New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

Posts

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#26

Re: It is more that just what is there

TomD

Marketing hype is to some extent in origin a US specialty. How many other cultures have a show like the Music Man. There are many places, in fact a lot of people everywhere who are not that comfortable with what is at best blind enthusiasm, and in some industries evil. There was a time pre-that.

That is the critical thing. There was a time when if you lied once and got caught at it your reputation was ruined for life. People made simple stuff with their name on it, and sold it based on quality and their reputation. And to some extent that is why a lot of us want to make our own stuff because that seems right. Isn't that what our woodworking is about.

So if you went to some place and found someone who is still doing the same craft that their ancestors did and still working in the way they did hundreds of years ago, yeah with electricity added. Should you judge them by the standards of someone who is trying to sell product to a global audience. Nike is not trying to make bespoke hand made shoes the same way they were made in the 19th century for actual "Gentlemen". If they did, even though they don't come from that tradition, it would be pretty likely the shoes would be a lot better.

Marketing is driven by the needs of the marketplace. You want to sell 1 billion servings of a drink every day, you have to say something different than you would if you wanted to sell one bottle of wine. It isn't helping to apply the same standards that exist to global commerce to some guys with a small shop somewhere selling stuff to craftsmen who apprenticed and are doing something for which the pay in almost any other industry is a lot better. Though, in that case, the people selling those tools here to a foreign audience may say stuff about them that isn't true. In my case, I have never made a dime from Japanese tools.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#27

Re: It is more that just what is there

CStan

All of that is very interesting.

The recipe for the steel these guys use today is not coming out of some tattered little volume that's been handed down for the last 500 years. It comes from Hitachi and other large industrial suppliers of tool steel. I'm not taking anything away from the craftsmanship that follows, but the raw material (i.e. tool steel) is an industrial commodity made in huge quantities, in huge factories, by huge multi-national corporations.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#28

Re: It is more that just what is there

TomD

"The difference in steels from japanese to newer western steels is that their industrially made steels are supposedly cleaner."

I have heard that argument in a number of crafts. Could be true about record, I wouldn't know. I would find it hard to believe it is true about O1, not that you were implying that. Some of the magic steels of old were supposed to have charcoal added in the forge, which sounds pretty dirty to me. :)

"Even the old japanese irons used industrially made english and swedish steels, both of which are still available.'

I have these Sandvick tool box saws that are ok, but they aren't as good as my Record saws with Japanese pull blades. Confusing, huh.

I still think a lot of it is just business. To make a really great tool you need three things. One is a very well defined brief that supports your objective. Maloof may have made great rockers, but I doubt they would have been a winner for state run Psych hospitals, dangerous and too expensive. So you need a tight definition focused on excellence. Then you need a market that will support that. LV started making their second generation planes slanted for a no-name vibe and to come under LN. That was not a market that supported high quality and innovation, which it turned out were their strong suits so they have had a problem with their branding, according to me. And finally you need to execute. 90% of the discussion is about execution, when the real stuff is the other two points. Western tools are improving in direct proportion to the demands of the woodworkers. They are now closing in on being as demanding as Japanese pros. I am not comparing their capabilities, just how they see their needs.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#29

Re: It is more that just what is there

david weaver

No, what I'm saying (i may have mistyped it) is that the japanese industrial steels (like white paper and blue paper) have a cleaner spec than the western steels. Less sulfur and other stuff that makes a steel brittle.

By the way, I don't know where Charles gets the idea that people think white paper and blue paper steel come from an old guy hunched over with a hammer. Just the very explanation of them as being shipped in a white paper wrapper or a blue paper wrapper would suggest they're coming from a factory.

I haven't seen a western iron of any type that was 65 hardness, I don't think even the high speed steel irons are that hard, I could be wrong, though. I don't want HSS in most of my planes.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#30

Re: It is more that just what is there

TomD

"The recipe for the steel these guys use today is not coming out of some tattered little volume that's been handed down for the last 500 years."

Given the alloys in blue steel I think that is likely, though whether that is a plus a negative or neutral I don't know.

"It comes from Hitachi and other large industrial suppliers of tool steel. I'm not taking anything away from the craftsmanship that follows, but the raw material (i.e. tool steel) is an industrial commodity made in huge quantities, in huge factories, by huge multi-national corporations."

I don't know enough about industrial steels, but I don't think finished high tech steels are a commodity. More like cakes than sugar.

Not do I think that tools steels as a category really help us that much they are made for stuff other than the making of woodworking tools many of the characteristics they have are negative to our uses.

And finally, I'd love to know whether blue and white are made by the mega ton, or are made for the cutlery market. Are they formulated for this kind of use or like O1 are they being diverted, and the best of a bad lot.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#31

Charles?

