New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Woodworking Course

Posts

Re: Woodworking Course

#51

Randomness of the Aha-moment

Texchappy

One of the limiting factors with any kind of learning and seemingly especially with woodworking is the 'aha' moments that occur along the way. Those little times when something just clicks. Sometimes you can see, do, experience the same thing a 100 times and then it just makes sense what is going on.

Here's an example from my own addled brain. I've read through the Jim Toplin book I have at least twice and some sections many more. I was re-reading the first project - wooden straight edge - and the phrase "'capture' the grain" suddenly made sense to me. Likewise I had read the Wearing book I have early on in my experience and I just reread a large section of it. I didn't realize the first time I read it how much of it sailed right over my head and this time I 'got' a lot more of it.

Of course the 'aha' moment isn't magical, it is a compilation of information and experience that goes into our perceptions. We collect this info higgledy piggedly through our filters and daydreams until it gets connected to where it actually does us good. The we go 'aha' that's why they said that - Eureka, I have found it! We can't predict if that will happen with the best curriculum or in a month or 20 years (in people as dense as moi).

Another 2p free of charge.

Re: Woodworking Course

#52

Jim in Burlington Ont.

My Experience

Jim in Burlington ON

You need more than a month. Most places are revolving around a 12 week program these days. My experience is that it takes more than 1 month to even machine wood properly and at the best a few months to learn the basics of hand tools.

Re: Woodworking Course

#53

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Woodworking Course

#54

With all due respect with Mr. Joplin

Texchappy

Did I mention I'm dyslexic (and I really am)?

Somewhere between the 100 times and the Aha moment should come the Einstein quote on insanity ;)

Re: Woodworking Course

#55

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Woodworking Course

#56

Re: My Experience

James Watriss

I think the gist of the original idea is, what's the minimum amount of time before students are sufficiently equipped to begin learning on their own, through trial and error.

Many aspiring woodworkers don't even know where to start. So, (and I'm shocked to become the advocate for this thread) what's the bare minimum before they're able to go and start figuring things out on their own?

I'm not assuming their early work will be good. I'm assuming they'll learn from it, and do better work the next time around. And, I'm assuming they'll make enough mistakes to have some good questions to ask, next time they encounter someone who can teach them.

Re: Woodworking Course

#57

Re: Woodworking Course

Mark Hennebury

I like that.

If you had to distill all that you have learned and to pass the most important information on to someone and only had one month to teach them, I bet you would teach them a lot.

Most of what you use to build any projects is the same knowledge you just apply it slightly differently and with more skill and better judgment as you progress.

Woodworking is not that complicated, projects you can make as complicated as you like.

"Teach a Man to fish"

Re: Woodworking Course

#58

Re: Aha!

Texchappy

Sey!

Re: Woodworking Course

#59

Re: Woodworking Course

CStan

I actually have done this and this points back to what I think was my first or second post in this thread - you can DEMONSTRATE a whole lot of woodworking in a month (160 hours or 4 weeks at 40 hours). Stopping to teach, while students are practicing, severely restricts the amount of material that can be covered in which the students become somewhat proficient.

Re: Woodworking Course

#60

Re: Randomness of the Aha-moment

CStan

Read Charles Hayward. Please.

Re: Woodworking Course

#61

why is everyone backing talkwards


Re: Woodworking Course

#62

Hayward Books

Texchappy

I found the Cabinetry for $20 new and the Junior Woodworker book for $33 used. Is the Junior worth the difference?

Re: Woodworking Course

#64

Kcabsdraw?


Re: Woodworking Course

#65

Re: Hayward Books

CStan

Probably not in the strictest sense. I believe you would benefit greatly from both of those books but I came across the Hayward titles I own for probably no more than five bucks apiece.

Re: Woodworking Course

#66

Re: Hayward Books

AlanWS

Here's a book and article by Hayward that can be downloaded for free:

http://toolemera.com/Books%20%26%20Booklets/booksplans.html

Re: Woodworking Course

#67

David Barnett

Yeah, me too.


Re: Woodworking Course

#68

Re: A basis for learning

Bob Hackett

By comparison, it takes 10 weeks for a civilian to complete Army basic training. At the end of it you graduate and are officially considered a soldier.

