let's liven it up.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#9

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

CStan

Do us a favor and re-articulate that here. This forum software becomes difficult to navigate.

That's a pretty serious gauntlet to have thrown down. It would be helpful if you'd be willing to provide additional color and support.

Thanks.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#10

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

CStan

I have to be honest David in admitting to not having read much of Sellers' blog. Maybe you'd be willing to link to a few of the entries you found disturbing or maybe provide quotes (though in context, please).

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#11

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

david weaver

Jeez, charles, if you're curious just read through it - if you're into that kind of message, maybe you'll like it. I'm not going to go back and restate posts, I feel like I said the same thing over and over 6 times already.

I have trouble with sellers' blog, anyway, it takes forever for it to load. I don't know if it's a compatiblity issue with my browser or what, but his isn't the only blog that troubles it, though his does the worst. (what that amounts to is that it's not awful to wait for everything to work itself out if you're reading something interesting, but if you were going to navigate around through dozens or hundreds of entries to find stuff, it'd be torturous).

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#12

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

david weaver

Charles, it's just stating what is, it's not "throwing down".

I'd consider it no worse compared to the accusation that retailers are recreating history to sell you tools - except I could actually find the information that i cited on the blog while you're arguing supposition against what joel seems to be offering as a little more historically based (and it's not like it's only joel, that's just this time).

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#13

Re: Sharpening..

david weaver

..i think if I read between the lines, Charles was requesting to have a discussion about sharpening, too.... let's call it "sharpening mortise chisels of different steels, and how you can apply the hanging hair test"

:b

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#14

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

CStan

David, I don't have a problem with Sellers. I've read a little bit of the blog and found nothing objectionable. Like most woodworkers, he has a stance and an opinion. I've met few that don't.

But this isn't about me - I just need to understand what you read that rises to the level of labeling the man a huckster. Maybe there's something creepy in there I missed. Just link to it. What's the big deal?

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#15

Re: Sharpening..

CStan

Well, there would be no need to have a chat about sharpening. You could do a monologue on this I'm sure.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#16

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

CStan

I just read the biography posted on his blog and he says he had his first job in woodworking in a joiner's shop in 1965.

Did you read his biography? It doesn't appear to be embellished but I don't know that for sure. Do you think he's misrepresented himself?

I'm looking at this thing on the whole, the blog and the videos, and I honestly don't get what's wrong with the picture. I'll grant he does a few things in a bit of an unorthodox way but I find it refreshing, not hucksterism.

You're coming across a bit like Elsworth Toohey to his Howard Roark - crucifying the poor guy for having a mind of his own and not swimming with the rest of the school.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#17

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#18

Re: Laughed out loud

CStan

Unfortunately for David our central air conditioner went out a few days ago and the HVAC guys have been here all day installing a new outside unit. I don't have a whole lot to do, but need to be around. I did have to chainsaw a shrub that was in their way. That was fun.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#19

Re: Laughed out loud

CStan

Thanks be to Ellis Wallentine!

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#20

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

david weaver

me: "selling the message of simple life in the blog, not into it"

charles: "I don't see that in the video"

me: "it's not in the video, it's on the blog"

charles: "gauntlet, throw down, chain mail armor, morning star, lance"

me: "it's in the blog"

charles: "can you link the posts in the blog"

me: "no, hard to link"

charles: "i don't see it in the biography"

New name: "Charles 'i don't read no steenkin chronological blog entries' stanford"

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#21

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

CStan

Well, whatever David.

That's it? That's what you got?

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#22

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

CStan

Please tell us what makes the man a huckster.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#23

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

david weaver

Read the huckster definition. It goes like this, summarized as i interpret it:

* we've become detached from craft

* i do a lot of craft, I can teach you how to do craft

* here's a picture of my students having a good time at my classes in the UK

* tools are bad, because of industrialization

* we need to get back to craft, it'll make us more fulfilled. People that don't do what I do seem to be less fulfilled (these seem to be straw people. I wouldn't trade what I do to work wood in a million years, I don't work with my hands).

* it's a shame this nice stuff at the castle is tied to wealth

* here's a few blog entries in a row showing my classes in the US, I can teach you how to do craft

Seems simple enough. Rail against the lack of fulfillment, offer solution, attach it to presentation of classes and other purchased items.

That's huckstering. Lots of people do it, like I said below, it's not bad on its own. It is the objection to industrialization and productivity at the expense of craft while reaping a better life due to the increased disposable income from industrialization.

It happens all over the woodworking world, including one-off furniture makers. "here...looky...industrially produced furniture is ruining everything. I will make you a piece of furniture in the traditional way, and you'll pay me for something the middle and upper middle classes never would've been able to afford if we all did traditional woodwork".

Same thing. Huckstering.

Works on the positive side, too. "Here, you have problems sharpening your tools with vintage stones. Here are newer easier to use stones and a power grinder. Now go sharpen quickly and well and do woodwork. "

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#24

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

david weaver

Charles, sometimes I can't tell if you do it on purpose, or if it just comes naturally.

Re: Tuesday Night Hand Tool Chat

#25

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)