Schtoo

I'd like to explain what the difference is between common blue steel and your beloved Record irons.

However there are a few stumbling blocks...

#1. I'm sure that my time will be completely wasted, as you won't read it.

#2. If by some fluke of nature you do read it, you won't believe what you've read.

#3. If by the grace of the great pumpkin you do believe it, you'll still regard anything made with the steel to be little more than over hyped trash.

So, there's little point to making the effort.

I will tell you that it's made by Hitachi in large batches, you can only buy it directly from Hitachi by the ton with a 1 ton minimum order. It's not excessively expensive, supplied in bars of whatever thickness and width you want (hey, you're buying a ton of the stuff, the least they can do is roll it to your specifications!) and it's made as needed to strict quality control. It does not, as far as I am aware have a JIS specification (like 'M2' is called JIS SKH-51) and these steels made specifically for the knife and tool blade industry, they're not modified or altered standard steels.

What the blade maker does to it after getting it from Hitachi is up to the particular maker, and much of the difference lies with what they do it while it's being turned from raw steel into a finished blade.

There is no hype, there are no secrets except those created by many of those selling these tools in languages other than Japanese.

You may not even believe this, but your attitude is not so far removed from what many of the makers themselves think. They're sick of the hype and BS surrounding their tools and would like to dispel a lot of the mystery around them created by people they must rely on to get the information out there.

It's just simple, sound blacksmithing more than anything else. Stuff that's been known for centuries but conveniently 'forgotten' by many people around the world.

Funny, there's been a lot of talk around here lately about 'forgotten facts'...

Stu.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#32

Re: Charles?

CStan

Well, I read the first sentence and hoped to hear, specifically, what the differences are but the rest was mostly personal insults.

Hitachi makes the steel and anybody who can handle the minimum order can have the proverbial boatload of it. I figured as much, but it is nice to have it confirmed by boots on the ground.

I did get the nugget it's 'sound blacksmithing'. Super. The problem with that is it is too reminiscent of the now familiar marketing strain of "Fill-in-the-Blank San" making a last run of plane irons before he kicks the bucket at age 114 and has no sons to which his mysterious techniques and secrets can be passed. Or "Fill in the Blank San" filled a special request for a set of exquisite chisels whist suffering from bunions and a bad case of gout--- yada, yada, yada...

Too much of this, shall we say "fluff," flying around on the 'net to believe much of it. And I don't. Sharp is sharp. And Mr. Goddard and Townsend are Mr. Goddard and Townsend. Mr. Marples is Mr. Marples.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#33

Re: Charles?

Schtoo

So, was I wrong in pre-empting what you'd reply with? :\

You see, I could have written a long treatise that basically said Hitachi removes the impurities that cause the steel to be brittle (like silicon, sulphur and phosphorous) which then allow these steels to be left in a harder final state than something like O1 where stuff is added to the steel to make it behave better (easier to add than remove), but that would have elicited a similar response.

But merely 'leaving it hard' without going through all the 'fluff' motions still doesn't quite work. The 'old guy with a tea-towel on his head bent over a hot forge in the dead of winter' still has a part to play in making a blade. If he doesn't do his part, the blade is hard, but brittle garbage or made deliberately softer than it could be, just so it doesn't chip and crack.

Last guy I met who makes chisels here rode a Harley Davidson and wasn't much older than me. He does wear a tea towel on his head though...

Heck, they even have *gasp* Mexicans (!) making chisels here...

(Only one. His name is Ricardo. He married into the family.)

Stu.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#34

Re: Charles?

CStan

The truth of the matter, Stu, is that there are fine small-batch toolmakers in practically every country on the planet. Why not Sweden, why not Denmark? They're there. These guys in Japan supplying the US market can't possibly be small-batch toolmakers.

I don't doubt you have contacts for bona fide craftsmen making a limited number of tools a year either working in total isolation or with only a very few colleagues. That's great. But like I said, this can be found in every country. Unfortunately, these guys in Japan do suffer from what has now become parody that writes itself - the aforementioned "Fill in the Blank San" with a fill in the blank practically unbelievable story and worse - bloated and puffed claims about the fineness of the tools and the mystical qualities of the steel -- steel produced by Hitachi each year in the hundreds of thousands of tons.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#35

Re: Charles?

david weaver

I don't think charles believes in anything that isn't induction hardened on an assembly line.

Of course, it sounds like he's never tried blue steel in anything, so his doubts are more superstitious than what he thinks he's arguing against in the first place.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#36

Re: Charles?

david weaver

How many of the places you're talking about use steel with 1.2-1.5% carbon?

