New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

Posts

Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#1

Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

david weaver

Does anyone have a moderate amount of experience for using blue super in western hardwoods?

I guess I should've asked this question before buying a plane with blue super, I'd assume it will be eclipsed by HSS at some point, but I see conflicting accounts about the steel itself, most centering around how fine of an edge it takes and how hard it is to sharpen.

I don't know what I intend to use it for, but it was at a price I couldn't pass up and curiosity got the best of me.

I already have planes in various blue, white, swedish and one of the lower toughness togo steels (inukubi). The plane I have in white #1 is actually the hardest thing I have to sharpen because the blacksmith tempered it to extreme hardness.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#2

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello David and all,

I had a Funahiro plane blade in super blue steel. Not the vacuum process. Also, 12mm and 30mm Funahiro slicks in super blue steel.

It will take and hold an excellent edge. However. I found this steel a bear to sharpen on Shapton stones, for example. You can tell something about it from the composition:

http://zknives.com/knives/steels/steelgraph.php?nm=Aogami%201%2CAogami%202%2CAogami%20Super

Like blue steel #1, it's a tungsten steel with chromium, but has more tungsten. It also is alloyed with molybdenum and vanadium. I eventually was given by a friend a natural stone that would cut it (and HSS) pretty well.

I still have the chisels. I hollow grind them on Tormek, right to a burr. Then use that natural stone followed by Lee Valley 0.3micron chromium green paper. Chromium green is a good final hone on all the real toughies like 3V, M2, and super blue. (BTW, the most miserable steel to sharpen I ever saw was Holtey S53. It sets the curve, for me at least.)

Don't know about your experience, but I don't like diamond paste on Japanese steel, because the blue and white seem to chip due to the high RC tempering hitting the hard diamond. However, you might try a real fine diamond like 1/4-micron as a final hone on the super blue. Because of the high alloy, I suspect it would not chip and of course you could examine the edge as you go.

I think you'll like it, once you get a sharpening routine down.

Wiley

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#3

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

david weaver

Wiley, thanks for the thorough response - I did think it was odd that there was an individual or two who called it easy to sharpen.

I agree completely on diamonds and harder white and blue (I have spared my better irons from it). I don't feel like the edge is ever quite where I want it to be (probably because it's being abused by diamonds on a hard surface), even on 1/2 micron diamonds (i have powder to a tenth, but i can't see using it when there is other suitable stuff).

I have no microscopic proof of that, but I do get a better edge from natural stones than I do from 1/2 micron diamonds, and I know the natural stone particles are much larger than 1/2 micron - they are just more dull and gentle compared to diamonds.

I did notice a predictable issue with japanese chisels on coarser loose diamond a long time ago (predictable now that I did it). The kamaji grabbed the diamonds and used them to scratch up the kanaban I had them on. Short term lapse to not not think about how soft wrought iron is, and how it would win the battle against mild steel. I'd assuming that's probably happening on softer steels, too.

For a final medium, I like so much better what 1/2 micron chromium oxide powder on a surface with just a little give will do for very hard steels - it's almost magic.

I do use shaptons, so I'll probably have to forego that - fortunately I have some other synthetic finishers that will be worth trying (courtesy of stu, and others from naniwa). I'm assuming that if shaptons don't like it, natural stones are probably out of the question for anything other than possibly final finish.

Thanks again for the experienced input.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#4

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

TomD

I don't have a comment except to say BS normally strikes me as fairly HSS like to start with.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#5

Missed the Natural Stone Comment..

david weaver

..missed reading the first read-through that someone provided a natural stone that would cut it.

Presumably something soft, like a tomae strata stone, or something like a hiderayama mine stone?

My natural stones are generally harder (nakayama and oozuku, generally), and they like simple steels a lot. When things get more complicated than that, they won't cut much at all without a slurry.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#6

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

david weaver

Does BS refer to Blue Steel or Blue Super?

Blue Steel itself (I only have it in chisels, except for a swedish blue concoction that feels more like plain carbon) is hard to compare to any 60 hardness steel if it's at 65 hardness or something.

