New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

Posts

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#51

Re: by the way..

david weaver

Hopefully, you can find that there is a vast majority, otherwise someone would draw the same conclusion about western chisels the first time someone advocated a 35 degree microbevel.

Of course, that would make about the same amount of sense.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#52

A2 maybe?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Charles,

You may be referring to LN's instructions on sharpening A2 chisels. 30 degree bevel and 5 degree micro bevel.

Wiley

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#53

Point of information

wilbur

Here's some data on the composition of the more common western and Japanese tool steels.


Overall, the Japanese steels have anywhere from 10-40% more carbon content than O-1 or A-2, which probably has something to do with the carbides that are formed, and less alloying agents for the most part, with the exception of tungsten in both types of blue steel. On the other hand, blue steel has considerably less chromium than A-2.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#54

Re: Point of information

Kees

And also considerably less Sulphur in the Japanese steel, which is a good thing!'

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#55

Re: by the way..

wilbur

Well, whatever somebody said, I can say that for the Japanese chisels that I have, the paring chisels are somewhere below 25º, the bench chisels are about 30º, and the only Japanese chisels that I have that are at 35º are my mortise chisels.

I'm pretty sure that's more or less in line with how people set up western chisels for these purposes.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#56

Re: Point of information

david weaver

That's the key, less sulfur and less silicon.

The carbon and chromium swap pretty much evens out in terms of edge retention as long as blue steel is brought to the same hardness.

But the wear is much finer and more even. So despite the edge retention being the same, the surface quality on a smoother is much better with blue steel when the plane has been used a fair bit already. I can't tolerate a lot of A2 smoothers after they're about 1/3-1/2 dull, they leave marks in raking light like someone pulled wire across the surface.

But a blue steel iron you can use right up to dull if you'd like.

I have less of a preference for blue steel in rough planing where the result doesn't matter (i'd be indifferent at that, I guess)

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#57

History of Hitachi Metals *LINK*

wilbur

It looks like Hitachi Metals was in production going back to the beginning of the 20th century.

There's some more information about the Hitachi Metals Yasugi Works, which is the arm of the company that deals with more "traditional" steels here: http://www.hitachi-metals.co.jp/e/tatara/nnp0301.htm


History of Hitachi Metals

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#58

Re: Point of information

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Wilbur, you call O-1 and A-2 "more common western tool steels", but in my experience most companies that make chisels still do not tell us what the steel is, so these charts are not much help. Do know the steel for any of these bench chisels: Marples, Hirsch or Two Cherries, Narex, H Taylor, Ashley Isles, Footprint, Stubai, Sorby, Stanley, Buck Brothers, Crown, Barr, MHG,Wood River, Pfeil, and others?

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#59

Re: Point of information

wilbur

Well, I think it's a fair statement that when western chisel makers identify the steel used in making chisels or plane blades, O-1 or A-2 are the more common types identified, Lee Valley's new and upcoming offerings notwithstanding.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#60

Re: Chrome Vanadium

david weaver

With the exception of the carving tools (and they may not be the exception at all), all of the ones you've mentioned are probably chrome vanadium of some concoction, right? It's probably a lot cheaper than a2 or O1. O1 is the closest thing we have to a good plain carbon chisel steel.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#61

Re: Chrome Vanadium

TomD

O1 is a good steel for stock reduction, because it comes in very accurate finished stock due to being ground for gauge use. Many of the tools made by larger makers are forged, so there would be little reason to prefer O1 to that, other than the fact that it is now a brand.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#62

Re: by the way..  The real reason

TomD

While Japanese chisels have whatever use, if one thinks classically, bench chisels/dovetails; mortise chisels/mortise; timber chisels/mortises. And the edges might be 25, 30-35, 25. In essence all these uses are the same. You take the chisel and you whack it into a piece of wood. In the case of Japanese chisels for the most part, energetic prying is not the way you do it. So my thought is that when cutting the 30-35 degree angle has nothing to do with edge chipping, which is not experienced in any novel way between the various uses. It has to do with the aspect ratio of the mortise being cut. If you cut it as they do you need the wider angle to get the correct entry angles for the mortises. But this is not what you have in the other two cases so the angles are different. Thus the higher the aspect ratio of the mortise, the lower the angle you want the bevel.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#63