How is it that you've so convinced yourself that everyone uses the same method completely without experience?

You only need to look to the beach test to see that there's a difference in the irons and the fineness of the steel, but I guess you've drawn a conclusion and reality won't get in the way of it.

The rest of the countries you're talking about are using less pure die steels or cheap chrome vanadium. The composition of the blue steel is out there for you to view freely. But don't let facts get in the way of your superstition.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#37

Re: Charles? *LINK*

Schtoo

You're right, these tools can be made nearly anywhere. There are folks making knives around the world using these Japanese steels, and there's no doubt they're making very good blades.

Forging a blade is not as simple as hacking up a block of O1 or A2, running it through a computer controlled furnace and having a blade of known specs popping out the other side. You actually need to know what you're doing.

Kind of like planing a board. Any clown can drive a sander, but you need to have an idea of what you're doing to plane the board smooth. The best plane in the world set up to the nth degree but driven by a fool isn't going to make that board smooth.

Total isolation? I don't know who said that, but if you actually believe that you've swallowed the hype. These blade makers tend to congregate together, know each other and help each other out. The bigger folks buy in a ton of steel, hack it up and sell it on to the smaller folks who can't quite manage a ton of steel in one shot. A few smaller folks will get together, order their ton of steel and divvy it up between them over a weekend. They're not strangers to one another, and they're no different to you or me. Yes, some of them are grizzly old curmudgeons but for the most part, the folks I've met are good, honest and completely normal people.

As for the steel itself, it's not normal steel. It comes from a single steel mill and I wouldn't think they make more than 100 tons of the stuff even in a good year. You could actually ask Hitachi's specialty steels division too. See how much steel they actually pump out in a year, although I'd guess that the lesser grades used in cheap knives and tools probably keep that particular steel mill's lights on.

As far as the planes being made, I wrote up a visit to Tsunesaburo in the link.

It riles me quite a lot, this talk of 'mystery and myth' about Japanese tools, only because those folks at Tsunesaburo have specifically and explicitly asked me to NOT to propagate it and to try and correct the BS whenever possible.

These makers know what's been said in the past, and they don't like it.

It does make it especially difficult to go against the tide of 100 folks saying "It's all BS!" and 100 folks saying "it's all true!" with my single voice of "Well actually, here's how it really is..." I'm not alone with trying to get rid of the mystery and myth, but I am (as far as I know) the only person who's actual job description reads "BS debunker".

I'm not expecting you to jump of the bandwagon Charles. Heck, I live here and swap lunches with these guys and I won't jump on the bandwagon.

Simply put, these guys are craftsmen (no women, yet) and not much different to any craftsman who makes a living with their trade.

(And I can see that you are trying to understand it, even with what may appear to be a jaundiced eye. It's better than a blind eye, and thank you for the effort.)

Stu.


Road trip; Tsunesaburo.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#38

Re: Charles?

TomD

"I did get the nugget it's 'sound blacksmithing'. Super. The problem with that is it is too reminiscent of the now familiar marketing strain of "Fill-in-the-Blank San" making a last run of plane irons before he kicks the bucket at age 114 and has no sons to which his mysterious techniques and secrets can be passed. Or "Fill in the Blank San" filled a special request for a set of exquisite chisels whist suffering from bunions and a bad case of gout--- yada, yada, yada..."

How in the word does sound blacksmithing sound like the tripe you reeled off? I've heard those other stories. In theory there are people who collect these tools for investment purposes. That strikes me as a bad idea, though they could hardly be doing worse than my index funds. But if people want to do that, the death of a master would be a consideration. I remember people pumping the sudahide awaji planes back in the 80s. He was going to die and everyone who bought his planes would be rich. Not my kind of investment, but do you know who bought one? Odate. I'm not saying it was a real investment opportunity, and they were definitely pumping it up, but that market is out there. Don't confuse it with working guys spending their own money for using tools. Guys selling the tools sell to both. At the time I did think I was getting value for my dollar compared to what american knife makers were getting for knives.

"Too much of this, shall we say "fluff," flying around on the 'net to believe much of it. And I don't. Sharp is sharp. And Mr. Goddard and Townsend are Mr. Goddard and Townsend. Mr. Marples is Mr. Marples."

Yeah, but do you think you are the only person who realizes it. I would imagine 99% of the people who read it, are onto it. But even the most hostile, at times racist reviewers of hand tools have had a hard time not giving the top rating to Japanese maker by a long shot. So how does that happen?

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#39

Re: Charles?

TomD

"The truth of the matter, Stu, is that there are fine small-batch toolmakers in practically every country on the planet. Why not Sweden, why not Denmark?"