Mosaku is the blacksmith who did my #1 white steel plane - if I didn't know it was white steel, I'd not guess it after a few minutes on the stone because it is so hard.

Blue #1 and blue #2 are fairly plain, though, and without 65 hardness (often combined with a subpar backing metal on cheaper tools), they'd probably be pretty pedestrian on most stones.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#7

Re: Missed the Natural Stone Comment..

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David,

This particular stone I don't know how to characterize. It came out of a big pile that a widow up in the Bay Area was selling off piecemeal to people who had patronized her husband while he was alive. It's not magic, but does cut better than Shapton on high alloy steel.

The thing is, you don't need a great stone. Try what you have. You're just trying to get close enough to an edge that you can go to the CrO paper. That's where, as you say, the real magic happens. I have never found anything that gave a finer edge on alloy steel than the 0.3micron LV paper--of course, there's a world of stuff I don't know about.

What CrO does to high alloy steel makes me subscribe to Bill Tindall's and I think Larry Williams' hypothesis that dulling and sharpening are--or can be--two distinct processes, rather than being the flip sides of the same coin.

Wiley

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#8

I'd like to ask Tom

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

whether his blue steel comments apply to Tasai-san? His chisels seem to me to sharpen easily, disproportionate to their edge holding.

Wiley

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#9

Once again......

Bill Tindall

The typical failure of a "struck" chisel edge is not by abrasive wear so it is not surprising to find lack of correlation between ease of sharpening and edge life for a chisel.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#10

Tungsten and Vanadium

CStan

...sounds like a Record plane iron.....

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#11

Re: I'd like to ask Tom

TomD

Most of my info is from 30 years ago. I bough 2K worth of tasai chisels about 10 years ago and they are superhuman in their ability to take an edge and hold it. They give performance better than any others I have and in winter I use sandpaper on them when they need a touch up. I don't know what it is about them. I'm not sure what they are. I kinda figured they were white, but maybe just because they were so easy to sharpen, and the cycle is so awesome.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#12

Re: Once again......

TomD

My Tasai are push chisels, and I have a few mortising ones. The latter are more for show than anything else, because I bought them to fill in sizes I don't use. :) Whatever he does, they don't correlate to the other chisels I have by several other makers.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#13

they make exceptionally hard carbides

Bill Tindall

These two elements can combine with the carbon in the steel to make exceptionally hard carbides that provide the "rocks in the field" to hinder the plowing action of abrasive wear.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#14

Re: they make exceptionally hard carbides

CStan

Just found it interesting that a 'fashionable' Japanese tool steel has the same elements as Record tool steel from the 1960s (maybe earlier?).

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#15

It is more that just what is there

Bill Tindall

The steel has to be processed so that the carbon finds the vanadium and makes these carbides. And they need to be finely divided and likely a dozen other things I don't know about. Bottom line is that processing is as important as composition. So, the Record blade may or may not be equivalent.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#16

Re: they make exceptionally hard carbides

david weaver

There are only four common alloying elements. They are not remotely similar quality, though (the record irons and the japanese blue steels). Even the budget laminated western plane irons from tsunesaburo are miles better. You can maintain them entirely with a medium stone and a fine stone just as fast as you can do a western iron with both of those plus a grinder, and they hold an edge much longer.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#17

Re: It is more that just what is there

CStan

... and the automatic assumption these days seems to be that the Japanese all do this much better than the old, big English firms. Doesn't this steel come from large manufacturers like Hitachi, et al?

Record, or anybody else for that matter, could have hardened steel to 60+ RC but they chose not to for what I think are obvious reasons for irons sold in the Western European and US markets. FWIW, both Record and Stanley did sell HSS plane cutters to the Australian and New Zealand markets hardened accordingly.

Most of what I hear about this stuff (Japanese steel) sounds like it was ripped out of the marketing materials for these firms. It's hard. So what.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#18

Re: It is more that just what is there

david weaver

It comes down to it taking a finer edge and the edge lasting longer.

It is also a cleaner steel in general than a lot of the industrialized western steel.

I guess you're assuming that record et. al. could've cleaned up their steel so they could introduce more carbon and still have a good tough temper at a higher hardness. Maybe they could've, but they didn't.