Re: Point of information

TomD

It used to be said that it was hard to make use of more than 1% carbon, which is why a lot of serious cutting tools are made of steel with 90 points. The stuff that can be going on it often a lot more complex that simple rules. You can certainly get stuff really hard with less.

One thing that might be worth considering is whether steels with the same chemical composition are in fact the same steels. Could there not be differences in steels in which assembly was done differently, in different order, with different conditions.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#64

Re: Tungsten and Vanadium

TomD

"I've used hard(er) steels before, just not Japanese made tools. All is right with the world until the SOBs chip."

Chipping is a bad sign, and often means tool abuse. I rarely otherwise have chips. I hate them also, and have hand ground out some dousies. I don't have problems with chipping in Japanese tools. And they are relatively easy to sharpen. The thing is that you can work wood without Japanese tools. It is largely a luxury product of sorts, in the hands of weekend warriors. But the fact that one does not need them, or would prefer not to have to consider them, does not change how they are. It is both hooey to over promote, or under rate tools. It is the same thing to oversell tools based on no experience and just having read the promos, as it is to under rate them on the same basis.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#65

My chest of drawers analogy

wilbur

I do think that how the steel is processed in making a tool has as much to do, if not more, than its composition in terms of how it performs.

I've made this analogy before, but it bears repeating. Worrying about buying a tool based on whether it's made of O-1, A-2, white steel, or blue steel is kind of like buying a chest of drawers based on whether it's made of cherry or walnut. To some extent, it doesn't matter. Charles Stanford, TomD, and Warren Mickley will do a far better job of it than I will.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#66

Re: Chrome Vanadium

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think it is preposterous to lump all these chisels together as O1 or as "chrome vanadium". These manufacturers do not tell us the composition of their tools, but we know from experience that the steel can be very different. The only tools I have seen identified as O1 were not even forged.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#67

Re: Chrome Vanadium

david weaver

Well, until someone tells us what they are, all we know is Chrome Vanadium vs. O1.

If you want to know what a modern chisel maker has in their chisels, you'll drive yourself nuts, won't you?

I don't know if I've heard of any tools being O1 and forged, have you? How is the steel made before it's ground, is it rolled, and is the grain structure packed just as part of the process?

It's easier to find a lot of turning tools that look like they're just cut from stock, few are forged, right? Presumably the O1 chisels are also in that category? Even the O1 chisels that look to me to be ground from flat stock seem to fare pretty well in use.

I'd guess the chrome vanadium stuff is drop forged, but I don't know and I don't care much, because many are cheaper than I can get O1 stock to begin with.

Do you know the composition of the steel in your vintage chisels?

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#68

Re: Chrome Vanadium

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I gather that chrome vanadium steel has a chrome content near 1%, but can have various carbon percentages. I think we are in the dark with a lot of chisels and that many manufacturers are happy to keep it that way. I think it is foolish to talk about the composition of "the more common western tool steels" when we are so in the dark.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#69

Re: Chrome Vanadium

david weaver

I suppose I figured that anyone who saw the word chrome vanadium steel would describe it as unknown, but something that had chromium and vanadium carbides added.

I doubt there is any benefit to the user over a cleaner plain carbon steel, other than maybe it's cheaper to make tools with chrome vanadium steel because the stock is cheaper and it makes it easier to heat treat them by induction hardening.

But I don't worry about it too much. I'd imagine most manufacturers don't make the data available because the customers they're targeting don't care. In the case of someone like two cherries, who calls their steel secret, if I were talking to them, I'd ask them why it's such a big secret when the steel they use is passable but not that great.

