Re: It is more that just what is there
TomD
"How much of what you say is simply due to the steel being hardened to a higher RC value?"
I don't know, that is the question I was raising. At one time I guess I thought it was a lot because they said how hard the steel is, and how it had to be welded to softer iron to survive. But having seen tests where in theory the three cherries wasn't 10 points off but two, while the observed degree of separation of performance was reportedly the same, and huge, I no longer know. Another vexing thing is the cycle thing. These steels are not only longer lasting, but sharper, and easier to sharpen. Accross the board performance that if hardness were the only thing some of that would run against the results.
Also, while one could say it is just subjective and hooey, My own experience doesn't support that. Not all the tools I have bought have been equally pleasing. Some I had high hope for I ended up being disappointed in while others I had no great expectations for were exceptional. Some of both the good and the bad are cheap or expensive.
"Am I wrong when I say that these steels are made by very, very large industrial concerns?"
You are correct the white and blue steel are the colour of the wrappers these steels are sold in from hitachy. Just as O1 comes in a dull brown wrapper -Brown Paper Steel
.
What I don't personally know about white and blue is whether hitachi makes them for what they are used for, or like brown, they are made for something else. In Japan, there is enough interest in blades that Hitachi could be making purpose built steels for all the knives, scissors, planes, razors, etc... O1 and A2 are not produced for those markets, and they have "toxins" in them relative to tool use.
" I think that there might be an impression in the marketplace that old Japanese gentlemen are making this steel themselves. They buy it from industrial suppliers just like the rest of us can (could), right?"
In the case of industrial steels which is the large part of it, they do just buy them from industrial suppliers. But Maloof bought his wood from the same place you did/could, and with steel there is actually arguably a lot more you can do with it that you can wood. For instance just welding it to iron completely changes how it heat treats.
That said, I, and others, will tell you that there are cheap Japanese tools out there that are better. In my as objective as I can be opinion of using tools from many different places, I have several complete national sets, and manufacturers within nations. Every Japanese tool is better than every other tool. I used to want to believe that to some extent, but these days, a lot of the tool I use are ones I made. I'm a competitor in my own shop, just the way it is. The point being that some of the benefits of these tools can be had from industrial produced versions. Japanese saws have taken over even at home depot, and those are mass produced resistance hardened tools.
Also, some of these guys do make their own steel for certain special tools, though that is more an exercise in art, in my opinion, not an exercise in making what the market wants. I might be wrong. They are certainly too expensive for every day use.