As a former DI. I can tell you if you took those new soldiers out onto a front line battlefield and asked them to put what we showed them to use very few of them would survive for long. The more focused follow on training in their particular military specialties was what actually gave them the specialized skills they required and very few of those courses were less than 3 months. Ask any Seasoned NCO and they`ll tell you that it isn`t until about the 2 year mark that most troops are competent enough to begin standing on their own and operating without close supervision.

I think a more effective means of measuring the time required for basic skill knowledge and retention would be to ask a journeyman joiner or cabinetmaker how long it would take for a high school graduate with no WWing experience to get to the point where that person can be trusted to hand them acceptable, meaning properly prepared and closely fit, parts while working independent of their mentor.

Intellectual possession of the skills required and being able to quote the "book of knowledge" chapter and verse doesn`t mean you can effectively make your hands translate that knowledge. It just means you know how to be a good student and pay attention in class. Combining a series of individual tasks, in their proper sequence allowing you to manifest a finished project of moderate difficulty using the most appropriate materials and techniques might be a completely different thing all together and require more hand holding than you think, even after a one month intensive course.

Re: Woodworking Course

#69

My question.

James Watriss

So, I think I get the premise. Most woodworkers don't even know where to start. So, the idea is to get them to the starting line, where they know just enough to start messing around, and actually learning, and storing up questions that they can bring up when they're in the company of someone more knowledgable.

My question is, when they're led to the point where they should be capable of experimenting on their own, and sustain their own learning process... How many will actually do so? And if they won't, what would it take to keep them 'on the path?'

Re: Woodworking Course

#70

Re: My question.

Mark Hennebury

Passion.

Woodworking, above all else is about passion!

We dont see what they are looking at. Our eyes are blind, our minds are numb.

Most people have never actually looked at a piece of wood.. I mean really looked.

Take a pile of sawdust press it into a shape like a Queen anne table paint it red and put it in a furniture showroom, most people will think that its beautiful Mahogany table.

Show them up close in minute detail what goes into a real piece of furniture, then take them back to the first one you showed them.

You will then have opened someones eyes and mind forever.

Take them to a woodworking course, fill their head all the fascinating beauty of wood , the weight, the textures , smells, colors, the cells structure, get them to tune up a handplane and make magnificent shavings and then watch them holding them up in the air like a holy offering. Then watch them gently running their fingers over the perfectly planed surface: you have them hooked... for good, life as they once new it is over. You now have a woodworker if only in spirit at this point.

Re: Woodworking Course

#71

Re: Woodworking Course

Sgian Dubh

Mark, I have read all the posts in the thread up to this point, and those beyond.

I still think you are wrong. I think you could present a vast amount of essential and basic information information to a woodworking beginner in a short space of time. The fact that the information is presented to a learner doesn't mean he or she remembers it, understands it, can put it into context, nor be able to understand the link between one piece of information or skill and others.

Learning just doesn't happen quickly, nor does developing skill. There's a big difference between superficial learning and deeply embedded learning. You mention timber technology and wood as being essential to learning. I agree, but I can present key essential information about wood to a learner in a short time. The problem is that learners can't take it in fast enough, memorise it, contextualise it, and be able to effectively use that information.

I think a reasonable analogy would be taking a raw and unfit beginner and saying to him something like, "By the end of this month's planned training and fitness regime you'll become a decent quality rugby player". It's too short a time for that raw recruit to develop the necessary fitness, knowledge, and understanding of the game's laws, techniques and skills, eg, everything from passing the ball, drop kicking, scrummaging, loose play, back play, offside, penalties, etc. True, there would be improvements in fitness and gains in knowledge and basic skills, etc, but there would still be much to work on before you could say that rugby player has got all the basics in place to go on and develop high level skill and understanding of the game. Slainte.

Re: Woodworking Course

#72

Re: Woodworking Course

Mark Hennebury

Sgian Dubh,

Hi, well I would like to thank you for reading all of the posts.

I dont know anything about rugby, so I will leave that alone.