I guess the one benefit I've seen to the mystery chrome vanadium tools is that they rust less. Maybe that was a consideration in the past. I don't think we're going to see plain carbon steel tools again, though because beginners probably wouldn't be able to care for them, and the number of people who want them is probably limited mostly to folks who use japanese tools (where you can still get such a thing and know what the steel is).

If a US maker decided to forge weld white #2 to something, they could make a very nice chisel. But I guess one would wonder what they'd forge weld it to in the US.

I am at the point where I won't buy any chisel from any maker if I don't know the composition of the steel no matter what it is, unless it's really cheap. So there are at least two of us. But how many more do you think there are?

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#70

Re: Packing and forging

TomD

"I don't know if I've heard of any tools being O1 and forged, have you? How is the steel made before it's ground, is it rolled, and is the grain structure packed just as part of the process?"

If you mean packing the way I have heard that, it is apparently nonsense. This is one of those things that gets savaged if one mentions it around blacksmiths with a technical bent. Of course it does not mean that what they are doing when they think they are packing does not have a beneficial effect. It might well.

Quite a lot of people forge O1, in tools the only current person I know is Barr. There used to be another, the guy who made those spokeshaves out of solid bar. He may still do it, I just lost track. The Barr O1 tools I bought were bought around 97. The edge holding was not good, and I know he was working on it, so I would expect that in this amount of time he would have improved them. That said, I really like his chisels and spokeshaves. His chisels are almost my favourite, and his spokeshave is my favorite modern one, though the handle is not as I would do it. But still better than most.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#71

Re: Packing and forging

Kees

Clifton forges their irons. They start with a round bar of O1. And then hammer it flat. There should be a how-it's-made video somewhere.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#72

What the Super Blue is like so far.

David Weaver

..only got to sharpen the iron, didn't fit it to the dai yet.

Reminds me a lot of the blue cutting steel that yamamoto uses, but the kamaji is softer than the yamamoto plane (that plane itself was only $170, so it wouldn't be surprising if the kamaji is a better softer grade on a plane that's normally about 3-4 times as much).

a bit more slick and greasy on the stones than my carbon steel irons (the plainer carbon steel give you a real sense that the stones are biting in hard). I have a suita that cuts the super blue, and doesn't cut the blue cutting steel well, but at the same time, the shapton 1k cuts the blue cutting steel like butter, and this super blue iron it cuts fine, but without the aggressive filing feeling you get with most steels.

The suita is not super fine, but it is fine, and it's easily in reach that a couple of swipes of chromium powder on horse leather will make it super sharp without dubbing it.

It'll be interesting to see how it holds up, especially after it's been honed a few times. It seems like a nice iron, but not quite as artsy as the mosaku, and not quite as hard (subjectively). Maybe a little more experience with the two will prove me wrong.

I do get so much satisfaction from experimenting with the different planes, but I wish I could resist buying them. I think the powder metal planes will surpass them if they haven't already, but I like so much dealing with the all of these different more traditional steels.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#73

Re: What the Super Blue is like so far.

CStan

About half of what you wrote was unintelligible to me and I don't know whether to be ashamed of it or proud of it. You know your stuff. I assume it's worth knowing. Cheers.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#74

Re: What the Super Blue is like so far.

david weaver

It's esoteric, and only of interest to someone who's used the steel before.

It's too expensive to ever say anything like "I think this is something people should have".

It doesn't solve my two biggest problems, though, which are standing around getting a mental block about what will look good, and then figuring out how to mark it.

But the different steels themself are interesting, and after a session with it last night, it is definitely tough, definitely hard, and it takes an edge like an old carbon steel.

When I find something that makes designing easy and prevents people from making ugly original furniture and ugly original tools, I'll let you know. Until then, I've only got esoteria to satisfy my curiosity.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#75

Re: What the Super Blue is like so far.

CStan

Please do let me know because my designs are notoriously ugly and ill-proportioned. I just don't have that gift.