Priority was elsewhere, and maybe it was elsewhere because they were afraid their users wouldn't be able to handle a 65 hardness steel with novaculite (which is probably true).

But the details of why don't change what is. The blue steel in japanese irons is far superior (presuming you can sharpen it), and it's not just marketing hocum.

Take a look at the wear on the edge of the blue steel iron (brent beach can get better pictures than I can, for sure). Note how uniform it is:

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/TSUtest.html

Compare it to ECE:

http://www3.telus.net/BrentBeach/Sharpen/ECEtest.html

The stuff on the edge of the ECE is what leaves lines on your work, which doesn't matter, I guess if you always follow with a scraper. I don't, though, and I'd have to follow that with a resharpening or something.

The uniform wear on the blue steel iron in my experience so far means the surface looks good (astonishingly good) almost right up to the point the plane iron completely stops cutting.

They don't have a record iron.

I am shocked when I am using the blue steel iron in a cheap smoother at how you expect to go through the normal progression of creeping dullness and noticed surface flaws, but instead it stays even keel for a very long time.

that is only a $35-$40 or so iron, too, so it's not a matter of having to spend gobs to get a big thick bunch of steel for hundreds of dollars, to throw into a wedged block.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#19

Re: It is more that just what is there

TomD

"... and the automatic assumption these days seems to be that the Japanese all do this much better than the old, big English firms. Doesn't this steel come from large manufacturers like Hitachi, et al?"

What part of the old big firms are we talking about. Historic cast steel was pretty nice. And I haven't bought an english tool since maybe the 90s so i don't know about the current stuff. Japanese steel is pretty nice, and started to take over the custom US knife market, in perhaps the 80s, with stuff like 154cm. White steel and Blue steel turn out to sorta be like O1 and maybe A2. They are industrial steels. I thought for years they were something sacred for swords. Maybe they are, or maybe they are lawnmower blade stock.

.

The thing in the past was that the objectives were just different. I can remember reading about how the carbides in carbide were too large to take a razor edge. Now that I think about that, machinists much have been rolling on the floor over that one. But anyway, one day I took a Hitachi TR12 router out of a box, and it came with this super long 1/2" double flute bit. That router bit shaved hair. So imagine the surface it left a 20 000 rpm. That is what Japanese carpenters wanted in the 80s. Today the west is getting almost as demanding. Demand drives the product. we are getting great tools today, but the standards and probably the skills, are still more rooted in Japan, so for a while, we can continue to expect them to offer "better" products.

It's like ABS in the US. They came up with some pretty odd blade testing standards a lot of folks are still scratching their heads over. But in short order people invented the blades to meet them. Other smiths got interested in pattern welding, and before you know it people came up with ways to weld a repeating pattern of their name in multi coloured steel, right through the blade. It's all about the questions you ask of the craft.

In Japan you have hitachi coming to the party, but you also have a lot of smiths in small shops. Again, a bit like our knife business over here. So you also have a really wide range of "custom" tools. You don't really have that here. There are custom folks doing stuff, but it isn't that artisinal. American have most of the bits in place to take the next few steps, they just aren't doing it.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#20

Re: It is more that just what is there

TomD

+1. Almost all my western planes, record jointer, ECEs, infil, etc... Have Japanese Blue steel replacement blades in them. And these are standard western thickness blades. So even when I say nasty things about western metal planes, I am talking about ones that cut like crazy. If I had to use the crap that comes in those planes, I would have switched to croquet a long time ago.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#21

Re: It is more that just what is there

TomD

"Most of what I hear about this stuff (Japanese steel) sounds like it was ripped out of the marketing materials for these firms."

Most of the tool makers don't have a marketing department. I don't even know that we know how they market their tools for real. If I had to guess I would imagine it was reputational. We have master huxters like Japan woodworker, or Masterpiece tools who developed a lot of promo for these tools. This is a case where you might want to shoot the messenger. The guys that make this stuff are making it for real workers in Japan who are spending their own money.