Those that are lucky enough to get a three year well structured course taught by a highy skilled teacher are very fortunate indeed. I am sure that if I had been given that oppurtunity I could have shaved at least 10 years off of my learning curve.

I guess that is the motivation for my suggestion, that and the whole chipbreaker revelation.

I see that for whatever reason, many woodworkers with any number of years experience and many courses under thier belts, still have not got a comprehensive knowledge of the basics, that they could have recieved in a month. There are large very important gaps in the "common knowlege" made painfully obvious by the chipbreaker episode. How many people dont fully understand wood, or cutting tools, or joinery design, yet have been woodworking for 10 or 20 years. The problem is of course that we dont even realise what we dont know, until someone points it out. We excuse it, dismiss it, blame it on something else. A lot of it is very simple basic stuff.

Wood, from the needs of a woodworker is not that complicated to learn to work with.

Cutting tools are just a chisel in various disguises and are easily demystified.

Marking out principals and procedures for making a bunch of parts fit are a set of procedures and critcal references that need to be developed and followed.

I am in no way saying a one month course wood turn out competent furnituremakers or in any way would be a comparison to a three year progam.

Anyone doing woodworking realizes that it takes years of practice to develop the skills and judgement to work at a high level. I never meant that a one month course would be the end of the road, but a beginging, a journey on which you were well prepared to travel.

You could take many courses after, about any manner of topics and continue to grow.

What I am saying is that most everyone that i know of could have benefitted by taking that fictitious one month starter course, i know I would have.

The highpoint of my woodworking was a pedestal table joint. Took me 25 odd years of woodworking to arrive there. Mostly because of mindblock, not because it was difficult, someone could have explained it to me in a day. Just like someone could have explained the chipbreaker to everyone in a day.

I could have learned a lot faster had someone open a few doors in my mind,

shown me, questioned me, and pushed me to examine and understand.

Guide me, point me in the right direction, show me what wood is and help me learn how a chisel cuts it, and I can figure out what shape saw teeth should be. It may take me a while, but i will figure it out. And i will know it to be right.

I am talking about the building blocks of understanding, thats all.

Re: Woodworking Course

#73

Re: A basis for learning

Mark Hennebury

I think that you are comparing bullets to bayonets here:

I did not suggest putting rookies up against seasoned vets.

What would be a closer comparison is if you looked around that battlefield and realized that some of your seasoned vets hadnt ever learned how to load their rifle, (or chipbreaker)

then maybe a quick course on the basics may be a good course for starters.

I am talking about just a prep course so that eveyone gets the basics. before they go off to get the hands on training and developing the skills and experience. If everyone takes a basic knowledge course than everyone is up to date and on the same page with no major gaps in their knowledge.

Re: Woodworking Course

#74

Re: A basis for learning

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

By comparison, it takes 10 weeks for a civilian to complete Army basic training. At the end of it you graduate and are officially considered a soldier.

As a former DI. I can tell you if you took those new soldiers out onto a front line battlefield and asked them to put what we showed them to use very few of them would survive for long.

Hi Bob

Would you agree that the motivation to enlist to fight in Iran is no where as strong as the motivation to enlist in WWII? The question is why?

The answer is, I suggest, that the average person in 1940 understood and agreed with the reason for signing up, and why they wanted to part of the war. I cannot imagine many, if any, actually wanting to be there, but the conviction would have helped them become better soldiers.

As I understand, Mark's suggestion is about something similar. It is not intended to create physical skills - that takes time, in the same way that time in the field builds experience and makes one a better soldier. It is intended to prepare one for entering the field - what to expect and what to look out for, basically an orientation to the woodworking field of action.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Woodworking Course

#75

I would still say...

Bob Hackett

That if you are going to start off with an in depth understanding of the characteristics of wood and how to get the best out of it when using it as your chosen material then it`s gonna take longer than 30 days to open their heads and pour in everything they need to know to get started properly.

If you were able to convey all the required knowledge within the 30 day time frame then I`d be curious to see what standards were to be met for a final evaluation prior to graduation and going out into the world. I would be even more interested in the findings of a follow up study to see how much of the knowledge the students had retained at 6 and 12 months after graduation.