Because they aren't as good. Axes yes, I like and own some axes. I'm not seeing a lot of other tools I like. Not seeing the tool quality. Just don't like the design of the Japanese axes I own.

"I don't doubt you have contacts for bona fide craftsmen making a limited number of tools a year either working in total isolation or with only a very few colleagues. That's great. But like I said, this can be found in every country."

Uhh, no it can't. The fact is that these countries have their woodworking points, but they don't have either the craftsmen or the tools that compare. There isn't that much love lost US to Japan. It is a stretch getting this market going. If there was another option we would have seen it by now. Morse commented on the superior quality of the tools and the craftsmen when traveling in japan in the 19th century.

"Unfortunately, these guys in Japan do suffer from what has now become parody that writes itself - the aforementioned "Fill in the Blank San" with a fill in the blank practically unbelievable story and worse - bloated and puffed claims about the fineness of the tools and the mystical qualities of the steel -- steel produced by Hitachi each year in the hundreds of thousands of tons."

Do you have a citing for hundreds of thousands of tons? Where does that number come from?

If you look at stones, chisels saw, and planes, the Japanese have converted a lunchbucket audience on 3 out of 4 of those products. Even as you accept the puffery, why would one choose the crappiest segment of the tool market to promote in this way.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#40

Thanks very much for the Tsunesaburo

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

tour, Stu! At least one good thing did come out of Charles' raillery.

Wiley

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#41

Re: Tungsten and Vanadium

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Charles,

That's interesting. I recall from a Spear & Jackson catalogue from the 19teens that that firm was offering a vanadium steel saw. Back in the day, no question the Brits were cutting edge (pun intended) in tool development and innovation.

Wiley

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#42

Re: Charles?

CStan

I do very much appreciate the fact the the Japanese manufacturer you mentioned recognizes how out of hand all of this 'stuff' has gotten. And it is out of hand.

I read some of the threads on Japanese tools in the various forums purely for their comedic value - guys who have owned Japanese tools for two months are all of a sudden 'experts' and offering advice on makers, tool steels, blacksmithing methods, etc. It's a joke.

I've asked of some of these folks, a time or two, where all of their information is coming from and they don't seem to be able to point me to any source beyond tool catalogs and other marketing materials, or what appears to be outright hearsay or just passing along something they heard somebody else say in another thread or on another forum.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#43

Re: Tungsten and Vanadium

CStan

I don't doubt it for a moment Wiley. I wouldn't be surprised, frankly, to learn that the Japanese picked up their alloying methodologies and formulations from westerners during the occupation and rebuilding after WWII. Can't say for sure, but I'd like to know. Maybe a research project for a rainy day when my arthritis is acting up.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#44

Re: Charles?

CStan

Thank you Stu.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#45

Re: Tungsten and Vanadium

david weaver

For commodity steels, I don't know, but they were using english and swedish steel before WWII. The reason they were using it is because (wiley, correct me if I get some part of this wrong) they had a ton of silica in their iron and their choice was to use an industrialized high carbon steel offering from sweden or england (made to special spec - clean and higher carbon) or to beat the silica out of the steel in small batches over several days.

Even at that, the blade steels the english were using were inferior to the stuff that they were passing to the japanese (cheaper, dirtier, less carbon). Maybe there was no demand in countries where hand tools gave way to machines long before (all of western europe and the US).

There was a point in the US where the quality of items like files, etc, was far better, they had a higher percentage of carbon by a significant amount. Why did that go away? All you have to do is ask george wilson which files are better - modern european files or turn of the century american and european files.

Why were irons held to a lower hardness and lower carbon content in the US? Was it the stones?

At this point, you'll not have a good idea of what you're talking about until you actually have used something made of blue steel next to a record iron. It will take only one cycle of dulling the iron to find out that even a pedestrian iron made of blue #1 is far better than whatever record was offering solely because they could produce it cheaply.

No durability test that I've seen shows the record and emmerich (english and continental european) alloyed irons to wear any longer than their older carbon steel counterparts, and their failures are spectacular compared to carbon steel - leaving lines all over the workpiece.

Given the quality of file steel around 1900, and its high carbon content, it's not like the US and england and continental europe couldn't have gone the same route the japanese did, they just chose not to. But could've and didn't is the same as didn't when it comes to using a tool.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#46

Re: Tungsten and Vanadium

CStan

I am far less concerned about edge longevity than you seem to be. And if that's the sole benefit or about the only thing I would notice in a side-by-side comparison then it's a total non-starter for me. I understand that I am totally swimming upstream on this since as woodworkers we are deluged with notion of edge longevity by the purveyors of A2/D2 and all the rest. I can't stand that stuff. It's harder than Chinese arithmetic and I hate trying to hone it. I had a D2 mortise chisel for about two days before I sent it back. Couldn't put a scratch on it.