In a lot of ways you are talking about your own cultural assumptions, rather than how stuff is run in Japan. Japan is different. Compare their rice production to ours. I'm not taking sides, I am just saying assumptions about how ADM does agriculture are probably not a reliable guide. Name the most culturally significant US building that signifies US power, that is made of wood.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#22

Re: It is more that just what is there

CStan

How much of what you say is simply due to the steel being hardened to a higher RC value?

Am I wrong when I say that these steels are made by very, very large industrial concerns? I think that there might be an impression in the marketplace that old Japanese gentlemen are making this steel themselves. They buy it from industrial suppliers just like the rest of us can (could), right?

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#23

Re: It is more that just what is there

CStan

I'm personally unable to separate fact from marketing hype from certain known phenomena of consumer psychology/behavior.

At first blush a blade hardened to a higher RC value SEEMS to be the cat's pajamas.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#24

Re: It is more that just what is there

david weaver

I don't think there is or has been for a long time the assumption that people are taking iron filled with silica and beating the impurities out of it over several days to come up with tamahagane.

The difference in steels from japanese to newer western steels is that their industrially made steels are supposedly cleaner.

If there is anything misleading to folks, it's the idea that all of the planes are made by a guy sitting on a stump with a small charcoal forge, beating and scraping everything totally with only his own power.

Even the old japanese irons used industrially made english and swedish steels, both of which are still available.

The argument that does exist from time to time is whether the new steel is better than tamahagane or as good as tamahagane. I have never met anyone with a plane where the hard bits were actually made of the stuff, and have no interest in ever getting that esoteric as good as the commercially produced steels are.

It is, to me at least, a safe assumption that if record tried to harden their concoction to 65 or 66 hardness, the result would be pretty ugly.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#25

Re: It is more that just what is there

TomD

"How much of what you say is simply due to the steel being hardened to a higher RC value?"

I don't know, that is the question I was raising. At one time I guess I thought it was a lot because they said how hard the steel is, and how it had to be welded to softer iron to survive. But having seen tests where in theory the three cherries wasn't 10 points off but two, while the observed degree of separation of performance was reportedly the same, and huge, I no longer know. Another vexing thing is the cycle thing. These steels are not only longer lasting, but sharper, and easier to sharpen. Accross the board performance that if hardness were the only thing some of that would run against the results.

Also, while one could say it is just subjective and hooey, My own experience doesn't support that. Not all the tools I have bought have been equally pleasing. Some I had high hope for I ended up being disappointed in while others I had no great expectations for were exceptional. Some of both the good and the bad are cheap or expensive.

"Am I wrong when I say that these steels are made by very, very large industrial concerns?"

You are correct the white and blue steel are the colour of the wrappers these steels are sold in from hitachy. Just as O1 comes in a dull brown wrapper -Brown Paper Steel :).

What I don't personally know about white and blue is whether hitachi makes them for what they are used for, or like brown, they are made for something else. In Japan, there is enough interest in blades that Hitachi could be making purpose built steels for all the knives, scissors, planes, razors, etc... O1 and A2 are not produced for those markets, and they have "toxins" in them relative to tool use.

" I think that there might be an impression in the marketplace that old Japanese gentlemen are making this steel themselves. They buy it from industrial suppliers just like the rest of us can (could), right?"

In the case of industrial steels which is the large part of it, they do just buy them from industrial suppliers. But Maloof bought his wood from the same place you did/could, and with steel there is actually arguably a lot more you can do with it that you can wood. For instance just welding it to iron completely changes how it heat treats.

That said, I, and others, will tell you that there are cheap Japanese tools out there that are better. In my as objective as I can be opinion of using tools from many different places, I have several complete national sets, and manufacturers within nations. Every Japanese tool is better than every other tool. I used to want to believe that to some extent, but these days, a lot of the tool I use are ones I made. I'm a competitor in my own shop, just the way it is. The point being that some of the benefits of these tools can be had from industrial produced versions. Japanese saws have taken over even at home depot, and those are mass produced resistance hardened tools.

Also, some of these guys do make their own steel for certain special tools, though that is more an exercise in art, in my opinion, not an exercise in making what the market wants. I might be wrong. They are certainly too expensive for every day use.