Re: It is more that just what is there
TomD
Marketing hype is to some extent in origin a US specialty. How many other cultures have a show like the Music Man. There are many places, in fact a lot of people everywhere who are not that comfortable with what is at best blind enthusiasm, and in some industries evil. There was a time pre-that.
That is the critical thing. There was a time when if you lied once and got caught at it your reputation was ruined for life. People made simple stuff with their name on it, and sold it based on quality and their reputation. And to some extent that is why a lot of us want to make our own stuff because that seems right. Isn't that what our woodworking is about.
So if you went to some place and found someone who is still doing the same craft that their ancestors did and still working in the way they did hundreds of years ago, yeah with electricity added. Should you judge them by the standards of someone who is trying to sell product to a global audience. Nike is not trying to make bespoke hand made shoes the same way they were made in the 19th century for actual "Gentlemen". If they did, even though they don't come from that tradition, it would be pretty likely the shoes would be a lot better.
Marketing is driven by the needs of the marketplace. You want to sell 1 billion servings of a drink every day, you have to say something different than you would if you wanted to sell one bottle of wine. It isn't helping to apply the same standards that exist to global commerce to some guys with a small shop somewhere selling stuff to craftsmen who apprenticed and are doing something for which the pay in almost any other industry is a lot better. Though, in that case, the people selling those tools here to a foreign audience may say stuff about them that isn't true. In my case, I have never made a dime from Japanese tools.