Anything harder will last longer (generally speaking) assuming the edge doesn't chip first. I'd MUCH RATHER roll the edge a bit than chip it out. To some extent, a rolled edge can be straightened on a strop and 'brought back' for those last few paring strokes before back to a honing stone or the power strop. A chip is a chip and moving that through the stock will put score marks on the wood, where a rolled edge will produce what I call a sort of burnished cutting action but no score marks. I can't think of single good thing that happens when a chipped edge is pushed through wood.

I've used hard(er) steels before, just not Japanese made tools. All is right with the world until the SOBs chip. And I refuse to hone a chisel I expect to use for paring at some ridiculously obtuse angle like 35* like I've often seen recommended. I'm SURE people get nice work done at these angles, but it seems to me too much like pushing a loaded wagon uphill.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#47

Re: Tungsten and Vanadium

CStan

I think I'll hold out for Cowry-Y:

BLADE STEELS

Hitachi Metals Ltd. is one of top manufactures of high grade metal products and materials, electronics devices, high grade functional components and equipment. The company is well known as a manufacture of its “Yasuki Hagane” YSS (Yasuki Speciality Steel) for cutlery industries.

Yasuki Hagane steel has been produced in their plant in Shimane prefecture in Japan where the high quality iron sand has been produced for making traditional Japanese swords since ancient times. These are three main premium grade high carbon steels (Shirogami, Aogami and Aogami Super) that have been used for making Japanese made field & kitchen knives. Hitachi metal is also known as the manufacture of high grade premium stainless steel, ATS-34 and ZDP-189.

ZDP-189 is the highest performing steel in the knife industry today.

◆White Steel (Shirogami)

This is refined carbon steel that does not contain any ingredients and can be used for making high-grade Hocho (Japanese kitchen knives), hatchets, axes, sickles and chisels.

◆Blue Steel (Aogami)

This is made by adding chromium and tungsten to Shirogami (White Steel) that makes the material more durable and provides corrosion resistance and mostly used for making high-grade Hocho (kitchen knives) and outdoor knives.

◆Super Blue Steel (Aogami Super)

This is the highest grade steel in their product line that contains high percentage of carbon, chrome to increease hardness, improviding edge retention and corrosion resistance.

◆Cowry-Y

Cowry-Y is a powdered metallurgical steel produced by Daido Steel in Japan and it not available in the United States. This steel is capable of a higher hardness without being brittle. The resulting edge has extremely good edge retention and can get better finish if you prefer mirror finish on your knife blade. Cowry-Y contains 1.25 of Carbon, 14.5 of Chromium, 3.0 of Molybdenum, 1.0 of Vanadium, 0.3 Nb in HRC62-64.

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#48

Re: Tungsten and Vanadium

david weaver

If you're using oilstones and you think A2 is hard to sharpen (blue is probably a little easier than a2, but maybe similar with hardness differences), then you should stick to the steels designed for it.

But you seem to have fallen off a wagon here and decided that what you like means that something different isn't different, that it's just marketing hype.

nobody can tell what you're trying to prove, unless you're just in a bad mood lately.

The iles chisels are pretty easy to sharpen if you're not using oilstones. I guess they're not if you are, and if you like oilstones, then stick with what you know.

But don't pretend for a second that there's no difference between blue and white steel (and their offshoots) and the diemaker's steels we have plugged into tools in the US. It's flat out false.

Edge longevity without compromise is nice. Good A2 is that. Bad A2 leaves lines all over your work. Blue steel at a higher hardness - less alloying but harder, is like the best A2 iron, except a little better. If you can't sharpen it, don't use it, but you ought to be wise enough by this point in your life to know that making claims about something you don't have experience with and always trying to wrap the conversation back to what you want your conclusion to be is a good way to look like you're in space or in need of a sedative - at best.

The hitachi steels are better than diemaker's steels. You can't sharpen them because your stones won't do it easily. That's all anyone can gather from this. You may have noticed that you are the only individual who is trying to make some point that the difference is marketing, and you've got only every single other person who has actually used them all disagreeing with you. What does that tell you?

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#49

by the way..

david weaver

.my parers are just under 25 degrees. My bench chisels are at about 27 or 28.

Who said that japanese chisels need to be used at 35 degrees?

Re: Anyone have comments on super blue steel?

#50

Re: by the way..

CStan

Somebody, somewhere. Let me see if I can find it for you.